SIX CASES THE STATE WAS TOO BUSY FOR

In January 1994, as South Africa counted down to its first democratic election, the boys of Mitchells Plain had been dying for eight years. More than fifty years earlier and half a world away, a railwayman in blacked-out Berlin killed eight women while the regime kept his crimes out of the newspapers. In postwar Tokyo, scores of infants died in a respected midwife’s care, and a ward office processed more than a hundred death reports from her home without asking why. In Inner Mongolia in 1996, an eighteen-year-old was tried, sentenced and executed within about two months of a killing, in the middle of a national campaign that demanded results fast.

The six cases that follow have little in common in method, motive or place. What joins them is the condition of the state around them. In each, the police, the prosecutors or the courts were occupied with something they considered larger: an uprising, a war, a ration system, a campaign quota. The killings, or the miscarriage of justice that followed one of them, went on in the space that was left.

Mitchells Plain: the boys of the Cape Flats

Mitchells Plain was built on the Cape Flats, the sandy, wind-scoured districts east of central Cape Town. Its people, wrote the University of Cape Town film scholar Ian-Malcolm Rijsdijk in 2024, had been moved from the 1950s onward away from the city and from the green slopes of Table Mountain, which were reserved for white South Africans. Rijsdijk argued that this marginal position, together with the political violence of the 1980s, gave the killer of the Cape Flats boys the perfect cover. A coordinated investigation, he wrote, began only in the months before the 1994 election.

Between 1986 and 1994 about twenty-two boys died in the series the press attributed to a single unknown man it called the Station Strangler. Reuters, reporting in June 1995, said police believed he had killed twenty-one boys and a young man over eight years. Their deaths came to light in Bellville in 1986, across the Cape Flats in 1987 and 1988, and in Mitchells Plain in October 1992 and again in January 1994, when eleven deaths came to light in a single month, according to IOL. Among the boys named in the reporting were Jonathan Claasen, 14; Calvin Spires, 9; Jacobus Louw, 10; Jeremy Smith, 12; Fabian Willmore, 8; Marcelino Cupido, 10; Neville Samaai, 13; Owen Hoofmeester, 12; Elino Sprinkle, 11; and Donovan Swarts, 11. Several boys were never identified, and reports do not agree on every age or spelling.

The Mail & Guardian, covering the trial in March 1995, described how slowly an absence registered in the township. Children moved among aunts, grandmothers and cousins, and families trusted the wider family to keep them. Few households had a telephone. When a boy did not come home, it could take days to establish that he was not simply staying with someone else. Jeremy Smith’s aunt told the Weekend Argus in 2023 that the boy, who had lost his mother when he was about three, was full of energy and devoted to his dog. Elino Sprinkle’s family said the same year that the police had never visited them.

In 1994 police arrested Norman Afzal Simons, a teacher at a primary school in Mitchells Plain. The arrest came at a time of intense pressure on the police, the Mail & Guardian noted, and vigilante groups had brought parts of the township close to anarchy. Simons was tried in the Cape Supreme Court in early 1995 on one case only: the kidnapping and murder of Elroy van Rooyen, a ten-year-old from Strand. Police had investigated him for ten of the deaths attributed to the Strangler in 1993 and 1994, the paper reported, but the state had decided the evidence in those cases was not strong enough to bring to court. About forty people, most of them relatives of dead boys, filled the public gallery in the first week. Several of them could not read or write and leaned forward to follow the legal argument.

Simons was convicted. On June 14, 1995, Judge Wally van Deventer sentenced him to twenty-five years for murder and ten for kidnapping, to run concurrently, and said it was difficult to find any sympathy "for a child murderer," Reuters reported. Simons appealed, and the appeal court not only dismissed his appeal but raised the sentence to life imprisonment, as the Department of Correctional Services' regional head in the Western Cape, Lawrence Venter, later confirmed.

No one has been convicted of any other death in the series. In August 2005 Simons was brought from Drakenstein prison to the Mitchells Plain Magistrate’s Court for an inquest into the deaths of three of the boys, Donovan Swarts, Elino Sprinkle and Marcelino Cupido; the prosecutor said the state would ask for every Station Strangler docket, and Simons agreed to give fresh samples for DNA comparison, the South African Press Association reported. The inquest’s final finding was not reported. In 2023 the Saturday Star and the Weekend Argus reported that forensic results in two of the other cases, including Jeremy Smith’s, did not match Simons, and that nothing had linked him by DNA to the remaining deaths.

Doubts about his single conviction have grown over three decades. The University of Cape Town psychologist Colin Tredoux, who studied the case with the Innocence Project in the United States, told the Saturday Star in 2023 that both the eyewitness identification and the confession had flaws. Others, among them Elroy’s family and Jeremy Smith’s aunt, have continued to hold Simons responsible.

