ELEVEN WHO WROTE TO THE PRESS

In 2002 Tomas Guillen of Seattle University went through a run of American cases in which a killer had sent anonymous messages before he was caught: letters, poems, ciphers, telephone calls, words left at a scene. He wanted to know whether the messages had helped the police or hurt them. His answer, published in the Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture, was unsentimental. The communications rarely identified anyone. They tied cases together, they gave investigators handwriting, fingerprints and, later, DNA to use once a suspect was in hand, and they kept detectives busy chasing leads that went nowhere. More than one of the writers, Guillen noted, seemed to want to be caught.

These eleven cases run from Depression-era Cleveland to Delhi in the first years of this century. In some, the message was the mistake that ended the case. In others, it was the only voice the public ever heard.

Dennis Rader: the man who asked a question

In October 1974, nine months after four members of the Otero family were killed in Wichita, a letter claiming the killings was left in a book at the Wichita Public Library, and police recovered it. The writer described the crime in detail and gave himself a set of initials, BTK. In February 1978 a second letter reached KAKE-TV. In it the writer complained, in so many words, that he had not been given his name in the paper or any national attention, and the police chief, Richard LaMunyon, went before the public that evening to say that a serial killer was at large in Wichita. In 1979 he wrote to a 63-year-old Wichita woman whose home had been entered while she was out, to tell her he had been there. Then he stopped writing.

He came back on the 30th anniversary of the first killings, after a local newspaper suggested he might be dead or in prison. On March 19, 2004, The Wichita Eagle received a letter containing a photocopy of Vicki Wegerle’s driver’s license. She had been killed in 1986, and her death had never been publicly linked to BTK. Over the next eleven months, packages and messages went to police and television stations. In May 2004 KAKE received a word puzzle; among the words hidden in it, the Associated Press later reported, were letters spelling "D. Rader."

The ABA Journal’s account of the investigation counted 19 messages in all, ten of them in the eleven months before the arrest. Lieutenant Ken Landwehr acted as the task force’s go-between, writing his replies with advice from two FBI behavioral analysts whose aim was to keep the writer talking. In January 2005 a cereal box recovered by police held a question: could he communicate by floppy disk without being traced? He asked for the answer in a newspaper ad. The ad ran: "Rex, it will be OK." About two weeks later a disk reached a Wichita television station. It held a single test file. Its properties showed that it had last been saved by someone named Dennis and had been used at Christ Lutheran Church. The president of that church’s council was Dennis Rader, a Park City code enforcement officer.

He was arrested on February 25, 2005. In June he pleaded guilty to 10 counts of first-degree murder, and that August he was sentenced to 10 consecutive life terms. He was reported to be held at the El Dorado Correctional Facility in August 2025, twenty years after his sentencing.

The Zodiac: letters without a name

Five people were killed and two more wounded in four attacks around the northern San Francisco Bay Area between December 1968 and October 1969, in Benicia, Vallejo, at Lake Berryessa and in San Francisco. Police attribute all of them to a man who called himself the Zodiac. He has never been identified, and no one has been charged.

On July 31, 1969, three handwritten letters went out, to the Vallejo Times-Herald, the San Francisco Examiner and the San Francisco Chronicle. Each claimed the first two attacks and enclosed one third of a cipher, with a demand that the papers print it. A Salinas schoolteacher, Donald Harden, and his wife, Bettye, solved it at home within about a week. It contained no name. On August 4 the Examiner turned over another letter to the Vallejo police; it began with the line the writer would use for years, "This is the Zodiac speaking." After the San Francisco cab driver Paul Stine was killed that October, a letter to the Chronicle enclosed a piece of his shirt, and laboratory tests confirmed where it had come from. A second cipher of 340 characters followed in November, and the FBI’s cryptanalysts reported the next month that they could not break it. Just before Christmas the writer wrote to the lawyer Melvin Belli, asking for help, the Associated Press reported, and Belli publicly offered to meet him on any terms.

