The Murder of Rosemary Nelson

Victims
1 murder, unsolved; claimed in the name of the Red Hand Defenders; no one charged or convicted
Years active
March 15, 1999
Location
Lurgan, County Armagh, Northern Ireland (killing)
Method
Bombing or explosives (public inquiry report, 2011).
Status
Inquiry report published May 23, 2011: no state act directly facilitated the murder; state omissions left her more at risk. Unsolved; no one charged as of May 2011.

Rosemary Nelson was killed in Lurgan, County Armagh, on Monday, March 15, 1999, in the year after the Good Friday Agreement had promised Northern Ireland a way out of three decades of political violence. That evening a caller telephoned a newsroom in Belfast and claimed the killing on behalf of the Red Hand Defenders, a loyalist group. No one has ever been charged with her murder.

The case reaches beyond the killing because of what came before it. For two years she had said, privately and then in public, that officers of the Royal Ulster Constabulary were abusing her and threatening her life through the clients they questioned. A United Nations special rapporteur raised her situation with the British government, and in September 1998 she carried the same account to a committee of the United States Congress. Twelve years after her death, a public inquiry reported on whether the state had failed her.

She studied law at Queen's University in Belfast and was admitted as a solicitor in Northern Ireland in 1983. Between 1985 and 1988 she ran a community advice center in Lurgan, helping local people with benefits, housing, family problems and debt, and in March 1989 she opened her own practice in the town, working at first in family law and property. In those early years, the inquiry found, local police treated her like any other solicitor.

From 1993 she represented people held on suspicion of terrorist offenses, among them a high-profile republican client from Lurgan. In 1996 she became legal adviser to the Garvaghy Road Residents' Coalition, the Portadown residents' group that opposed the Orange Order's annual parade through their neighborhood, and the role put her in public view; in January 1999 she went with the coalition's leaders to a meeting with the Prime Minister in Downing Street. The inquiry found that as her defense work grew, some RUC officers came to identify her with republican paramilitaries, as did loyalist extremists.

In the early hours of July 6, 1997, police moved protesters off the Garvaghy Road so that the parade could pass. She was there. The next day she gave a statement to a worker from the Committee for the Administration of Justice, a Belfast civil liberties group, saying RUC officers had assaulted her and abused her verbally. Her complaint was investigated by the RUC's own complaints department under the supervision of the Independent Commission for Police Complaints, and the Director of Public Prosecutions directed no prosecution, finding the evidence insufficient to identify an officer.

Over the same period her clients began telling her what detectives had said about her during interviews, remarks that ranged from insults to suggestions that she would come to harm. She did not trust the RUC to investigate its own officers and at first lodged no complaint herself. In March 1997 a lawyers' group, the Lawyers Alliance for Justice in Ireland, wrote on her behalf alleging threats, and in April a United States senator raised the matter with the British ambassador in Washington. Both letters reached the RUC, whose complaints department opened an investigation under the commission's supervision. In June 1998 the commission told the Chief Constable that, for the first time in its history, it could not confirm that a police investigation had been conducted to its satisfaction. An officer from the Metropolitan Police was brought in to investigate the complaints again. His report was signed on March 22, 1999, a week after her death, and the complaints were treated as unfounded.

Warnings had come from outside as well. The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers took up her situation during a mission to the United Kingdom in October 1997; his draft report, sent to the British government in February 1998, recorded allegations that she had received numerous death threats, and his published report urged the government to investigate threats against defense lawyers and to protect them. That February the lawyers' group raised her safety with Northern Ireland Office officials and with the Chief Constable, and in March the Committee for the Administration of Justice wrote to the security minister about her allegations of police harassment and death threats.

In June 1998 an anonymous threatening note reached her office. Around the same time a leaflet circulating in Portadown falsely gave her a paramilitary past. In August the Committee for the Administration of Justice sent copies of both to the security minister, and the Northern Ireland Office passed them to the RUC. The RUC assessed the risk to her twice that year, in April and in September, and neither assessment found a threat that called for action. Shortly before her death the government offered protection under its Key Persons Protection Scheme to two Portadown councillors who led the residents' campaign. She was not offered it.