He served twenty-eight years. When the department met residents and families in Mitchells Plain before his release in July 2023, Venter explained the limits of the law. "I know this is quite an emotive issue," he said, "but the minister only has the one conviction legally that he can consider." Simons was released on life parole on July 20, 2023, to house arrest with relatives in Parow, barred from Mitchells Plain and from contact with children. The South African Human Rights Commission said the state had failed the families of the boys whose deaths were never solved, eNCA reported. In November 2023 the department said he was complying with his conditions.

Atteridgeville, Boksburg and Cleveland: the women nobody hurried for

In September 1995, the Mail & Guardian set out a problem that had already defeated the newly formed South African Police Service for months. Three series of killings of young women were running at once around Johannesburg and Pretoria. Most of the dead were young; many had come to the cities from rural areas. Rural Black women, the paper wrote, were widely regarded as close to the bottom of South African society, and the police, eager to prove that they now served every citizen, were struggling to solve the cases.

The first series was in Cleveland, in Johannesburg. In December 1994 police arrested a man, identified in the reporting only as D.S., for fifteen killings there. He was shot dead by a policeman, who said D.S. had tried to attack him while in custody, and he was never tried. The second series, around Atteridgeville west of Pretoria, had fifteen deaths linked to it by September 1995. The third came to light near Boksburg, on the East Rand, in the week before September 22, 1995, when the deaths of ten more women were reported. Police were officially silent, the Mail & Guardian wrote, perhaps to avoid alerting the killer, perhaps because investigators disagreed among themselves.

On October 19, 1995, police in Pretoria announced that they had arrested Moses Sithole, then 31, whom they described as the most wanted man in the country, according to Keesing’s Record of World Events as summarized by South African History Online. They linked him to the deaths of at least thirty-seven women and one child. A man claiming to be the killer had telephoned reporters at The Star in Johannesburg before the arrest; at Sithole’s trial in 1996, a voice expert told the Pretoria court there was "no doubt whatsoever" that the caller’s voice was his, the Mail & Guardian reported. His wife, who had married him in March 1995 and who was never accused of any crime, gave evidence for the prosecution.

In December 1997 the Pretoria High Court convicted Sithole of 38 murders, 40 rapes and six robberies. The dead were thirty-seven women and a two-year-old boy who was killed with his mother. Judge David Curlewis sentenced him to 2,410 years and barred him from parole consideration for 930 years, IOL and SA People reported. South Africa no longer had a death penalty: in June 1995 the Constitutional Court had held capital punishment unconstitutional in S v Makwanyane. Curlewis made plain from the bench that he disagreed, and a Mail & Guardian editorial on December 12, 1997, rebuked him for denouncing the government in the Sithole case. Sithole told the press he had killed seventy-six people; that number is his own claim and has never been tested in court.

In November 2025, SA People reported that Sithole was among the prisoners held in the C-Max section of Kgoši Mampuru II prison in Pretoria. A Showmax documentary series, The ABC Killer, directed by Jasyn Howes, was released in July 2025. Several of the women, the Sunday Tribune reported in its account of the series, were never identified.

East London: the inquests that asked nothing

Louis van Schoor had served in the South African Police dog unit before he went into private security in East London, the port city on the Eastern Cape coast. By the late 1980s, the journalist Chiara Carter wrote for IOL in 2004, his firm guarded about seven in every ten businesses in the town, and his work was alarm response. Between 1986 and 1989 he shot dead a long succession of people he encountered on the premises he guarded. After each shooting he telephoned the police himself. Survivors were arrested. When the person died, the only legal step was an inquest.

The years were those of the states of emergency, a time of mass revolt and harsh repression, as Carter put it. The dead were Black, she noted, and the judicial officers who handled their inquests were white, and that went a long way toward explaining how van Schoor escaped scrutiny for so long. On November 1, 1989, the Deseret News, citing police and the owner of the business concerned, reported that van Schoor had shot dead an eighteen-year-old, Lindile Hilti, at an East London factory the previous weekend, and that Hilti was the twenty-seventh Black burglary suspect he had killed since 1986. Van Schoor declined to comment.

What broke the silence was reporting, not policing. Carter credited the journalists Patrick Goodenough and Dominic Jones, who worked through inquest files and court records and interviewed survivors; Goodenough struggled to get the story published until the Sunday Tribune put it on its front page, after which more accounts reached the Black Sash, the human rights organization. Van Schoor was charged with nineteen murders and twenty-one attempted murders, IOL reported. The trial divided the Eastern Cape. Andrew Trench, who covered part of it as a young reporter, told Eyewitness News in 2024 that van Schoor showed no remorse at all and that a support club formed around him; Carter recalled cars in the town carrying "I love Louis" stickers.

