Sylvestre Gacumbitsi had been the bourgmestre of Rusumo commune, in the far southeast of Rwanda along the Tanzanian border, for almost eleven years when the country's president was killed on April 6, 1994. Within twelve days, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda later found, the man who had governed Rusumo as its highest-ranking local official had chaired a meeting that set killings in motion, toured his commune with army officers and a militia leader, told crowds at a market and a trading center to keep anyone from escaping, and led attacks on Tutsi civilians who had gathered at the Catholic parish of Nyarubuye. One Tutsi man, the tribunal found, he killed himself.
Arrested in a Tanzanian refugee camp in June 2001, Gacumbitsi was tried in Arusha in 2003 and 2004. Trial Chamber III found him guilty of genocide and of extermination and rape as crimes against humanity, acquitted him of murder as a crime against humanity, and sentenced him to thirty years. Both sides appealed. On July 7, 2006, the Appeals Chamber dismissed his appeal in its entirety, found that he had aided and abetted the murder of two of his Tutsi tenants, held him responsible for ordering the crimes of every attacker at Nyarubuye and at Kigarama, and replaced the thirty-year term with imprisonment for the remainder of his life.
Gacumbitsi was born in 1943 in Kigina secteur, in Rusumo commune, Kibungo préfecture. He taught in Kibungo préfecture, went on to chair the Banque Populaire de Rusumo, and then became bourgmestre of Rusumo commune, a post he held from 1983 until April 1994.
When he testified in his own defense in November 2003, he said he had taught for about twenty years before he was appointed bourgmestre on August 2, 1983.
The office he took on was the most powerful in the commune. The Trial Chamber, drawing on expert evidence about Rwanda's administrative structure, found that the bourgmestre represented the central administration in the commune and was its highest-ranking local administrative official, and that the local population saw him that way. Before multiparty politics came to Rwanda, Gacumbitsi had also been the local leader of the ruling party, the MRND. The bourgmestre had legal authority over communal workers and the communal police, and he was specifically responsible for maintaining law and order.
Rusumo reached the Tanzanian border at Rusumo Falls. Its people were Hutu, Tutsi and Twa, the three groups into which the Trial Chamber found Rwandan citizens were categorized in 1994. Witnesses for both sides agreed on one point about the years before the genocide. Even prosecution witnesses testified that Gacumbitsi had been of good character, had kept Tutsi friends and had good relations with Tutsi in the commune before the death of President Juvénal Habyarimana. The Trial Chamber accepted that evidence and later counted his conduct before April 1994 in his favor.
The Trial Chamber's account of the days that followed rests largely on two protected prosecution witnesses, one of them an alleged accomplice whose evidence it treated with caution. It found both credible.
On the morning of April 7, 1994, the day after the president's death, Gacumbitsi went to a provisional gendarmerie camp in Rusumo to meet its commander, then to the military camp at Rusumo Falls, and later received a gendarmerie colonel at the communal office.
On April 8 he attended a meeting in Kibungo with the préfet, the gendarmerie colonel, the other bourgmestres of the préfecture, local party representatives and local militia leaders. Gacumbitsi's own account of that meeting was different. He testified that it was a security meeting chaired by the préfet, that each bourgmestre reported on conditions in his commune, that he alone reported no trouble in Rusumo, and that the instructions issued there called for night patrols, a curfew and no racial discrimination.
The Trial Chamber placed the planning of the killings at a meeting on Saturday, April 9. Gacumbitsi chaired a meeting at the communal office attended by the conseillers of every secteur except one, who was Tutsi, and by the chairman and secretary of the local MRND. Gacumbitsi spoke about the war and about young Tutsi leaving the commune to join the Rwandan Patriotic Front. He asked the conseillers to hold meetings in their own secteurs between April 9 and 12, without the knowledge of the Tutsi, and to tell the Hutu there that all the Tutsi had to be killed so that the RPF would have no more accomplices. The witness said that before that meeting he had never heard Gacumbitsi say anything aimed at the killing of Tutsi. Gacumbitsi testified that he had called the conseillers together only to ask them to keep the peace.
