The Murder of Ilaria Alpi

Victims
2 murders (Mogadishu, 1994). The only man convicted was acquitted on review in 2016; no one else has been charged.
Years active
March 20, 1994
Location
Mogadishu, Somalia (killings); Rome, Italy (trials); Perugia, Italy (review trial)
Method
Shot by a group of about seven armed men (prosecution and press accounts); the killers have never been identified.
Status
The one man convicted was acquitted on review and freed October 19, 2016, and compensated in 2018. Unsolved: the Rome inquiry was formally still open as of March 2024.

On March 20, 1994, two Italians were killed in Mogadishu, the capital of Somalia, during the last weeks of the international military presence in the country. Ilaria Alpi, a Roman, and Miran Hrovatin, from Trieste, had come to Somalia on assignment for Italian state television. A Somali driver and a guard who were with them survived. The deaths opened an inquiry that has outlasted three decades, three trials in Rome, a parliamentary commission and a review trial in Perugia, and it has never answered the two questions at its heart: who killed them, and why.

Only one man was ever convicted. A Somali who had traveled to Italy in 1998 to give evidence about the conduct of Italian troops in his country was arrested on the word of a single witness, acquitted, convicted on appeal, and sentenced in 2002 to 26 years. In 2016 the Court of Appeal of Perugia acquitted him "per non aver commesso il fatto," for not having committed the act, after the witness admitted that he had invented his account. By then he had spent about 16 years in custody. The people who carried out the killings, and anyone who may have ordered them, have never been identified, and as of March 2024 the judicial inquiry in Rome was formally still open.

The woman at the center of the case was born and raised in Rome. She studied Arabic at university and lived for a time in Cairo. By early 1994 she had been following events in Somalia for about two years, and the journey that ended in Mogadishu was her seventh visit to the country.

Her companion on that last journey came from Trieste. The two had come to Somalia to cover the end of the international mission that had begun in 1992, when a United States-led operation, Restore Hope, arrived under United Nations authority to protect the delivery of aid during the Somali civil war. The fighting had not stopped. By March 1994 the American contingent was leaving, and the withdrawal was the story the two Italians had come to cover.

They died in Mogadishu on March 20, 1994, at the hands of men who have never been identified. The public prosecutor's office in Rome opened an investigation two days later. In 1996 prosecutors registered a Somali regional leader as a suspected instigator; his position was later archived, the Italian term for a case closed without charges.

In October 1997 a Somali man presented himself to the police in Rome. He said that he had been present on March 20, 1994, and that he could identify one of the men responsible. Shown a video, he picked out a fellow Somali.

That man was in Italy in January 1998 because he had come to testify about alleged abuses by Italian soldiers during the first United Nations mission in Somalia. On January 12, 1998, he was arrested in Rome and accused of the double murder. The driver who had survived also named him.

Before the trial began, the first accuser disappeared. He never testified in court, his pretrial statements were never confirmed before a judge, and the driver said that he had not seen that man at the scene. Three Somali witnesses told the court that the accused had been in another city, about 200 kilometers away, when the Italians died.

The first trial was heard by the Corte d'assise of Rome, which acquitted him on July 20, 1999, finding the identification evidence unreliable. On appeal, the Corte d'assise d'appello of Rome overturned that verdict on November 24, 2000, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. On October 10, 2001, the Court of Cassation, Italy's highest court for criminal matters, upheld the murder conviction but found premeditation not proved and sent the case back for a new hearing on sentence. On June 26, 2002, the term was fixed at 26 years, and the judgment became final.

On July 31, 2003, the Italian Chamber of Deputies set up a parliamentary commission of inquiry into the deaths. It sat until early 2006 and ended divided. The majority report, approved on February 23, 2006, concluded that the deaths had resulted from an attempted robbery or kidnapping that went wrong. Two minority reports pointed instead toward the trafficking of arms and toxic waste through Somalia.

The commission's work also cast doubt on the conviction. Its 2006 report questioned the testimony of the vanished witness and sent the material to the prosecutor general in Perugia, though no review followed at the time.

In 2007 the Rome prosecutors asked a judge to archive the remaining inquiry, the one into anyone other than the convicted man, arguing that no evidence pointed to another person. In 2010 the judge for preliminary investigations refused and ordered further inquiries. One of them concerned a confidential intelligence source who had given information about the killings in 1997. In 2008 and again in 2018 the authorities declined to disclose his identity, and he has never testified.

