The Murder of Natalia Estemirova

Victims
1 murder, Chechnya and Ingushetia, July 2009; no one tried. The Investigative Committee charged an insurgent in absentia in 2010; never arrested, his part disputed.
Years active
July 15, 2009
Location
Grozny, Chechnya, Russia (abduction); Nazran district, Ingushetia, Russia (killing)
Method
Shot (official investigation; no one tried). Abducted first.
Status
European Court of Human Rights, August 31, 2021: investigation ineffective, file withheld; EUR 20,000 to her sister. No one arrested or tried as of July 2024.

Natalia Estemirova spent nearly ten years recording abductions, torture and killings in Chechnya for the Memorial Human Rights Center, and on July 15, 2009, her own case went into that record. Unidentified armed men abducted her in Grozny that morning, and she was found dead the same day in the neighboring republic of Ingushetia. No one has ever stood trial.

Russia's Investigative Committee settled in early 2010 on a single suspect, an insurgent it charged in absentia and who has never been arrested. Her colleagues at Memorial, the Moscow newspaper Novaya Gazeta and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) ran their own inquiry and concluded in 2011 that the official case against him was unproven and appeared to have been arranged. In August 2021 the European Court of Human Rights held that Russia had failed to carry out an effective investigation and had kept most of the case file from the court. It also held that the evidence did not prove that agents of the state had carried out the abduction and murder.

She was born on February 28, 1959, in Saratov province in southern Russia, and grew up in the Urals, where she finished secondary school and a teacher-training college. She moved to Chechnya as a young woman, took a degree in history at the state university in Grozny and taught history in a Grozny school until 1998. In 1992 she helped found an independent union of education workers, and the same year, during the Ossetian-Ingush conflict, she persuaded armed guards to let go of hostages they were holding on a bus. In the middle of the decade she worked with an association of people who had passed through the filtration camps of the first Chechen war, and from 1998 she made programs for Chechen television about civilians who had suffered at the hands of federal forces in the fighting of 1994 to 1996.

When Russia's second campaign in Chechnya began in 1999, she went back to Grozny. She lived through the rocket strikes on the city on October 21, 1999, and later gave evidence about them in Moscow. That autumn she began working with Memorial, and when the group opened its Grozny office in mid-2000 she became one of its central figures. From that year she also worked closely with Human Rights Watch, and she wrote for Novaya Gazeta, often without a byline.

Her subject was what happened to civilians, and enforced disappearance stood at the center of it. She worked on the events at Novye Aldy in February 2000, where federal forces were accused of killing more than 50 people, and in 2002 she was the first to make public the killing of six civilians near Shatoy. With a lawyer and a journalist, she pursued the case of a young man who vanished after being taken into custody in Grozny in 2001; her evidence helped lead to the arrest of a riot-police officer who was later sentenced to prison, the first known outcome of its kind in Chechnya.

She sometimes held back facts rather than publish them, and she exposed a source only when doing so might save a life or protect someone's health. She turned down offers to stay safely in Europe. Away from the work she loved the theater and music, and she hoped one day to write a book about Chechnya.

In February 2008 the Chechen leadership tried a different relationship with Memorial, and she was brought in to chair a newly formed human rights council for the city of Grozny, attached to the mayor's office. She had been criticizing the republic's campaign to make women cover their heads since 2007, and on March 30, 2008, a national television program carried an interview in which she called the policy unlawful and a violation of the right to privacy. The next day the head of the republic dismissed her from the council in person. By the account she gave Human Rights Watch that evening, he warned her of consequences for what she had said. She left Chechnya for a short time and then came back, and that spring she secured the release of two teenagers held at a police regiment in Grozny.

By the summer of 2009 violence in Chechnya was rising again, and she was investigating several of its newest cases jointly with Human Rights Watch: extrajudicial executions, punitive arson against the families of suspected insurgents, abductions and arbitrary detentions. On July 7, 2009, she made public the killing of a man suspected of helping the insurgents, carried out in front of villagers in Akhkinchu-Borzoi by men in camouflage uniforms.

She had received numerous threats in Chechnya and had told only close friends about them. Several other Memorial staff had also been threatened, and three of them had left the region. On the day she was abducted she had an appointment with prosecutors about a kidnapping she was investigating. Her colleagues learned of the abduction from eyewitnesses, and after her death Memorial suspended its work in Chechnya.

On the day of the killing, the Memorial chairman publicly blamed the head of the Chechen Republic, who denied any part in it. A Moscow court found against the chairman in a civil defamation case in October 2009, and on June 14, 2011, the Khamovniki District Court in Moscow acquitted him of criminal slander, finding that his statement was a hypothesis and an opinion rather than a knowingly false assertion of fact.

The Investigative Committee opened its case on July 16, 2009, and its chairman took it under his personal oversight. Investigators listed four lines of inquiry: that the killing was connected with her work; that it was meant to discredit the Chechen authorities; that it arose from personal hostility; and that members of the Chechen security forces had killed her for publicizing their abuses.

