Before dawn on Wednesday, July 1, 1981, four people were killed in Laurel Canyon, in the Hollywood Hills of Los Angeles. A fifth person, a woman, survived with critical injuries and could not identify the people responsible. Over the next decade the Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office put three men on trial for the murders, and none of those prosecutions ended in a conviction. A federal case in 2000 reached back to the same night and closed with a guilty plea to racketeering, not to murder. The four deaths have never been answered by any court.
The men accused were well known in Los Angeles. The first charged was John Holmes, an actor in adult films. The men charged seven years later were Adel Gharib Nasrallah, a nightclub owner who went by the name Eddie Nash, and his bodyguard. Holmes was acquitted in 1982. Nash and the bodyguard were acquitted in 1991, after a first round of trials ended in mistrials. In law each of the three remained innocent of the killings, and each left court that way.
The dead were Ronald Launius, of Yuba City, California; William DeVerell; Joy Audrey Miller; and Barbara Lee Richardson, of Sacramento. The woman who survived recovered from her injuries, but in 1988 she was still unable to say who had come in that night.
The Los Angeles Police Department took the case. By the spring of 1982 the prosecution had settled on the theory that would shape every case that followed: that the four had died in retaliation for a theft two days earlier in Studio City, in which cash and property were taken from Nash and his bodyguard. Neither Nash nor the bodyguard was charged for another six years.
Holmes was arrested in Florida in December 1981 and returned to Los Angeles, where he was charged with four counts of murder and one count of attempted murder. Prosecutors alleged that he had helped set up the theft from Nash, had led others to Laurel Canyon and had been present for the killings. Holmes told police he had taken no part in the killings and had been forced to lead others there. He did not testify at his trial in Los Angeles Superior Court, and in June 1982 the jury acquitted him on every count.
The acquittal did not free him. The following month Holmes was jailed for contempt after he refused to tell the Los Angeles County grand jury who had ordered or carried out the killings, saying he feared for his life. He was held for more than 100 days and was released after he agreed to appear before the grand jury. His testimony was never made public, and the transcripts stayed sealed.
In October 1982, in an unrelated case, a Los Angeles Superior Court jury convicted Nash of possessing a large quantity of drugs for sale, and he was sentenced to eight years in state prison. That conviction had nothing to do with the four deaths. Holmes died in March 1988, in the Sepulveda district of Los Angeles.
In September 1988, more than seven years after the killings, Nash and his former bodyguard were arrested and charged with four counts of murder and one count of attempted murder. The murder counts carried special-circumstance allegations that could have made each man eligible for the death penalty. Nash maintained that he was innocent.
The case came to trial in 1990, and both juries failed to reach a verdict. The judge declared mistrials. The district attorney's office tried both men again, and in 1991 the retrial juries acquitted Nash and his bodyguard of all the Laurel Canyon charges. In ten years the state had brought three rounds of trials and secured no conviction. The bodyguard died in 1995.
Nine years after the acquittals, the case returned in federal court. On May 19, 2000, Nash, then 71, was arrested in Tarzana, and a 16-count federal grand jury indictment against him was unsealed in Los Angeles. It charged him under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act with leading a criminal enterprise for about 25 years. Among the racketeering acts it alleged were the four Laurel Canyon killings, which it accused Nash of ordering, and the bribery of a juror in his 1990 trial.
The federal case never reached a jury. In 2001 Nash pleaded guilty to a racketeering charge under an agreement with prosecutors. In pleading, he admitted it had been understood that violence, up to and including killing, might occur in getting back the property taken from him. He did not plead guilty to murder, and no court has convicted him of any of the four deaths. In October 2001 a federal judge sentenced him to 37 months in federal prison.
What happened in Laurel Canyon that night has never been established by a verdict. Prosecutors in 1982 alleged that Holmes was present; a jury acquitted him, and he told police he had been forced to lead others there and had taken no part. The state's case in 1990 and 1991 rested on the theory that Nash ordered the killings in retaliation for the theft from him; it produced mistrials and then acquittals for both men. The federal indictment of 2000 repeated the accusation that Nash ordered the killings and charged that he had bribed a juror in 1990; neither accusation was tried, and the plea that ended the case was to racketeering. Nash's admission in that plea concerned what had been understood about recovering his property, not who killed the four victims. Holmes's grand jury testimony, the one sworn account he gave, has remained sealed.
July 1, 1981: Four people are killed and a fifth is critically injured in Laurel Canyon, Los Angeles.
December 1981: John Holmes is arrested in Florida and charged with four counts of murder and one count of attempted murder.
June 1982: A jury acquits Holmes of all counts.
July 1982: Holmes is jailed for contempt for refusing to testify before the county grand jury; he is later freed after agreeing to testify.
October 1982: In an unrelated case, Nash is convicted of possessing drugs for sale; he is sentenced to eight years in state prison.
March 1988: Holmes dies in Los Angeles.
September 1988: Nash and his former bodyguard are arrested and charged with four murders and one attempted murder.
1990: Both men's trials end in mistrials after the juries fail to agree.
1991: Retrial juries acquit Nash and his bodyguard of all charges.
1995: The bodyguard dies.
May 19, 2000: Nash is arrested and a 16-count federal racketeering indictment is unsealed in Los Angeles.
2001: Nash pleads guilty to a racketeering charge under a plea agreement; no murder charge is part of the plea.
October 2001: A federal judge sentences Nash to 37 months in federal prison.