The letters thinned out after 1970. One received in January 1974 claimed 37 victims, a figure police have never accepted. In December 2020, 51 years after it was mailed, three amateur codebreakers, David Oranchak in the United States, the mathematician Sam Blake in Australia and the programmer Jarl Van Eycke in Belgium, solved the 340. The FBI verified their solution. It named no one, and the bureau said only that the investigation was ongoing.

Guillen counted the Zodiac’s letters among the most frustrating of his cases. They linked the attacks and brought the agencies together. They never pointed to a man.

David Berkowitz: Son of Sam and the columnist

The gunman who shot 13 people in New York City between July 1976 and July 1977, killing six, left a note for the police after an April 1977 shooting in the Bronx. Time reported that it described a father figure called Sam who directed him. The label Son of Sam, which police later said they had coined, attached itself to the case.

A second letter went to Jimmy Breslin, a columnist at the New York Daily News. It was postmarked in New Jersey, which Time took as a sign that the writer moved freely. He told Breslin that he read his column every day and found it "quite informative," and asked him to pass on a message: "Please inform all the detectives working the case that I wish them the best of luck." The letter joked that the detectives would need new shoes. Breslin printed excerpts and, in the same column, urged the writer to give himself up "to me, if he trusts me, or to the police." Women flooded the police tip line, Time later recalled, at about 100 calls an hour.

The letters did not catch him. A parking ticket did. It traced his car to David Berkowitz, a 24-year-old postal worker in Yonkers, who was arrested on August 10, 1977. In May 1978 he pleaded guilty to six murders, and in June he received the maximum of 25 years to life for each. In May 2024 he was refused parole after his 12th appearance before the board. Years after the shootings, Berkowitz sent Breslin a Christmas card from Attica.

Maury Travis: the letter

Between 2000 and 2002 women were killed on both sides of the Mississippi around St. Louis, in the city itself, in West Alton, Missouri, and in towns across the river in Illinois. In late May 2002 a reporter at the St. Louis Post-Dispatch received a letter, arrogant and mocking in tone, the St. Louis writer Traci Angel noted that July. The writer claimed 17 victims. The St. Louis police chief, Joe Mokwa, told ABC News that police could account for twelve: "We’re missing five of them."

The letter was traced, and the trail led to Maury Travis, a 36-year-old hotel waiter who lived in Ferguson, a St. Louis suburb. He was taken into custody in June 2002 and charged in a federal complaint with kidnapping two of the women. Days later he was found hanged in his cell in the St. Louis County jail. He was never indicted or tried, and no court heard the evidence. Police believe he killed at least 12 women, St. Louis Public Radio reported in 2025, when three women found in Illinois in 2002 were finally identified, as Kelly Johnson, Crystal Lay and Carol Jean Hemphill.

Keith Hunter Jesperson: the smiling face

In January 1990 Taunja Bennett, 23, was killed near Portland, Oregon. Two people were convicted of her death, and both went to prison. In 1994 newspapers and authorities in Oregon began receiving anonymous letters from a man who said he had killed her, the National Registry of Exonerations records. One, a six-page letter to The Oregonian, was signed with a drawn smiling face, Guillen wrote. Police doubted it at first. No one could put a name to the writer.

The name came in 1995. Keith Hunter Jesperson, a 40-year-old long-haul trucker, was arrested in March in the death of Julie Winningham, 41, and charged in Clark County, Washington. Before his arrest he had written to his brother that he had killed eight people in five years, that he was sorry he had "turned out this way" and that his "luck has run out," the Associated Press reported. He confessed to Bennett’s death with details only her killer and the police could have known. On November 27, 1995, a Marion County judge ordered the two people convicted in her death released, and that month Jesperson pleaded no contest to her murder.

Guillen concluded that the smiling-face letters had not identified Jesperson, but that his handwriting and fingerprints on them helped tie him positively to several killings once he was caught. Further pleas followed in other states, among them a guilty plea in Riverside County, California, in January 2010. In August 2026, when the last woman whose death was tied to his convictions was identified as Lydia Jane Wade McWhorter, the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office in California said he was serving multiple life sentences in Oregon.

