The Death of Father Niall Molloy

Victims
1 death; no one convicted. The only man tried, Richard Flynn, was acquitted of manslaughter and assault on the judge's direction, June 12, 1986
Years active
July 8, 1985
Location
Clara, County Offaly, Ireland (killing); Castlecoote, County Roscommon, Ireland (other, his parish); Dublin, Ireland (trial); Tullamore, County Offaly, Ireland (other, inquest)
Method
Blunt-force blows to the face and head (State Pathologist's evidence); death from head injuries (inquest jury, July 1986); no court has found who struck them
Status
No conviction. Inquest, July 1986: death from head injuries. Commission of investigation refused after 2015 and on September 23, 2021. Never caught: unsolved as of July 2025

Father Niall Molloy, the parish priest of Castlecoote in County Roscommon, died at Clara, County Offaly, on July 8, 1985, while staying with friends he had known for more than thirty years. An inquest jury later returned a verdict on the medical cause of his death. One man, Richard Flynn, the owner of the property where the priest died, was charged with manslaughter and assault and tried at the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court in June 1986. On the day the trial opened, before the jury had begun to deliberate, the judge directed it to return verdicts of not guilty on both counts, and Richard Flynn was acquitted. No one else has ever been charged.

What happened that night has never been established in any court. A cold-case review by the Garda Síochána ran for about three years, and in 2013 the Director of Public Prosecutions decided that no charges should follow. A senior counsel appointed by the Minister for Justice examined the whole case, and his report, published on March 31, 2015, found that the precise events surrounding the death "cannot now be ascertained." In a report published on July 9, 2018, the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission found that original documents and the exhibits gathered in 1985 could no longer be found. Successive governments declined to open a commission of investigation, the one form of inquiry that could compel witnesses to give evidence. On September 23, 2021, a Minister of State told the Dáil that the Garda investigation "remains open."

He came from a large family in Roscommon town. His interest in horses began in childhood, and it stayed with him after his ordination in 1957 and through the various postings of a priest's working life. In 1961 he was moved to Athlone. He served for a time in St Anne's parish in Sligo, and by the summer of 1985 he was back in his native county as parish priest of Castlecoote, in south Roscommon.

Horses also gave him the friendship that shaped much of his adult life. Through them he came to know a Galway woman who later married the owner of the house at Clara, and the friendship between them lasted more than three decades. She and the priest bought and sold horses together as a business partnership, show jumpers among them, and they invested in land and property. They shared a bank account for the horse dealing, and in the year before his death he took out an insurance policy that named her as its beneficiary. He stayed regularly with her family near Clara, where they kept a room for him. The household was well connected, with friendships among senior politicians.

On the first weekend of July 1985 the family at Clara held a wedding for their daughter. The priest did not officiate. The celebrations carried on into a second day, and he was there for it. He died in the night that followed, and a local doctor confirmed the death. The time at which he died was never established, and the review published in 2015 found "a significant delay" in alerting the authorities, a delay it called "unexplained."

Gardaí opened an investigation, and the owner of the house was charged with manslaughter and with assault. The later reviews were sharply critical of the way that investigation was run. The 2015 report found that statements had been taken poorly and late, that the relationship between the household and the priest was never examined, and that the physical evidence was analyzed only in a cursory way. It found no evidence that the household's friendships with senior politicians had been used to its advantage.

The trial opened at the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on June 12, 1986, before a judge and jury. The State Pathologist, who had carried out the post-mortem examination, held that the injuries were the cause of death. Under questioning by the defense he accepted that the priest's heart had been diseased and could have contributed to the death. The defense then applied for a direction of acquittal, submitting that the priest might have died of a heart attack. The judge accepted the application and directed the jury to find Richard Flynn not guilty on both counts. Richard Flynn left the court acquitted of manslaughter and of assault, and that acquittal stands. The 2015 review found that the judge's ruling was "partially attributable" to concessions made by the State Pathologist in evidence.

In July 1986, about six weeks after the trial, a two-day inquest sat at Tullamore with a jury. It returned a verdict on the medical cause of death and made no finding on who was responsible.

The case file did not stay where it belonged. On August 29, 1987, burglars broke into the offices of the Director of Public Prosecutions on St Stephen's Green in Dublin and took about sixty files, among them the file on the priest's death. Most of the stolen files were recovered in October 1991. That one was not among them. It turned up only in January 1993, when gardaí recovered it in the course of an unrelated inquiry.

