Charles Bravo was a London barrister who had been married for less than six months when he died in Balham, in the southern suburbs of London, in April 1876. He fell ill on the evening of Tuesday, April 18, and died three days later, without ever saying who he believed was responsible. A first coroner's inquest, whose proceedings were kept from the press, returned an open verdict. The way it had been run was questioned in the House of Commons within weeks, the Home Secretary declared himself dissatisfied, and the inquiry was reopened. The second jury sat for about five weeks and concluded that Bravo had been murdered, but that the evidence was not enough to name anyone. No one was ever arrested, charged or tried.
The case turned on a small household: Bravo, his wife, and her paid companion, with the shadow of an elderly physician who had once been close to his wife and a coachman Bravo had dismissed. Each was suspected at one time or another, and none was ever brought before a criminal court. The inquest that tried to sort among them became a public sensation, and the questions it raised about how coroners were chosen and how they conducted their inquiries reached Parliament.
Bravo's wife had money of her own, and the terms on which she brought it to the marriage shaped everything that followed. She had first married, at 19, in 1864. Her husband was a wealthy army officer, and the marriage broke down. In late 1870 she left him and went back to her parents, and in April 1871, before any separation had been settled, he died in Cologne. She inherited about £40,000 and settled in Balham.
In the years that followed she formed a close attachment to a well-known physician many years her senior, who bought property near hers. When the relationship became known, it was a scandal across London society. In 1875 she told the physician that she was thinking of marrying again and wished to end their friendship. A few months later she married Charles Bravo.
They had met through her companion, a widow who had once worked for the Bravo family. Under the Married Women's Property Act of 1870, the new wife kept control of her fortune, and Bravo agreed to the marriage only after she had made a will in his favor and leased him the Balham property for the rest of her life.
The marriage was short and quarrelsome. Bravo took over the household accounts, dismissed servants, and told his wife to give up her horses and her garden. He wanted to let the companion go as an unnecessary expense, and his wife refused. In the later inquiry, testimony about how he treated his wife drew a measure of public sympathy toward her, even as the story of her earlier attachment drew scorn.
On the evening of Tuesday, April 18, 1876, Bravo dined with his wife and her companion, and that night he was taken ill. He lived for three days and died in April 1876 without accusing anyone.
From the start the companion insisted that he had taken his own life, and the police at first leaned the same way. Within a week, the detectives had concluded otherwise: everything pointed to murder rather than suicide. A royal physician who had seen him in those three days later wrote to the Home Secretary that he had received no assurance from the dying man that he had not attempted suicide, a letter that left the question exactly where it had been.
The first inquest was held within weeks of the death, and its proceedings were kept from the press. The jury returned an open verdict.
The way that inquiry had been conducted came under attack almost at once, and on May 18, 1876, two members of the House of Commons put questions about it to the Home Secretary. They asked whether the coroner had declined to hear medical men who had offered evidence, whether the depositions had been read back to the witnesses and signed as the law required, whether the physicians and members of the household had been examined, why the proceedings had been kept from the press, and whether a fuller investigation would follow.
The Home Secretary's answers were candid. Four physicians and some of the servants had not been examined; he could not say whether they had offered to give evidence, but their evidence had not been taken. He understood the law to require that statements be read over to witnesses and signed, and that had not been done. No account of the proceedings had been sent to the press until newspapers had already taken up the case. The royal physician had not been called at all.
He then set out what the government had done. Detectives had been put in touch with Bravo's friends, the police had been told to assist, and the case had been placed in the hands of the Solicitor to the Treasury. He had no power over a coroner, he told the House, but he was not satisfied with the way the inquest had been conducted. He had sent the papers to the Law Officers of the Crown for advice on whether to apply to the Court of Queen's Bench for a writ ad melius inquirendum or to take some other step.
The police work that ran alongside the inquests never broke through. A chief inspector led it. The dismissed coachman, the physician and the two women of the household all came under suspicion; the case against any one of them could not be made out.
The coroner's inquiry was reopened, and the second inquest in Balham became a public event. On July 11, 1876, the Commons debated a resolution on the qualification and appointment of coroners and the conduct of inquests. One member, arguing that inquests too often had to be reopened, gave "the case of Mr. Bravo" as his example. The Home Secretary asked the House not to tie the resolution to a recent case. The motion passed without a division.
This time the evidence was heard in full, and much of it concerned the household rather than the night of April 18. The companion, who had kept a damaging secret about her mistress's past, gave it up under questioning. The widow was examined about her earlier attachment to the physician in a session that became a humiliation in public. Opinion divided sharply. Some were outraged by what she admitted; others saw her as a figure who deserved sympathy.
After about five weeks of evidence, the jurors gave their finding. Charles Bravo had been murdered, but the evidence was insufficient to name the person who had done it. Nobody was charged.
The length of the inquiry raised a practical question that came back to the House two years later. In December 1878, when a member asked whether the jury in another long inquest might receive some public recognition, the minister who replied said that the matter had been considered at the time of the Bravo proceedings, and that no precedent had been found for making a grant to a jury for serving in such matters.
The verdict closed the legal inquiry without closing the case. The widow was never charged or tried. She sold the Balham property about a year after her husband's death and moved to Southsea, where she died in 1878, shortly after her thirty-third birthday.
The physician, whose reputation had suffered but was not ruined, died in Balham in 1883, aged 75. The companion lived on for decades. Five years after the death she was living in Westminster with her grown sons, and she later lived on independent means in Lewisham for about thirty years. She died in 1917, at 91.
The Commons debate of July 1876 ended with agreement that the law of coroners, then spread across more than thirty Acts, needed new legislation. On February 14, 1879, the Home Secretary moved for leave to bring in a bill "to consolidate and amend the Law relating to Coroners," and it was sent to a select committee that month.
Whether Charles Bravo was murdered at all was contested from the first day. The companion maintained that he had taken his own life. The second jury rejected that and found murder, but no court ever tested the finding against an accused person, and some later writers have argued that the death was an accident arising from his own actions rather than a killing.
Every named suspect remained just that. The widow, the companion, the physician and the dismissed coachman were each said at one time or another to have had reason to want Bravo gone, and none was ever charged. Later writers have each argued for a different member of that circle. A leading crime novelist set out her own conclusion in 1968, and a book published early in this century claimed to identify the killer from police reports, medical reports, full witness statements and family papers that the investigators of 1876 had not seen. None of these theories has been tested in any court.
1864: Bravo's future wife, then 19, marries her first husband.
Late 1870: She leaves her first husband and returns to her parents.
April 1871: Her first husband dies in Cologne; she inherits about £40,000.
1875: She tells the physician she plans to remarry and ends their friendship; a few months later she marries Charles Bravo.
April 18, 1876: Bravo is taken ill in Balham.
April 1876: Bravo dies three days later.
Spring 1876: The first inquest returns an open verdict.
May 18, 1876: Members question the Home Secretary in the House of Commons about the inquest; he refers the case to the Law Officers.
July 11, 1876: The Commons debates the appointment of coroners; the Bravo case is cited as an inquest that had to be reopened.
1876: The second inquest sits for about five weeks and finds that Bravo was murdered, with insufficient evidence to name anyone.
1878: The widow dies at Southsea.
December 13, 1878: A minister tells the Commons that no precedent was found for a grant to the Bravo jury.
February 14, 1879: A bill to consolidate and amend the law of coroners is brought in.
1883: The physician dies in Balham.
1917: The companion dies.