In January 2010 the investigation changed course. Its main version became abduction and murder by A. B., an insurgent from the village of Shalazhi, "and other unidentified persons," and investigators said he had acted in revenge for an unsigned Memorial report about his recruiting of fighters, with the aim of discrediting the Chechen government. The Investigative Committee charged him in absentia in 2010 and placed him on federal and international wanted lists. Whether he was even alive was never settled: the Federal Security Service said he had been killed in a counterterrorism operation in November 2009, while the Investigative Committee's chairman said in September 2010 that he was alive and in Russia. Investigators also named one of his brothers, who lived in France, as a suspect, and France refused to extradite him. The case against A. B. rested largely on material that investigators said they had recovered in his village, and police experts later found that one item said to link him to the crime had been falsified.

Memorial, Novaya Gazeta and FIDH spent two years on their own examination of the evidence and released their report in Moscow on July 14, 2011. It found no serious evidence that A. B. had taken part in the abduction and murder and argued that the evidence pointed instead to a deliberate effort to make his involvement the main version. The scientific evidence collected in the case did not match him, the report said, and investigators had not used it to test whether anyone else, including state security employees, had been involved; the falsified item could not have been produced by him, and further items found in the same place had not been examined. The authors also observed that a killing in Ingushetia made little sense for anyone whose aim was to embarrass the Chechen authorities.

On July 21, 2011, the Investigative Committee's chairman said he had ordered investigators to check every possible version of the murder, including those Memorial had put forward, and the lead investigator then sought evidence from about 20 Chechen police officers, most of them men she had named in her reports. By July 2013 Memorial was saying the investigation had been suspended. The Investigative Committee denied it, said more than 1,000 witnesses had been questioned and said A. B. was on the Interpol wanted list and thought to be in France. In 2014 the Committee to Protect Journalists found that the case had dropped off the list of high-priority cases on the Investigative Committee's website. Memorial's position was that the killing was linked to her work on abductions of ordinary people by police in the Kurchaloi district.

Her sister took the case to the European Court of Human Rights, arguing that state security services had taken part in the abduction and murder. In its judgment of August 31, 2021, the court found no violation of Article 2 of the Convention, the right to life, under its substantive limb. Much of the evidence offered was hearsay, the abduction showed none of the marks of a special operation by state forces, and it was not established beyond reasonable doubt that agents of the state were responsible.

On the investigation the court reached the opposite result. It accepted that the authorities had opened their inquiry promptly and charged a suspect, but Russia had given the court only an incomplete copy of the case file, and without the full file the court could not conclude that the investigation had been thorough. Contradictions in the expert evidence had never been resolved, investigators had not explained why the scientific evidence showed no trace of the suspect or of members of his armed group, and the court doubted that the authorities had made a genuine attempt to identify everyone involved. It found a violation of Article 2 in its procedural limb and a violation of Article 38, which obliges a state to give the court all necessary facilities to examine a case. Because the criminal investigation was still open, it said the authorities should continue, as far as possible, to establish the circumstances, identify those responsible and punish them where appropriate, and it ordered Russia to pay her sister 20,000 euros for non-pecuniary damage.

As of July 2024, fifteen years after the killing, no suspect or accused person had been brought before a Russian court and the investigation had not advanced. A. B. has never been arrested, and no court has heard who carried out or ordered the abduction and murder.

Whether the official suspect is alive or dead has never been settled, and no court has examined the evidence against him.

Whether he took any part in the killing is equally unproven. The Investigative Committee maintained that he did, as revenge for her publications; her colleagues' 2011 inquiry found no serious evidence for that version. The European Court of Human Rights did not rule on his guilt, but it found the investigation's expert evidence contradictory and its failure to explain the absence of any scientific link to him unaccounted for.

Whether officials were involved is also unproven. Memorial, Novaya Gazeta and Human Rights Watch pointed to the threats against her and the nature of her last investigations as signs of possible official involvement or acquiescence, and the head of the Chechen Republic denied any role. The Strasbourg court held that state responsibility had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt, while finding that Russia had withheld the material that would have allowed the investigation to be fully assessed. The 2011 slander acquittal made no finding on who was responsible for the killing.

Timeline

February 28, 1959: Born in Saratov province, Russia.

1992: Helps found an independent education workers' union.

1998: Leaves school teaching and begins making programs for Chechen television about civilians harmed in the first Chechen war.

Autumn 1999: Begins working with the Memorial Human Rights Center.

Mid-2000: Memorial opens its Grozny office, where she becomes a central figure.

February 2008: Named to chair the new Grozny city human rights council.

March 31, 2008: Dismissed from the council by the head of the Chechen Republic, the day after a televised interview criticizing the headscarf policy.

July 7, 2009: Makes public a killing carried out in front of villagers in Akhkinchu-Borzoi.

July 15, 2009: Abducted in Grozny and found dead the same day in Ingushetia.

July 16, 2009: The Investigative Committee opens its case.

January 2010: Investigators make an insurgent from Shalazhi their main suspect.

2010: The Investigative Committee charges the suspect in absentia.

June 14, 2011: The Khamovniki District Court acquits the Memorial chairman of criminal slander.

July 14, 2011: Memorial, Novaya Gazeta and FIDH release their report on the investigation.

July 21, 2011: The Investigative Committee orders every version checked, including those Memorial put forward.

July 2013: The Investigative Committee denies that the investigation has been suspended.

2014: The Committee to Protect Journalists finds the case dropped from the Investigative Committee's high-priority list.

August 31, 2021: The European Court of Human Rights finds violations of Article 2 (procedural limb) and Article 38, and no violation of Article 2 (substantive limb).

July 2024: Fifteen years on, no one has been arrested or tried.