Lynette White died in Cardiff on February 14, 1988, Valentine's Day. She lived in Butetown, the docks district of the city. Within a year South Wales Police had charged five men with her murder. Three of them, Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi and Tony Paris, were convicted in November 1990 and sentenced to life imprisonment. The other two, John Actie and his cousin, were acquitted. In December 1992 the Court of Appeal quashed the three convictions, and the men walked out of prison.
The man who had killed her was Jeffrey Gafoor. He had no part in the 1988 inquiry, and he was found only after South Wales Police reopened the case in 2000. In 2003 the reopened inquiry identified him, and he admitted the killing. At Cardiff Crown Court in July 2003 he pleaded guilty to her murder and was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 13 years. He is the only person ever convicted of her death. On October 17, 2024, after his sixth review, the Parole Board directed his release on licence. That is where his case stood as of October 2024.
The three men convicted in 1990 became known as the Cardiff Three. Their convictions rested from the start on a confession that the Court of Appeal would later find had been obtained by bullying.
The first months of the inquiry brought no charge. In December 1988 police arrested the five men. Seven men were arrested in the course of the inquiry in all, and five of them were charged with murder: Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi, Tony Paris, John Actie and John Actie's cousin.
The Crown's case did not rest on scientific evidence linking any of them to her death. It rested on three things. There were eyewitnesses who said they had seen the men in the district. There were civilians who said the men had confessed to them. And there was a long series of police interviews with Stephen Miller.
Those interviews would decide the case twice, once at trial and once on appeal. Miller was questioned over five days. The sessions ran to 19 tapes and about 13 hours in all, and at the end of them he confessed. That confession became the center of the prosecution. The eyewitnesses and the civilian witnesses were called to support it.
The five men were sent for trial at Swansea Crown Court. The first trial began in 1989 and was abandoned when the judge died. The case was tried again, and in November 1990 the jury returned its verdicts. Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi and Tony Paris were convicted of murder. John Actie and his cousin were acquitted.
The three convicted men were sentenced to life imprisonment. Paris was 32 when he went to prison, Abdullahi 28 and Miller 24. John Actie and his cousin left the dock free, but only after nearly two years held in prison awaiting trial for a murder they had nothing to do with.
The three men appealed. The Court of Appeal heard the case over four days in December 1992, and the argument turned on the Miller interviews and whether the jury should have heard them at all.
The judges listened to the tapes. They found that Miller had been bullied and hectored by the officers questioning him. The court also had before it fresh material bearing on the reliability of the witnesses and on the integrity of the police. In December 1992 it quashed the convictions of Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi and Tony Paris, and all three were released. There was no retrial.
The ruling freed the three men, but it left the central question of the case unanswered. For most of the next decade no one was charged with her murder.
South Wales Police reopened the investigation in 2000. Advances in the science of identification made it possible to test the evidence from the original inquiry again, and in 2003 that work led detectives to Jeffrey Gafoor.
When police reached him, Gafoor made an attempt on his own life. He then admitted that he had killed her. He was charged with her murder.
Gafoor did not contest the charge. At Cardiff Crown Court in July 2003 he pleaded guilty to murder. He was 38. The judge sentenced him to life imprisonment and set a minimum term of 13 years, the time he had to serve before the Parole Board could consider his release.
Three days after his admission, South Wales Police apologized to Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi and Tony Paris for their wrongful conviction and imprisonment. The men were later compensated.
The plea also opened an inquiry into how the case against the five had been built. The main eyewitnesses and civilian witnesses withdrew their evidence and said the police had pressured them into it. In 2008 three of the prosecution's witnesses were convicted of perjury and sentenced to 18 months each.
A criminal investigation into the original inquiry brought eight former officers to trial in 2011 on charges of conspiring to pervert the course of justice, and on December 1, 2011, the trial collapsed without a verdict when the Crown offered no evidence.
Gafoor's minimum term expired, and he remained in prison through review after review. Over those years he was moved to lower-security conditions and then to open prison, where he was allowed periods of temporary release to prepare for life outside. In December 2022 the Parole Board considered his case for the fifth time. That panel was not satisfied that he was suitable for release and recommended that he stay in open conditions.
His sixth review was heard on October 3, 2024. On October 17, 2024, the Parole Board announced that the panel was satisfied that imprisonment was no longer necessary for the protection of the public, and directed his release. The licence set conditions: he must live at a specified address, disclose any relationships he forms, wear an electronic tag and keep to a curfew.
Yusef Abdullahi died in January 2011. Tony Paris died in September 2022, at 65, after a period of ill health.
No court found any of the five men charged in 1988 responsible for her death. Three were convicted and then cleared by the Court of Appeal, and two were acquitted by the jury in 1990. The only conviction for her murder is Jeffrey Gafoor's, on his own plea of guilty.
No police officer was convicted in connection with the original investigation. The 2011 trial ended when the Crown offered no evidence, so no jury ever ruled on the allegations against the officers.
Two dates in the record are not settled. Most reports give 2003 as the year of Gafoor's conviction, while one gives 2004, and the perjury convictions of the three witnesses are dated 2008 in most accounts and 2007 in another.
February 14, 1988: Death of the victim in Cardiff.
December 1988: South Wales Police arrest five men, who are charged with her murder.
1989: The first trial at Swansea Crown Court is abandoned after the judge dies.
November 1990: At the retrial, Stephen Miller, Yusef Abdullahi and Tony Paris are convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment; John Actie and his cousin are acquitted.
December 1992: The Court of Appeal quashes the three convictions; the men are released.
2000: South Wales Police reopen the inquiry.
2003: Jeffrey Gafoor is identified and admits the killing.
July 2003: Gafoor pleads guilty to murder at Cardiff Crown Court; life imprisonment, minimum term 13 years.
2008: Three prosecution witnesses are convicted of perjury.
January 2011: Yusef Abdullahi dies.
December 1, 2011: The trial of eight former officers collapses without a verdict.
September 2022: Tony Paris dies at 65.
December 2022: The Parole Board declines to release Gafoor at his fifth review.
October 17, 2024: The Parole Board directs Gafoor's release on licence after his sixth review.