Pier Paolo Pasolini died in Ostia, the seaside district of Rome, in the night between November 1 and November 2, 1975. Within hours the Carabinieri had a 17-year-old in custody, and by the end of the day he had confessed. Giuseppe Pelosi, known as Pino, was tried in Rome's juvenile court, convicted of voluntary homicide in April 1976 and sentenced to nine years, seven months and ten days. The judges who convicted him did not believe he had acted alone. The judges who heard his appeal did. When the Court of Cassation confirmed the conviction in April 1979, the law settled on one young man as the only person responsible for the death.
The case never settled anywhere else. Thirty years after his confession Pelosi withdrew it and said other men had done the killing. Prosecutors reopened the file, closed it, reopened it again in 2010 and closed it in 2015, when a judge accepted that the presence of other people had become more probable but found that none of them could be identified. Later requests to reopen the investigation were turned down. On November 2, 2026, the 51st anniversary of the death, the Rome prosecutor's office opened a new file. Pelosi had been dead for more than nine years. The question the first court asked in 1976 was still open: who else was in Ostia that night.
The victim was born in Bologna on March 5, 1922. He grew up moving from town to town across northern Italy, and Friuli became the place he thought of as his own; his first book, Poesie a Casarsa, a short collection in Friulian dialect, appeared there in 1942. In 1949 a scandal in Friuli cost him his position and his membership in the Italian Communist Party, and in January 1950 he left for Rome.
Rome made him. He was a poet, novelist, playwright and film director, the author of the novels Ragazzi di vita and Una vita violenta and the poetry collection Le ceneri di Gramsci, a screenwriter who worked with Federico Fellini, and from the 1960s a filmmaker whose work marked the history of Italian cinema; he also wrote for the Corriere della Sera. By the 1970s he was one of the best-known and most argued-over public figures in Italy, a man of the left who had been taken to court more than once and who spoke openly about power, the governing parties and the bombings of the period.
The Carabinieri of Ostia arrested Pelosi on November 2, 1975. He was first held for theft. At that point no one knew that anyone had died. The death came to light later that morning, and Pelosi then confessed to the killing. He was from Guidonia, a town east of Rome, and he had been born in Rome in 1958.
From the first day his confession was the spine of the case. He said he had acted alone, and his account of a quarrel that ended in the death became the version the appeal court accepted. He later abandoned it. Others doubted it from the start.
Because Pelosi was a minor, his case went to the Tribunale per i minorenni di Roma, the juvenile court of Rome. The trial opened on February 2, 1976. He faced three charges: voluntary homicide, aggravated theft and obscene acts in a public place.
The court gave its verdict on April 26, 1976. It convicted Pelosi of voluntary homicide committed "in concorso con altre persone rimaste ignote," in complicity with other persons who remained unknown, and of the other two charges. He was sentenced to nine years, seven months and ten days, with a fine of 30,000 lire. The court found Pelosi unreliable as a witness to his own act and considered the participation of others certain, calling the hypothesis that more than one person had been involved "assai più logica," far more logical, than the account he had given.
So the court convicted the only defendant in the dock while finding that he had not been the only person there. Nobody else was charged. The phrase "in concorso con ignoti," with unknown others, stayed attached to the case for the next half century, because it kept the door open to later investigation.
The Court of Appeal in Rome ruled on December 4, 1976. It upheld the conviction for voluntary homicide and removed the finding that others had taken part, holding that it was "estremamente improbabile," extremely improbable, that Pelosi had had one or more accomplices. The convictions for obscene acts and theft fell away. The appeal judges named Pelosi as the sole person responsible.
The Court of Cassation, Italy's highest court for criminal cases, confirmed the appeal ruling on April 26, 1979, three years to the day after the first verdict. With that judgment the conviction became final. In law, Giuseppe Pelosi alone had caused the death in Ostia.
Pelosi served most of his term. He was admitted to semi-liberty in 1982 and granted conditional release on July 18, 1983. In later years he was convicted of other, unrelated offenses. In 1994 he gave a long television interview about the case, and he still held to his confession.
In May 2005 Pelosi went on Italian state television and said, by his own account, that he had not been the killer. He now said that three other men had carried out the killing and that he had confessed falsely because one of them had threatened him and his family. He said he had waited until that man and his own parents were dead, so that no one could be harmed in retaliation.
