The Death of Wilma Montesi

Victims
1 death, April 1953, never established as a crime; three men tried in Venice were acquitted with full formula, May 1957.
Years active
April 1953
Location
Rome, Italy (residence); Torvaianica, Lazio, Italy (place of death; no killing established); Rome, Italy (inquiry); Venice, Italy (trial).
Method
Drowning (autopsy finding). Police called it an accident; the Rome investigating judge concluded she was left to die; no court found a crime.
Status
All defendants acquitted with full formula, Venice, May 1957. Two accusers later convicted of calunnia. Never solved; unsolved as of April 2023.

Wilma Montesi was a young woman from Rome. She died in April 1953, and on Saturday, April 11, the day before Easter, she was found dead at Torvaianica, a fishing village on the coast south of the capital. Within days the police had called it an accident and closed the file. Within a year the case had become the gravest political scandal of the young Italian Republic, one that cost the foreign minister his post, forced out the chief of the national police and brought the government of the day to the edge of collapse.

The end of it all was a trial in Venice in the first months of 1957. The foreign minister's son, a jazz musician, stood accused of omicidio colposo, causing a death through fault rather than intent, and two older men stood beside him: a Sicilian landowner settled in Rome who styled himself a marquis, and the former police chief of Rome. In late May 1957 the Venice tribunal acquitted every defendant "con formula piena," with a full formula, the strongest acquittal an Italian court could give. The two people whose accusations had built the case, the editor of a small weekly and a young woman from Milan, were later convicted of calunnia, the offense of falsely accusing others of a crime. No court ever found that a crime had caused the death, and no one has ever been able to establish how it came about, who was with her or what happened in her last hours.

The first inquiry was short. The police weighed two explanations, that she had taken her own life or that she had died by misadventure, and they settled on accident. On April 17 the police chief of Rome, the questore, declared the case resolved and set it aside to be archived. The speed of it troubled people from the start. A Rome daily asked in print why the file had been shut so quickly, and under pressure from the press and the public the police ran a second, informal inquiry over the following months, without involving the judiciary, since no crime was suspected. It reached the same conclusion as the first.

Rumor moved faster than the police. In May, weeks before the general election of June 1953, newspapers began to hint that powerful people were hiding something and to link the death, by rumor alone, to the family of the Christian Democratic deputy prime minister. He had been expected to become prime minister after the election. The rumors damaged him, the post went to another party figure, and he stayed in government, becoming foreign minister in January 1954. His son, the musician, had not been charged with anything, and no evidence connected him to the dead woman.

In October 1953 a weekly magazine revived the case. Its director, a young journalist, published a long story under his own name claiming that the death had been no accident, that it was tied to private gatherings held by the self-styled marquis, and that she had been abandoned while still alive. He named the foreign minister's son and the landowner. The public prosecutor charged him under a law from the Fascist period against spreading false and tendentious news likely to disturb public order. He retracted the story, then in January 1954 withdrew the retraction and set out to prove it in court.

His trial in Rome turned into something else. In March 1954 the young woman from Milan, who had come to Rome hoping to act and had been the landowner's companion, testified in support of the editor's account. She went far beyond the death on the coast, alleging favoritism and corruption that reached into the leading party, and she had already set her accusations down in a written memorandum that reached the interior minister. None of it had been tested, and the courts would later reject it. When the memorandum reached the authorities, the prosecutor's office had the autopsy examined again, and the review came back with the classification the police had already given: an accident. The government ordered the carabinieri, the military police force separate from the ordinary police, to look into the landowner, and after the Council of Ministers urged the courts to clear the matter up, the editor's trial was suspended and the case went back to the judges. By then the Rome prosecutor's office had opened three separate investigations into the death and archived all three.

