In the early hours of July 22, 2006, after five days of hearings in the 1st Jury Court of São Paulo, a jury convicted Suzane Louise von Richthofen of the murders of her parents, Manfred Albert von Richthofen and Marísia von Richthofen. The two had died in São Paulo on October 31, 2002. Tried with her were Daniel Cravinhos de Paula e Silva, her boyfriend at the time, and his brother, Cristian Cravinhos de Paula e Silva. The jurors found all three guilty of two counts of homicide qualified by base motive, cruel means and a resource that made the victims' defense impossible, and of procedural fraud. Suzane and Daniel were each sentenced to 39 years of reclusão and six months of detenção. Cristian received 38 years of reclusão and six months of detenção, together with a further year for theft.
She was 18 when her parents died, and she had just turned 19 when she confessed. Her defense told the jury she had been coerced by her boyfriend, and the jury rejected that defense by a majority. The years that followed were a long run of habeas corpus petitions, a release before trial and a return to custody, appeals that reached the Superior Court of Justice and the Supreme Federal Court, and, from 2015, a slow progression through Brazil's sentence regimes. On January 11, 2023, a sentence-enforcement court in Taubaté moved her to the open regime, and she left custody that evening after a little more than twenty years.
Suzane von Richthofen was 18 in October 2002. Daniel Cravinhos, her boyfriend, was 21; his brother, Cristian, completed the group the prosecution later put before the jury.
The defendants told the story differently, and they told it against one another. Her lawyers argued that she had acted under her boyfriend's pressure. The brothers' lawyers did not seek an acquittal; their aim was to keep the sentences as short as possible and to show that she had planned everything. The conflict between those two positions ran through the case from the first weeks to the jury's last answers.
Her parents died in the south zone of São Paulo on October 31, 2002. The convictions record that both killings were committed by the three defendants acting together, with the brothers as authors and her as a co-author of each. The jury's findings, and the sentences that followed, are the court's account of that night. They describe a planned crime, committed for a base motive, by cruel means, against victims who were given no chance to defend themselves.
Within eight days, investigators had turned their attention to the two brothers, and through them to her. On November 8, 2002, she confessed to having planned the crime with Daniel. Daniel and Cristian admitted their own part. All three were taken into custody that day. A first order of preventive custody was issued on November 19, 2002.
The confessions defined the case for the next four years. What the defendants disputed was who had planned the killings and why, and whether she had acted freely. Those were the questions the jury would have to answer.
The prosecution charged all three with two counts of homicide qualified under article 121, paragraph 2, items I, III and IV of the Penal Code, committed in concert under article 29, and with procedural fraud under article 347, sole paragraph. Cristian also faced a charge of theft under article 155. A judge of the 1st Jury Court of the capital issued the pronúncia, the decision that sends a homicide case to a jury, on those charges. The defense appealed it, and the appeal traveled through the São Paulo courts and on to a special appeal at the Superior Court of Justice. The question of whether the pronúncia had become final would return again and again in later petitions.
She spent more than two and a half years in pretrial custody. On June 28, 2005, the Superior Court of Justice granted her a writ of habeas corpus, holding that the grounds given for her preventive detention were insufficient, and she was released the following day to await trial in liberty. The brothers obtained provisional liberty later the same year and left a state penitentiary on November 9, 2005.
The brothers' freedom lasted barely two months. On January 16, 2006, they gave a radio interview about the case. The prosecution asked for all three defendants to be detained again. On January 23, 2006, the presiding judge of the 1st Jury Court ordered the preventive detention of both brothers. He refused the request in her case. She had given her residential address when her release order was carried out, he found, the Superior Court of Justice had imposed no condition that she attend every hearing, and no step in the case had yet required her presence. She could not, he held, be treated as a fugitive.
That changed in April 2006. After a television interview with her was broadcast, the prosecution asked again for her detention, and on April 10, 2006, a judge of the 1st Jury Court ordered it. The grounds were a risk to a witness in the case; a risk to the application of the criminal law; and concern for the fairness of the jury trial. She surrendered and on April 13 was transferred to a women's center in São Paulo state.
Her lawyers filed for habeas corpus the next day. The 5th Criminal Chamber of the São Paulo Court of Justice refused it, calling the custody reasonable. On May 26, 2006, a justice of the Superior Court of Justice granted a provisional order allowing her to wait for trial under house arrest, writing that there was no real indication of a risk to public order, the course of the case or the application of the criminal law. She left that center on May 29.
On June 29, 2006, the panel heard the full petition. The rapporteur voted to free her, holding that the April order repeated a detention the court had already reviewed and that the alleged threat to the witness was unsupported by evidence. He was outvoted three to one. The panel denied the writ, revoked the house arrest and sent her back into custody to await trial, and she presented herself at the same center.
A new petition went at once to the Supreme Federal Court. Her lawyers argued that the detention rested on a supposed risk of flight with no evidence behind it, that she had obeyed every summons while free, and that public outcry was not a lawful ground for preventive detention. On July 4, 2006, the president of the Supreme Federal Court refused a provisional order, on the procedural ground that the Superior Court of Justice's judgment had not yet been published. The merits waited. When the full court took the petition up on August 7, 2007, the rapporteur voted to relax the detention, finding no concrete evidence that the witness had been at risk, but another justice asked for more time and the judgment was suspended. By then she had been convicted.
