On September 17, 1948, in the Katamon district of Jerusalem, Count Folke Bernadotte of Sweden, the United Nations Mediator for Palestine, was killed together with Colonel André Serot of the French Air Force, a United Nations observer who was riding beside him. A group calling itself Hazit Hamoledeth, the Fatherland Front, claimed the killings at once. The Provisional Government of Israel concluded within days that the group was drawn from Lehi, the underground organization known as the Stern Group, and moved against it with mass detentions, a new emergency law against terrorism and a decree outlawing both names.
No one was ever charged with the murders. Two of Lehi's leaders were tried before a special military court in Acre for directing a terrorist organization, and in February 1949 they were convicted and sentenced to prison, but the court found itself unable to establish with any certainty that the killings had been carried out on Lehi's orders. Within days the men were covered by a general amnesty. Four decades later, after the time for prosecution had passed, former members of Lehi acknowledged the operation in public, and the man who had run it in Jerusalem lived until 2009 without ever facing a court.
The count was born in Stockholm on January 2, 1895, a member of the Swedish royal house. He became a cavalry officer in the Swedish army in 1915, rose to the rank of major after the First World War, and by the late 1930s was head of the Swedish Boy Scouts. The Second World War made his name. In 1943 he became vice president of the Swedish Red Cross, and that autumn he directed the practical work of the first large exchange of prisoners of war between Germany and the Western Allies; on October 25, 1943, more than 5,000 freed prisoners came ashore at Leith and Liverpool. In the last weeks of the war, after direct negotiations with Heinrich Himmler, he led the Swedish Red Cross expedition that became known as the White Buses, which carried about 20,000 Scandinavian and Jewish prisoners out of German concentration camps.
In late May 1948, days after the declaration of the State of Israel and the outbreak of war between Israel and its Arab neighbors, the Secretary-General of the United Nations asked him to serve as Mediator in Palestine. It was the first mediation in the organization's history. He began work on May 28, and after two weeks of negotiation a one-month truce took effect on June 11. He pressed the cause of the Palestinian refugees, work later credited with laying the foundation for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, and he secured the deployment of military observers drawn from several nations, the beginning of what became the United Nations Truce Supervision Organization. When fighting resumed in July, he arranged a second truce with the Security Council's backing. His proposals for a settlement, which neither side accepted, would have placed Jerusalem under United Nations control as an international city. He completed his final proposals on September 16, 1948, the day before his death.
The colonel came from the Vosges, in eastern France. He enlisted in the infantry in 1915, entered the officer school at Saint-Cyr in 1916 and transferred to aviation a year later. After the war he joined French military intelligence and spent the interwar years working against German intelligence from Strasbourg and Belfort. After the French defeat of June 1940 his work went underground, and with another air officer he laid the foundations of the security service of the French Air Force. From January 1943 he helped direct French counterintelligence and military security from Algiers, and after the war he headed the security services of the French armed forces. In 1948 he was named the French delegate to the United Nations mission in Palestine, and in Jerusalem he served as chief United Nations truce observer for the city.
Lehi had fought British rule in Palestine before the state was founded, and in Jerusalem, whose future the Mediator's proposals placed under international control, it still kept its own camps after many of its members had joined the Israeli army. Through the summer of 1948 the organization made its hostility to the mission public, in broadcasts, in a demonstration against the Mediator in Jerusalem and, on September 6, in an article in its newspaper by Nathan Friedman-Yellin, one of its three leaders, calling for the expulsion of the Mediator and his observers.
The count arrived in Jerusalem on September 17, a day earlier than planned. Late that afternoon, in Katamon, he and the colonel were killed; three other members of the party survived, and the killers got away. A statement issued in the name of Hazit Hamoledeth claimed responsibility the same day. The name was new, and the Irgun, the other underground organization still active in the city, denied any part. On September 18 the Security Council adopted Resolution 57, attributing the Mediator's death to a terrorist group in Jerusalem, and his deputy took over the mission as Acting Mediator.
The Provisional Government of Israel acted the same night. Lehi camps in Jerusalem were surrounded and occupied, and within twenty-four hours 150 Lehi members had been taken into custody in Jerusalem and 40 in Tel Aviv. On September 20 the government promulgated Emergency Regulations for the Prevention of Terrorism and declared both Lehi and Hazit Hamoledeth terrorist organizations; on September 23 the Provisional State Council reenacted the regulations as an ordinance. On September 29 police arrested Friedman-Yellin in Haifa together with Matatiahu Shmuelevitz, his chief lieutenant.
The government later told the Security Council that the detentions were meant both to find the men who had carried out the killings and to break the organization. The screening produced no case. Witnesses' descriptions of the assailants differed too widely even to support an identification parade, and most detainees were released after signing undertakings to cut all ties with the outlawed groups. By the government's own account in May 1949, the investigations had produced no evidence sufficient to found a criminal prosecution.
The two leaders went on trial before a special military court in Acre on December 5, 1948. They were charged with committing terrorist activities and with membership of terrorist groups under the emergency regulations, offenses dated from the day of their arrest, because the new ordinance could not reach back to an act committed before it took effect. Both pleaded not guilty and conducted their own defense.
