Joseph Bowne Elwell died in Manhattan on the morning of June 11, 1920. He was rich, well known in the city's society and better known still to the card players of the day, who counted him the country's leading authority on bridge. The police who arrived that morning first took the case for a suicide attempt. That view did not last. New York City's chief medical examiner, head of an office the city had created only in 1918 to replace its old coroner system, ruled the death a homicide, and from then on it was a murder inquiry.
It never became anything more. The Manhattan district attorney's office spent the summer of 1920 on the case. No one was arrested. No one was charged. By 1928 the case had been dropped and filed as unsolved, and it has stayed that way for more than a century.
The man at the center of it had made his name and his money at the card table. Bridge was then passing from the older bridge-whist to auction bridge, and he became the leading American authority on both. A run of books carried his name and spread his reputation. He taught the game for fees, and his pupils included some of the wealthiest players in New York.
Cards paid, and so did wagers. He made a good living betting on horses and on cards, and he held a share in a racing stable. By 1920 he was a man of means who moved easily among bankers, politicians and the very rich, several of whom were guests at his table.
That circle became the inquiry's ground. Nothing appeared to have been taken, and investigators had no clear motive to follow and no obvious suspect. Detectives and the district attorney's staff worked through the bridge expert's friends, business associates and acquaintances while the press followed every turn. Each new name drew fresh headlines, and each lead ended without a charge. None of the people whose names filled the papers that summer was ever accused of the killing in any court.
The inquiry wound down the same way it had run. A 1928 retrospective put it plainly: when nothing could be proved, the case was dropped and tagged unsolved.
Because no one was ever charged, every account of who was responsible rests on theory: in 1920 the theories ran from suicide to murder by a man or by a woman, and a book-length study of 1987 and 1988 argued for a crime of passion, but no court has ever tested any of them. The early suicide view was set aside by the medical examiner's ruling and was never revived in any official finding. No one has ever been identified as the killer, and the case remains unsolved.
1918: New York City establishes the Office of Chief Medical Examiner, replacing the coroner system.
June 11, 1920: He dies in Manhattan; police first treat the case as a suicide attempt, and the chief medical examiner rules it a homicide.
Summer 1920: The district attorney's office questions his associates; no one is arrested or charged.
1928: The case is described as dropped and classed as unsolved.
2026: The case remains unsolved.