The Assassination of Benazir Bhutto

Victims
1 former prime minister and more than 20 others killed. No murder conviction. Two police officers convicted of negligence and destroying evidence (2017).
Years active
December 27, 2007
Location
Rawalpindi, Punjab, Pakistan (killings; trial at the Anti-Terrorism Court and appeals at the Lahore High Court, Rawalpindi Bench).
Method
Gunfire and a bomb blast; Scotland Yard (2008) found the blast caused her death, a finding her party rejected.
Status
Five acquitted, August 31, 2017; two officers given 17 years (not murder), bailed October 2017. Musharraf died untried February 5, 2023. Unsolved; appeals pending as of December 27, 2025.

Benazir Bhutto, twice prime minister of Pakistan and the first woman to lead a Muslim country in modern times, was killed in Rawalpindi on the evening of December 27, 2007, as she left an election rally. More than twenty other people died with her, most of them members and supporters of the Pakistan Peoples Party she led. Parliamentary elections were twelve days away, and she was campaigning to return to office for a third time.

Nearly two decades later, no court has convicted anyone of her murder. An anti-terrorism court in Rawalpindi heard the case for close to ten years. On August 31, 2017, it acquitted five men accused of conspiring in the killing, convicted two senior police officers of negligence and of destroying evidence, and declared the former president, retired General Pervez Musharraf, an absconder. Musharraf died in Dubai in February 2023 without having stood trial. The appeals against the 2017 judgment were still pending before the Lahore High Court at the end of 2025. A United Nations commission had concluded in 2010 that her death could have been prevented.

Benazir Bhutto was born on June 21, 1953, in Sindh. She went to school in Karachi and then to Harvard and Oxford, where she became the first Asian woman elected president of the Oxford Union. She spent years in exile during the military rule of General Zia ul Haq and came back to Pakistan in 1986 to begin her own political career.

In 1988 she became prime minister. In 1990 President Ghulam Ishaq Khan dissolved parliament and dismissed her government, which was charged with corruption and other irregularities. She returned to office in 1993 and was dismissed again in 1996, this time by President Farooq Leghari, after which she led the opposition. In October 1999 General Musharraf took power in a coup, and she went into a self-imposed exile that lasted most of the next eight years. Her return in 2007 was negotiated with the close involvement of American officials.

She flew back from London and arrived in Karachi on October 18, 2007. That same day an attempt on her life in the city killed well over a hundred people. She survived it. On November 3 Musharraf suspended the Constitution and imposed emergency rule, and he lifted the emergency only twelve days before her death.

The danger to her was no secret. According to the UN commission's later report, she faced threats from al-Qaeda, from the Taliban, from local jihadi groups and potentially from elements in the Pakistani establishment; she understood the risks of coming back, the government knew them too, and merely warning her was not enough. An American lobbyist who had worked as her speechwriter later testified that Musharraf had threatened her in a telephone call before her return and had not wanted her back before the elections. Musharraf denied any role in her death and said he had warned her of the danger she faced.

On the morning of December 27, Bhutto met the Afghan president, Hamid Karzai, in Islamabad. The two agreed to work together against extremism if she became prime minister after the elections, which were set for January 8. She then traveled to Rawalpindi for a campaign rally in the final days before the vote, and she was killed as she left it that evening.

The party members and supporters who died with her came from Rawalpindi and from towns across Punjab and beyond. Among those whose names have been made public are Raja Habib, Raja Amin, Mumtaz Ahmed, Asif Samar, Jamil Mughal, Rafique Raza, Javed Iqbal, Muhammad Shafique, Anwar Khan, Siraj Khan and Muhammad Ghous, all of Rawalpindi; Muhammad Naeem Akhtar of Toba Tek Singh; Naeem Asghar of Gakhar, near Gujranwala; Zulfiqar Ali of Faisalabad; Tauqeer Akram Qaira of Lala Musa; Muhammad Bashir of Muzaffarabad; and Nazir Butt and Raja Afraz. Some of them died that evening and others in the days after, and dozens more were hurt. Published counts of the dead besides her range from twenty to twenty-seven.

The elections were postponed by six weeks, to February 18, 2008. Musharraf resigned the presidency later that year under threat of impeachment.

