On August 25, 1913, a jury in the Fulton County Superior Court in Atlanta found Leo Max Frank guilty of the murder of a girl who worked at the pencil factory he ran. She had died at the factory four months earlier, on April 26. The state's case rested on the sworn account of the factory's sweeper, a man whose story had changed several times before he told it to the jury and who had himself been held as a suspect. Frank denied the killing from the day he was questioned to the day he died. The judge sentenced him to death the next morning.
What followed made the case one of the most argued-over in American legal history. Frank's appeals went through the Supreme Court of Georgia three times and reached the Supreme Court of the United States, which turned him down in April 1915 over the dissent of two justices. In June 1915 the governor of Georgia commuted his sentence to life imprisonment. Two months after that, about twenty-five men took Frank from the state prison farm at Milledgeville, drove him across the state to Marietta, and lynched him there on the morning of August 17, 1915. No one was ever prosecuted for his death. In 1986 the State Board of Pardons and Paroles granted Frank a posthumous pardon, but it did so in recognition of the state's failures, and it said plainly that it was not deciding whether he was guilty. The murder conviction still stands.
Leo Frank was born in 1884 in Cuero, Texas, and grew up in Brooklyn, New York. He went to the public schools there, studied at the Pratt Institute and then at Cornell University. At the invitation of his uncle, the principal owner of the National Pencil Company, he moved to Atlanta to help set up the company's pencil factory, and he became its superintendent and a part-owner. He married in 1910. Frank was Jewish, and in 1912 he became president of the Atlanta chapter of B'nai B'rith. In the spring of 1913 he was 29 years old, a manager who spent much of his working week in the factory office, overseeing a workforce that included children.
The girl who died was one of those children. She worked at the factory, and her family's roots were in Marietta, the town in Cobb County, northwest of Atlanta, that would later figure so heavily in the case. She was killed on Saturday, April 26, 1913. Her death became known early the next morning, and within hours the case had taken hold of the city.
The first man arrested was the factory's night watchman, who was taken into custody on April 27 and held for several days. He was never indicted. On April 28 the police questioned Frank, at first as a matter of routine; he had been at the factory that Saturday. That same day Frank hired a private detective from the Pinkerton agency to work on the case. By April 30 suspicion had begun to turn toward him, and he was held in custody within days of the death.
On May 1 the police arrested the factory's sweeper. On May 8 a coroner's jury ordered the night watchman and Frank both held on murder charges. Testimony at the inquest from factory employees and others had pushed suspicion toward the superintendent, though several of the early statements against him were later retracted.
A Fulton County grand jury indicted Frank for murder in late May 1913. No indictment was sought against the night watchman. The sweeper's position changed over the same weeks. Two notes had been found in the investigation, and under repeated questioning he admitted that he had written them, but he said he had done so on Frank's orders. He gave the police four affidavits in all, each one changing the story, and the last of them became the core of the case against Frank.
The trial opened in the Fulton County Superior Court on July 28, 1913, and ran for about four weeks, one of the longest trials in the state's history to that time. On August 4 the state called its chief witness, the sweeper. He testified that Frank had placed him on watch at the factory that Saturday, that Frank had told him afterward that he had killed the girl, and that Frank had dictated the two notes to him and offered him money to help hide what had happened. He also gave testimony about Frank's conduct on other days, which the defense said was untrue and had nothing to do with the charge. A cross-examination of about sixteen hours exposed lies he had told investigators and gaps in his memory, but it could not shake the center of his account.
The defense set out to show that Frank could not have done what the sweeper described in the time the sweeper allowed. It called more than a hundred witnesses, many to speak to Frank's good character and others to say that the sweeper was not to be believed, and its case was that the sweeper himself was the killer. On August 18 Frank addressed the jury for about four hours. He denied the accusations against him and called the sweeper's account "a tissue of lies."
Crowds filled the courtroom and gathered outside, and spectators had laughed and applauded during the trial. Fearing violence if the jury acquitted, the judge suggested privately to defense counsel that Frank and his lawyers stay away when the verdict was returned. Counsel agreed, and Frank was not in the courtroom on August 25, 1913, when the jury, after only a few hours of deliberation, found him guilty. As the jurors were polled, cheering from the crowd outside could be heard inside. On August 26 the judge sentenced Frank to death.
