The Murder of Ken McElroy

Victims
1 man killed in Skidmore, Missouri, July 10, 1981; unsolved. No one has been charged; state and federal grand juries returned no indictment.
Years active
July 10, 1981
Location
Skidmore, Nodaway County, Missouri (killing)
Method
Shot; the person or persons responsible were never identified
Status
The county prosecutor found the evidence insufficient for trial. Unsolved; no one charged as of April 2026.

On July 10, 1981, Kenneth Rex McElroy was killed in Skidmore, a farm town in Nodaway County, in the northwest corner of Missouri. That same month a coroner's jury found that he had been killed by "person or persons unknown." A state grand jury heard the witnesses that year, and a federal grand jury heard them again the next. Neither returned an indictment. As of April 2026 no one has been charged with his murder, and the case remains open and unsolved.

He had been charged over the years with nearly two dozen felonies, from burglary and livestock theft to arson, assault and sexual offenses, and almost none ended in a conviction; a 1976 assault trial ended in acquittal. In 1981 a Harrison County jury, hearing a case moved there on a change of venue, convicted him of second-degree assault over a July 1980 attack on a Skidmore man, and he received a two-year term, the first felony conviction of his life. Most accounts say his appeal was still pending, and he was free on bond, when he died, though two later reports describe the conviction as overturned or successfully appealed. A hearing on the county prosecutor's request to revoke that bond had been set for July 10, 1981, and was postponed that morning.

The people who had been nearby when he died told investigators that they had not seen who was responsible. His wife was the exception: she told investigators that she had seen who did it, and she gave the same account to the coroner's jury, to the county prosecutor, to the FBI and to the grand juries. No other witness supported it. The coroner's jury set her identification aside, the state grand jury found no corroboration for it, and no charge was ever brought against anyone.

The FBI then sent agents to Skidmore to question residents, and a federal grand jury heard the witnesses in its turn. It returned no indictment, and the case went back to the county prosecutor, who concluded that there was not enough evidence to take anyone to trial. In all, six law enforcement agencies took part in the investigation at one stage or another, and none built a case that a prosecutor was willing to bring to court. The file now sits among the county's cold cases, and no witness present in 1981 has ever, in any proceeding, named the person responsible.

No court has ever found who caused his death. His wife's identification was heard by the coroner's jury and by the grand juries; no other witness corroborated it, the coroner's jury set it aside, and no indictment or charge followed against anyone. It remains an account that no court tested.

How many people were involved has never been established in law; no inquest, grand jury or court has made a finding on the point. The case has been widely described in the press as vigilante justice, as in an Associated Press report in 2019 on a documentary series about it; that is a characterization, not a finding, and no court has ruled on motive.

The long list of crimes charged against him is itself largely unproven. His one felony conviction, for second-degree assault, was under appeal at his death by most accounts, and the earlier charges ended in acquittal, dismissal or no prosecution. The record against him outside that single verdict consists of accusations and charges, not findings.

Timeline

June 1, 1934: He is born.

1976: He is tried for assault; a jury finds him not guilty.

July 1980: He is accused of assaulting a Skidmore man and is arrested.

1981: On a change of venue to Harrison County, a jury convicts him of second-degree assault; he receives a two-year term and is freed on bond pending appeal.

July 10, 1981: A hearing on revoking his bond is postponed; he is killed in Skidmore later that day.

July 1981: A coroner's jury returns a verdict of death by "person or persons unknown."

1981: A state grand jury hears the witnesses and returns no indictment.

1982: A federal grand jury returns no indictment; the county prosecutor finds the evidence insufficient for trial.

April 2026: The case remains unsolved; no one has been charged.