On December 28, the day after her death, the government said at a news conference that Baitullah Mehsud, the chief of the Pakistani Taliban, was behind the killing, and the interior ministry released the transcript of what it said was an intercepted conversation in which Mehsud appeared to congratulate a militant cleric on her death, though her name was not used in it. Mehsud denied any involvement. He was killed in South Waziristan in August 2009 and never faced a court.

The same news conference gave an official explanation of how she had died. Her party disputed it and called for an independent investigation by the United Nations. Musharraf refused a UN inquiry but invited Scotland Yard to help establish the cause of death. The British team's report, published on February 8, 2008, supported the government's account of how she died and did not address who was responsible. Her party rejected that finding as well.

The UN Commission of Inquiry was a three-member fact-finding body, not a criminal investigation. It began work in July 2009, more than eighteen months after the killing, made three visits to Pakistan, interviewed more than 250 people and reviewed hundreds of documents, videos and photographs. Some senior Pakistani officials with detailed knowledge of the case were not made available to it, and it said high-ranking officials had tried to block its access to military and intelligence sources. Its 65-page report was handed over on April 15, 2010, after a two-week delay Pakistan had requested.

The report found that Pakistani authorities had failed on all levels to protect her and that her assassination could have been prevented. Responsibility for her security that day had rested with the federal government, the government of Punjab and the Rawalpindi District Police, and none of them had taken the measures the known and urgent risks required; the federal government under Musharraf, in light of the Karachi attempt two months earlier, had largely passed threats on to her and to the provincial authorities instead of acting to neutralize them. The investigation had been compromised from the first hours. The Rawalpindi police had cleared the scene without collecting and preserving the evidence, the authorities had deliberately prevented a post-mortem examination, and the government's early public statements about how she died and about Mehsud's responsibility had prejudiced everything that followed. The intelligence agency ISI had run parallel inquiries, shared evidence selectively with the police and withheld intelligence about militant cells that were targeting her, and investigators had given little attention to those who planned, financed or ordered the killing.

The commission judged the police failure to investigate largely deliberate, and in other cases driven by fear that the intelligence agencies were involved. It accused no serving or former official of complicity in the murder itself. It recommended a criminal investigation into the possible roles of al-Qaeda, the Taliban and the establishment, and it left the pursuit of the planners, the perpetrators and those responsible for negligence to the Pakistani state.

The criminal case moved separately and slowly. Rawalpindi police arrested five men accused of belonging to Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan: A.S., S.Z., H.G., R.H. and A.R. Prosecutors alleged that they had conspired in the killing and helped the man who carried it out reach Rawalpindi. All five denied the charges.

The Federal Investigation Agency later took over the inquiry, and its work widened the case. It named two senior Rawalpindi police officers, the city police officer and the superintendent of police for Rawal Town at the time. In February 2011 the anti-terrorism court named Musharraf in the case and issued a warrant for his arrest. He was living abroad, between Dubai and London, did not respond, and was declared a fugitive. A joint investigation team implicated him on the ground that his government had failed to provide adequate security despite her repeated requests for it.

In November 2011 the court indicted seven accused. The five alleged militants were charged with killing her, conspiring to kill her and abetting those who carried it out. The two police officers were charged with negligence in providing her security; prosecutors alleged that they had allowed the scene to be cleared, with the loss of material evidence, and had failed to ensure a post-mortem examination. All seven pleaded not guilty.

Musharraf returned to Pakistan in early 2013. On August 20 of that year the anti-terrorism court indicted him on charges of murder, criminal conspiracy for murder and facilitation of murder, the first time a former army chief of Pakistan had been charged with a crime. He pleaded not guilty. In March 2016 he was allowed to leave Pakistan for medical treatment and settled in Dubai. He never returned to face the court, which separated his case from the others.

The Anti-Terrorism Court in Rawalpindi gave its judgment on August 31, 2017, almost ten years after her death. The five alleged militants were acquitted of all charges for lack of evidence.

The two police officers were convicted, one for failures of security at the rally and the other for the handling of the scene. The court convicted each under Sections 119 and 201 of the Pakistan Penal Code and sentenced each to ten years under the first section and seven under the second, seventeen years in all. Neither conviction was for murder. Both had been free on bail during the trial, and both were taken into custody after the verdict. They remain the only people convicted in connection with her death.

