Linda Cook lived in Portsmouth, and she died in its Buckland district on December 9, 1986. She was raped and murdered. Until 2003 the law named her killer, and it named the wrong man. On January 28, 1988, a jury at Winchester Crown Court convicted Michael Shirley, a young Royal Navy sailor, of her murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. He never stopped saying he was innocent. On July 29, 2003, after a review by the Criminal Cases Review Commission and fresh testing of exhibits kept since the trial, the Court of Appeal ruled his conviction "plainly unsafe" and quashed it. There was no retrial. Hampshire police reopened the murder inquiry, and the killing was still unsolved as of March 2019.
The prosecution had been built from small pieces, none of them decisive on its own: a laboratory grouping result, marks on the sailor's skin, a shoe, and a gap in his account of the night. Testing that did not exist when the jury sat took the case apart.
The inquiry had scientific material from the trial exhibits, analyzed with the grouping techniques of the mid-1980s, which could narrow a suspect pool but could not name one man. There was also a footwear impression from a kind of shoe sold in large numbers.
Michael Shirley was an able seaman stationed in Portsmouth, serving with HMS Apollo, and he was due to sail for the Falkland Islands. On the night of the murder he had been drinking at a club on the seafront. He had hoped to leave with a young woman he met there; instead she left him in a taxi, and he made his way back to his ship.
That young woman later identified him to the police. He was arrested, and on January 6, 1987, after his arrest, a doctor examined injuries on his face, his arms and his back. The doctor dated them to about four weeks earlier.
Two days after the killing, he had met that young woman again. A taxi driver had pointed out the scene of the murder to him, and he had not gone to the police. When he was interviewed, he said he could not remember her name. Each of these points would be put to the jury.
Shirley stood trial at Winchester Crown Court, and the Crown built its case on four main pillars.
The first was the scientific grouping evidence. Material recovered in the investigation had come from a man with the same group as Shirley, a group shared by about 23 percent of the adult male population of Britain. It could not exclude him, and it could not single him out.
The second was the injuries the doctor had seen in January 1987. The Crown said they had been inflicted by the victim as she fought back.
The third was the footwear. The footwear impression could have been made by a pair of Shirley's shoes, and he accepted that he may have been wearing them. The judge told the jury about the sales figures for shoes of that kind.
The fourth was time. Shirley admitted he had been in the area. His own account of the night left about half an hour unexplained, and the Crown argued that this was time enough for the crime.
Around those pillars the prosecution placed the smaller matters: his second meeting with the young woman, his silence after the taxi driver pointed out the scene, and his inability in interview to recall her name.
On January 28, 1988, the jury found him guilty of murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment.
Shirley applied for leave to appeal against his conviction. On May 4, 1989, the full Court of Appeal refused it, holding that the jury had been entitled to convict on the evidence. For the next decade the conviction stood unchallenged in law.
Shirley entered custody at 18 and continued to maintain that he had not committed the murder. In 1992 he staged a protest on a prison roof, and the protest turned into a hunger strike. A journalist took up his case and pursued it for years.
In November 1997 the Criminal Cases Review Commission received Shirley's application to review his conviction.
During its review, the commission arranged new DNA testing of exhibits that had been kept since the investigation. Material that could not be tested at the time of the trial could now be examined with modern methods.
The results did not fit the case the jury had heard. The tests showed that the material came from a man who was not Michael Shirley. The commission referred the conviction to the Court of Appeal on April 20, 2001. The reference rested mainly on the new scientific evidence.
The second appeal turned on a single proposition. The Crown accepted that the material recovered in the investigation came, at least in part, from a man who was not the appellant. It could keep the conviction alive only by showing that this man was not the killer.
The Crown therefore put forward a narrow case. It disavowed any suggestion that two men were involved. It maintained that Shirley alone was the killer, and that the unidentified man had been with her earlier and had nothing to do with her death. The Crown accepted that, for the conviction to be safe, the court would have to be sure of that account.
The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) handed down its judgment on July 29, 2003. It rejected the Crown's two-man account. It found that the evidence pointed to the material having been left by the killer. It also found an earlier encounter unlikely, because a friend's evidence showed that the victim had been with her for almost all of that day. The court concluded that the "overwhelming probability" was that one man had left all of the material, and that man was the killer. Shirley could not have been that man.
The court then weighed the rest of the prosecution case against that finding, and none of it survived. The injuries evidence did not dislodge it. Nothing recovered in the investigation had been linked to Shirley, and no one had seen injuries on him in the days after the killing. The criticism that the trial judge had leaned too heavily on local sales of the shoes was rejected, but the court held that the footwear evidence, even taken with the injuries, could not overturn the strong probability of a single contributor.
On time, the court found "at least a substantial question mark" over the Crown's case, including the unexplained half hour. The taxi log, the taxi driver's statement and the first statement of the young woman from the club all suggested that the two of them had left the club later than the Crown's case allowed, which compressed the window it had relied on. The court regarded the remaining points, the second meeting, his failure to go to the police and his lapse over her name, as insubstantial. Later tests on his shoe and his clothing tied him to nothing.
The court's conclusion was plain. The Crown's materials did not dispel the strong probability that only one man had left the material, and Shirley could not have been him. The court held that "this appellant's conviction is plainly unsafe," and it made its order in a single sentence: "The appeal will be allowed and the conviction quashed." No retrial was ordered.
Michael Shirley left custody in 2003 after about sixteen years. He was in his mid-thirties when he was released. His case is counted among wrongful convictions with affirmative evidence of innocence: the new testing did not merely weaken the prosecution but showed that the killer was someone else.
Shortly after the conviction was quashed, Hampshire police reopened the murder investigation and appealed for new information.
In March 2019 Hampshire police said that a review of all the information and evidence available in the case was ongoing as part of routine work. No one else had been charged. The only person ever convicted of her murder had been cleared by the Court of Appeal, and her killer was still unidentified.
The identity of the killer is unknown. The Court of Appeal's finding means only that Shirley could not have been the man who left the material recovered in the investigation; the court did not identify anyone else. As of March 2019, no one else had been charged, tried or convicted in the case.
December 9, 1986: The murder is committed in the Buckland district of Portsmouth.
January 6, 1987: After his arrest, Michael Shirley is examined by a doctor.
January 28, 1988: Winchester Crown Court jury convicts Shirley of murder; life imprisonment.
May 4, 1989: The full Court of Appeal refuses leave to appeal.
1992: Shirley stages a rooftop protest that becomes a hunger strike.
November 1997: The Criminal Cases Review Commission receives his application.
April 20, 2001: The commission refers the conviction to the Court of Appeal.
July 29, 2003: The Court of Appeal quashes the conviction as "plainly unsafe"; no retrial.
2003: Hampshire police reopen the murder inquiry.
March 2019: Hampshire police say a review of the evidence is ongoing.