On September 16, 1922, Edward Wheeler Hall and Eleanor Reinhardt Mills were found dead in Franklin Township, just across the boundary from New Brunswick, New Jersey. Both had belonged to the congregation of St. John the Evangelist Episcopal Church in New Brunswick, and investigators soon learned that the two had been in a relationship. The killings fell on the wrong side of a county line, began with an inquiry that came apart almost at once, and produced no indictment. Four years later a New York newspaper reopened the matter and carried what it found to the governor. The state arrested the dead man's widow, a grand jury indicted her and her two brothers for murder, and in the autumn of 1926 all three stood trial at the Somerset County seat of Somerville. The jury acquitted them. No one else has ever been tried, and more than a century later the question of who killed the two victims has no answer in law.
New Brunswick is the seat of Middlesex County, but the place where the two were found lay just over the city's edge, in Franklin Township, which belongs to Somerset County. Two counties had a claim on the case, and the confusion over which one should lead it ran through the first weeks of the inquiry. Investigations ran in parallel, and the work suffered for it.
The early handling of the evidence did as much damage as the split authority. The ground was not secured in the first hours, and no police photograph was taken. Every later attempt to prove what had happened depended on a record compromised from the start.
The first inquiry produced one arrest that did not hold. A man was briefly charged on the strength of a perjured statement from a doubtful witness, and the charge did not stand. It was an early sign of how fragile the witness evidence in the case would prove to be.
In November 1922 the matter went before a grand jury. It heard five days of testimony and returned no indictment. For more than three years after that, the killings stayed open and untouched.
In December 1925 the managing editor of the New York Daily Mirror sent investigators of his own to reopen the case, among them one of the paper's reporters and a county detective. In June 1926 he took their material to the governor of New Jersey, who promised a state investigation. State detectives went over the evidence the paper had compiled, and on July 28, 1926, a captain of the New Jersey State Police arrested the widow in New Brunswick and took her to Somerville.
In September 1926 indictments for murder were obtained against the widow and her two brothers. The prosecution rested much of its hope on a woman who kept a farm in the area and said she had witnessed a confrontation involving the victims. Her account changed with each retelling, and that weakness followed it into the courtroom.
The trial opened at the Somerset County Courthouse in Somerville on November 3, 1926, and ran for 23 days. The farm witness was the state's central figure. The widow testified as well, and her account and the farm witness's could not both be true.
The jury acquitted the widow and both of her brothers. That trial was the only time anyone faced a jury for the two deaths. No one else has been tried since, and the case remains unsolved as of November 2026.
The identity of the killer is the central unanswered question. The state's 1926 case was rejected by a jury, and no later prosecution followed, so every theory of the killings remains untested in court.
The farm witness's account was central to the state's case. It changed over the years between the killings and the trial, and it did not carry the jury.
The man briefly charged in 1922 was held on a perjured statement, and the charge against him did not stand.
September 16, 1922: Two members of a New Brunswick congregation are found dead in Franklin Township, Somerset County, New Jersey.
November 1922: A grand jury hears five days of testimony and returns no indictment.
December 1925: The managing editor of the New York Daily Mirror sends investigators to reopen the case.
June 1926: The paper's material is taken to the governor of New Jersey, who promises a state investigation.
July 28, 1926: A New Jersey State Police captain arrests the widow at New Brunswick.
September 1926: Indictments for murder are obtained against the widow and her two brothers.
November 3, 1926: The trial opens at the Somerset County Courthouse in Somerville.
Late 1926: After a 23-day trial, the jury acquits all three defendants.
November 2026: No one else has been tried; the case remains unsolved.