The trial was first set for June 5, 2006, and it collapsed on the day. The brothers' lawyers did not appear, alleging that the defense had been restricted. Her four lawyers asked for a further postponement because a defense witness was abroad. When the judge refused, they walked out of the courtroom. The judge appointed a public defender to represent her if her lawyers failed to appear next time, and set a new date of July 17, 2006.
The hearings began on July 17. The prosecution's theory was that the three had planned the killings together and that she was the one who conceived them. Her defense advanced two related theses: that she had acted under irresistible moral coercion, and that no other conduct could reasonably have been demanded of her, because of her boyfriend's pressure. The brothers' defense set out to show that she had planned the whole of it. On the third day, given over to witnesses, the prosecution asked for a face-to-face confrontation between two of the defendants, whose earlier accounts conflicted. The case file ran to fourteen volumes, and the prosecutors proposed that only the most relevant parts be read to the jury.
The jury answered the questions put to it in the early hours of July 22. For Daniel, it recognized authorship of the death of the father by a majority and of the mother by a majority, with the three qualifying circumstances found unanimously for the father and by a majority for the mother. For Cristian, the findings ran the other way: authorship of the father's death by a majority, authorship of the mother's death and all three qualifiers in her case unanimously. Both brothers were found guilty of procedural fraud unanimously, and Cristian of theft by a majority. Each was given a mitigating circumstance by a majority.
For Suzane von Richthofen, the jury recognized her as a co-author of each death by a majority. It rejected, by a majority, both of her defenses: that no other conduct could be demanded of her, and that she had acted under irresistible moral coercion. It found base motive by a majority, and the cruel means and the resource that made defense impossible unanimously. It found her a co-author of the procedural fraud by a majority, and it recognized mitigating circumstances in her favor by a majority.
The presiding judge set the sentences at once. For each homicide he fixed the base sentence on one qualifying circumstance and treated the other two as aggravating circumstances, weighing culpability, the intensity of intent, public outcry and the consequences of the crime under article 59 of the Penal Code.
For Daniel, each homicide carried a base of 20 years, reduced to 19 years and six months for his confession in court. For Cristian, each carried 19 years, reduced to 18 years and six months for the same reason; the court treated his culpability as lower than that of the other two. For her, each homicide carried 20 years, reduced to 19 years and six months because she had been under 21 at the time of the crime. Procedural fraud added six months of detenção and ten day-fines for each defendant, and Cristian's theft added a year of reclusão and ten more day-fines. Because the offenses were separate crimes under article 69, the material-concurrence rule, the terms were added together: 39 years of reclusão and six months of detenção for her and for Daniel, 38 years of reclusão and six months of detenção for Cristian, plus a year for theft.
The prosecution had asked for 50 years for each defendant. Because qualified homicide is a crime hediondo under Brazilian law, the judge ordered the reclusão to be served in a wholly closed regime, with the detenção to follow in the semi-open regime. He refused all three the right to appeal in liberty and directed that their names be entered in the roll of the guilty once the judgment became final. That night the three were held at a police station in São Paulo before transfer to the prisons where they would serve their sentences.
The appeal to the 5th Criminal Chamber of the São Paulo Court of Justice failed on its central point. The chamber refused to annul the trial. It did give her partial relief: it changed the regime from wholly closed to initially closed, declared the punishability of the procedural fraud extinguished, and left the reclusão at 39 years. It refused to recognize her confession as a mitigating circumstance.
Her lawyers carried the case to the Superior Court of Justice. In a habeas corpus filed in January 2008 they argued that the trial was void for incurable and absolute nullities: defects in the pronúncia and in the notice given to her, reliance by the São Paulo court on a cancelled precedent, the pronúncia's not yet being final while a special appeal was pending, a nullity raised on appeal and left unanswered in breach of article 416 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, a badly framed question to the jury on the inexigibility defense, and a criminological examination ordered without any request.
On September 26, 2008, the court's 6th Panel unanimously refused to annul the trial. The special appeal, it held, had already been judged; a pronúncia does not produce res judicata, because it convicts no one and only decides that a charge will go to a jury; and the appeal had no suspensive effect, so the trial did not have to wait for it. A separate petition asking the court to recognize her confession as a mandatory mitigating factor under article 65 of the Penal Code had already been refused a provisional order on April 28, 2008, the rapporteur finding no manifest illegality on the face of the São Paulo judgment.
The petitions continued after the conviction was settled. On May 14, 2009, a justice of the Superior Court of Justice, ruling alone, ordered the São Paulo courts to recalculate her remission, the days credited for work in custody. The remitted days, he held, must be added to the time already served rather than subtracted from the total sentence, a method more favorable to prisoners in calculating progression, conditional release and pardon. In January 2010 she asked the Supreme Federal Court to let her serve the sentence in the semi-open regime, after the São Paulo Court of Justice and the Superior Court of Justice had both refused the same request.