In 1992 he was convicted of seven murders and two attempted murders and given an effective sentence of twenty years. He served twelve of them at Fort Glamorgan prison in East London and was released on parole in October 2004. Leaving the prison, he read a statement written in pencil. "To the families and friends of my victims, I apologise if my action caused any hurt and discomfort," he said. A week later he told Carter that he rejected the labels mass murderer and serial killer. "I’m not a serial killer. I called the police after each encounter," he said, and insisted that race had nothing to do with it. IOL reported in 2004 that he was alleged to have killed thirty-nine people; only the seven murders of which he was convicted have been tested in a court. The law on the use of lethal force by security guards was later changed, Carter wrote.

In July 2024 BBC Africa Eye released a documentary on the case, The Apartheid Killer, made by Isa-Lee Jacobson and Charlie Northcott, Eyewitness News reported.

Berlin: a killer the newspapers were told to ignore

When the Second World War began in September 1939, Berlin went dark. The blackout ordinance put out street lamps, station lights and train lights to deny targets to enemy bombers. With men called up to the Wehrmacht, many of the women riding the S-Bahn alone late at night were shift workers keeping the war economy going while their husbands were at the front, t-online reported in 2026 from the files of the Berlin police history archive. The darkened railway was lethal in its own right: twenty-eight people died on the S-Bahn in December 1940 alone, Maclean’s noted in a 2014 review of Scott Andrew Selby’s book on the case, most of them in falls or struck by unlit trains.

Paul Ogorzow, born in East Prussia in 1912, worked for the Deutsche Reichsbahn on the line running east from Rummelsburg. He had joined the Nazi Party and had been a member of the SA, the party’s stormtroopers, since 1931, according to a 2014 article by Marcel Piethe in the Berlin magazine Maulbeerblatt. As a railway worker he was exempt from military service. Between October 1940 and July 1941, t-online reported, he killed eight women and seriously injured six more in eastern Berlin.

Five of the eight women have been named. Gerda Ditter, who had two small children and whose husband was serving with the Wehrmacht in Potsdam, died in Friedrichsfelde on October 4, 1940, according to the criminal police report the historian Roger Moorhouse transcribed from the Berlin archives. Elfriede Franke, a 26-year-old nurse, died at Karlshorst on December 3, 1940. Irmgard Freese, 19, died in hospital in Köpenick the next day. Johanna Voigt, 39, died on February 11, 1941, and Frida Korziol, 35, on the night of July 3, 1941, according to Maulbeerblatt. Three women who died in December 1940 and January 1941 have not been publicly named.

The criminal police mounted one of the largest operations in their history. A police protocol quoted by t-online lists members of the homicide squad, railway surveillance officers, a special unit of a commissioner and twenty men, a hundred criminal investigators and ten officers of the women’s criminal police. Male officers rode the trains dressed as women; detectives worked the line in railway uniform; more than five thousand railway workers were screened, by Maulbeerblatt’s count, and about eight thousand by Selby’s. The local party organization even set up an escort service for women traveling alone at night.

What the investigators could not do was ask the public for help. Joseph Goebbels’s Propaganda Ministry ordered that the press be kept out of the investigation, Maulbeerblatt reported, and the Maclean’s review says the leadership forbade any appeal to the public, arguing that an open investigation would have exposed him far sooner. The decisive lead came from an undercover officer, t-online reported, and investigators narrowed the list through the railwaymen’s night-shift rosters. Ogorzow was arrested in July 1941, denied everything at first, then confessed. Moorhouse records that he admitted eight counts of murder and more than thirty of assault. He was sentenced to death in Berlin and executed at Plötzensee prison the day after the sentence; Maulbeerblatt gives the date as July 24, 1941. The case was largely forgotten until Moorhouse came across the files in 2008.

Tokyo: the ration and the ward office

Miyuki Ishikawa, born in Miyazaki Prefecture in 1897, trained as a midwife at the hospital of Tokyo Imperial University and by early 1948 was one of the most senior figures in her profession in Tokyo, a director of the national association of midwives, nurses and public health nurses. With her husband, Takeshi, a former policeman, she ran the Kotobuki maternity home in Ichigaya, in Shinjuku Ward. Besides delivering babies, the home took in, for a fee, infants whose mothers could not keep them, most of them born outside marriage, and passed some on to people who paid for a child. Abortion was then a crime under the Penal Code.

