On the night of February 25, 1996, Haing S. Ngor was killed in Los Angeles, on the edge of Chinatown. He had survived the four years of Khmer Rouge rule in Cambodia, crossed into exile in 1980, and won an Academy Award for playing Dith Pran in The Killing Fields, a film about the fall of his own country. Two months later, prosecutors charged three young men from a Chinatown street gang with murder and robbery, and in 1998 the three were convicted of the robbery and the killing.
The case did not end there. More than two decades later, a Los Angeles court ruled that under California's amended murder law no reasonable jury could convict Tak Sun Tan of murder. His murder conviction was vacated in 2020, his robbery conviction stood, and in January 2024 he was released from federal custody.
He had lived through the Khmer Rouge years from 1975 to 1979 and escaped the country in 1980, eventually settling in Los Angeles. The role that made him known around the world came from a story close to his own: Dith Pran had been trapped in Cambodia when the Khmer Rouge seized power in 1975. The performance won him the Academy Award for best supporting actor, and he had never acted before. After the award he went back to Cambodia to deliver aid and build health clinics, and he spoke openly against the Khmer Rouge.
In the first days after his death police had no suspects, and no one came forward as a witness to the killing itself. The case detectives built was circumstantial, resting on witnesses who had seen the young men in the neighborhood, and the investigation concluded that the killing was a street robbery.
Two of the eventual defendants were already in custody by the spring of 1996. Jason Chan, 18, and Indra Lim, 19, had been arrested on an unrelated robbery charge. On April 26, 1996, police arrested Tak Sun Tan, 19, and that same day prosecutors charged all three with the murder and robbery. The three were identified as members of the Oriental Lazyboys, a Chinatown street gang. Because the killing was charged as having taken place during a robbery, all three faced a possible death sentence if convicted. From the start the defendants denied any part in it.
The three were tried together in Los Angeles County Superior Court beginning in February 1998, almost exactly two years after the killing. The prosecution's case was that they had killed him in the course of a robbery. Tan's jury found him guilty of first degree murder and robbery, and the court sentenced him to 56 years to life. Tan and two others were convicted in 1998 of the robbery and the killing. Tan also faced a federal sentence of about 13 years from a separate robbery conviction, to be served after his state term.
On January 1, 2019, a new California law, Senate Bill 1437, narrowed when an accomplice in a felony could be convicted of murder and let people convicted under the old rules petition to have their murder convictions vacated. Tan petitioned under the new section 1170.95. After an evidentiary hearing, the court held that no reasonable jury could convict him of murder under current law and granted the petition. On August 17, 2020, it vacated the murder conviction and resentenced him on the robbery count alone, to a determinate term of 16 years. Because he had already served more than 24 years in state custody, he was released on time served and handed over to begin his federal sentence.
His parole term then went to appeal. On August 19, 2021, the California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, held that a later statute, Penal Code section 3000.01, capped his parole at two years and reduced it from three to two.
In federal custody, the Federal Bureau of Prisons at first did not credit his extra years in state prison against his federal sentence; in 2022 it agreed to recalculate the sentence. Immigration authorities then sought to remove him from the country, and his removal was deferred. Tan was released from federal custody on January 17, 2024.
The motive was contested from the first week. Political and business theories about his death were reported at the time, but no charge or court finding has tied the killing to either; the case prosecutors put to the juries was a street robbery.
The evidence against the defendants was circumstantial. The prosecution's main witness recanted at the preliminary hearing in July 1996, saying he had been pressured by police, and the defense maintained throughout that the wrong men had been charged. Tan's murder conviction no longer stands: in 2020 a Los Angeles court held that no reasonable jury could convict him of murder under current law. His robbery conviction remains.
1975 to 1979: Khmer Rouge rule in Cambodia, which he survives.
1980: He escapes Cambodia and later settles in Los Angeles.
February 25, 1996: He is killed in the Chinatown district of Los Angeles.
April 26, 1996: Tan is arrested; Tan, Jason Chan and Indra Lim are charged with murder and robbery.
July 1996: The prosecution's main witness recants at the preliminary hearing.
February 1998: The three are tried together in Los Angeles County Superior Court.
1998: Tan and two others are convicted; Tan is sentenced to 56 years to life.
January 1, 2019: Senate Bill 1437 takes effect.
August 17, 2020: Tan's murder conviction is vacated; he is resentenced to 16 years for robbery and released on time served to federal custody.
August 19, 2021: The Court of Appeal reduces his parole term to two years.
2022: The Federal Bureau of Prisons recalculates his federal sentence.
January 17, 2024: Tan is released from federal custody.