Harvey and Jeannette Crewe were killed at Pukekawa, in the lower Waikato south of Auckland, on June 17, 1970. Their deaths produced the most argued-over criminal case in modern New Zealand history. A neighbor, Arthur Allan Thomas, was arrested in November 1970 and sentenced to imprisonment for life. A jury in the Supreme Court at Auckland convicted him of both murders in 1971, and a second jury convicted him again at a retrial in 1973; on December 17, 1979, after a campaign that reached the Prime Minister, the Governor-General granted him "a free pardon in respect of his conviction of those murders," and he walked free that day.
A Royal Commission of Inquiry then examined how he had come to be convicted. Its report in November 1980 found that he had been wrongly charged and convicted, and that two detectives on the inquiry had planted a key exhibit in order to incriminate him. Neither detective was ever prosecuted. Thomas was paid over $1 million in compensation. Decades later, at the request of the couple's daughter, New Zealand Police reopened the file. Their review, released on July 30, 2014, accepted that the exhibit at the center of the case may be fabricated evidence, and concluded that no new evidence had come to light implicating any specific person in the murders. No one has been convicted of the killings, and no one has been identified as the killer.
The couple married in Auckland on June 18, 1966. They had met a few years earlier in Wanganui, and after the wedding they settled on a 340-acre property at Pukekawa, which they owned together and farmed with sheep and beef cattle. The 2014 police review described them as a couple who kept a low profile in the district.
The review settled the date of the deaths as Wednesday, June 17, 1970, confirming the view the original investigators had reached. The killings came to light on Monday, June 22, when police were called to the property. The couple's infant daughter was found there unharmed. Within days the inquiry was treated as a likely homicide, and the deaths of both husband and wife were confirmed in August and September 1970.
The investigation was led by a detective inspector from Auckland. The 2014 review found that senior officers expected this case, with two victims and no obvious suspect, to be solved, and that the expectation put heavy pressure on the officer in charge.
It also found that the inquiry was badly organized from the start. No officer was put in charge of the scene for 24 hours after police were alerted. Decisions about what counted as evidence were often left to individual detectives. Exhibits were not always recorded in order or stored securely, some items that should have been taken as exhibits were overlooked, and at least one item visible in police photographs was never logged at all and later disappeared. The second in command fell ill early and was never replaced. Householders canvassed in the area were never asked to account for their own movements.
In mid-October 1970 the inquiry turned toward Thomas, a local man who had known the wife since their school days. On October 27, 1970, police produced the item that would become Exhibit 350, which they said they had found at the couple's property after two earlier examinations of the ground had not turned it up. The 2014 review called its discovery the tipping point that set the prosecution in motion. The Royal Commission would later find that two detectives had planted it there to incriminate him.
On November 11, 1970, Thomas was arrested and charged with both murders. His trial in the Supreme Court at Auckland began in February 1971 and lasted two weeks. The jury found him guilty of both murders, a conviction since covered by his free pardon of December 17, 1979, and on March 2, 1971 he was sentenced to imprisonment for life. Thomas had given an account of where he was at the time of the killings, and two people supported it. The 2014 review recorded that this alibi has never been contradicted by any other evidence.
His first appeal failed in June 1971. A petition and a referral followed, and in February 1973 the Court of Appeal treated the conviction as unsafe and ordered a new trial. The retrial was held in the Supreme Court at Auckland in April 1973. The jury again found Thomas guilty of both murders, a second conviction also covered by the 1979 free pardon, and his life sentence was imposed once more. A second appeal, a second petition and a second referral, between 1973 and 1975, left the conviction standing.
On July 27, 1973, police destroyed 135 exhibits from the case. The 2014 review found no breach of the law or of police policy in that decision but criticized it sharply, because it ended any chance of testing those items with later methods.
Outside the courts, the case would not settle. Public criticism of the convictions continued, and the Prime Minister asked a Queen's Counsel to inquire into aspects of the evidence. His report concluded that the case against Thomas may not have been established beyond reasonable doubt.
On the recommendation of the Prime Minister, the Governor-General granted Thomas a free pardon on December 17, 1979, and he was released that day. In the words of the warrant that later set up the Royal Commission, he had been "detained in prison under that sentence until the 17th day of December 1979" when the Governor-General "was pleased to grant to Arthur Allan Thomas a free pardon in respect of his conviction of those murders."