The deaths came to light in Tokyo in January 1948, and the couple were arrested on January 15. The scale of what had happened was never settled. An early Asahi Shimbun report put the dead at 169; the same paper corrected the figure within days to 103; the official history of the Tokyo police gives 85, according to the writer Arata Koike in Bunshun Online. A House of Representatives report published in 2023 says more than a hundred infants died. On January 21 Ishikawa told the Yomiuri Shimbun, in written answers, that she had known the children would die on what she gave them, and that she had cut their food because there was no prospect of paying for more.

The press looked past the couple almost at once. The Shinjuku ward office’s sanitation section told the Asahi it had received 103 death reports from the home and had thought the number odd; the section that issued ration tickets said the paperwork had been in order. The Asahi called it bloodless office work. A Jiji Press commentary argued that an infant fed only on the official ration would die regardless of anyone’s intent, since the ration supplied two cans of milk a month when eight to ten were needed. In the House of Representatives on February 2, 1948, Michiko Yamazaki of the Japan Socialist Party called the case the tip of the iceberg and asked for an accounting from the police, doctors and officials who had let it continue. The Minister of Health and Welfare, Sadayoshi Hitotsumatsu, conceded that such homes were not properly supervised and that the milk ration could not raise an infant.

The prosecution told the Tokyo District Court in September 1948 that eighty-four infants had died at the home between April 1946 and January 1948, and that in twenty-seven of those deaths the evidence of murder was clear. On October 11, 1948, the court held the evidence insufficient on twenty-two of the twenty-seven. On the remaining five, it convicted the Ishikawas of jointly causing the deaths through malnutrition by omission and sentenced Miyuki Ishikawa to eight years. On April 28, 1952, the Tokyo High Court set that judgment aside and imposed four years; the Supreme Court upheld the appeal ruling. How much of the sentence she served has not been reported. In 1948 the Diet passed the Eugenic Protection Law and brought maternity homes under national regulation for the first time, and the 2023 parliamentary report opens its account of that law’s origins with the Kotobuki case. Ishikawa died in May 1987, aged 90.

Hohhot: sixty-two days

On April 28, 1996, China launched a nationwide "strike hard" campaign against crime. By early July, Amnesty International reported, at least a thousand people had been executed since it began, and Amnesty believed the true number was far higher; in one province three men were arrested on May 24, sentenced on May 27 and executed on May 31. The Ministry of Public Security set up a strike-hard office that April, and on May 3 the campaign group in Inner Mongolia described its task as pressed for time and heavy, the Beijing News reported in 2014. Cases were to be handled under the directive to punish harshly and swiftly.

On the evening of April 9, 1996, a woman surnamed Yang was killed in Hohhot, the regional capital. The person who reported the crime to the police was Hugjiltu, an eighteen-year-old ethnic Mongolian who worked at a cigarette factory. On May 17, 1996, the Hohhot Intermediate People’s Court sentenced him to death for intentional homicide, and to five years for hooliganism, with the death sentence to be carried out at once. The Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court rejected his appeal on June 5. He was executed on June 10, 1996. The Beijing News, which put the time from crime to execution at sixty-two days, placed the case squarely within the second national strike-hard campaign.

Nine years later, in October 2005, police in Inner Mongolia arrested Zhao Zhihong, who confessed to more than twenty robberies, killings and other crimes. The first killing of its kind he described, the People’s Court Daily reported, was the one in Hohhot on April 9, 1996. His confession did not reopen the case. Prosecutors left the 1996 killing out of his indictment, a closed hearing in November 2006 was adjourned, and his trial did not resume until 2015. Hugjiltu’s parents spent close to a decade petitioning.

On December 15, 2014, the Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court set aside the 1996 conviction and the appeal ruling and declared Hugjiltu not guilty, holding that the facts were unclear and the evidence insufficient: his confession did not fit the forensic record, the scientific evidence could not identify him, and his statements were unstable and contradicted other evidence. Xinhua reported on December 31 that the court had awarded his parents 2,059,621.40 yuan in state compensation. Money could not bring back a life, they said. In March 2015 the president of the Supreme People’s Court, Zhou Qiang, told the national legislature that the courts deeply reproached themselves for wrongful convictions, and the report that carried his remarks said detectives had admitted their work was measured by an annual quota of solved cases. On February 1, 2016, the authorities in Inner Mongolia announced that twenty-seven people had been held responsible: a former deputy police chief of Hohhot was dealt with under criminal law, and twenty-six others from the police, the procuratorate and the courts received Party or administrative discipline. Hugjiltu’s mother told Radio Free Asia the handling had been too hasty.

