Lamont Coleman, who recorded as Big L, was killed in Harlem on the night of February 15, 1999, a few blocks from where he had grown up and first made his name. He had released one album on a major label, had lost that contract, had started his own independent label and was said to be close to a deal with Roc-A-Fella Records when he died. Three months later the New York City Police Department arrested a man who had known him since childhood, and the man was charged with murder in the second degree. The case against him did not hold. It was dropped for insufficient evidence, and he went free without a trial. No one else has ever been charged. More than a quarter of a century later, the killing of one of the most admired lyricists of 1990s New York remains an open case, and the questions it raised in 1999 have never been answered in a courtroom.
He was born on May 30, 1974, in New York City and grew up in a Harlem brownstone. The neighborhood of his youth was known for a violent drug trade, and what he later wrote about was what surrounded him there: the violence, the dealing, the poverty, and the loyalty among the young men who grew up together on the same stoops.
He began to rhyme as a teenager. He practiced on the steps of the buildings on his block and in the halls of his high school, where his skill in the battles that settled a young rapper's standing earned him the name Big L. In the parks of the neighborhood he cleared space for other local rappers, and he took an interest in younger boys on the block who would later become stars in their own right, among them Cameron Giles, known as Cam'ron, and Mason Betha, known as Mase. With them he formed a Harlem group called Children of the Corn.
His way into the record business ran through a Harlem record store, where he met Lord Finesse, the Bronx producer and rapper. After a short display of what the younger man could do, Finesse gave him a verse on the remix of his song "Yes You May," released in 1992, and the verse drew attention well beyond Harlem. The same year he appeared on "Represent," a track by the Bronx duo Showbiz and A.G. He became one of the youngest members of Diggin' in the Crates, the Bronx-based collective of rappers and producers built around Finesse, whose members included Fat Joe and Buckwild.
Columbia Records signed him. Before the album he released singles including "Devil's Son," a dark record that has since been counted among the early examples of the style later called horrorcore, and "Put It On," the closest he came on Columbia to a radio record. Finesse later said the label had wanted a catchy hook that radio would play.
In February 1995 he and Jay-Z traded verses for seven minutes on a New York radio show. The session led to a posse track on the coming album that put him beside Finesse, Jay-Z, Microphone Nut, Party Arty and Grand Daddy I.U.
His debut album, Lifestylez ov da Poor and Dangerous, came out on Columbia on March 28, 1995. Its title played on a television program about the very rich. It had twelve tracks, with guest turns from DJ Kid Capri, Lord Finesse and Jay-Z. Buckwild produced "Put It On," and Finesse produced "M.V.P.," built on a sample of the DeBarge song "Stay With Me." One track, "8 Iz Enough," brought seven rappers from his own neighborhood onto the record, Cam'ron among them; another was a warning about the life the rest of the album described. The record reached No. 22 on Billboard's Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart and No. 149 on the Billboard 200.
That was not enough for Columbia. The album sold below the label's hopes, and the company dropped him. Critics praised the record's lyricism and its rough, underground sound from the start, and its standing grew in the years that followed, until it was regularly described as one of the classics of 1990s New York rap.
He did not stop. He made guest appearances on other artists' records and produced tracks of his own, and in 1998 he founded an independent label, Flamboyant Entertainment, through which he released "Ebonics," one of his best-known records. He was recording a second album. By early 1999 his name was moving again: Dame Dash of Roc-A-Fella Records had begun the process of signing him, and he was said to be close to a deal. Neither the deal nor the album was finished in his lifetime; the album, The Big Picture, came out on Rawkus Records on August 1, 2000.
The killing came on a winter night in the same few blocks he had put into his songs, in the neighborhood that had raised him and that he had never really left, even after the record deals and the radio sessions downtown. Outside the world of New York rap the death drew little notice at first.
The investigation belonged to the New York City Police Department, and at first it moved quickly. In May 1999, about three months after the killing, police arrested a man from the same block who had known him since they were children, and the man was charged with murder in the second degree.
The early police theory did not center on the rapper himself. Detectives believed the killing was retaliation aimed at one of his older brothers, who was in prison at the time; a second account held that he had been mistaken for that brother. Neither was ever tested before a jury.
The case never reached one. The charge was dropped for insufficient evidence, and the man was released without a trial. He was never convicted, and no one else was ever charged. In June 2016 he was himself killed in Harlem, and investigators did not connect his death to the 1999 case. The killing of February 1999 remained unsolved in September 2026, more than 27 years after it happened.
The motive has never been established in court. Both explanations offered in 1999, retaliation aimed at an imprisoned brother and a case of mistaken identity, were theories that were never put to a jury.
The man charged in May 1999 was never tried and never convicted, and the charge against him ended without any finding of guilt.
May 30, 1974: He is born in New York City; he grows up in Harlem.
1992: He appears on the remix of Lord Finesse's "Yes You May" and on Showbiz and A.G.'s "Represent," and joins the Diggin' in the Crates collective.
February 1995: He and Jay-Z trade verses on a New York radio show, a session that leads to a posse track on his first album.
March 28, 1995: Lifestylez ov da Poor and Dangerous is released on Columbia; it reaches No. 22 on Billboard's Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart.
After 1995: Columbia drops him after the album's sales disappoint the label.
1998: He founds the independent label Flamboyant Entertainment and releases "Ebonics."
Early 1999: Roc-A-Fella Records begins the process of signing him.
February 15, 1999: He is killed in Harlem.
May 1999: Police arrest a man from his block; he is charged with murder in the second degree.
1999: The charge is dropped for insufficient evidence, and the man is released without a trial.
June 2016: The man charged in 1999 is killed in Harlem; investigators do not connect his death to the 1999 case.
September 2026: The killing remains unsolved, with no one convicted.