The government appointed a Royal Commission of Inquiry in April 1980. Its terms of reference asked whether the police investigation had been carried out in a proper manner, including any impropriety over Exhibit 350; whether Thomas's arrest and prosecution were justified; whether the prosecution had failed in any duty to the defense; and what sum, if any, should be paid to him in compensation.
The commission reported on November 28, 1980. It found that Thomas had been wrongly charged and convicted. It found that the officer in charge of the inquiry and one of his detectives had planted Exhibit 350 at the couple's property to incriminate Thomas, and that the officer in charge had also exchanged another exhibit during the second trial. The detective had died in 1978 and could not give evidence; the officer in charge did give evidence and was disbelieved on a number of points. The commission recommended compensation of over $1 million, which the government accepted and paid.
In 1981 the Solicitor-General concluded that there was not enough evidence to implicate any individual in fabricating the provenance of the exhibit. No charge was laid against either detective. The officer in charge died in 2013.
After the pardon, and again after the commission reported, police did not reexamine the original investigation to see whether the evidence pointed to anyone other than Thomas. The 2014 review could find no explanation for that. It also found that after the commission's findings in 1980 the Commissioner of Police should have opened a formal criminal inquiry into the conduct of the two detectives, and that none was begun.
In August 2010 the couple's daughter, by then an adult, asked police to look at the case again. A small team of senior investigators and analysts began work in October 2010, with an independent Queen's Counsel overseeing it. The team gathered the material from the 1970 investigation, both trials and the Royal Commission, digitized about 92,000 pages of documents, interviewed surviving witnesses again and commissioned new expert analysis of the exhibits that remained.
The review was released on July 30, 2014. It concluded that no new evidence had come to light implicating any specific person in the murders, and that nothing new offered a realistic way to identify the offender. After 44 years many key witnesses had died, the memories of those still living were less reliable than their first accounts, and significant exhibits had been destroyed.
On Exhibit 350, the review accepted that the item may be fabricated evidence and that, if it had been planted to implicate Thomas, a member of the police was responsible. Expert research showed that it could not have been connected with the deaths in the way the Crown had argued at both trials. The review stopped short of the commission's finding, holding that the evidence did not establish with certainty that the exhibit was fabricated.
On the question of charges, the review held that the Solicitor-General's 1981 opinion remained authoritative, because the evidence against any individual was the same as it had been in 1980, and it concluded that there was not enough evidence to support any prosecution for an offense against the administration of justice.
The legal position is settled. Thomas holds a free pardon for both convictions, a Royal Commission found that he was wrongly charged and convicted, and no court has convicted anyone else. What has never been settled is who killed the couple. Thomas declined to take part in the 2014 review.
The review and the Royal Commission differ on one point of degree. The commission found as fact that Exhibit 350 was planted by two detectives to incriminate Thomas. The review found that it may be fabricated evidence, without holding that this was established with certainty; the independent counsel overseeing the review sided with the commission's view.
June 18, 1966: the couple marry in Auckland and settle at Pukekawa.
June 17, 1970: the couple are killed at Pukekawa.
June 22, 1970: police are called to the property; the couple's infant daughter is found unharmed.
August and September 1970: the deaths of both are confirmed.
October 27, 1970: police produce Exhibit 350, which the Royal Commission later found was planted.
November 11, 1970: Arthur Allan Thomas is arrested and charged with both murders.
March 2, 1971: convicted in the Supreme Court at Auckland, Thomas is sentenced to imprisonment for life (a conviction covered by his 1979 free pardon).
February 1973: the Court of Appeal orders a new trial.
April 1973: Thomas is convicted again at the retrial (also covered by the 1979 free pardon).
July 27, 1973: police destroy 135 exhibits.
December 17, 1979: the Governor-General grants Thomas "a free pardon in respect of his conviction of those murders"; he is released.
April 1980: a Royal Commission of Inquiry is appointed.
November 28, 1980: the commission reports that Thomas was wrongly charged and convicted and that two detectives planted Exhibit 350.
1981: the Solicitor-General concludes that there is not enough evidence to prosecute anyone over the exhibit.
October 2010: at the daughter's request, a police review of the case begins.
July 30, 2014: police release their review, which finds no new evidence implicating any specific person.