Colin Ireland: the complaint about coverage

Between March 8 and June 12, 1993, five gay men were killed in London: Peter Walker, Christopher Dunn, Perry Bradley, Andrew Collier and Emmanuel Spiteri. After the first death, the killer contacted the Samaritans and The Sun, PinkNews reported. Later he telephoned the police himself, to ask why they had not linked the deaths. In recordings of his police interviews broadcast in 2017, he spoke of killing as a "career" that would make him "famous."

He was Colin Ireland, a 37-year-old former soldier, and he was caught after security camera footage showed him with the last of the five men, the Yorkshire Post reported. On December 20, 1993, at the Old Bailey, he pleaded guilty to all five murders and received a whole life tariff. A Metropolitan Police advisory group review in 2007 found that the inquiry had been hampered by a lack of knowledge of London’s gay scene and had lost valuable time before the deaths were connected. Ireland died in Wakefield Prison on February 21, 2012, aged 57.

Lee Roy Martin: two calls to an editor

On May 19, 1967, Annie Lucille Dedmond disappeared near Gaffney, South Carolina, and her death came to light the next day in Union County. Her husband, Roger Dedmond, was arrested. Police testified that he had confessed in custody; he denied it, and witnesses placed him in a cafe in Spindale, North Carolina, at the time. On December 12, 1967, a jury convicted him of manslaughter, and he was sentenced to 18 years.

On February 8, 1968, Bill Gibbons, managing editor of a local newspaper, picked up the telephone to a man who would not give his name. The caller said he had killed Annie Dedmond, and he gave information that led the sheriff to two more missing young women, named in later reporting as Nancy Christine Rhinehart and Nancy Carol Farris, who had also been killed. Four days later the man called Gibbons again. He said more people would die, gave details of the Dedmond killing that had not been made public, and said her husband "should be released," according to the National Registry of Exonerations.

The next morning, February 13, Opal Dianne Buckson, 15, was abducted while her brother and sister watched. Two days later two men saw a man matching their description, wrote down his license plate number and gave it to the police. It led to Lee Roy Martin, a 30-year-old textile worker and father of three. He admitted all four killings. Roger Dedmond walked out of prison on February 29, 1968, after about ten months, and the charge against him was dismissed that September. Martin pleaded guilty to Annie Dedmond’s murder, was convicted on four counts of murder and was sentenced to four life terms, FOX Carolina reported in 2023, when a Gaffney exhibit recalled the case 55 years on. The Registry lists Dedmond’s case among its exonerations, with false confession and official misconduct as factors.

The Cleveland torso killings: postcards to Eliot Ness

Between September 1935 and August 1938, at least a dozen people were killed in Cleveland. Most were poor drifters, and most were never identified. The press called the unknown killer the Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run. Eliot Ness, the city’s director of public safety, led the hunt. No one was ever tried for any of the killings, and the killer has never been identified.

Ness believed he knew who it was. In 1938, Cleveland Magazine reported, investigators held a physician, Francis E. Sweeney, for days of secret questioning at a downtown hotel, and a polygraph examiner told Ness he had his man. There was not enough evidence to take to court, and Sweeney was released. He was never arrested or charged. About a week after the last bodies were found in August 1938, he checked himself into a veterans' home in Sandusky, Ohio, whose staff told police whenever he left.

For years afterward, Ness received cryptic, taunting postcards. Among his papers, donated in the 1970s, was one signed "F.E. Sweeney, paranoidal nemesis," the magazine reported, and the Encyclopedia of Cleveland History holds an image of a card mailed to Ness in 1954 by an asylum inmate whom some believe to have been the torso killer. Sweeney died in 1964. The postcards remain a curiosity in a case that no court ever resolved. Since 2024 the Cuyahoga County medical examiner has been working with genetic genealogists to put names to the unidentified dead, CBS News reported.

Tsutomu Miyazaki: the name of a woman who did not exist

Between August 1988 and June 1989, four girls aged 4 to 7 disappeared from their neighborhoods in Saitama Prefecture and Tokyo. In February 1989 the Tokyo head office of the Asahi Shimbun received a declaration of responsibility for the death of the first girl, and later a confession letter. Both were signed with the name Imada Yuko. Letters also went to the girl’s family. The letters gave a return address in Tokorozawa, in Saitama. Coverage of the case intensified after they appeared, a Fuji TV news team later wrote, and Japanese commentators came to describe it as a theater-style crime, staged partly for an audience.