The case returned in 2010, a quarter of a century after the death. A series of newspaper articles alleged that witness statements had been mishandled and that the original investigation had not been thorough, and that July the family called publicly for an inquiry. The articles led the Garda Serious Crime Review Team, the force's cold-case unit, to take up the case with a team of ten detectives. Its examination ran for about three years and identified shortcomings in the 1985 investigation. A file went to the Director of Public Prosecutions, and in 2013 the DPP directed that no prosecution should follow.

On November 5, 2013, the Minister for Justice announced an independent review by a senior counsel, who was to examine the cold-case report, decide what in it could be released in the public interest, identify matters of significant public concern and advise whether any other form of inquiry could establish the truth. The minister declined to publish the cold-case report itself.

The senior counsel's report was published by the Minister for Justice on March 31, 2015. It found that some of the concerns raised about the case were not supported by the evidence, and it identified shortcomings in the original investigation. It concluded that the precise events of July 7 and 8, 1985, could not now be ascertained, and that "unanswered questions do remain." Further inquiry, it found, was unlikely to answer them, because of the passage of time, the deaths of many of the important witnesses and the reluctance of others to give evidence voluntarily. It recommended that "examination by a further inquiry would not be warranted."

The minister accepted the recommendation. Later in 2015 the family asked her for a commission of investigation, and she refused it about fourteen months later.

In June 2016 one of the priest's nephews complained to the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission about the handling of the original investigation. The Ombudsman published its report on July 9, 2018. It had received a significant amount of material from 1985 and had inspected documents held by An Garda Síochána. Many of the original documents, including the exhibits, could not be found. There was no record of who had handled the exhibits, so the person responsible for their loss could not be identified, and the exhibits had still not been found when the Ombudsman finished its work. The commission found the retention of the files "wholly inadequate." Most of the gardaí who worked on the case in 1985 had retired, and the law barred the Ombudsman from investigating retired members in disciplinary matters. The State Pathologist had retired too, and Richard Flynn, acquitted in 1986, had died in 2017.

On September 23, 2021, a Minister of State at the Department of Justice told the Dáil that the government would not establish a commission of investigation. He relied on the 2015 review, and he said that the Garda investigation "remains open." As of July 2025, forty years after the death, no commission had been set up, and no one had been convicted of any offense arising from it.

The part played by the priest's heart was argued at the trial and never resolved in court. The State Pathologist held that the injuries were the cause of death; the defense argued that a heart attack was possible; and the inquest jury returned its verdict on the medical cause of death the following month.

The family has alleged a cover-up and has questioned the trial judge's reported social ties to the household at Clara. The 2015 review found that some of the concerns raised were not supported by the evidence and found no sign that political friendships had been used to anyone's advantage, and no inquiry has made a finding that the judge's ties affected the case. In October 2022 a television investigation put forward a theory of motive based on papers prepared for the defense in 1986; no court or official inquiry has tested it. No court has made a finding of guilt against anyone, and Richard Flynn's acquittal stands.

Timeline

1957: The priest is ordained.

1961: He is moved to Athlone.

July 1985: The family at Clara, County Offaly, holds a wedding for their daughter.

July 8, 1985: The parish priest of Castlecoote dies at Clara.

June 12, 1986: At the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court the judge directs the jury to find Richard Flynn not guilty of manslaughter and assault.

July 1986: An inquest jury at Tullamore returns its verdict on the medical cause of death.

August 29, 1987: The case file is among about sixty taken in a burglary at the offices of the Director of Public Prosecutions in Dublin.

January 1993: Gardaí recover the file.

2010: The Garda Serious Crime Review Team takes up the case.

2013: The DPP directs no prosecution.

November 5, 2013: The Minister for Justice orders an independent review by a senior counsel.

March 31, 2015: The review is published and recommends no further inquiry.

June 2016: A nephew complains to the Garda Ombudsman.

2017: Richard Flynn, acquitted in 1986, dies.

July 9, 2018: The Garda Ombudsman reports that original documents and exhibits cannot be found.

September 23, 2021: The government rules out a commission of investigation and says the Garda investigation remains open.