Neither man was charged with the murders; the government told the Security Council there was no evidence to support such a charge. Yet the question of Lehi's responsibility ran through the whole trial, because the prosecution set out to prove that Hazit Hamoledeth was a fiction, a name created so that Lehi could carry out the killing and disclaim it. Friedman-Yellin denied under oath that his organization had taken any part, swore that he had never ordered the killing and knew of no Lehi meeting at which it had been discussed, and said he had been surprised when he heard of it. He acknowledged that the Front was a terrorist group whose ideas resembled Lehi's, but denied that the two were one body. Both defendants, and every Lehi witness, told the court they had first heard the name Hazit Hamoledeth when its announcement of the killing appeared.
The court delivered its judgment on February 2, 1949. On the killing of the Mediator, it found that all the evidence was circumstantial and that there was no direct evidence of any kind. It rejected any idea that the killing was the work of one person or of a group that had come together by chance, finding that it had been planned by an organized body with an experienced commander, and that if Hazit Hamoledeth existed at all, its members could have come only from Lehi or the Irgun. It expressed its conviction that those who took part came mainly from the ranks of Lehi.
The law demanded more. Under the regulations, Lehi could be held responsible only if the killing had been carried out on the movement's express orders, and circumstantial evidence could convict only where every inference pointed to guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The defendants had left the court with the impression that the killing might have been the work of members who rejected the movement's decision to leave the underground; Shmuelevitz told the court it was possible that men who had left or rebelled against Lehi had done it. The court found itself "unable to establish with any degree of certainty" that the murder had been carried out on Lehi's orders, and gave the organization the benefit of the doubt.
On the charges actually before it, the court convicted both men and sentenced Friedman-Yellin to eight years in prison and Shmuelevitz to five. A general amnesty followed on February 14, 1949, for the opening of the Constituent Assembly. It did not extend to murder or to any crime carrying death or life imprisonment, so it stood in the way of no future prosecution for the two killings.
In its May 1949 report to the Security Council, Israel accepted the court's findings on the murders but said it did not regard the case as closed. No prosecution came. In 1950, after Sweden delivered a memorandum charging that the inquiry had been lax, Israel accepted that its police investigation had failed in several respects and took responsibility for those failures, and Sweden declared the exchange closed.
The limitation period for prosecution ran out in 1968, and after it had passed, several former members of Lehi admitted responsibility. In September 1988, according to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Yehoshua Zettler, who had led Lehi's operations in Jerusalem in 1948, admitted the crime in an interview with an Israeli daily newspaper, saying that four men had carried it out and that Yitzhak Shamir, then Prime Minister and in 1948 one of Lehi's leaders, was not directly implicated in the act. A former Lehi ideologue said that year that the Prime Minister had been one of four men responsible for planning the movement's killings, but could not confirm that he had attended the meeting at which this one was ordered. Sweden asked Israel for a second apology, and Israel declined. Zettler died in May 2009 without having been tried. No court ever heard evidence against any of the men who planned or carried out the killings.
Who ordered the killing has never been settled by any court. The military court found the operation planned by an experienced underground body, most likely from Lehi's ranks, but could not find that Lehi had ordered it, and the defendants denied under oath that any Lehi body had decided on it. The 1988 statements of former members placed the operation in Lehi's Jerusalem command, but they were never tested in evidence, and the two men who spoke that year gave different accounts of the future Prime Minister's part.
Whether Hazit Hamoledeth was anything more than a name is also unresolved. The prosecution called it a cover for Lehi; the defendants called it a separate group they had learned of only from its announcement; the court found that, if it existed, its members came from the underground.
January 2, 1895: The future Mediator is born in Stockholm.
October 25, 1943: First large prisoner-of-war exchange between Germany and the Western Allies, directed by the count, lands freed prisoners at Leith and Liverpool.
1945: White Buses expedition evacuates about 20,000 prisoners from German camps.
May 28, 1948: The count begins work as United Nations Mediator in Palestine.
June 11, 1948: First truce takes effect.
September 16, 1948: The Mediator completes his proposals.
September 17, 1948: The Mediator and the French colonel are killed in the Katamon district of Jerusalem; Hazit Hamoledeth claims the killings; mass detentions of Lehi members begin.
September 18, 1948: Security Council adopts Resolution 57.
September 20, 1948: Emergency Regulations for the Prevention of Terrorism promulgated; Lehi and Hazit Hamoledeth declared terrorist organizations.
September 29, 1948: Friedman-Yellin and Shmuelevitz arrested in Haifa.
December 5, 1948: Their trial opens before a special military court in Acre.
February 2, 1949: Judgment; the court cannot establish that the murder was ordered by Lehi; both men are convicted of terrorist-organization offenses.
February 14, 1949: General amnesty; it excludes murder.
May 3, 1949: Israel reports to the Security Council that the case is not closed.
1950: Israel accepts Swedish criticism of its police inquiry.
1968: Limitation period for prosecution expires.
September 1988: Lehi's former Jerusalem operations chief admits the crime.
May 2009: The former operations chief dies, untried.