The case was reopened and handed to the president of the investigating section of the Rome Court of Appeal. He worked in secret through the spring and summer of 1954 and questioned about 500 witnesses. He commissioned new expert reports, and they contradicted the accident account on which the police had closed the file. On that basis he rejected the police finding. In his view she had been left to die while still alive, a conclusion that turned a closed accident into a case of culpable death. It remained his conclusion; no court ever confirmed it.

The pressure fell first on the police. The chief of the national police resigned under the weight of the scandal. On September 19, 1954, the foreign minister resigned as well, to stand beside his son. Two days later, on September 21, the son and the landowner were arrested in Rome. The son was charged with omicidio colposo, usually rendered in English as manslaughter, and the landowner with helping him. The former police chief of Rome was charged with aiding and abetting and, because of his age, was allowed to remain free pending trial. The musician denied everything. He swore he had never met the young woman and gave an alibi for the days in question. After 54 days in custody he and the landowner were released.

On June 23, 1955, the investigating judge sent the case to trial. The musician was committed for omicidio colposo. The landowner was committed for concorso in omicidio colposo, complicity in a culpable death. The former Rome police chief was committed for favoreggiamento, the offense of helping others evade justice, on the theory that he had covered for them when the case was closed. At the prosecutor's own request the trial was moved out of Rome to Venice.

The trial opened at the Tribunale di Venezia early in 1957. The prosecution rested almost entirely on the word of the young Milanese woman, and the hearings soon made plain that nothing but her unsupported testimony suggested the musician had ever met the dead woman. On the stand her account proved full of contradictions. In the last week of May the public prosecutor reviewed the evidence, abandoned his own case and asked the court to clear the musician and his co-defendants.

The court went further. In late May 1957 the Venice tribunal acquitted the musician, the landowner, the former police chief and every other defendant con formula piena. The judges held that there was not a single element against the musician and the landowner, not even a circumstantial one. With no crime established, there was nothing to have been covered up, and the charge against the former police chief fell with the others. All three men left the case acquitted, and in law they are innocent.

The accusers did not escape the courts. The editor and the Milanese woman were tried for calunnia over what they had said about the musician, the landowner and the former police chief, and both were convicted. She was sentenced to two years and he to two years and four months, and the convictions became final.

How the death should be classified was never settled. The police treated it as an accident and closed the case within a week. The investigating judge, on the strength of new expert reports, concluded that she had been left to die while still alive. The Venice tribunal found no evidence against anyone, and in acquitting every defendant con formula piena it left no crime on the record at all.

The accident finding never satisfied the press or the investigating judge, and later writers found it implausible. It was never replaced by anything a court accepted.

The allegations that drove the scandal, the gatherings, the powerful guests and the cover-up, came from two people later convicted of calunnia. No court found any of them proved. The musician, who swore he had never met the young woman, was never shown to have known her.

As of April 2023, seventy years on, how she died, who was with her and what happened in her final hours remained unknown.

Timeline

April 11, 1953: The young woman is found dead at Torvaianica, on the coast south of Rome.

April 17, 1953: Police declare the case resolved as an accident and set it aside to be archived.

May 1953: Newspapers link the death, by rumor, to the family of the deputy prime minister.

October 1953: A weekly magazine publishes its director's account alleging a cover-up; he is charged with spreading false and tendentious news.

January 1954: The editor withdraws his retraction and sets out to prove his story in court.

March 1954: A young Milanese woman testifies in support of the editor at his trial in Rome.

Spring and summer 1954: The investigating section of the Rome Court of Appeal questions about 500 witnesses.

September 19, 1954: The foreign minister resigns.

September 21, 1954: His son and the self-styled marquis are arrested in Rome; the former Rome police chief is charged with aiding and abetting.

June 23, 1955: The investigating judge commits the three men for trial.

Early 1957: The trial opens at the Tribunale di Venezia.

Late May 1957: The prosecutor abandons his case; the tribunal acquits every defendant con formula piena.

After 1957: The editor and the Milanese woman are convicted of calunnia; the convictions become final.

April 2023: Seventy years on, the circumstances of the death remain unknown.