The letters did not catch the writer. In July 1989 the father of a 6-year-old girl caught a man with his daughter in a park in Hachioji, and police arrested Tsutomu Miyazaki, a 26-year-old photo technician who lived with his family in western Tokyo. The girl survived. Under questioning he confessed to the death of the girl from Koto Ward, and his statements led investigators to the others. Interrogation recordings broadcast by Fuji TV in 2017 showed, the team reported, that he had wanted the killer to appear to be a woman from Saitama.

The Tokyo District Court sentenced him to death in April 1997 for the murder of the four girls, with other charges, after years of conflicting psychiatric evaluations; Amnesty International Japan summarized the ruling as finding that he understood what he had done and bore criminal responsibility. The sentence became final in 2006, and he was hanged at the Tokyo Detention House on June 17, 2008, at 45.

Chandrakant Jha: letters in Hindi

Between October 2006 and May 2007, three young men were killed in west Delhi. Each time a handwritten letter in Hindi was left with the case. The letters mocked the Delhi Police. One, linked by the courts to the April 2007 case, named two police officers, warned of more deaths and was signed "CC." The third, written in green ink and found in May 2007, confessed to that killing and two earlier ones, ridiculed the police for failing to catch the writer and boasted of a yearly toll that the Delhi High Court later declined to accept as proved.

The writer also used the telephone. After the October 2006 death, calls were made from a public phone booth, and the booth operator later identified the caller in court. Police arrested Chandrakant Jha, a vegetable hawker from Bihar who worked around north Delhi’s Azadpur market, on May 20, 2007. A magistrate supervised the taking of 64 pages of his handwriting, and an expert matched them to the letters. The High Court treated the letters as the thread that tied the three cases together.

A Delhi sessions court convicted Jha of all three murders in January 2013. One of the three men, Anil Mandal, was identified through fingerprint records and DNA; another, Upender, through leads Jha gave after his arrest; the third has never been identified. Jha was sentenced to death twice and to life for the rest of his life in the third case. In January 2016 the Delhi High Court upheld all three convictions and replaced the death sentences with imprisonment for the rest of his natural life without remission. Police attribute seven killings to him in all. Released on parole in 2023, he did not return, and the Delhi Police Crime Branch rearrested him at Old Delhi Railway Station on January 17, 2025, the Press Trust of India reported.

Paul Michael Stephani: the weeping caller

Paul Michael Stephani did not taunt anyone. From the last night of 1980 to the summer of 1982, a man called police and emergency operators in St. Paul and Minneapolis after attacks on women, sobbing and apologizing. "Will you find me?" he asked in one call, according to Guillen, who quoted the Star Tribune’s coverage at the time. Some of the calls were traced, but the caller was gone each time officers arrived. Broadcast stations played the recordings, and police received more than 150 tips. None identified him; the crying distorted the voice too much, Guillen wrote. The newspapers called the caller the weepy-voiced killer.

He was caught in August 1982 after a 19-year-old woman survived an attack in Minneapolis and he was himself injured; on August 21 he called for an ambulance, the Minnesota Court of Appeals recorded. He was convicted of attempted second-degree murder and assault in that case, and of the murder of Barbara Simons, a 40-year-old nurse killed in Minneapolis that month. At the Simons trial, Guillen wrote, his former wife, his sister and a former housemate testified that they believed the voice on the recordings was his.

In 1997, ill with cancer in prison, Stephani confessed to two more killings, of Kimberly Compton, 18, in St. Paul in 1981, and Kathleen Greening, 33, in 1982, and to an earlier beating. He was never charged with them. Guillen judged that the calls had been of no investigative value while the cases were open. Stephani died in prison in June 1998, the Star Tribune reported, at 53.