The defense moved for a new trial on grounds that included the disorder in and around the courtroom, the admission of the sweeper's testimony about other days, and a claim that one juror had been biased against Frank before the trial began. The trial judge denied the motion on October 31, 1913. On February 17, 1914, the Supreme Court of Georgia affirmed the conviction by four votes to two. The majority found that only two incidents of disorder, the laughter and the applause, had taken place within the hearing or knowledge of the jury, and that neither required a new trial. It upheld the testimony about Frank's conduct on other occasions as bearing on motive and plan. The two dissenting justices would have held that the testimony was offered to prejudice the jury.
The sweeper's own case was settled the same month. He was convicted as an accessory and was sentenced on February 24, 1914, to a year on a chain gang.
Two more motions failed in Georgia that year. An extraordinary motion for a new trial, built on the retracted statements and on evidence that undercut parts of the physical case the state had offered at trial, was refused, and on October 14, 1914, the Supreme Court of Georgia affirmed the refusal. A motion to set the verdict aside as a nullity argued for the first time that Frank's absence when the verdict was returned had been involuntary: the judge had suggested it, counsel had agreed, and Frank had known nothing of the arrangement. On November 14, 1914, the Supreme Court of Georgia held that Frank had known the facts of his absence when he moved for a new trial and had not raised them then, so he could not raise them now.
Refused a writ of error to take the case to the Supreme Court of the United States, Frank's lawyers petitioned the United States District Court for the Northern District of Georgia for a writ of habeas corpus. They argued that he was held without the due process of law that the Fourteenth Amendment guaranteed, because a hostile crowd had dominated his trial and because he had been absent, without his consent, when the verdict was delivered. The district court refused the writ on December 21, 1914.
The Supreme Court decided Frank v. Mangum on April 19, 1915, and affirmed by seven votes to two. The majority accepted that a trial actually dominated by a mob would violate due process. But Georgia, it held, had given Frank a corrective process in the new-trial motion and the appeals that followed, its courts had examined his claims of disorder and found them unfounded, and it could treat his presence at the verdict as something counsel could waive. The two dissenting justices, taking the petition's allegations as true, found that it described a packed and hostile courtroom and a roar from the crowd outside so loud that the polling of the jury had to stop. In their view a federal court was obliged to hear such a claim on its facts rather than defer to the state court's findings. The execution was set for June 22, 1915.
With the courts closed to him, Frank's last hope was clemency. The state Prison Commission voted two to one against recommending it, and the decision passed to the governor. More than 100,000 letters asking for mercy reached his office. The governor spent twelve days on the record and went to the factory himself, and on June 21, 1915, the day before the execution date, he commuted Frank's sentence to life imprisonment. His long written statement set out, point by point, physical evidence that he found inconsistent with the state's account at trial.
Frank was moved from the Fulton County jail to the state prison farm at Milledgeville, where he was entered as prisoner number 965. In Atlanta the commutation brought crowds into the streets, and the governor called out the militia to protect his residence.
In July 1915 another inmate at the prison farm attacked Frank and seriously wounded him. Two fellow prisoners who were doctors helped save his life, and he was still recovering on the night of August 16, 1915, when about twenty-five men from Marietta took him from the prison farm. They drove him to Marietta and lynched him there in the early morning of August 17. A Cobb County coroner's jury returned a verdict that he had been lynched by persons unknown. No one was ever charged.
For almost seventy years the record stood where the courts had left it. Then, in March 1982, a man who had been a 14-year-old office boy at the factory in 1913, and who had testified briefly at the trial, signed an affidavit near the end of his life. He said that on the day of the death he had seen the sweeper in the factory lobby, in circumstances that the sweeper's sworn trial account ruled out, and that he had kept silent ever since out of fear.
