On Thursday, October 12, 1944, Georgette Bauerdorf was found dead in West Hollywood, a district that was then unincorporated county land between the city of Los Angeles and Beverly Hills. She was 20 years old, the daughter of an oil executive, and for some months she had spent her Wednesday nights as a volunteer at the Hollywood Canteen, the club where film people entertained enlisted servicemen passing through Los Angeles during the Second World War. The Los Angeles County autopsy surgeon found that she had been killed. Sheriff's investigators spent the following weeks working through the servicemen she had danced with and the men she had befriended.
No one was ever charged. A man who confessed in December withdrew his account within days, and men questioned over the next six years were each cleared. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, which investigated because the killing took place outside any city's limits, still lists it among its unsolved murders.
She was born in New York on May 6, 1924, and moved to Los Angeles in the 1930s. At the end of August 1944 the rest of her family left for the East Coast, and from then on she lived alone in West Hollywood.
She had spent several weeks working at a Los Angeles daily paper in the hope of becoming a reporter, but by the autumn she had no job and was not enrolled in any school. What occupied her was the war. On Wednesday nights she volunteered at the Canteen, one of about 30 young women who took that shift. Like every volunteer there, she had been fingerprinted, photographed and issued a laminated identity card.
She was generous to the men in uniform she met, and that generosity ran well past the Canteen's doors. She paid for evenings out, lent money, offered rides and let servicemen with nowhere else to stay sleep in her living room. When investigators later went through her belongings, they found bundles of letters from men in every branch of the service, thanking her for her hospitality.
One of those men mattered to her more than the others. In June 1944 she had met a private at the Canteen, an artillery trainee from Chicago, and after he was posted to Fort Bliss, Texas, the two kept up a correspondence and spoke by telephone. One of the last entries in her diary recorded a call from him on October 9. She had been planning a trip to El Paso to see him.
Because the address lay in unincorporated territory, the case went not to the Los Angeles Police Department but to the county sheriff, and investigators from the Sheriff's Department's Hollywood station and its headquarters bureau took it over. The scope of the task was set by the way she had lived. Investigators could not draw up a list of the people who knew her, because so many of them were servicemen in transit, known to her by a first name, a letter or an evening's conversation.
Detectives began where her life had been most public. They interviewed more than 100 people connected with the Canteen, but the club kept no record of the names of the servicemen who came through its doors, and many of the men had already moved on. They went through her datebook and diary and compiled names from the thank-you letters. Some of those men could be reached only through military security officers, and at least one was stationed at a location the Army would not disclose, so that he could be questioned only through military channels.
The private she had planned to visit was among the first to be reached. He told Army officials that he had met her at the Canteen in June and had not seen her since, although they had written and spoken by telephone. Nothing tied him to her death.
A corporal whom Canteen witnesses remembered was traced next. He came forward, accounted for his movements and was eliminated. Two former employees were questioned and cleared in turn.
Every lead was checked against federal, state and Army records, and no identification came of it. One entry in her datebook, a name and a title written for October 10, two days before her death, was never traced to anyone. A coroner's inquest was held on October 20, 1944, and no charge followed it.
In mid-November 1944, investigators questioned a man already in custody for the killing of two women in downtown Los Angeles. No link was found between him and her death.
At the end of December 1944, a former Navy man walked in to the FBI in San Francisco and gave a rambling account of having killed her. Confronted with the contradictions in his story, he admitted he had invented it, and he was not charged.
Investigators made further inquiries in 1949 about one man and in 1950 about an Army corporal; neither inquiry led to a charge. In 1950 they cleared another man in the case. No one has been charged since.
The Sheriff's Department's own history of the 1940s describes the young woman as a goddaughter of William Randolph Hearst. No independent source confirms that tie.
Accounts of her final hours varied from one Los Angeles newspaper to another in October 1944, and because no one was ever tried, they were never tested in court.
May 6, 1924: She is born in New York.
1930s: She moves to Los Angeles.
June 1944: She meets an artillery trainee at the Canteen; they correspond after he is posted to Fort Bliss, Texas.
August 28, 1944: Her family leaves for the East Coast; she lives alone in West Hollywood.
October 12, 1944: She is found dead in West Hollywood; the Sheriff's Department takes the case.
October 1944: Investigators interview more than 100 people connected with the Canteen; a corporal and two former employees are cleared.
October 20, 1944: The county coroner holds an inquest; no charge follows.
November 1944: A man in custody for two other killings is questioned; no link is found.
December 1944: A former Navy man confesses to the FBI in San Francisco, then admits he invented the account; he is not charged.
1949 and 1950: Further inquiries about two men lead to no charge.
Present: The Sheriff's Department lists the murder as unsolved.