Syed Rizwan Farook and Tashfeen Malik

Victims
14 deaths attributed to a couple, San Bernardino, 2015. Neither was charged or tried; both were killed by police that day. The FBI investigated the attack as terrorism.
Years active
December 2, 2015
Location
San Bernardino, Redlands and Riverside, California
Method
Fourteen deaths investigated by the FBI as an act of terrorism; never brought to court because both accused died the same day
Status
Both dead (December 2, 2015). Marquez pleaded guilty in February 2017 to material-support conspiracy and a false-statement count; 20 years in federal prison, October 23, 2020

On December 2, 2015, fourteen people were killed and twenty-two others were wounded at a San Bernardino County public health department gathering in San Bernardino, California. Federal investigators attributed the deaths to Syed Rizwan Farook, a 28-year-old county employee, and to his wife, Tashfeen Malik, who was 29. The couple fled, and later the same day both were killed by police in San Bernardino. Two officers were hurt.

Two days later the FBI announced that it was investigating the killings as an act of terrorism. Neither Farook nor Malik was ever charged, arrested or tried, and no court has ever ruled on what happened that morning. The only conviction to come out of the case belongs to a third man, Enrique Marquez Jr., a friend and former neighbor of Farook's, who pleaded guilty in 2017 to conspiring with Farook years earlier to provide material support to terrorists. In October 2020 a federal judge in Riverside sentenced him to 20 years in prison.

Farook was born in Illinois and grew up in Southern California. He finished La Sierra High School a year early, according to school records, and graduated from California State University, San Bernardino, in 2010 with a bachelor's degree in environmental health, and he went to work for the San Bernardino County Department of Public Health as an environmental inspector. By December 2015 he had been in the job for about five years.

Malik was born in Pakistan and spent most of her life in Saudi Arabia. She came back to Pakistan to study pharmacy at Bahauddin Zakariya University in Multan, in the south of Punjab province, and earned her degree there in 2013. That April she enrolled in a two-year course of Quran study at the Multan branch of Al-Huda International, a seminary for women. She attended until May 2014 and left without finishing, telling the school she would soon marry and move to the United States.

In July 2014 Farook traveled to Saudi Arabia, and that same month the two came to the United States together, she on a K-1 fiancée visa. They married in August 2014, the month after she arrived, and settled in Redlands. Neither had been under FBI investigation before December 2015.

Marquez came into Farook's life as the boy next door, moving in beside the Farook household in 2005, when he was 13. In 2011 and 2012, by Marquez's own later admission, he and Farook planned two attacks in the Riverside area. Neither was carried out. In 2012, by his account, Marquez dropped the plans and drew away from Farook. In November 2014 he married, and that marriage later became the basis of a marriage-fraud count against him.

On the morning of Wednesday, December 2, 2015, the county public health department held a meeting and holiday gathering for its employees in San Bernardino. Farook was there. Fourteen people in the room did not survive the morning.

The names of the dead were made public over the following days. They were Robert Adams of Yucaipa; Isaac Amanios of Fontana; Bennetta Bet-Badal of Rialto; Harry Bowman of Upland; Sierra Clayborn of Moreno Valley; Juan Espinoza of Highland; Aurora Godoy of San Jacinto; Shannon Johnson of Los Angeles; Lawrence Daniel Kaufman of Rialto; Damian Meins of Riverside; Tin Nguyen of Santa Ana; Nicholas Thalasinos of Colton; Yvette Velasco of Fontana; and Michael Raymond Wetzel of Lake Arrowhead. They came from towns across the Inland Empire and from as far away as Los Angeles and Santa Ana. Twenty-two other people were wounded.

By December 3 police in San Bernardino had identified the two dead suspects as Farook and Malik. On December 4 the FBI's Los Angeles office announced that the bureau was investigating the killings as an act of terrorism, and on December 9 the FBI director told the Senate Judiciary Committee what the bureau had found: both Farook and Malik had been radicalized before their online courtship began, as early as the end of 2013, and they had been inspired by foreign terrorist organizations rather than directed by one. The bureau had found no evidence that they belonged to a wider network or cell, and it was still working to learn whether anyone had helped them.