Who they wrote to

Set side by side, the eleven cases show where these messages went. Almost none were addressed to the investigation. Berkowitz wrote to a columnist, Travis to a reporter, Jesperson to newspapers and the authorities, the Zodiac to three newspapers and a celebrity lawyer. Ireland contacted a tabloid and later asked the police why the killings had not been linked. Miyazaki wrote to a national daily and to a grieving family in the name of a woman who did not exist. Martin rang an editor, and Jha left his letters where the police would find them.

The messages that ended a case did so through the paper trail they left. Rader’s disk carried a name and a church. Travis’s letter was traced to him. Martin’s second call was followed within days by a license plate number that two men wrote down. Jesperson’s handwriting and fingerprints, and Jha’s handwriting, became evidence once the men were in custody. The Zodiac’s ciphers, decades later, still give no name. Guillen’s advice to investigators, at the end of his study, was to keep such writers talking, because every message is another chance for a mistake.

Timeline

• September 1935 to August 1938: at least a dozen people are killed in Cleveland; the killer is never identified.

• 1938: Francis E. Sweeney is questioned in secret and released; he is never charged. Postcards to Eliot Ness follow for years, one of them mailed in 1954.

• May 19, 1967: Annie Lucille Dedmond disappears near Gaffney, South Carolina; her husband is convicted of manslaughter that December.

• February 8 and 12, 1968: an anonymous caller tells a Gaffney-area newspaper editor he killed Annie Dedmond and says her husband should be released.

• February 1968: Lee Roy Martin is traced through a license plate number and admits four killings; Roger Dedmond is freed on February 29.

• July 31, 1969: letters and a three-part cipher reach the Vallejo Times-Herald, the San Francisco Examiner and the San Francisco Chronicle.

• November 1969: the Zodiac’s 340-character cipher reaches the Chronicle.

• October 1974: a letter claiming the Otero killings in Wichita is left in a library book; the writer calls himself BTK.

• 1977: Son of Sam letters go to the New York police and to Jimmy Breslin; David Berkowitz is arrested on August 10.

• February 1978: a BTK letter to KAKE-TV leads the Wichita police chief to announce that a serial killer is at large.

• May 1978: Berkowitz pleads guilty to six murders.

• 1980 to 1982: a weeping caller phones police and emergency operators in St. Paul and Minneapolis after attacks on women.

• August 21, 1982: Paul Michael Stephani is caught after a woman survives his attack; he is later convicted of her attempted murder and of the murder of Barbara Simons.

• February 1989: letters signed Imada Yuko reach the Asahi Shimbun in Tokyo.

• July 1989: Tsutomu Miyazaki is arrested in Hachioji.

• March to June 1993: Colin Ireland contacts the Samaritans, The Sun and the police during a series of five killings in London.

• December 20, 1993: Ireland pleads guilty to five murders at the Old Bailey.

• 1994: anonymous letters, one signed with a smiling face, reach The Oregonian and Oregon authorities.

• March 1995: Keith Hunter Jesperson is arrested; that November two people wrongly convicted of Taunja Bennett’s death are freed.

• April 14, 1997: Miyazaki is sentenced to death.

• 1997: Stephani confesses in prison to two more killings; he dies in June 1998.

• May 2002: a letter reaches a St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter; Maury Travis is taken into custody that June and dies in jail days later.

• March 19, 2004: a BTK letter reaches The Wichita Eagle after years of silence.

• January 2005: police answer BTK in a newspaper ad: "Rex, it will be OK."

• February 25, 2005: Dennis Rader is arrested; he pleads guilty to 10 murders in June.

• October 2006 to May 2007: three young men are killed in west Delhi, each case followed by a letter mocking the Delhi Police; Chandrakant Jha is arrested on May 20, 2007.

• June 17, 2008: Miyazaki is hanged in Tokyo.

• February 21, 2012: Ireland dies in Wakefield Prison.

• January 2013: Jha is convicted of three murders; in January 2016 the Delhi High Court upholds the convictions and commutes his death sentences.

• December 2020: the Zodiac’s 340 cipher is solved and verified by the FBI; it gives no name.

• May 2024: Berkowitz is refused parole for the 12th time.

• January 17, 2025: Jha is rearrested in Delhi after absconding from parole.

• August 27, 2026: the last woman whose death is tied to Jesperson’s convictions is identified in California.