The Murder of Edmund Berry Godfrey

Victims
1 London magistrate's death, 1678; never solved. Three men convicted and executed in 1679 on the evidence of a witness who later pleaded guilty to perjury are widely held innocent.
Years active
October 1678
Location
London, England (killing; found near Primrose Hill); Westminster Hall, London, England (trial); London, England (executions)
Method
Strangled, by contemporary findings; the 1679 jury accepted murder, but who killed him has never been established
Status
All three found guilty February 10, 1679 (convictions never overturned; guilt disputed). Green and Hill executed in London February 21, 1679; Berry executed in London February 28, 1679.

In the autumn of 1678 a London justice of the peace named Sir Edmund Berry Godfrey died at the hands of a person or persons never identified, and his death turned a political scare into open panic. Weeks earlier he had taken the sworn statements of Titus Oates, the informer behind the Popish Plot, a fictitious conspiracy to assassinate Charles II. He was found dead near Primrose Hill, then open country north of Westminster, on the evening of Thursday, October 17. Within days the King had issued a proclamation for the discovery of the murderers and Parliament had opened its own inquiry, and by the end of the year three men were in prison on the word of a Covent Garden goldsmith who had confessed, withdrawn his confession and confessed again.

Robert Green, Henry Berry and Lawrence Hill were tried at the King's Bench bar in Westminster Hall on February 10, 1679, and a jury found all three guilty of the murder. They were executed in London later that month. The man whose evidence convicted them later pleaded guilty to perjury, and the three are widely held to have been innocent. No other person was ever charged. More than three centuries later, the questions the jury thought it had answered remain open: whether the magistrate was murdered at all, and if so, by whom.

He was born on December 23, 1621. He was educated at Westminster School and at Christ Church, Oxford, and went on to study law, but ill health and deafness kept him from finishing. In 1650 he set up in London as a wood and coal merchant.

He lived in Westminster, in the district around Charing Cross, and his parish church was St Martin-in-the-Fields. He held the unpaid office of justice of the peace for both Westminster and the county of Middlesex. The office made him the man to whom his neighbors brought their complaints, the local officer who kept the peace and received accusations of crime.

He was knighted in 1666, the year of the Great Fire. Accounts of the honor differ in emphasis: one ties it to his part in helping to put down the fire, another to his courage and diligence through both the plague and the Fire, when other officials fled.

Little of his private life survives. One rare survival is a small leather-backed letterbook in the National Library of Ireland, holding seventeenth-century copies of his letters to Valentine Greatrakes, the Irish healer known as "the stroker"; they may be the only personal letters of his to survive from the late 1660s and early 1670s. The gap has a cause of its own: shortly before his death he was said to have burned a great many of his papers.

Some weeks before his death, Oates came before the Westminster magistrate and swore to his story. The examinations were sealed, and the men who spoke with him afterward recalled someone who felt the weight of what he had done. Two of them later gave the House of Commons his words. To one he said, "I believe I shall be the first Martyr." To the other, five or six days before his death, he said that he was "threatened by others."

After his death the sealed examinations were found in a drawer in his study. They were brought to the House of Commons on October 23, 1678, and the next day the Speaker opened them and read them to the House.

He left his house on the morning of Saturday, October 12, 1678, and was probably killed later that day. He was found dead on the evening of Thursday, October 17, several miles outside Westminster, near Primrose Hill.

The news went through London at speed. The magistrate who had sworn the Plot's chief informer was dead, and to a public already primed by Oates's story the meaning seemed obvious. Within hours two explanations were competing: that he had been murdered, and that he had taken his own life. Those who spoke for the second were accused of covering up the first.

On October 20, 1678, the King issued a proclamation from Whitehall for the discovery of the murderers, printed as a broadside by the royal printers. The next day the House of Commons appointed a committee "to examine concerning the Murder" and to "inquire into the Manner and Means how he came by his Death," with power to send for persons, papers and records. The House of Lords set up a committee of its own, and kept its examinations private until they were complete.

The first witness to claim knowledge of the death was a second informer of the Plot, who came forward in November 1678 with an account he gave to both Houses.

