The Killing of Mahmoud al-Mabhouh

Victims
1 murder in Dubai, January 2010; attributed by Dubai police to Israel's Mossad; Israel neither confirmed nor denied; no one tried
Years active
January 19, 2010
Location
Dubai, United Arab Emirates (killing); Jabalia refugee camp, Gaza (birth); Warsaw, Poland (passport arrest); Cologne, Germany (passport case)
Method
Sedated, then suffocated (Dubai police findings, February 28, 2010); no court has tested this
Status
No trial. Interpol red notices for 27 suspects by March 2010 and 35 by 2012. Unsolved; no one tried as of January 2012.

Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, a senior official of the Palestinian group Hamas and one of the founders of its armed wing, died in Dubai on the night of January 19, 2010, the day he arrived in the city from Damascus. Dubai Police concluded within weeks that he had been murdered by a team of more than two dozen people traveling on false or fraudulently obtained British, Irish, French, German and Australian passports, and the emirate's police chief said he was certain that Israel's foreign intelligence service, the Mossad, was behind it. Israel has never confirmed or denied a role. Interpol issued red notices for 27 suspects by March 2010, all of them known only by the names on their passports, and those names turned out in many cases to belong to real people whose identities had been stolen.

No one has stood trial for the killing. The case produced diplomatic consequences instead, and a single arrest in Europe that had nothing to do with the death itself. The killers were never identified in any court.

He was born on February 14, 1960, in the Jabalia refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip. He left school young, barely able to read and write, and as a young man he was more drawn to bodybuilding than to the politics of the camp; Hamas later said he had won a bodybuilding contest in Gaza. He spoke Hebrew as well as Arabic, and in later years he learned to write Arabic and began to study English and Turkish.

By his mid-twenties his outlook had changed. He joined the Gaza branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, and in 1986 Israel jailed him for a year. In custody he came to know Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, the cleric who went on to found Hamas. When the first Palestinian uprising began in 1987, he joined the movement's military wing, the group that became the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades, and he is counted among its founders.

In 1989 two Israeli soldiers were captured and killed. Hamas has said that he was involved, and he became one of Israel's most wanted men. He went into hiding for about two months and then crossed into Egypt. By the early 1990s he was living in Syria, and Damascus remained his base for the rest of his life. He traveled widely on Hamas business.

Outside Gaza he was little known. Inside Hamas he was described as an active commander until the day he died, and Israel regarded him as the point man for smuggling into Gaza. He was also alleged to have helped forge links between Hamas and Iran. None of these allegations was ever tested in a court.

His death was discovered on January 20. For more than a week nothing was said in public. At the end of January, Hamas announced the death in a statement issued from Damascus and accused Israel. Israel made no comment.

Dubai Police built their case from the records of a city that logs its visitors. Interpol later summarized the evidence that linked the suspects: passport records, video surveillance, witness interviews, and accommodation, telephone, transport and credit-card records.

On February 15, 2010, the police chief said arrest warrants would be issued for 11 suspects who had traveled on European passports: six British, three Irish, one French and one German. Two Palestinians living in the UAE were also arrested and questioned on suspicion of giving the team logistical support; their names were not made public. Three days later Interpol issued red notices for the 11, describing them as people "charged by Dubai authorities with coordinating and committing the murder." That same day the police chief said he was all but certain the Mossad was responsible.

The list kept growing. By the end of February Dubai Police had named 26 suspects: on the police tally, the group had traveled on 12 British, six Irish, four French, three Australian and one German passport. On February 28 the police also announced their findings on the cause of death, which, like the rest of the police case, have never been tested in a court. In March Interpol issued notices for 16 more suspects, 27 in all. A later Dubai update brought the count to 32, and by January 2012 Dubai officials put the figure at 33 suspects using 45 passports, with Interpol red notices in place for 35 people.

The passports carried a second set of victims. Many of the names Dubai Police released belonged to living people who had nothing to do with the killing, and none of them was regarded as a suspect. Inquiries in Britain, Australia and Ireland found that genuine passports had been copied, or that false applications had been made in the names of real people.

Each of those three governments concluded that Israel was responsible for the misuse of its passports and expelled an Israeli diplomat: Britain on March 23, Australia on May 24 and Ireland on June 15, 2010. Britain said it had reached no conclusion on who carried out the killing itself. France opened its own investigation into the four French passports and summoned an Israeli diplomat.

The one man held in Europe in connection with the case, U.B., an Israeli citizen, was arrested at Warsaw airport in early June 2010 at Germany's request. German prosecutors said he had obtained a German passport in Cologne in 2009 under a false identity, and that a member of the team in Dubai had later used it.

Germany first sought him on espionage charges, but a Polish court allowed his handover only on the charge of obtaining a passport under false pretenses. Poland extradited him on August 12, 2010, and the next day a Cologne magistrate released him on bail. He flew to Israel. No court in Germany, Poland or anywhere else heard any charge connected with the death itself.

In January 2012, two years after the killing, Interpol's notices for 35 suspects were still in place, but only one person had been arrested, and only briefly, and no charges had come to trial. Hamas continued to accuse Israel of the killing. The death remains unsolved in law: Dubai Police named the team by its passports and laid the blame on a foreign intelligence service, but no person has been identified in any court as having taken part.

Responsibility for the killing rests on attribution, not on any court finding. Dubai Police and the emirate's police chief attributed it to the Mossad; Britain, Australia and Ireland concluded that Israel was responsible for the misuse or fabrication of their passports, and Britain said explicitly that it had reached no conclusion on who carried out the killing.

The identities of the suspects are unknown. The names on the red notices are aliases, and many belonged to people found to be innocent victims of identity theft.

The cause of death was given by Dubai Police and has not been tested in court.

The allegations against the victim himself, including his part in the deaths of two Israeli soldiers in 1989 and Israel's claims about his later activities, come from Hamas statements and Israeli accusations and were never tried.

Timeline

February 14, 1960: The future Hamas official is born in the Jabalia refugee camp, Gaza.

1986: Israel jails him for a year.

1987: He joins the military wing of Hamas at the start of the first uprising.

1989: After two Israeli soldiers are captured and killed, he leaves Gaza for Egypt and later settles in Syria.

January 19, 2010: He arrives in Dubai from Damascus and dies there that night.

January 20, 2010: His death is discovered.

Late January 2010: Hamas announces the death and accuses Israel.

February 15, 2010: Dubai Police say warrants will be issued for 11 suspects; two Palestinians are held.

February 18, 2010: Interpol issues red notices for 11 suspects.

February 28, 2010: Dubai Police announce their findings on the cause of death and name 26 suspects.

March 8, 2010: Interpol issues red notices for 16 more suspects, 27 in all.

March 23, 2010: Britain expels an Israeli diplomat.

May 24, 2010: Australia expels an Israeli diplomat.

Early June 2010: U.B. is arrested at Warsaw airport at Germany's request.

June 15, 2010: Ireland expels an Israeli diplomat.

August 12, 2010: Poland extradites U.B. to Germany on the passport charge only.

August 13, 2010: A Cologne magistrate releases U.B. on bail.

January 2012: Interpol notices cover 35 suspects; no one has been tried.