Paul Klebnikov, the American-born founding editor of the Russian edition of Forbes, was killed in Moscow on the evening of July 9, 2004. Within days Russian officials described the killing as a paid murder connected to his work, and the Prosecutor General of Russia assigned the inquiry to a special crimes unit.
What followed produced arrests, a charge sheet and a trial, but never a conviction. A jury at the Moscow City Court acquitted the accused in May 2006 after a trial held behind closed doors. The Supreme Court of Russia overturned the acquittals on November 9, 2006 and ordered a new trial, and that retrial was suspended on March 14, 2007, when one of the defendants failed to appear. Another suspect was detained in Kyiv in 2017 and handed to Russia in 2018. No court has convicted anyone of the murder.
The first arrests came in November 2004. On November 17, security officers in Belarus detained a man, K.D., in Minsk, in a joint operation with Moscow police, and Belarus handed him over to Russia. Two days later police in Moscow detained a second man, M.V. In 2005 investigators arrested F.S., a Moscow notary. Two more men the investigators sought in the case, M.D. and M.E., were placed on international wanted lists.
In June 2005 prosecutors declared the investigation complete and set out their account. They alleged that a criminal group formed in Moscow around F.S. had carried out the killing, with K.D. and M.V. as the men who did it, and that the order had come from a former official of the self-declared Chechen Republic of Ichkeria who resented a book the editor had written about him. That official, believed to be abroad, was placed on the wanted list and never arrested. Prosecutors made no evidence connecting him to the killing public.
The trial opened at the Moscow City Court on January 10, 2006, closed to the public and the press at the prosecution's request. K.D. and M.V. were tried for the murder; F.S. was tried for attempted murder and for organizing a criminal group. All three pleaded not guilty. On May 5, 2006 the jury found for the defense, and the court acquitted all three men.
The acquittals did not stand. On November 9, 2006 the Supreme Court of Russia overturned them and sent the case back to the Moscow City Court for a new trial before a different judge. The court did not publish its reasons.
The retrial began in early 2007 and never reached a verdict. When K.D. failed to appear on March 14, 2007, the judge suspended the proceedings, placed him on the federal wanted list and ordered his arrest in absentia. M.V. was released on a written undertaking not to leave. The Moscow City Court then returned the case to the Prosecutor General's Office for further investigation, a course the Supreme Court upheld in May 2007 and its Presidium upheld in June 2008. The three men remained defendants in a case that never went back to court. The federal Investigative Committee reopened the investigation in 2009.
In November 2017 the Security Service of Ukraine detained a Russian citizen in Kyiv who was wanted through Interpol over the murder. The Russian Interior Ministry identified him as M.D., one of the men sought since the earliest stage of the case. Russia asked for his extradition in December 2017, and Ukraine handed him over in 2018; the transfer became public in April 2019.
No court has convicted anyone of the murder. The man prosecutors accused of ordering it has never been arrested or tried.
The prosecution's account of who ordered the murder has never been tested in a court. Prosecutors named the former separatist official in June 2005, but they made no evidence connecting him to the killing public, and he was never brought to trial.
Other possible motives tied to the editor's reporting were raised after his death and never resolved. No evidence linking anyone he had written about to the killing was ever made public.
The roles alleged against the accused men remain allegations. K.D., M.V. and F.S. were acquitted by a jury; the Supreme Court overturned that acquittal and ordered a retrial, which was suspended before any verdict. No conviction ever replaced the acquittal. M.D. has never been tried.
July 9, 2004: The killing in Moscow.
November 17, 2004: K.D. is detained in Minsk, Belarus; M.V. is detained in Moscow two days later.
2005: F.S. is arrested in Moscow.
June 2005: Prosecutors declare the investigation complete and accuse a former Chechen separatist official of ordering the murder.
January 10, 2006: The closed jury trial opens at the Moscow City Court; all three defendants plead not guilty.
May 5, 2006: The court acquits all three defendants on the jury's verdict.
November 9, 2006: The Supreme Court of Russia overturns the acquittals and orders a new trial.
March 14, 2007: The retrial is suspended; K.D. is placed on the federal wanted list and his arrest is ordered in absentia.
May 2007: The Supreme Court upholds the suspension.
June 2008: The Presidium of the Supreme Court upholds the return of the case to the Prosecutor General's Office.
2009: The federal Investigative Committee reopens the investigation.
November 2017: M.D. is detained in Kyiv, Ukraine.
December 2017: Russia requests M.D.'s extradition.
2018: Ukraine hands M.D. over to Russia; the transfer is made public in April 2019.