The case that went to trial came from Miles Prance, a goldsmith of Covent Garden. News of the magistrate's death had made him an object of suspicion, and late in 1678 he was held in prison in London. There he confessed and recanted several times. In the version on which he finally settled, he named three men: Robert Green, Henry Berry and Lawrence Hill, working men of no great standing. On December 28, 1678, at the request of the House of Commons, the King agreed to a special commission to try the men in prison for the murder.

The three men were arraigned at the King's Bench bar in Westminster Hall and tried on February 10, 1679, before the Lord Chief Justice. The prosecution rested on the evidence of Prance and the second informer, and its account placed the killing among men of the Queen's household.

The jury found all three prisoners guilty. On February 11 they were sentenced to death.

Green and Hill were executed in London on Friday, February 21, 1679. Berry was executed in London a week later, on Friday, February 28.

Pamphlets printed in London that year described the condemned men as penitent, but none has any of the three admitting the murder in his own words, and the three maintained their innocence to the end. Their refusal to confess left many convinced that whoever had really killed the magistrate was still at liberty.

Prance later pleaded guilty to perjury. The men his evidence had sent to their deaths were long past any remedy.

In 1686 James II gave the royalist writer Roger L'Estrange a warrant to reopen the inquiry into the magistrate's death, with the aim of discrediting the Plot. L'Estrange gathered copies of the original depositions and took new statements from witnesses. In April 1686 he wrote to William Lloyd, by then bishop of St Asaph, who in October 1678 had been curate of the magistrate's parish and had questioned the leading witnesses and the suspects, among them the three men later executed.

In 1688 L'Estrange published the third volume of his "Brief History of the Times," which argued that the magistrate had taken his own life, and cited Lloyd's replies in support. Much of the evidence L'Estrange collected has since been lost or destroyed, and his partisan account has shaped almost every later version of the case.

How the magistrate died remains contested. The jury of 1679 accepted the prosecution's case of murder. L'Estrange argued in 1688 that he had died by suicide. Roger North, a lawyer of the period, rejected suicide outright and held that the magistrate had been murdered at the direction of the same unseen men who had launched the Plot.

Who was responsible, if he was killed, has never been settled. Over three centuries the theories put forward by writers and historians have pointed to Catholic plotters, to figures at the court of Charles II, to opponents of the court among the Whig lords, and to the magistrate himself. None has been proven. Lloyd's private shorthand drafts of his replies to L'Estrange, held in the Gloucestershire Archives and deciphered only in the 2020s, argue nearly the opposite of what L'Estrange printed: Lloyd insisted that the magistrate had been murdered, and hinted that he knew who was responsible.

On one point modern writers largely agree. The case against Green, Berry and Hill rested on a man who confessed and recanted repeatedly and who later pleaded guilty to perjury, and the curate who questioned them, like the historians who have studied them since, counted them innocent men. The convictions of February 10, 1679, were never overturned and remain the only judicial finding ever made on the death.

His own words in his final weeks show that he believed himself in danger. They do not show from whom.

Timeline

December 23, 1621: Born.

1650: Sets up as a wood and coal merchant in London.

1666: Knighted.

1678: Titus Oates swears his examinations before the Westminster magistrate.

October 12, 1678: Leaves his house in Westminster; probably killed that day.

October 17, 1678: Found dead near Primrose Hill, north of Westminster.

October 20, 1678: Royal proclamation for the discovery of the murderers.

October 21, 1678: The House of Commons appoints a committee to examine the murder.

October 23 and 24, 1678: The sealed examinations of Oates are delivered to the Commons and read in the House.

Late 1678: Miles Prance held in prison in London; confesses and recants several times; names Robert Green, Henry Berry and Lawrence Hill.

December 28, 1678: The King agrees to a special commission to try the men in prison.

February 10, 1679: Green, Berry and Hill tried at the King's Bench bar, Westminster Hall; found guilty.

February 11, 1679: Sentenced to death.

February 21, 1679: Green and Hill executed in London.

February 28, 1679: Berry executed in London.

1686: Roger L'Estrange receives a royal warrant to reopen the inquiry; in April he writes to William Lloyd, bishop of St Asaph.

1688: L'Estrange publishes the third volume of his "Brief History of the Times," arguing suicide.

2020s: Lloyd's shorthand replies to L'Estrange deciphered.