On the night of March 31 to April 1, 1922, six people living at Hinterkaifeck, an isolated holding outside the village of Gröbern in Upper Bavaria, were murdered. Three generations of one family died that night, together with a woman who had joined the household only that afternoon. Neighbors discovered what had happened four days later, on April 4. The Munich Police Directorate sent its criminal investigators the same night, the Bavarian Interior Ministry offered a reward of 100,000 marks, and over the next eight years the Munich police pursued more than 100 separate lines of inquiry. None of them led to a charge.
The case passed from the public prosecutor at Neuburg an der Donau to the prosecutor at Augsburg, survived the destruction of much of its own evidence in an Allied air raid in 1944, and was taken up again in the early 1950s, in 1971 and, as a study exercise, by Bavarian police analysts at the turn of the twenty-first century. Each time the result was the same. The perpetrator has never been identified, and no one was ever tried.
Hinterkaifeck lay in open country about 500 meters southwest of Gröbern and roughly six kilometers from the market town of Schrobenhausen. Administratively it belonged to the municipality of Wangen, a community that no longer exists; the land is part of Waidhofen today. The holding stood well apart from its neighbors.
Six people lived there in the spring of 1922. Andreas Gruber and his wife, Cäzilia Gruber, had handed the holding to their daughter, Viktoria Gabriel, a widow since the First World War. Her two children lived with her: a daughter who attended the village school, and a son, the youngest of the household, still a small child.
The sixth was Maria Baumgartner. She arrived at Hinterkaifeck on the afternoon of Friday, March 31, 1922, to take up a new position with the family, and had been part of the household only a few hours when she died. The investigators accepted that all six had died within the space of a few hours that night.
For four days no one outside recognized that anything was wrong. Passers-by noticed that the place was unusually quiet. The older child did not appear at school on Saturday, and on Sunday no one from the family came to church. Because the family was known to keep to itself, no one at first read much into the silence. On Tuesday, April 4, a mechanic who had come to repair an engine spent hours on the property without meeting anyone and mentioned it on his way back through Gröbern. That afternoon three men from the village went to Hinterkaifeck, and the six deaths were discovered. The gendarmerie post at Hohenwart passed the report to the Munich Police Directorate that evening.
The Munich officers did not reach Gröbern until that night. By then word had spread through the district, and onlookers had already been on the property in numbers; investigators later accepted that much of what might have been useful was lost before their work began. The judicial side of the case belonged to the public prosecutor at the Landgericht Neuburg an der Donau, and the local court at Schrobenhausen sent a judge to conduct the formal inspection. On April 7, 1922, the Bavarian Interior Ministry set its reward, and the Munich Police Directorate issued special bulletins and wanted notices.
The first theory was robbery, and the police began with strangers to the district and with men recently released from custody, tracing and questioning them one by one. None of these leads held, and the robbery theory weakened as the inquiry went on: how much money had been in the household, and whether any was taken, was never established. The questioning, which the senior inspector in charge kept up until 1930, gave investigators a detailed picture of the family and its neighbors. It did not give them a perpetrator.
Over the years the police examined a number of suspects, among them people from the district and strangers to it. None was ever charged. By 1930 the Munich police had opened more than 100 investigative proceedings, all without result.
The buildings at Hinterkaifeck did not outlast the inquiry; they were demolished in February 1923. In 1932 the Landgericht Neuburg an der Donau and its public prosecutor's office were dissolved in a reorganization of the Bavarian state administration, and the Hinterkaifeck file went to Augsburg. On the night of February 25, 1944, Royal Air Force raids destroyed large parts of that city, among them the Augsburg justice building. The written records of the Neuburg prosecutor and key physical evidence from the case were lost in the fire. What survived were incomplete Munich police files, held as copies and carbons, and Augsburg prosecutor's records preserved or reassembled in the 1950s.
The case was taken up again after the war. From December 1951 through 1952 the Bavarian Landespolizei took new statements from people who had known the family and from the men who had been at Hinterkaifeck in April 1922. In 1971 new information prompted the public prosecutor at the Landgericht Augsburg to investigate once more, and that inquiry, too, closed without result.
From the 1970s a retired detective chief inspector from Ingolstadt spent decades on the case, taking statements from surviving witnesses, among them a former schoolmate of the older child, and building a large collection of files that he later gave to the Bavarian Army Museum in Ingolstadt. On July 21, 2000, a detective chief inspector at Munich police headquarters prepared a formal case analysis from that collection. Later still, a final-year class at the Bavarian police college in Fürstenfeldbruck took up the case as a study project. Neither named a perpetrator, and no proceedings followed.
Even the shape of the night remains unsettled. The investigators of 1922 could not determine whether one person or several were responsible. No court has ever heard evidence against anyone for the six deaths, and the perpetrator is unknown.
March 31, 1922: A new member of the household arrives in the afternoon; that night, six people at Hinterkaifeck are murdered.
April 4, 1922: The deaths are discovered; the Hohenwart gendarmerie reports them to the Munich Police Directorate, whose criminal investigators arrive that night.
April 4 and 5, 1922: A court commission from Schrobenhausen inspects the property.
April 7, 1922: The Bavarian Interior Ministry offers a reward of 100,000 marks.
February 1923: The buildings at Hinterkaifeck are demolished.
1930: By this year the Munich police have opened more than 100 investigative proceedings without success.
1932: The Landgericht Neuburg an der Donau and its prosecutor's office are dissolved; the file goes to Augsburg.
February 25, 1944: Air raids destroy the Augsburg justice building and much of the case's evidence and records.
December 1951 to 1952: The Bavarian Landespolizei takes new statements.
1971: The Augsburg public prosecutor reopens inquiries; the investigation closes that year without result.
July 21, 2000: A Munich police detective completes a case analysis; no perpetrator is named.