On September 29, 1998, she appeared before the Subcommittee on International Operations and Human Rights of the House of Representatives Committee on International Relations. Her clients, she told the members, had reported an increasing number of incidents in which RUC officers abused her, "including several death threats against myself and members of my family," and her complaints had brought no satisfactory response. Less than six months later she was dead.

The RUC opened a murder investigation the same day. To give it an independent element, an officer from outside Northern Ireland was brought in to lead it, agents of the FBI assisted, and on the first day every officer named in her complaints was removed from the team. It became the most extensive murder investigation in the history of Northern Ireland. Over the years the team made 32 arrests. No one was charged.

Calls for an independent inquiry began within days and did not stop. At Weston Park in England on August 1, 2001, the British and Irish governments agreed that certain killings involving serious allegations of security force collusion should be examined independently, hers among them, and in May 2002 a retired justice of the Supreme Court of Canada was appointed to review them. He recommended a public inquiry into her murder, and on April 1, 2004, the government announced that one would be held. It was established on November 16, 2004, under section 44 of the Police (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, to decide whether any wrongful act or omission by the RUC, the Northern Ireland Office, the army or another state agency had facilitated her death or obstructed the investigation of it, and whether that investigation had been carried out with due diligence.

The report was published on May 23, 2011. The panel found "no evidence of any act by or within any of the state agencies we have examined ... which directly facilitated" her murder, and in the next sentence added: "But we cannot exclude the possibility of a rogue member or members of the RUC or the Army in some way assisting the murderers to target" her. It was sure that she "was abused and assaulted by RUC officers on the Garvaghy Road in the early hours of 6 July 1997," and it found that the abuse had "the effect of legitimising her as a target." It believed that some officers had made abusive or threatening remarks about her to her clients, and that intelligence about her had leaked outside the RUC and increased the danger to her life.

The panel set out a series of omissions. RUC management had negligently failed to stop officers from abusing and threatening defense solicitors. The two threat assessments had amounted to little more than a check of Special Branch records. No one had analyzed the intelligence about her, and the RUC had failed to warn her of her vulnerability or offer her security advice. The Northern Ireland Office had dealt "in a mechanistic way" with the letters sent about her. "The combined effect of these omissions by the RUC and the NIO," the panel concluded, "was that the state failed to take reasonable and proportionate steps to safeguard the life" of the woman it had been warned about.

On the investigation, the inquiry found "no evidence of any deliberate attempt by any of the organs of the state corporately to obstruct" it, although Special Branch's cooperation had been incomplete, and it judged the murder investigation "exhaustive, energetic and enterprising" and carried out with due diligence. The report made no recommendations, because the RUC had since been replaced, complaints against the police had passed to an independent Police Ombudsman, and policing and justice had been devolved.

Who carried out the murder has never been decided by any court. Responsibility was claimed in the name of the Red Hand Defenders, which the murder team and the inquiry both treated as a group of loyalist dissidents, and the inquiry judged the investigation's focus on certain loyalist paramilitary groups and their associates "in all probability, correct." No one has been charged, and no one has been tried.

Whether the state colluded in the killing remains disputed. The inquiry did not define collusion and did not use the word in its conclusions, so its report has been read both as a finding of collusion through omission and as a finding of none.

Special Branch files held intelligence reports making allegations about her that were never tested in any court; the inquiry treated them as evidence of how she was perceived, not as fact. The leaflet that gave her a paramilitary past was untrue.

Timeline

November 16, 1983: She is admitted to the Roll of Solicitors in Northern Ireland.

March 1989: She opens her own practice in Lurgan.

July 6, 1997: RUC officers abuse and assault her on the Garvaghy Road in Portadown, as the public inquiry later found.

June 19, 1998: The police complaints commission refuses, for the first time in its history, to certify an RUC complaints investigation.

September 29, 1998: She testifies before a subcommittee of the US House of Representatives.

March 15, 1999: She is killed in Lurgan; the killing is claimed in the name of the Red Hand Defenders.

August 1, 2001: The British and Irish governments agree at Weston Park to an independent review of her case and others.

April 1, 2004: The government announces a public inquiry.

November 16, 2004: The public inquiry is established.

May 23, 2011: The inquiry report is published.