Over the next three days, the Chamber found, he traveled through Rusumo with the gendarmerie commander, an army major and a militia leader from outside the commune, and went from secteur to secteur to check whether the conseillers had held their meetings. On April 12 he met the local leader of the CDR party and repeated a request he had first made two days earlier: that people not be allowed to flee to Tanzania. The Chamber found that he traveled every day within and beyond the commune, to meet gendarmerie officers or militia, to make sure the orders of April 9 were carried out, or to urge the people of Rusumo to join in the fight against the enemy and in the extermination of the Tutsi.
On the morning of Wednesday, April 13, about a hundred people gathered at Nyakarambi market at Gacumbitsi's request. He addressed them, gave them instructions and asked them not to let anyone escape. The Trial Chamber found that the instructions were directed at the Hutu majority, that they were meant to stop Tutsi from escaping the attacks to come, and that they prepared the Hutu to eliminate the Tutsi.
The same day he dealt with the tenants of a building he owned in Rusumo. Among them were two young Tutsi sisters. Witnesses testified that Gacumbitsi, accompanied by communal police, ordered the tenants to leave, and that he later ordered the two sisters out again. Both sisters were killed that night.
The Trial Chamber found that Gacumbitsi had expelled his Tutsi tenants knowing that he was exposing them to the imminent risk of being targeted by Hutu attackers, and it treated that as part of the wider attack on Tutsi civilians. It did not find, on the evidence, that he had ordered their deaths, and it acquitted him of murder as a crime against humanity. That question would return on appeal.
On April 14, at the Rwanteru trading center, Gacumbitsi addressed about a hundred people and urged them to join the fight against the enemy, stressing that all the Tutsi had to be driven away. He then drove toward Kigarama, and some of the crowd followed. In Kigarama the attackers fell on the property of a Tutsi resident and looted it. The Appeals Chamber later held Gacumbitsi responsible for ordering the crimes committed by all the attackers at Kigarama that day.
By April 15 thousands of Hutu and Tutsi civilians had taken refuge at the Catholic parish of Nyarubuye, in Rusumo commune. That day Gacumbitsi arrived at the parish in a convoy of vehicles carrying communal police and militia, and the Trial Chamber found that he took part in the attack that followed. The Hutu among the refugees were told to separate themselves from the crowd, and an indeterminate number of them were spared. The Tutsi were attacked.
The Chamber found that Gacumbitsi killed one Tutsi civilian at the parish that day, and that on April 15, 16 and 17 he directed the attacks by giving clear instructions to the attackers to set upon the Tutsi who had sought refuge there. Among the attackers on April 15 were militia, gendarmes and communal police. He had authorized or facilitated the use of commune vehicles to bring the communal police and the militia to the parish. The attackers returned on the following two days.
The Chamber could not determine on the evidence whether almost all of the several thousand Tutsi refugees at Nyarubuye were killed, as the indictment alleged. It found instead that very many Tutsi were killed on April 15 and that many Tutsi who had sought refuge at the parish were killed there between April 15 and 17. The Appeals Chamber, summing up the case as a whole, described Rusumo as the commune where thousands of Tutsis were killed or seriously harmed.
The Chamber also found him responsible for instigating rape as a crime against humanity in Rusumo commune in April 1994, the basis of his conviction under Count 5.
The Rwandan Patriotic Front took control of the area, and Gacumbitsi crossed into Tanzania. A foreign television journalist who filmed at Nyarubuye after the RPF arrived later found him in a refugee camp in Tanzania and spoke with him there, and that journalist became one of the prosecution's witnesses.
On June 20, 2001, a judge of the Tribunal confirmed an indictment against him and issued an arrest warrant, and the same day the Tanzanian authorities arrested him at a refugee camp in the Kigoma region of western Tanzania and transferred him to the Tribunal, where the Registrar placed him in the United Nations Detention Facility in Arusha.
The indictment of June 20, 2001, charged Gacumbitsi with individual criminal responsibility for crimes committed against the Tutsi population of Kibungo préfecture between April 6 and 30, 1994. It contained five counts: genocide; complicity in genocide, as an alternative to the first count; and three counts of crimes against humanity, for extermination, murder and rape. The Prosecution pleaded his responsibility both for his own acts, under Article 6(1) of the Tribunal's Statute, and as a superior over those who carried out the crimes, under Article 6(3).