Rome prosecutors reopened the file on the strength of the interview. Later in 2005 a judge for preliminary investigations archived it, finding no new evidence.
His accounts kept changing. In 2008 he gave yet another version, saying that two men, both since dead, had been present and that the meeting that night had to do with reels of film belonging to the victim that had been stolen in Rome in August 1975. None of these accounts was ever tested in court, and none led to a charge.
In 2010 a new proceeding against unknown persons was registered in Rome. It turned on the physical evidence kept since 1975, which was examined again with methods that had not existed then and was found to carry traces of several people who were neither the victim nor Pelosi. The traces could not be turned into names: none could be attributed to an identified person, and it could not be established when any of them had been left.
On May 25, 2015, the judge for preliminary investigations of the Tribunale di Roma archived the case. The order held that in substance every investigation that appeared reasonably possible had been carried out and that none had produced a result capable of being developed in court. That was true both of proof of the presence of other people besides Pelosi at the time of the killing, a presence whose probability, the judge wrote, could be considered higher in light of the scientific findings, and of the identification of anyone else involved.
The ruling closed the inquiry while recording that it had moved the probabilities. It was the closest any court had come since 1976 to the first verdict's view of the case.
Requests to reopen the case were rejected in 2016 and again by an order of November 20, 2023, when the prosecutor's office found that the new lines of inquiry added nothing to the investigation already carried out. A further request was filed in November 2025 and supplemented in May 2026 with an application to hear a witness who had never been questioned.
On November 2, 2026, the Rome prosecutor's office opened a new file on the killing and assigned it to a substitute prosecutor. The witness is to be interviewed, and the new material is to be examined. The opening of a file does not establish that anyone else was present, and no new step in the investigation had been made public by mid-November 2026. Pelosi's conviction remains the only final judgment in the case.
Pelosi did not live to see it. He died in Rome in July 2017, still the only person ever convicted.
Whether Pelosi acted alone is the central dispute. The juvenile court found that others took part; the appeal court and the Court of Cassation found he acted alone, and that finding is final. The 2015 archiving order held that the presence of others was more probable in light of the scientific findings but could not be proved, and that no one else could be identified.
Pelosi's own accounts are the second. He confessed in 1975, held to his confession in 1994, withdrew it in 2005 and blamed three unknown men, then in 2008 named two men who were both dead by then and tied the night to the stolen reels. No court has tested any of these later versions, and no one he named was ever charged.
The motive is the third. The theories range from blackmail over the stolen reels to a killing by the far right or by organized crime, to a link with the victim's public accusations about the state energy company and the bombings of the period. A 2022 parliamentary Anti-Mafia Commission report put forward the reels as a hypothesis; investigators had earlier set aside the blackmail theory. None has been proved, and no court has found anyone other than Pelosi responsible.
March 5, 1922: The victim is born in Bologna.
1942: His first book, Poesie a Casarsa, is published.
January 1950: He moves to Rome.
1958: Giuseppe Pelosi is born in Rome.
August 1975: Reels of film belonging to the victim are stolen in Rome.
November 2, 1975: The victim dies in Ostia; the Carabinieri arrest Pelosi, 17, who confesses the same day.
February 2, 1976: Pelosi's trial opens in the juvenile court of Rome.
April 26, 1976: The juvenile court convicts him of voluntary homicide "in concorso con altre persone rimaste ignote," with aggravated theft and obscene acts in a public place; nine years, seven months and ten days.
December 4, 1976: The Court of Appeal upholds the homicide conviction and excludes accomplices as "estremamente improbabile."
April 26, 1979: The Court of Cassation confirms the conviction, which becomes final.
1982: Pelosi is admitted to semi-liberty.
July 18, 1983: He is granted conditional release.
May 2005: Pelosi retracts his confession on state television and blames three unknown men.
2005: Prosecutors reopen the file; a judge archives it later that year.
2008: Pelosi names two men, both since dead, as present.
2010: A new proceeding against unknown persons is opened in Rome.
May 25, 2015: The judge for preliminary investigations archives the case.
2016: A request to reopen the case is rejected.
July 2017: Pelosi dies in Rome.
November 20, 2023: The Rome prosecutor's office rejects a further request to reopen the case.
November 2025: A new request to reopen the case is filed; it is supplemented in May 2026.
November 2, 2026: The Rome prosecutor's office opens a new file and assigns it to a substitute prosecutor.