Zhao was convicted in 2015 and sentenced to death. On its review of the sentence, the Supreme People’s Court confirmed seventeen crimes committed between September 1996 and July 2005, intentional homicide with other charges, including robbery and theft, in which six people were killed. It declined to confirm four others. One of the four was the killing of 1996. Zhao had confessed to it on his own initiative and had never wavered, the head of the court’s Fifth Criminal Division said, but his account of the time, of what the victim wore and of other details conflicted with the evidence. "The retrial of the 'Hugjiltu case' ended in acquittal because the evidence that Hugjiltu committed intentional homicide was insufficient, not because Zhao Zhihong admitted to being the real killer," the division head said. Zhao was executed at Hohhot on the morning of July 30, 2019.

The space that was left

Set side by side, the six cases show the same pattern from different angles. In Mitchells Plain, by Rijsdijk’s account, a coordinated investigation began only when the 1994 election drew the world’s attention, after eight years of deaths. Around Pretoria and Johannesburg, a new police service still learning to serve every citizen struggled with three series at once. In East London, a run of shootings passed through inquests until two journalists read the files. In Berlin, a regime that would not let its newspapers report a killer on the trains denied its own detectives the public’s help. In Tokyo, a ward office logged more than a hundred infant deaths from one address before anyone asked about them. In Hohhot, a campaign that measured success in speed sent a teenager to his death in sixty-two days, and the man who later claimed the killing waited nine years for a court to take up his confession, only for the highest court to hold that he had not been proved guilty of it.

None of it changes what the convicted did. It changes how long they had.

Timeline

• 1919: Miyuki Ishikawa graduates in midwifery from the course attached to Tokyo Imperial University’s hospital.

• September 1939: war begins, and the blackout ordinance takes effect in Berlin.

• October 4, 1940: Gerda Ditter dies in Friedrichsfelde, Berlin, the first of eight women Paul Ogorzow admitted killing.

• July 3, 1941: Frida Korziol dies in eastern Berlin, the last of the eight.

• July 1941: Ogorzow is arrested, confesses, is sentenced to death and is executed at Plötzensee; Maulbeerblatt gives the date of execution as July 24.

• January 1948: infant deaths at the Kotobuki maternity home come to light in Tokyo; Miyuki and Takeshi Ishikawa are arrested on January 15.

• February 2, 1948: the Kotobuki case is debated in the House of Representatives.

• October 11, 1948: the Tokyo District Court convicts the Ishikawas of five deaths by omission; Miyuki Ishikawa is sentenced to eight years.

• April 28, 1952: the Tokyo High Court reduces her sentence to four years; the Supreme Court later upholds it.

• 1986: the first death in the Station Strangler series comes to light in Bellville, Cape Town; van Schoor’s shootings in East London begin.

• May 1987: Miyuki Ishikawa dies, aged 90.

• November 1, 1989: the Deseret News reports that van Schoor has shot dead his twenty-seventh burglary suspect since 1986.

• 1992: van Schoor is convicted of seven murders and two attempted murders.

• January 1994: eleven deaths of boys come to light near Mitchells Plain.

• 1994: Norman Afzal Simons is arrested.

• December 1994: police arrest D.S. for fifteen killings in Cleveland, Johannesburg; he is shot dead by a policeman and never tried.

• June 14, 1995: Simons is sentenced for the kidnapping and murder of Elroy van Rooyen.

• September 1995: the deaths of ten women come to light near Boksburg.

• October 19, 1995: police announce the arrest of Moses Sithole.

• April 9, 1996: a woman surnamed Yang is killed in Hohhot.

• April 28, 1996: China’s national strike-hard campaign begins.

• June 10, 1996: Hugjiltu is executed.

• December 1997: Sithole is convicted of 38 murders, 40 rapes and six robberies and sentenced to 2,410 years.

• October 2004: van Schoor is released on parole after twelve years.

• August 2005: an inquest into three of the Station Strangler deaths opens at the Mitchells Plain Magistrate’s Court.

• October 2005: Zhao Zhihong is arrested in Inner Mongolia and confesses to the 1996 killing among other crimes.

• December 15, 2014: Hugjiltu is declared not guilty on retrial.

• February 1, 2016: twenty-seven officials are held responsible for the Hugjiltu case.

• July 2, 2019: the Supreme People’s Court approves Zhao’s death sentence on seventeen crimes and declines to confirm four, including the 1996 killing.

• July 30, 2019: Zhao is executed at Hohhot.

• July 20, 2023: Simons is released on life parole.

• July 2024: the documentary The Apartheid Killer is released.

• November 2025: Sithole is reported held in C-Max, Kgoši Mampuru II prison, Pretoria.