She served the closed part of her sentence in a women's penitentiary in São Paulo state, where she had been held since 2006. Her first chance at the semi-open regime came in 2014, and she turned it down. In August 2014, after her lawyer had applied for progression against her wishes, the 1st Sentence-Enforcement Court of Taubaté revoked its own decision granting the semi-open regime. Progression, the judge held, is a right and not an obligation, and a benefit cannot be imposed on a prisoner who does not want it. The court dismissed her lawyers and assigned her case to the Public Defender's Office.
She moved to the semi-open regime in October 2015, with the right to five temporary leaves a year, and took the first of them at Easter 2016. She worked six to eight hours a day in a sewing and crafts workshop, and by January 2023 those days had earned her about 1,800 days of remission. With court authorization she enrolled in a degree course at a private college in Taubaté, leaving the penitentiary during class hours and returning afterward.
The temporary leaves brought their own disputes. During the Christmas leave of 2018 she was found away from the address she had given the court. A judge of the sentence-enforcement court ruled that she had committed a serious fault and suspended three of her leaves. The Public Defender's Office appealed, and in April 2019 the 5th Criminal Chamber of the São Paulo Court of Justice held that there had been no serious fault, since the rules of temporary leave did not forbid social events, and restored her right to leave.
From 2017 she applied repeatedly for the open regime. On January 11, 2023, the 2nd Sentence-Enforcement Court of Taubaté granted it. The São Paulo Court of Justice stated that the progression had been granted after verification that the requirements of the Penal Execution Law had been met, and the case remained under seal. She left the penitentiary that evening. On January 12 the São Paulo Public Prosecutor's Office announced that it would appeal. Under the open regime she must spend nights and days off at the address designated by the court, may not leave the city without judicial authorization, must keep to her working hours and must report to the court when ordered. The São Paulo Court of Justice put the end of her full term at January 2041. In February 2026 she was still serving her sentence in the open regime.
Daniel Cravinhos moved to the semi-open regime in 2013 and to the open regime in 2018. Cristian Cravinhos reached the open regime on March 5, 2025. All three were then serving the rest of their sentences outside custody.
The central dispute at trial was her state of mind. Her defense said she had acted under irresistible moral coercion from her boyfriend and could not have been expected to act otherwise. The jury rejected both theses by a majority, not unanimously, and found her a co-author of each death, also by a majority. The brothers' defense placed the planning wholly on her; her defense placed the pressure wholly on Daniel. The verdicts settled authorship and the qualifying circumstances for each defendant, but the votes were divided on several of the questions.
Her pretrial detention was contested at every level. The trial judge refused to detain her in January 2006; another judge ordered her detention in April; the Superior Court of Justice granted house arrest in May and revoked it by three votes to one in June; and in 2007 the rapporteur at the Supreme Federal Court voted that the detention had been unjustified before the judgment was suspended. These rulings concerned whether she should wait for trial in custody, not whether she was guilty.
The prosecution announced an appeal against her move to the open regime in January 2023; in February 2026 she remained in the open regime.
October 31, 2002: Her parents die in São Paulo.
November 8, 2002: Suzane von Richthofen confesses to planning the crime; she and Daniel and Cristian Cravinhos are taken into custody.
November 19, 2002: First preventive custody order.
June 28 and 29, 2005: The Superior Court of Justice grants habeas corpus; she is released to await trial.
November 9, 2005: The brothers are released on provisional liberty.
January 23, 2006: Preventive detention ordered for the brothers after a radio interview; refused in her case.
April 10, 2006: Her preventive detention is ordered after a television interview.
May 26, 2006: A provisional order allows house arrest.
June 5, 2006: The first trial date collapses; the trial is reset for July 17.
June 29, 2006: The Superior Court of Justice denies habeas corpus by three votes to one and revokes house arrest.
July 4, 2006: The president of the Supreme Federal Court refuses a provisional order.
July 17 to 22, 2006: Jury trial in the 1st Jury Court of São Paulo; all three convicted; she and Daniel are sentenced to 39 years of reclusão and six months of detenção, Cristian to 38 years and six months plus one year for theft.
August 7, 2007: Supreme Federal Court judgment on her pretrial detention suspended after the rapporteur's vote.
April 28, 2008: Provisional order on the confession mitigating factor refused.
September 26, 2008: The 6th Panel of the Superior Court of Justice unanimously refuses to annul the trial.
May 14, 2009: The Superior Court of Justice orders her remission recalculated.
January 2010: Petition to the Supreme Federal Court for the semi-open regime.
2013: Daniel moves to the semi-open regime.
August 2014: The Taubaté sentence-enforcement court revokes her progression at her own request.
October 2015: She moves to the semi-open regime.
2018: Daniel reaches the open regime.
April 2019: The São Paulo Court of Justice restores her temporary leaves.
January 11, 2023: She is granted the open regime and leaves custody.
January 12, 2023: The São Paulo Public Prosecutor's Office announces an appeal.
March 5, 2025: Cristian is released to the open regime.
February 2026: She remains in the open regime.