On January 4, 1983, the Anti-Defamation League applied to the State Board of Pardons and Paroles for a posthumous pardon on the strength of the affidavit. In December 1983 the board refused. It said that "it is impossible to decide conclusively the guilt or innocence of Leo M. Frank," and it found that the new statement did not establish his innocence: even if the sweeper had lied about how he moved through the building, Frank could still have committed the murder.
The applicants came back with a different request. Instead of asking the board to declare Frank innocent, they asked it to acknowledge the state's failure to protect him. On March 11, 1986, all five members of the board signed a posthumous pardon. The board said it acted "without attempting to address the question of guilt or innocence." Proving Frank's innocence beyond any doubt, it said, was a standard almost impossible to meet in a case seventy years old, and it grounded the pardon instead on the state's failure to protect Frank while he was in its custody, a failure that ended his chance to pursue further appeals, and on its failure to bring his killers to justice.
The pardon left the verdict of August 25, 1913, untouched. In 2015 a rabbi filed an extraordinary motion asking that the murder conviction be vacated, and it was not set aside. In May 2019 the Fulton County district attorney announced that a newly created Conviction Integrity Unit, the first in Georgia, would reexamine the case. By then no witness to the events was still alive, the full trial transcript could not be found, and the prosecutor's case files had been lost or destroyed decades earlier. As of 2025 no recommendation had been put before a court and no court had vacated the conviction. In law, Leo Frank remains a man convicted of murder.
The central dispute is who killed the girl. The jury accepted the sweeper's account and found Frank guilty, and two Georgia courts and the Supreme Court of the United States left that verdict in place. Frank denied it to the end, and the man his defense named as the killer was convicted only as an accessory. The governor who commuted the sentence found parts of the state's physical case inconsistent with its account, and the 1982 affidavit challenged the sweeper's sworn testimony directly, but the pardon board found in 1983 that the affidavit did not settle the question, and when it granted the pardon in 1986 it again declined to decide it.
Antisemitism is part of the case's documented history. Frank's defense raised it at trial, and the Georgia Historical Society's marker at Marietta, erected in 2008, describes the trial as shaped by social tensions and antisemitism. The Atlanta History Center likewise names antisemitism, violence and sensational press coverage as features of the trial.
1884: Leo Max Frank is born in Cuero, Texas.
April 26, 1913: A girl who worked at the National Pencil Company dies at the factory in Atlanta.
April 27, 1913: The factory's night watchman is arrested; he is later released without indictment.
April 28, 1913: Police question Frank; he hires a Pinkerton detective.
May 1, 1913: The factory's sweeper is arrested.
May 8, 1913: A coroner's jury orders Frank and the night watchman held.
May 1913: A Fulton County grand jury indicts Frank for murder.
July 28, 1913: The trial opens in the Fulton County Superior Court.
August 4, 1913: The sweeper testifies for the state.
August 18, 1913: Frank addresses the jury for about four hours.
August 25, 1913: The jury finds Frank guilty; he is not in the courtroom.
August 26, 1913: Frank is sentenced to death.
October 31, 1913: The motion for a new trial is denied.
February 17, 1914: The Supreme Court of Georgia affirms the conviction, four votes to two.
February 24, 1914: The sweeper is sentenced to a year on a chain gang as an accessory.
October 14, 1914: The Supreme Court of Georgia affirms the refusal of the extraordinary motion for a new trial.
November 14, 1914: The Supreme Court of Georgia affirms the refusal to set the verdict aside.
December 21, 1914: The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia refuses a writ of habeas corpus.
April 19, 1915: The Supreme Court of the United States affirms in Frank v. Mangum, seven votes to two.
June 21, 1915: The governor commutes the sentence to life imprisonment; Frank is moved to the state prison farm at Milledgeville.
July 1915: Frank survives an assault by another inmate.
August 16 to 17, 1915: About twenty-five men take Frank from the prison farm and lynch him at Marietta.
March 1982: A former office boy at the factory signs an affidavit contradicting the sweeper's account.
December 1983: The State Board of Pardons and Paroles refuses a posthumous pardon.
March 11, 1986: The board grants a posthumous pardon without addressing guilt or innocence.
May 2019: The Fulton County district attorney announces a Conviction Integrity Unit review of the case.