He first appeared before the Tribunal on June 26, 2001, and pleaded not guilty to each of the five counts.
The trial opened on July 28, 2003, before Trial Chamber III, a bench of three judges, with the Prosecution's opening statement. The prosecution case ran sixteen hearing days and closed on August 28, 2003. Its fifteen witnesses included survivors from Rusumo, Rwandans who had confessed to their own part in the killings under Rwandan law, the foreign journalist, and an American historian of Rwanda whose expert testimony from an earlier case was admitted in place of live examination.
Two rulings from the prosecution phase shaped the verdict. In August 2003 a witness gave evidence of an offense she said Gacumbitsi himself had committed, an allegation disclosed to the defense only the day before. The Chamber heard her in full but reserved its decision, and in October 2003, ruling of its own motion, it excluded that allegation from its deliberations, because the indictment did not contain it and the Prosecution had neither given notice of it nor sought to amend the indictment. In the same decision the Chamber dismissed a defense motion for acquittal on several counts.
The defense opened on October 6, 2003, and rested on November 25. Twenty-two defense witnesses testified, among them two medical experts.
Gacumbitsi gave evidence in his own defense in late November. He told the Chamber that from the day after the president's death he had tried to keep order in a commune too vast and too wooded to control, that he had been threatened with death for standing against the wrongdoers, and that out of fear he had gradually withdrawn from public life.
Closing arguments were heard on March 1, 2004.
Trial Chamber III delivered its judgment in Arusha on June 17, 2004, in French and English, with the French text authoritative. The verdict was unanimous.
On Count 1 the Chamber found Gacumbitsi guilty of genocide. It found that a substantial number of Tutsi civilians had been killed in Rusumo commune between April 7 and 18, 1994, that he had killed one Tutsi civilian at Nyarubuye on April 15, that he had played a leading role in conducting and above all supervising the attack, and that he had acted with genocidal intent. It held him responsible under Article 6(1) for planning, instigating, ordering, committing and aiding and abetting genocide, beginning with the meeting of April 9. Because he was guilty under Count 1, the Chamber made no finding on the alternative charge of complicity in genocide, and Count 2 was dismissed.
On Count 3 it found him guilty of extermination as a crime against humanity: individually responsible under Article 6(1) for planning extermination, inciting it, ordering communal policemen to exterminate, and aiding and abetting the extermination of members of the Tutsi group in Rusumo commune in April 1994. Having found him liable on that basis, it did not decide whether he was also liable as a superior under Article 6(3).
On Count 4 it found him not guilty. The indictment's specific murder allegations had either drawn no evidence, rested on testimony the Chamber found unreliable, or did not match the killings the witnesses described. On Count 5 it found him guilty of rape as a crime against humanity.
The Chamber also drew a limit around his authority. It found that, as bourgmestre, he was the superior of the communal police and communal staff. It could not find, on the evidence, that he had superior authority over the conseillers, gendarmes, soldiers or militia in his commune, because neither the law nor the evidence placed him at the head of a formal hierarchy over them.
At sentencing the Prosecution asked for life imprisonment.
The Chamber weighed his position as bourgmestre, the most important and influential figure in Rusumo, as an aggravating circumstance, because he had used it to take part in the crimes as one of their ringleaders, and it counted the seriousness of the crimes as aggravating as well. On the other side it set his work as bourgmestre and his conduct before April 1994, which defense witnesses and some prosecution witnesses had described. It found that he had joined an ongoing process rather than preparing the events in Rusumo over a long period, and that apart from the communal police he had not been the superior of the perpetrators. It declined to adopt the further aggravating circumstances the Prosecution had argued.
Measured against the sentencing practice of the Rwanda and Yugoslavia tribunals and of the courts of Rwanda, the Chamber imposed a single sentence of thirty years' imprisonment, to be served in a state designated in consultation with the Chamber, with credit for his time in custody. Enforcement was stayed once notice of appeal was given, and he remained in detention in Arusha. He announced that he would appeal.
