Ta Mok

Victims
Unknown number of deaths, 1975 to 1979: charged with genocide and crimes against humanity by the Military Court of Cambodia; never tried.
Years active
1975 to 1979 (period of the charges)
Location
Southwest Zone (Takeo and Kampot provinces), Cambodia (alleged killings); Anlong Veng, Cambodia (arrest); Phnom Penh, Cambodia (detention and death).
Method
Cause of death not made public for any specific charged death; the charges covered killings by Khmer Rouge forces, 1975 to 1979 (never tried).
Status
Held without trial from March 1999; the Extraordinary Chambers had not yet charged him. Died in custody at a military hospital in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, July 21, 2006.

Ta Mok was the last senior commander of the Khmer Rouge still at large when Cambodian soldiers took him into custody on March 6, 1999, in Anlong Veng district near the Thai border. For most of the movement's history he had been one of its most powerful men: secretary of the Southwest Zone from the late 1960s, a member of the party's Standing Committee after the 1975 victory, chief of the general staff of its armed forces from 1977, and, in the movement's last years, its leader. The Military Court of Cambodia charged him with genocide in September 1999 and with crimes against humanity in February 2002, and he spent the rest of his life waiting for a trial that never came. He died in custody at a military hospital in Phnom Penh on July 21, 2006, weeks after the judges and prosecutors of the new United Nations-backed tribunal took their oaths. No court ever ruled on his guilt.

The regime he helped lead governed Cambodia from April 1975 to January 1979, and an estimated 1.7 million people died under it. The charges against Ta Mok held him responsible for part of that toll, through the authority he exercised over the Southwest Zone and through the army he commanded. He denied all of it. He told his lawyer that he had never killed anyone, and in 1997 he blamed the regime's killings on Pol Pot and on the chief of the S-21 security prison alone.

He was born Ung Choeun in 1926 in Prokeab village in Takeo province, in an area that the Khmer Rouge later called Region 33 of the Southwest Zone. Over his life he used several other names, among them Chhit Choeun, Ek Choeun, A'cha Choeun and Nguon Kang, and party documents referred to him by the code name Brother 15. He went to school in his native district until he was 18, then entered a Buddhist pagoda school and became a monk at Wat Mohamontrey, where he remained until he graduated.

He left the monkhood after the age of 30, and by then he was already active in the armed movement against French rule. In 1949 he led an Issarak resistance group in Tramkak district of Takeo. A 2001 legal study of the Khmer Rouge leadership, prepared for the War Crimes Research Office at American University's law school, places him in the Indochinese Communist Party from 1950, as a district chief in his native province, and has him organizing for the communists in the southwest through the late 1950s. In 1963 he became a member of the Central Committee of the Cambodian Communist Party, and in 1968 or 1969 he became party secretary of the Southwest Zone, the post on which his later power rested. Ieng Sary, the movement's foreign minister, would later say that Ta Mok sat on the party's Military Committee as well, though only in name after 1975.

The civil war that brought the Khmer Rouge to power began in earnest after Lon Nol removed Norodom Sihanouk as head of government in March 1970. Ta Mok's zone was one of the movement's strongholds. In 1972, at a meeting in Kampong Chhnang, he urged about 3,000 Buddhist monks to join the revolutionary army. In 1973 he took command of the Southwest Zone's army, and in 1974 his forces, together with those of the commander Ke Pauk, took Oudong district, the old royal capital, and Kampong Chhnang province.

The Khmer Rouge captured Phnom Penh on April 17, 1975, emptied the city and declared a new state, Democratic Kampuchea. In September 1975 Ta Mok took a seat on the party's Standing Committee, the small body that ruled the country. On March 30, 1976, he was named second vice chairman of the standing committee of the regime's assembly. In 1977 he became commander in chief of the army, and in November 1978 he became vice secretary-general of the party. Human Rights Watch, in a statement after his arrest, described him as chief of the general staff of the Khmer Rouge armed forces and the third-ranking figure in its military chain of command, after Pol Pot and Son Sen.

