On January 24, 1941, Josslyn Victor Hay, 22nd Earl of Erroll, was killed in the Karen district outside Nairobi, the capital of the British colony of Kenya. He was a hereditary peer, a former member of the colony's Legislative Council and, in wartime, Military Secretary for East Africa. Some weeks later the police arrested a 57-year-old baronet whose marriage stood at the center of the Crown's theory of the case. The accused baronet stood trial for murder before a jury in Nairobi and was found not guilty. No one else was ever charged, and no one has ever been convicted.
The trial made headlines far beyond Kenya while it was still running, and the case has drawn writers ever since. None of their answers has been put to a court, and the verdict of 1941 remains the only legal word on the death of Lord Erroll.
Josslyn Victor Hay was born heir to the earldom of Erroll, and with it to the hereditary office of High Constable of Scotland. He went to Eton College and left after two years. He chose Kenya over a career at home, and in the 1920s he settled in the central highlands, where he moved among the small circle of wealthy settlers that later writers called the Happy Valley set.
By the end of the 1930s he had entered the colony's public life. In 1938 he represented Kiambu, a district north of Nairobi, in the Legislative Council. When war came he held a commission as a captain in the Kenya Regiment, and shortly before his death he had been appointed Military Secretary for East Africa, a post that placed him inside the colony's wartime command.
The accused was a baronet with an estate in Kenya. In December 1940 he married in London and brought his wife out to the colony, and within weeks she had formed an attachment to the earl. That attachment was the whole of the motive the Crown would later put before a jury.
Some weeks after the death, the police arrested the baronet, and he was charged with the murder of the Earl of Erroll. The case was sent for trial before a jury in Nairobi.
The trial became the public sensation of the capital, and the proceedings ran on into the summer of 1941.
The Crown's case was that the accused had resented the attachment and had killed the earl. To support it, prosecutors called witnesses from his household, put before the jury evidence the police had gathered in the days after the death, and relied on a question he had put to a police inspector about the penalty the law would impose in such a case. They also called expert evidence that, they argued, tied the death to him.
The defense answered each strand. The baronet went into the witness box himself. He described the earl as "a very great friend, whose brain and sense of humor I admired," and he denied the murder. Medical evidence put to the court questioned whether he was physically capable of what the Crown alleged, and the defense challenged the Crown's expert evidence point by point.
The Nairobi jury found the accused baronet not guilty of the murder of the Earl of Erroll. The Crown brought no charge against anyone else. The death was left, in law, without a culprit.
The verdict did not restore the acquitted man's standing in the colony. He returned to England, and the following year he died by suicide in Liverpool.
Who killed the earl has never been settled. Writers since the 1960s have offered theories, some private and some political, the latter tied to the earl's place in the colony's wartime administration. None has been tested in a court, and none carries any legal weight.
Against all of them stands the one finding of a court: on the evidence the Crown could bring in 1941, a Nairobi jury was not satisfied that the accused baronet was guilty. The killing of the Earl of Erroll remains officially unsolved.
1938: The earl represents Kiambu in the Legislative Council of Kenya.
December 1940: The future accused, a baronet, marries in London and brings his wife to Kenya.
January 24, 1941: The earl is killed in the Karen district outside Nairobi.
1941: The baronet is arrested some weeks later and charged with murder.
1941: A Nairobi jury finds him not guilty.
The year after the trial: The acquitted man dies by suicide in Liverpool, England.