Both parties appealed. Gacumbitsi raised five grounds: errors in the Trial Chamber's interlocutory decisions, errors in each of his three convictions, and, if the convictions stood, a sentence that he asked to have reduced to fifteen years. The Prosecution raised six. It argued that the Trial Chamber had erred in sentencing, in acquitting him of murder, in failing to hold him responsible for further rapes, in its statement of the elements of rape, in refusing to consider joint criminal enterprise because it had not been adequately pleaded, and in holding that he lacked authority to order anyone but the communal police.
The appeal was heard by five judges of the Appeals Chamber. The appeals were argued in Arusha on February 8 and 9, 2006, and judgment was delivered there on July 7, 2006.
The Appeals Chamber dismissed Gacumbitsi's appeal in its entirety. It upheld the genocide conviction, holding that a defect in the indictment over the one killing he had committed at Nyarubuye had been cured by the Prosecution's later submissions, and that his other proven conduct at the parish, including his personal supervision of the attack, also amounted to committing genocide. The dismissal was unanimous, but the five judges reached it by different majorities on the two lines of reasoning.
It upheld the extermination conviction. Rejecting his argument that the mental element required proof of a widespread practice planned and tolerated by the state, it held that a plan or policy can be relevant evidence but is not a separate legal element of a crime against humanity. It upheld the rape conviction as well, and set out the elements of rape as a crime against humanity, holding that non-consent and the accused's knowledge of it are elements the Prosecution must prove.
On the Prosecution's side, the Appeals Chamber allowed three grounds in part. By majority, with two of the five judges dissenting, it found that Gacumbitsi had aided and abetted the murder of his two Tutsi tenants, whom he had expelled and who were killed later that night, and it entered a conviction for murder as a crime against humanity under Count 4. It held him responsible for ordering the crimes committed by all the attackers at Nyarubuye Parish on April 15, 16 and 17, 1994, and at Kigarama on April 14, not only those committed by the communal police. And it found that the sentence was wrong.
The Trial Chamber, the Appeals Chamber held, had correctly said that a sentence must first be commensurate with the gravity of the crimes and the convicted person's degree of responsibility, and had then disregarded those principles. Gacumbitsi had played a central role in planning, instigating, ordering, committing and aiding and abetting genocide and extermination in a commune where thousands of Tutsis were killed or seriously harmed, and he had been convicted of instigating rape as a crime against humanity. Unlike most of those convicted of genocide who had received less than a life term, he had no especially significant mitigating circumstances. The Appeals Chamber concluded that the Trial Chamber had gone outside its discretion. It quashed the thirty-year sentence and entered a sentence of imprisonment for the remainder of his life, with credit for the time he had spent in detention since June 20, 2001. The Prosecution's remaining grounds, including its argument on joint criminal enterprise, were dismissed. Gacumbitsi was ordered to remain in the Tribunal's custody until his transfer to the state where he would serve the sentence.
Gacumbitsi was later transferred to Mali to serve the sentence. On July 1, 2012, supervision of his sentence passed to the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, whose President designates the state of enforcement, supervises the sentence and decides any request for pardon, commutation or early release. The Tribunal's official figures for 2021 still listed him as serving it in Mali.
The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda was established by the United Nations Security Council in 1994, acting under Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter, and it was governed by the Statute appended to Security Council resolution 955 and by its own Rules of Procedure and Evidence. Its jurisdiction in time ran from January 1 to December 31, 1994, which is why Gacumbitsi's indictment was confined to April 1994. Because his indictment charged no violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions or of Additional Protocol II, the Trial Chamber made no finding on whether Rwanda was in a state of non-international armed conflict.
The five counts against him drew on two articles of the Statute. Article 2 covered genocide and complicity in genocide; Article 3 covered crimes against humanity, which the Prosecution had to prove were committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population. The Trial Chamber confined that attack, for this case, to Rusumo commune.
Two forms of liability ran through the case. Article 6(1) made a person responsible for planning, instigating, ordering, committing or otherwise aiding and abetting a crime. Article 6(3) made a superior responsible for subordinates' crimes he knew or had reason to know of and failed to prevent or punish. The Trial Chamber held that the two could not be charged cumulatively on the same facts and kept the form that best described his conduct. Its narrow view of his superior authority, limited to the communal police, was the point the Prosecution attacked on appeal; the Appeals Chamber answered it not through Article 6(3) but by holding that he had ordered the crimes of every attacker at Nyarubuye and Kigarama.
