The Murder of Helen Jewett

Victims
1 murder, unsolved; one man tried and acquitted, June 1836; no conviction
Years active
April 9 to 10, 1836
Location
Manhattan, New York City, New York (killing; trial); Augusta, Maine (early life)
Method
Struck with a hatchet (cause of death as published in 1836)
Status
R.P.R. acquitted, June 1836; he left for Texas and died in Louisville, Kentucky, in 1855. No one has been convicted; the case remained unsolved as of 2026.

In the spring of 1836 a young woman from Maine died violently in Manhattan. She had come to the city some years earlier and lived there under a name she chose for herself, Helen Jewett. Police, witnesses and printers used Helen and Ellen interchangeably, but she signed her own letters with an H.

She died on the night of Saturday, April 9, 1836. New York police arrested a 19-year-old clerk, R.P.R., who had known her for months. He was tried for murder before the Court of Oyer and Terminer for New York County in a trial that opened on June 2, 1836, and the jury acquitted him that same month. No court has ever found anyone responsible for her death.

She was born Dorcas Doyen in 1813 and came from Augusta, Maine. As a girl she was placed in service with the family of a prominent Maine judge, and she grew up working in that household. As a young woman she left Maine for New York, where she lived under a succession of assumed names before settling on the one by which the city came to know her. She kept up a steady correspondence with the men she knew, and the letters she wrote are among the few direct traces of her own voice.

R.P.R. was born in 1817 and came to New York from Connecticut, and in 1836 he was working in the city as a clerk. He and the young woman had carried on a relationship for several months, and it had ended a short time before her death. Like her, he went by an assumed name in the circle they shared.

New York police gathered evidence and arrested him on suspicion of her murder in April 1836. The case became one of the first true-crime sensations of the American press, and the city and its papers divided sharply over the dead woman and the accused.

At his trial the charge placed her death on "the night of the 9th of April, 1836." The defense set out an alibi for the accused and proposed that some other man had been responsible. The jury acquitted R.P.R. in June 1836.

Within days of the verdict he left New York for Texas, and he died in 1855 in Louisville, Kentucky. The acquittal remained the last word the law spoke on the case, and in law he died an acquitted man.

The central question, who caused her death, has no legal answer. The only man tried was acquitted, and the acquittal stands. His relationship with her, its ending and his departure for Texas are not proof of guilt, and no court ever found otherwise.

The alibi the defense offered and its suggestion of another killer were never tested in any later proceeding. The belief that the accused had been made to stand in for wealthier men was the talk of the city in 1836 and was never established.

Timeline

1813: Born in Maine.

Childhood: placed in service with the family of a Maine judge.

As a young woman: leaves Maine for New York, where she lives under assumed names.

1817: R.P.R. born; he later moves from Connecticut to New York.

Saturday, April 9, 1836: she dies in Manhattan.

April 1836: New York police arrest R.P.R.

June 2, 1836: his trial for murder opens before the Court of Oyer and Terminer for New York County.

June 1836: the jury acquits him.

Days after the verdict: he leaves New York for Nacogdoches, Texas, and lives under another name.

1855: he dies in Louisville, Kentucky.