On the afternoon of Wednesday, September 5, 2012, four people were killed in the hills above Lake Annecy, near the village of Chevaline in the French department of Haute-Savoie. Three of them were members of one British family on a camping holiday: a father, his wife and her mother. The fourth was a local man who had been out on his bicycle and who had, as far as any investigator has been able to establish, no connection to the family at all. The couple's two young daughters were also there. Both lived, the elder seriously hurt and the younger untouched. More than fourteen years later, after an inquiry that reached into Britain, Iraq, Sweden and Spain, after five people were held at one point or another and every one of them released, and after the file passed from the prosecutor's office in Annecy to a national unit for unsolved crimes in Nanterre, no one has been charged with any of the four deaths.
The case has never lacked lines of inquiry. Each one produced arrests, questioning or months of work. None produced a charge.
Saad al-Hilli was born in Iraq. He became a naturalized British citizen and had lived in the United Kingdom since 2002, and by 2012 the family lived in Claygate, a village in Surrey. A neighbor there remembered him as the man who had helped mend his lawnmower, and described the family as very nice people. His wife, Iqbal al-Hilli, held an Iraqi passport. Her mother, Suhaila al-Allaf, lived in Sweden and traveled on a Swedish passport, and she had come to France to spend the holiday with them.
The family drove to the French Alps with a caravan and arrived in the Annecy area on September 3, 2012. They stayed at a campsite at Saint-Jorioz, on the shore of the lake, and planned to remain for two weeks or less. Their two daughters traveled with them.
Sylvain Mollier lived in Ugine, a town not far from the lake. On the afternoon of September 5 he had gone out for a ride, and he was in the same hills above Chevaline as the family.
Not long after the killings a British cyclist staying in the area came upon the scene. He found the elder of the two girls badly hurt, gave her what help he could and raised the alarm. Gendarmes sealed the area until specialist teams from the national gendarmerie arrived. The younger girl was not found until late that night, unhurt. Fellow campers at Saint-Jorioz had told officers that the family had two children, and that information led investigators to her.
The investigation was French from the start: a judicial investigation under the authority of the Annecy prosecutor's office, with investigating judges directing it and the gendarmerie research unit at Chambéry doing the work in the field. Because the family lived in England, Surrey Police joined the effort, and at its height around 100 gendarmes and 40 British officers were working on the case. Lines of inquiry ran to Britain, Iraq, Sweden and Spain.
The first year established little beyond the basic sequence of the afternoon. A year on, the investigators still did not know whether there had been one killer or several, whether anyone had helped, or why the four people had died.
The two girls were the only living witnesses. They were placed under police protection in the days after the killings, and over the years, as they grew up in England, they were interviewed again by police. In June 2021 the elder sister asked to speak to Surrey Police and gave investigators a fuller account of what she remembered of that day.
In the first months the inquiry turned toward England, where investigators examined an inheritance dispute within the family. On June 24, 2013, the father's elder brother was arrested in England on suspicion of conspiracy to commit murder, questioned and released on bail. On January 15, 2014, Surrey Police cancelled his bail, saying there was insufficient evidence to charge him with any criminal offense. He was never charged, and the family line of inquiry was dropped soon afterward.
On November 4, 2013, French investigators released a composite image of a man in a motorcycle helmet. Two forest workers had seen a motorcyclist in the area that afternoon, and the rider had never come forward.
On February 18, 2014, gendarmes arrested a former municipal police officer, E.D., who lived near Chevaline. The Annecy prosecutor announced that inquiries and interviews had established no direct link between E.D. and the events of September 5, 2012, and that nothing recovered matched the evidence from the case. He was released and was never charged in connection with the killings.
The rider in the composite was identified in 2015. He was a man from the Lyon area who had come to the mountains for the day. He was questioned, and in 2015 the prosecutor announced that no evidence implicated him.
On September 30, 2021, close to the ninth anniversary, gendarmes staged a full reconstruction of the afternoon at Chevaline, with almost every witness summoned. On January 12, 2022, the Chambéry unit took the motorcyclist into custody for further questioning. On January 13 he was released without charge. The prosecutor said that his explanations and the checks carried out had ruled out his involvement.
In 2022, ten years after the killings, the file passed to a national unit in Nanterre, west of Paris, the division for serial and unsolved crimes. A cold-case investigating judge there took over the inquiry, and the Chambéry gendarmerie research unit continued to work alongside the judge.
The Nanterre judges ordered fresh scientific examinations of the material gathered in 2012, and in May 2024 it became public that the new analyses were under way. On October 17, 2024, the judge and the Chambéry unit staged a second reconstruction, this time at a disused air base in the Île-de-France region. It produced no new information.
On September 15, 2026, the Nanterre prosecutor's office confirmed that investigators wanted to stage a scene reenactment at Chevaline itself, and that they hoped to bring the two sisters, now adults living in Britain, to take part, in the hope of drawing more from their memories. As of September 2026 the case remained open, and no one had been charged.
No court has heard any part of this case. No one has been charged, and every person held in England or France was released, each time with an official statement that the evidence did not support a charge or that the checks had ruled the person out.
The motive is unknown. Over the years investigators examined an inheritance dispute within the family, the father's professional life in Britain and Iraq, the possibility that the cyclist rather than the family was the intended target, and the possibility of a contract killing, for which they found no way that a hired killer could have known where the family would be that afternoon. By 2022 the official working hypothesis had become an isolated, local act with an unknown motive. Whether one person or more took part has never been established.
The place of the cyclist in the events remains open. The first prosecutor said nothing in his background marked him as a target; later lines of inquiry treated him as a possible first victim; in September 2026 investigators still described his part as uncertain.
September 3, 2012: The family arrives at a campsite at Saint-Jorioz, on Lake Annecy.
September 5, 2012: Four people are killed near Chevaline; the couple's two daughters survive. The Annecy prosecutor's office opens the investigation.
June 24, 2013: The father's elder brother is arrested in England on suspicion of conspiracy to commit murder and released on bail.
November 4, 2013: French investigators release a composite of a helmeted motorcyclist seen in the area that afternoon.
January 15, 2014: Surrey Police cancel the brother's bail, citing insufficient evidence to charge him; he is never charged.
February 18, 2014: A former municipal police officer, E.D., is arrested; the prosecutor finds no direct link to the killings, and he is released and never charged.
2015: The motorcyclist is identified, questioned and cleared.
June 2021: The elder sister gives Surrey Police a fuller account.
September 30, 2021: Gendarmes stage a reconstruction at Chevaline with almost every witness.
January 12 to 13, 2022: The motorcyclist is held in custody and released without charge.
2022: The case passes to the Nanterre division for serial and unsolved crimes.
May 2024: New scientific examinations of the material from 2012 are under way.
October 17, 2024: A second reconstruction is held at a disused air base in Île-de-France.
September 15, 2026: The Nanterre prosecutor's office confirms plans for a scene reenactment at Chevaline with the two sisters.