Through all of it he kept the Southwest Zone. The zone took in Takeo and Kampot provinces and much of the country's southwest, and his authority there was formal and broad. On March 30, 1976, the Central Committee gave zone secretaries the power to decide on what the party called smashing, its word for arrest and killing, within and outside party ranks in their own zones. The 2001 study, which drew on documents found by the Documentation Center of Cambodia, concluded that this decision, together with his seats on the Standing Committee and the Central Committee, gave him both the legal and the practical authority to direct the conduct of the party's people in the southwest.

The study built its case against him in three layers. The first was his position. The second was what other leaders said about him after the regime fell. Kaing Khek Iev, known as Duch, the chief of S-21, said Ta Mok "had his own prison" in the Southwest Zone and that many people died there under his authority. Duch also said he had heard that in November 1978, acting on Nuon Chea's orders, Ta Mok personally arrested a fellow member of the Standing Committee in Phnom Penh so that he could be sent to S-21; Duch had that account secondhand. Ieng Sary said that Pol Pot, Nuon Chea and Son Sen made the overall decisions on killings and relied on Ta Mok, as zone secretary, to carry them out.

The third layer was paper. The records of S-21, the regime's central security prison in Phnom Penh, hold the forced confessions of more than thirty cadres and others from the Southwest Zone, and transfer notes from 1977 show prisoners being sent there from the zone. Several confessions carry cover notes marking them for Ta Mok. One, from a district secretary in Sector 25, is marked as sent to "Brother Mok" on November 12, 1977. Another, from the former secretary of Sector 25, is marked "Comrade Mok Has Read Already" and dated April 18, 1978. A third, from a battalion secretary, was presented to him in May 1977 and carries a margin note in Duch's handwriting saying that a cadre named in it had already been dealt with by Brother 15. Names of suspected traitors in the same document are underlined or marked with an X, many of them from Sectors 33 and 35 of the Southwest Zone.

On that record the study's authors concluded that there was a prima facie case of his criminal responsibility. As head of the zone, they wrote, he appeared to have directed subordinates to arrest and kill party cadres, which would make him individually responsible, and he could also be held responsible as a superior for failing to prevent or punish crimes by the people under his command. They were careful to call much of this evidence potentially probative rather than proof. A confession marked as read shows that a document reached his office. It does not show what he decided.

The Documentation Center's own chronology adds one more accusation, linking his group in 1978 to mass killings in Angkor Chey district of Kampot province. No court ever examined it.

Vietnamese troops invaded Cambodia at the end of December 1978 and occupied Phnom Penh on January 7, 1979. Ta Mok commanded a division in Kampong Tralach district of Kampong Chhnang province as the regime collapsed, then retreated with the rest of the movement toward the Thai border. In the twelve years of civil war that followed he remained one of its most powerful figures, controlling its northern territory from Anlong Veng. By the 1990s he was known as a one-legged general.

Cambodia's government outlawed the Khmer Rouge in 1994. From 1996 onward many of the movement's leaders defected to the government and lived freely afterward under what amounted to pardons. Ta Mok did not. In June 1997, as the movement split over whether to negotiate, Son Sen was killed on Pol Pot's orders and Pol Pot fled Anlong Veng. Ta Mok turned against him, declared himself supreme commander and took Pol Pot into his custody. A so-called people's tribunal of former comrades sentenced Pol Pot to lifelong house arrest at Anlong Veng on July 25, 1997.

That same year Ta Mok gave his own account of the regime's past. He said Pol Pot was the "Number One" in Kampuchea and that the security prison had been the affair of Pol Pot and its chief alone. He conceded that the Standing Committee held meetings and joint study sessions and that from late 1978 he had been "responsible for the countryside," but he denied any knowledge of or part in killings there.

Pol Pot died on April 15, 1998, still in Ta Mok's hands, as government forces closed in on Anlong Veng, and the town fell the same year. The last Khmer Rouge guerrillas surrendered on February 9, 1999. Ta Mok, who had refused the government's offer of amnesty, was left at the head of a small band of followers.