Musharraf was declared an absconder. The court ordered the seizure of his property and perpetual warrants for his arrest, and it listed Baitullah Mehsud and four other men as absconders. The judgment did not say who killed her.

In September 2017 the federal government and the Federal Investigation Agency challenged the judgment in the Rawalpindi Bench of the Lahore High Court, seeking the death penalty for the five acquitted men, longer sentences for the two officers and the sentencing of Musharraf. The officers appealed against their convictions. On October 6, 2017, a division bench of the High Court suspended their sentences and released them on bail pending their appeals, and on October 5, 2018, the Supreme Court declined to cancel that bail.

The appeals then stalled. A bench of the High Court heard the case in February 2023 and adjourned it indefinitely. Musharraf died in Dubai on February 5, 2023, never having been tried. In September 2024 a special division bench took the appeals up again, rejected a police report on the whereabouts of one of the acquitted men, R.H., who had not been traced since his release, ordered a fuller report and adjourned all the appeals without a date. By December 2024 the case was the oldest murder appeal before the Lahore High Court.

As of December 27, 2025, twelve appeals in the case remained pending before the Lahore High Court in Rawalpindi, and the two officers remained free on bail. Of the five acquitted men, three had been released, one remained in custody in Punjab, and the fifth had not been traced.

Who planned and who carried out the killing has never been established in court. Four separate inquiries, by the Punjab police, the Federal Investigation Agency, Scotland Yard and the UN commission, did not identify the masterminds or the perpetrators to the standard a court requires. The UN commission wrote that no one believed the teenager it described as the perpetrator had acted alone; the trial court acquitted the five men accused of helping him.

The government's attribution to Baitullah Mehsud rested largely on the transcript it released the day after her death. Mehsud denied it and died in 2009 without trial. The UN commission found the attribution premature and damaging to the investigation, while still calling for a criminal inquiry into the possible roles of al-Qaeda and the Taliban.

The cause of her death remains contested. The government's account and the Scotland Yard finding agreed, and her party has always rejected both. Without a post-mortem examination, the UN commission found, a definitive finding was beyond reach.

Musharraf's responsibility was never tested. He was charged with murder, criminal conspiracy and facilitation, pleaded not guilty and denied any part in her death until he died. The UN commission accused no serving or former official of complicity in the murder, while finding his government's failure to protect her especially grave.

Timeline

June 21, 1953: Benazir Bhutto is born.

1988: She becomes prime minister for the first time.

1990: President Ghulam Ishaq Khan dismisses her government.

1993: She returns to office as prime minister.

1996: President Farooq Leghari dismisses her government again.

October 1999: General Pervez Musharraf takes power in a coup; she remains in self-imposed exile.

October 18, 2007: She returns to Karachi; an attempt on her life that day kills well over a hundred people.

November 3, 2007: Musharraf suspends the Constitution and imposes emergency rule.

December 27, 2007: She and more than twenty others are killed as she leaves an election rally in Rawalpindi.

December 28, 2007: The government blames Baitullah Mehsud, who denies involvement.

February 8, 2008: The Scotland Yard report on the cause of death is published.

February 18, 2008: The postponed parliamentary elections are held.

July 2009: The UN Commission of Inquiry begins work.

August 2009: Baitullah Mehsud is killed in South Waziristan.

April 15, 2010: The UN commission's report is delivered; it finds that the killing could have been prevented.

February 2011: The Anti-Terrorism Court names Musharraf in the case and issues a warrant; he is later declared a fugitive.

November 2011: Seven accused, five alleged militants and two police officers, are indicted and plead not guilty.

August 20, 2013: Musharraf is indicted for murder, criminal conspiracy for murder and facilitation of murder, and pleads not guilty.

March 2016: Musharraf leaves Pakistan for Dubai.

August 31, 2017: The court acquits the five accused, convicts the two police officers under Sections 119 and 201, and declares Musharraf an absconder.

September 2017: The federal government and the Federal Investigation Agency file appeals in the Lahore High Court.

October 6, 2017: The High Court suspends the officers' sentences and grants them bail.

October 5, 2018: The Supreme Court declines to cancel the officers' bail.

February 5, 2023: Musharraf dies in Dubai, untried.

September 2024: A special division bench takes up the appeals and adjourns them without a date.

December 27, 2025: Twelve appeals remain pending before the Lahore High Court.