In November 2010 the first accuser was brought to trial in Rome on a charge of calunnia, the Italian offense of knowingly accusing an innocent person of a crime. On January 18, 2013, the Tribunal of Rome acquitted him.

In February 2015 a television crew found the original accuser in Birmingham, England. In an interview broadcast on February 16, 2015, he said that he had not been present on March 20, 1994, and that the man he had accused was innocent. That same year, with about 10 years of his sentence left to serve, the convicted man was released into the custody of the social services.

On January 14, 2016, the Court of Appeal of Perugia opened a review of the conviction, known in Italy as revisione. In June the former witness told the review court that he had never told anyone the defendant was part of the group. On October 19, 2016, with the prosecutor general's office itself asking for acquittal, the court cleared him of the double murder "per non aver commesso il fatto," and he was released at once. On March 30, 2018, the same court awarded him 3.181 million euros in compensation for his wrongful detention, which accounts put at between more than 16 and almost 17 years.

The ruling prompted another inquiry. On February 17, 2017, Rome prosecutors opened a file on suspected irregularities in the way the false witness had been handled in Italy, with no suspect named.

On July 4, 2017, the Rome prosecutors again asked a judge to archive the investigation into the killings, arguing that neither the killers nor anyone who had ordered the crime could be identified and that there was no proof of a cover-up. On June 26, 2018, the judge refused and gave investigators 180 days for further steps. A second request, on February 6, 2019, ended the same way: on October 4, 2019, the judge for preliminary investigations rejected it and ordered a new round of inquiries.

The man the Perugia court had cleared went back to Mogadishu after his release. He was killed there in July 2022; no group claimed responsibility, and no one has been charged.

As of March 2024, thirty years after the deaths, the judicial inquiry in Rome was formally still open, and neither the killers nor anyone who ordered the crime had been identified.

No court has ever found who carried out the killings or why. The only man convicted was acquitted on review "per non aver commesso il fatto," and the witness whose account put him in prison was himself acquitted of calunnia in 2013, two years before he publicly withdrew that account.

The motive remains unproven. The parliamentary commission's majority and minority reports reached opposite conclusions, neither has been tested at trial, and the confidential intelligence source of 1997 has never testified.

Timeline

1992: The United States-led operation Restore Hope begins in Somalia under United Nations authority.

March 20, 1994: Two Italians are killed in Mogadishu; their driver and a guard survive.

March 22, 1994: The Rome prosecutor's office opens an investigation.

1996: A Somali regional leader is registered as a suspected instigator; his position is later archived without charge.

October 1997: A Somali witness tells the police in Rome that he was present on March 20, 1994, and picks out a fellow Somali from a video.

January 12, 1998: The man he picked out, in Italy to testify about alleged abuses by Italian soldiers, is arrested in Rome.

July 20, 1999: The Corte d'assise of Rome acquits him.

November 24, 2000: The Corte d'assise d'appello of Rome convicts him and imposes life imprisonment.

October 10, 2001: The Court of Cassation upholds the murder conviction, rejects premeditation and orders a new hearing on sentence.

June 26, 2002: The sentence is fixed at 26 years and becomes final.

July 31, 2003: The Chamber of Deputies sets up a parliamentary commission of inquiry.

February 23, 2006: The commission approves its majority report; two minority reports are filed.

2007: Rome prosecutors ask to archive the inquiry into anyone other than the convicted man.

2010: A judge rejects the request and orders further inquiries.

November 2010: The original accuser goes on trial in Rome for calunnia.

January 18, 2013: The Tribunal of Rome acquits the accuser.

February 16, 2015: The accuser says in a television interview that the convicted man is innocent; the convicted man is released to the social services later that year.

January 14, 2016: The Court of Appeal of Perugia opens a review trial.

October 19, 2016: The Court of Appeal of Perugia acquits him "per non aver commesso il fatto"; he is released.

February 17, 2017: Rome prosecutors open an inquiry into the handling of the false witness.

July 4, 2017: Rome prosecutors ask again to archive the murder inquiry.

March 30, 2018: The Court of Appeal of Perugia awards him 3.181 million euros in compensation.

June 26, 2018: The judge rejects the archiving request and orders 180 days of further inquiries.

February 6, 2019: Rome prosecutors ask a second time to archive.

October 4, 2019: The judge rejects the second request and orders a new round of inquiries.

July 2022: The man cleared in Perugia is killed in Mogadishu; no one is charged.

March 2024: Thirty years after the deaths, the Rome inquiry remains formally open.