On March 6, 1999, the Cambodian army captured him in Anlong Veng district near the northern border with Thailand and flew him to Phnom Penh. He was held at the military prosecutor's detention facility of the Phnom Penh Military Court and arraigned three days later. The first charges came under the 1994 law outlawing the Khmer Rouge: membership in an illegal organization, and terrorism and anti-government activities. In April 1999 he chose a lawyer of his own, a Cambodian-American who had practiced in Washington and had never met him, giving a single reason in a handwritten note: that the lawyer was "old enough to defend my case."

From the first week the arrest raised the question of which court should try him. Amnesty International argued that the Military Court had no jurisdiction over him, since he was not a member of the armed forces, and that holding him before it amounted to arbitrary detention; the objection was never decided.

The more pressing problem was time. Cambodian law allowed six months of detention before trial, which would have forced a trial by September 1999. In August 1999 the National Assembly passed an amendment allowing three years of detention without trial for suspects charged with genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes.

On September 7, 1999, Ta Mok was charged with genocide under a decree issued in 1979, which brought him under the new three-year rule. The investigation moved slowly while the government and the United Nations negotiated over an international tribunal. In July 2001 the War Crimes Research Office study named him as one of seven living leaders against whom there was credible evidence, and on August 10, 2001, the law creating the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia was signed.

By early 2002 the three-year limit was close to running out. On February 22, 2002, the military court charged him with crimes against humanity, which gave it another three years. When that second period approached its end, the court laid further charges against him, allowing him to be held for three more years. By then the United Nations and Cambodia had signed their agreement on the tribunal, on June 6, 2003.

The tribunal's judges and prosecutors were sworn in early in July 2006, and the co-prosecutors began building their cases on July 10. Ta Mok did not live to face them. In late June he had been moved from prison to the Phnom Penh Military Hospital, and in mid-July he slipped into a coma. He died on Friday, July 21, 2006, in his early eighties, still untried.

No court tested any of the evidence against Ta Mok, and the charges against him remain allegations. The 2001 study called the case against him prima facie and much of its evidence potentially probative. Its account of his personal role in the November 1978 arrest rests on what Duch said he had heard from someone else. The confessions sent to him were extracted at S-21 and are evidence of what reached his office, not proof of what he ordered. The killings in Angkor Chey district attributed to his group in 1978 appear in the Documentation Center's chronology as an accusation, not a finding.

His own account was a flat denial. He said he never killed anyone, that Pol Pot and the S-21 chief decided who died, and that the Standing Committee did not interfere in security matters. Ieng Sary and Duch agreed that he had no direct responsibility for S-21 itself but contradicted his claim to have known nothing.

The challenge to the Military Court's jurisdiction over him was never decided, and none of the charges was ever put to a judge at trial.

Timeline

1926: Born Ung Choeun in Prokeab village, Takeo province.

1949: Leads an Issarak resistance group in Tramkak district.

1963: Joins the Central Committee of the Cambodian Communist Party.

1968 to 1969: Becomes party secretary of the Southwest Zone.

1974: His forces take Oudong and Kampong Chhnang province.

April 17, 1975: The Khmer Rouge take Phnom Penh.

September 1975: Joins the party's Standing Committee.

March 30, 1976: Zone secretaries are given authority over arrests and killings in their zones.

1977: Becomes commander in chief of the army.

November 1978: Becomes vice secretary-general of the party.

January 7, 1979: Vietnamese troops occupy Phnom Penh.

1994: Cambodia outlaws the Khmer Rouge.

June 1997: Takes Pol Pot into custody and declares himself supreme commander.

April 15, 1998: Pol Pot dies.

March 6, 1999: Arrested in Anlong Veng district and flown to Phnom Penh.

August 1999: The National Assembly allows three years of detention before trial for genocide suspects.

September 7, 1999: Charged with genocide.

August 10, 2001: The law creating the Extraordinary Chambers is signed.

February 22, 2002: Charged with crimes against humanity.

June 6, 2003: The United Nations and Cambodia sign the tribunal agreement.

July 2006: The tribunal's judges and prosecutors are sworn in.

July 21, 2006: Dies in custody at a military hospital in Phnom Penh, untried.