The Murder of PC Keith Blakelock

Victims
Police constable murdered in Tottenham, 1985; unsolved. Three men's 1987 murder convictions were quashed in 1991; a fourth man was found not guilty, April 9, 2014
Years active
October 6, 1985
Location
Tottenham, London, England
Method
Murder of a police officer on duty during public disorder; a colleague was the victim of attempted murder the same night
Status
1987 life sentences quashed by the Court of Appeal in 1991; 2014 acquittal by majority verdict; no conviction stands; the case remains unsolved

On the night of October 6, 1985, during the disturbances on the Broadwater Farm estate in Tottenham, north London, a Metropolitan Police constable named Keith Blakelock was killed while his unit was protecting a fire crew. He was the first British police officer to die in a riot since 1833. By March 1987 six people had been tried for his murder and three men had been sent to prison for life. Four and a half years after that, the Court of Appeal quashed all three convictions. A second investigation in the early 1990s ended without a charge, and a third, opened in 2003, brought a man to the Central Criminal Court in 2014, where a jury found him not guilty. No conviction for the murder stands, and the case remains unsolved.

The case is remembered as much for what went wrong in the investigation as for the killing itself. The first inquiry rested on statements taken from young suspects over long interrogations, much of it without a solicitor, and the Court of Appeal later found those convictions unsafe. The later inquiries turned to a different kind of evidence, witnesses who were promised immunity in return for their testimony. Neither approach produced a verdict that held.

The officer was a home beat constable in Muswell Hill, in north London, with no training in public order policing. That evening he was posted to a unit of ten constables under a sergeant, known by its call sign, Serial 502, and sent to the estate.

The disorder followed the death, the day before, of a local woman who collapsed while police officers were at her home after an arrest. Many local people blamed the police for her death. A demonstration was planned outside Tottenham police station for October 6, and by that evening the estate was in open disorder.

Serial 502 was assigned to protect firefighters on the estate. The officers and the fire crew were forced to withdraw, and the constable was killed during the withdrawal. A colleague from the same unit survived an attack that the Metropolitan Police later treated as attempted murder.

The murder inquiry was led by a detective chief superintendent, and it began without the material a homicide case normally depends on: there were no photographs of the killing and no scientific evidence. Hundreds of people were arrested in the weeks that followed. The inquiry came to rest on statements from suspects held for long periods and questioned again and again, much of the time without a solicitor. Six people were charged with the murder: three boys, and three men, W.S., E.R. and M.B.

The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court on January 14, 1987. The Crown did not try to prove who had struck the fatal blow; it charged murder as a joint enterprise. None of the three boys was convicted: two were acquitted on the judge's direction, and the case against the third ended without a conviction. The jury convicted W.S., E.R. and M.B. of murder and of riot, and in March 1987 each was sentenced to life imprisonment.

In 1988 the three men were refused leave to appeal. On December 4, 1990, the Home Secretary referred E.R.'s case to the Court of Appeal after a psychologist who had assessed him changed his view of E.R.'s mental condition, and all three cases came before the court in 1991. By then the Crown no longer defended the convictions.

For W.S., Electrostatic Deposition Analysis showed that the passage of his interview notes on which the case against him depended had been inserted after the surrounding notes were written. For E.R., the court had fresh evidence that he was highly suggestible and had been questioned for hours, part of the time without a solicitor. For M.B., the ground was the length of his interrogation, most of it without a solicitor. The court treated all three confessions as unreliable and quashed the murder convictions in 1991, four and a half years after the verdicts.

The detective chief superintendent who had led the first inquiry and a detective inspector who worked with him were later tried for perjury and perverting the course of justice over W.S.'s interview record, and a jury acquitted both.

A new investigation began in 1992 under a commander from the City of London Police, an outside force brought in to take the case away from the officers who had run the first. Anyone close enough to see the killing clearly might have been part of it, and the first inquiry had shown how little the case could rely on admissions taken in custody. With the agreement of the Director of Public Prosecutions, people who had taken part without being armed were treated as witnesses rather than suspects and offered immunity from prosecution in return for their evidence, and a conditional immunity arrangement on those terms was agreed with the Crown Prosecution Service in 1993. The Crown Prosecution Service later decided the evidence was not enough to justify proceedings against anyone, and the second investigation ended without a charge.

In January 2000 the Metropolitan Police began a review of the murder and of the attempted murder of the constable's colleague, and on December 3, 2003, it announced a fresh investigation into both offenses. Fourteen arrests were made in 2010.

On July 23, 2013, the Crown Prosecution Service announced that N.J. would be charged with the murder. He was the seventh person charged with the killing. His trial opened at the Central Criminal Court on March 3, 2014, with the Crown again putting its case as a joint enterprise, and he denied murder. On April 9, 2014, the jury found N.J. not guilty of murder by a majority verdict.

No one stands convicted of the constable's murder. The case remains unsolved.

No court has found who killed the constable. Every finding of guilt in the case was set aside: the 1987 convictions of W.S., M.B. and E.R. were quashed by the Court of Appeal as unsafe, and N.J. was found not guilty in 2014. The three boys charged in the first inquiry were not convicted.

The allegation that detectives fabricated part of W.S.'s interview record was never proved. The two officers charged over it were acquitted after experts disagreed on what the tests showed, although the quashing of W.S.'s conviction rested on the expert evidence about the notes.

Timeline

October 5, 1985: A local woman dies in Tottenham while police officers are at her home after an arrest.

October 6, 1985: A Metropolitan Police constable is killed on the Broadwater Farm estate in Tottenham while protecting firefighters; a colleague survives an attempted murder.

Late 1985: Hundreds are arrested; three boys and three men are charged with the murder.

January 14, 1987: The murder trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.

March 1987: The three boys are not convicted; W.S., M.B. and E.R. are convicted of murder and riot and sentenced to life imprisonment.

1988: The three men are refused leave to appeal.

December 4, 1990: The Home Secretary refers E.R.'s case to the Court of Appeal.

1991: The Court of Appeal quashes all three murder convictions.

1992: A second investigation begins under a City of London Police commander.

1993: A conditional immunity arrangement for witnesses is agreed with the Crown Prosecution Service.

1994: The second investigation ends without a charge.

January 2000: The Metropolitan Police begins a review of the case.

December 3, 2003: The Metropolitan Police announces a third investigation.

2010: Fourteen arrests are made.

July 23, 2013: The Crown Prosecution Service announces that N.J. will be charged with murder.

March 3, 2014: N.J.'s trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.

April 9, 2014: The jury finds N.J. not guilty of murder by a majority verdict.