A week later the director filled in the timing. The two had begun exchanging direct, private messages about a shared commitment to jihad and martyrdom in late 2013, before they had ever met in person, and those exchanges had led to the engagement and to Malik's move to the United States. Investigators had found no public social media post by either of them, then or later, expressing that commitment.

The question of whether anyone had helped the couple led investigators to Marquez. On December 3, the day after the attack, he had called 911 and given the operator Farook's name. From December 6 through December 16 he sat for interviews with FBI agents and described the plans of 2011 and 2012 and his own part in them. On December 17 agents arrested him.

Marquez was charged in federal court in Riverside on the day of his arrest, and on December 30, 2015, a federal grand jury indicted him on five counts: conspiring with Farook in 2011 and 2012 to provide material support to terrorists, two false statements tied to purchases he had made for Farook, marriage fraud, and a false statement on immigration paperwork. The indictment did not accuse him of taking part in the December 2 killings, and no charge alleged that he had known of the attack in advance.

On February 16, 2017, in federal court in Riverside, Marquez pleaded guilty under the agreement, which spared him a trial. He pleaded to the material-support conspiracy and to one false-statement count, admitting that he had made purchases in his own name with Farook's money while declaring himself the actual buyer. In the plea agreement he acknowledged the two attacks the pair had planned in 2011 and 2012 that never took place.

Marquez later asked to withdraw his plea on the material-support count, saying that depression and guilt over what his friend had done, not a belief in his own guilt, had driven him to plead. In June 2020 the court denied the request, ruling that he had not shown a "fair and just reason" to withdraw it.

On October 23, 2020, in federal court in Riverside, Marquez was sentenced to 20 years in federal prison. He was 28. In fixing the term, the judge said he had weighed Marquez's 911 call and his cooperation with investigators.

No court ever determined the couple's motive. The FBI's conclusion that they acted as extremists inspired by foreign terrorist organizations rests on its own investigation, and an online post attributed to Malik on the day of the killings, which investigators weighed, was never examined by a court.

Whether Marquez knew of the attack beforehand was argued at his sentencing and never resolved by a charge: his lawyers said he did not, prosecutors said he understood an attack was likely and did nothing, and the indictment never accused him of advance knowledge. When he pleaded guilty in 2017, federal prosecutors had said they had no evidence that he took part in the killings or knew of them beforehand.

Timeline

2005: Enrique Marquez Jr. moves in next door to the Farook household; he and Farook meet.

2010: Farook graduates from California State University, San Bernardino, and begins work with the county public health department.

2011 to 2012: Farook and Marquez plan two attacks in the Riverside area that are never carried out; Marquez drops the plans in 2012.

2013: Malik earns a pharmacy degree in Multan, Pakistan; in April she begins Quran study at the Al-Huda seminary there, which she leaves unfinished in May 2014.

Late 2013: The FBI later dates the couple's radicalization to this period.

July 2014: Farook travels to Saudi Arabia; he and Malik enter the United States together, she on a K-1 fiancée visa.

August 2014: Farook and Malik marry.

November 2014: Marquez marries; the marriage later becomes a marriage-fraud count.

December 2, 2015: Fourteen people are killed and 22 wounded in San Bernardino; Farook and Malik are killed by police the same day.

December 3, 2015: San Bernardino police name the two dead suspects; Marquez calls 911.

December 4, 2015: The FBI announces it is investigating the killings as an act of terrorism.

December 6 to 16, 2015: Marquez is interviewed by FBI agents.

December 9, 2015: The FBI director tells the Senate Judiciary Committee that both were radicalized before they met.

December 16, 2015: The FBI director says the couple's private messages about jihad began in late 2013, before they met in person.

December 17, 2015: Marquez is arrested and charged.

December 30, 2015: A federal grand jury indicts Marquez on five counts.

February 16, 2017: Marquez pleads guilty in Riverside to material-support conspiracy and a false-statement count.

June 2020: The court denies Marquez's request to withdraw his plea.

October 23, 2020: Marquez is sentenced in Riverside to 20 years in federal prison.