On sentence, Article 23 of the Statute limited the penalty to imprisonment and directed the Trial Chambers to have recourse to the general practice regarding prison sentences in the courts of Rwanda, and to take into account the gravity of the offense and the convicted person's individual circumstances. Rule 101 allowed a fixed term or imprisonment for the remainder of the convicted person's life, required the Chamber to weigh aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and required credit for time spent in custody. On appeal Gacumbitsi pointed to the Rwandan Penal Code, which he said capped fixed terms at twenty years, or thirty for several offenses. The Appeals Chamber's ruling turned instead on the Tribunal's own principle that the sentence must match the gravity of the crimes and the degree of responsibility.
Gacumbitsi denied the charges throughout. He testified that he had tried to keep order in Rusumo, that the meetings of April 8 and 9 had dealt only with security, and that he had been threatened for opposing the attackers. The defense argued that criminals from elsewhere, and at times the refugees themselves, had committed the crimes in Rusumo, and that some of the dead at Nyarubuye were victims of the Rwandan Patriotic Front. The Trial Chamber held that an argument that the other side had also committed crimes was no defense, and it found that the report of the two defense medical experts did not cast doubt on the attacks of April 15 to 17.
Several allegations failed at trial. The indictment's account of a killing at the Nyabitare Catholic Centre rested on a witness whose evidence the Chamber found inconsistent and unreliable, and it made no finding against Gacumbitsi on it. The Prosecution conceded that it had offered no evidence on two other murder allegations. Evidence of the killing of a Tutsi man and his two children in April 1994 was set aside because the indictment had not pleaded that killing; the Chamber found only that unknown perpetrators had killed them. The Chamber could not find that almost all of the several thousand Tutsi at Nyarubuye had been killed, as the indictment alleged. And the allegation that Gacumbitsi had personally committed an offense charged under Count 5, raised for the first time during the trial, was excluded from the Chamber's deliberations.
The murder conviction entered on appeal was not unanimous. Two of the five appeal judges dissented from the finding that he aided and abetted the deaths of his tenants. The trial evidence on that night was itself divided: a defense witness testified that the killings in the area began with the deaths of the two sisters and were led by other men, and that the bourgmestre had not expelled his tenants that day.
1943: Gacumbitsi is born in Kigina secteur, Rusumo commune, Kibungo préfecture, Rwanda.
August 2, 1983: He is appointed bourgmestre of Rusumo commune, a post he holds until April 1994.
April 6, 1994: President Juvénal Habyarimana is killed.
April 7, 1994: Gacumbitsi meets gendarmerie and army commanders in Rusumo.
April 9, 1994: He chairs a meeting of the commune's conseillers at which, the Trial Chamber found, he instructs them to tell the Hutu to kill the Tutsi.
April 13, 1994: He addresses a crowd at Nyakarambi market; his two Tutsi tenants are expelled and are killed that night.
April 14, 1994: He addresses a crowd at Rwanteru; attackers loot Tutsi property at Kigarama.
April 15 to 17, 1994: Attacks on Tutsi refugees at Nyarubuye Parish, which the Trial Chamber found he directed.
June 20, 2001: Indictment confirmed; he is arrested by the Tanzanian authorities in the Kigoma region and transferred to Arusha.
June 26, 2001: He pleads not guilty to all five counts.
July 28, 2003: Trial opens before Trial Chamber III.
March 1, 2004: Closing arguments.
June 17, 2004: Convicted of genocide, extermination and rape as crimes against humanity; acquitted of murder as a crime against humanity; sentenced to thirty years.
February 8 and 9, 2006: Appeal hearing in Arusha.
July 7, 2006: The Appeals Chamber dismisses his appeal, enters a conviction for murder as a crime against humanity and imposes imprisonment for the remainder of his life.
July 1, 2012: The International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals takes over supervision of ICTR sentences.
2021: Listed by the Tribunal as serving his sentence in Mali.