Sushil Sharma was the president of the Delhi Youth Congress, the youth wing of the Congress party in the capital, when his wife, Naina Sahni, was killed in New Delhi on the night of July 2, 1995. The two had married in secret. She was a party office-holder in her own right, and she wanted the marriage acknowledged. He did not, and the courts later found that he suspected her of being unfaithful. Within hours of her death police had detained the manager of a business Sharma ran. Sharma left Delhi, and he was arrested in Bangalore eight days later.
The case passed through every level of the Indian courts. A Delhi sessions court convicted him of murder in November 2003, after a trial that had run for eight years, and sentenced him to death. The Delhi High Court confirmed that sentence in February 2007. In October 2013 the Supreme Court of India upheld the conviction but commuted the sentence to imprisonment for life, holding that the murder grew out of a strained personal relationship and did not meet the standard of the rarest of rare cases. Five years later, after the board that reviews life sentences in Delhi refused to recommend his release, the Delhi High Court set that refusal aside and ordered him freed. He left custody in December 2018, more than 23 years after his arrest.
In 1989 Sharma was president of the Delhi Youth Congress (I), and his future wife was general secretary of its girls' wing in the capital. She had been part of Delhi University student politics since at least the mid-1980s, and a friend from those years, who later became a fellow Congress worker, knew her from the university's Students' Union. Sharma, by his own account, had known her since 1985.
The prosecution's case, which the courts accepted, was that the couple married secretly in 1992 and that she then lived with him in New Delhi as his wife. Later that year she told her friend from the university that she had married Sharma. Sharma later acknowledged that he had lived with her, though he said he had had no contact with her after January 1995.
The marriage was not made public. She wanted it to be. He did not, and the Supreme Court found that he had come to suspect her fidelity. A domestic employee in their household testified to frequent quarrels between the two, to violence by Sharma toward her, and to instructions from Sharma to watch her movements.
On the afternoon of July 2, 1995, she spoke by telephone with her friend from the university. That evening a neighbor saw her with Sharma, and other witnesses placed Sharma in central New Delhi later that night. She died in New Delhi that night. The trial court, the High Court and the Supreme Court all found that Sharma had killed her.
Police detained the manager of Sharma's business that night. Sharma, the courts found, got away before he could be held, and the prosecution's case was that he left Delhi the next day. He obtained anticipatory bail from a sessions court in Madras, and at the request of Delhi Police the Madras High Court cancelled it. On July 10, 1995, Sharma was arrested in Bangalore, and the next day he was handed over to Delhi Police. The courts later held that evidence gathered after his arrest linked him to the death. The Congress party expelled him.
Sharma was charged with murder and with criminal conspiracy, read with murder and with causing the disappearance of evidence of an offense. The manager of his business was charged with the same conspiracy, and three other men were charged with harboring Sharma after the death.
The trial ran for eight years and was among the longest murder trials heard in New Delhi. The prosecution's case was entirely circumstantial: there was no eyewitness to the killing. It rested on motive, on the evidence placing Sharma with his wife that evening and near the scene later that night, on his flight from Delhi, on the evidence gathered after his arrest and on the medical and scientific evidence.
Sharma called no witnesses. In his statement to the court he denied the murder. He said he had been on pilgrimage at Tirupati from July 1 to July 6, 1995, and had gone on to Madras on July 7, and that police had taken his car and other property in New Delhi while he was away.
On November 3, 2003, an Additional Sessions Judge in Delhi found Sharma guilty of murder and of criminal conspiracy read with causing the disappearance of evidence. The manager was acquitted of conspiracy to murder and convicted of the conspiracy to cause the disappearance of evidence. The three men charged with harboring Sharma were acquitted.
On November 7, 2003, the judge held that the case fell within the rarest of rare category set by the Supreme Court and sentenced Sharma to death for the murder, with seven years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine for the conspiracy and the disappearance of evidence. The manager received seven years of rigorous imprisonment; he had already spent more than eight years in custody, and his release followed. The judge referred the death sentence to the Delhi High Court for confirmation.
On February 19, 2007, the Delhi High Court dismissed Sharma's appeal and confirmed the death sentence, rejecting the argument that the killing had been an impulsive act. The manager did not appeal his own conviction.
Sharma took his case to the Supreme Court of India, which delivered its judgment on October 8, 2013. On guilt, it upheld every link in the prosecution's chain. It accepted the evidence of motive and the testimony placing Sharma at the scene that night. It held that his alibi was false and found that he had absconded from Delhi until his arrest in Bangalore. It accepted the evidence gathered after that arrest and the expert evidence that tied it to the death, and it described the procedural lapses in the investigation as minor. The conviction for murder and for conspiracy was confirmed.
On sentence the court reached a different conclusion from the courts below. Applying its own rule that life imprisonment is the norm and death the exception, reserved for the rarest of rare cases, it held that the brutality of an offense was not, on its own, enough to justify a sentence of death. It found that Sharma had no criminal antecedents and that the State had led no evidence that he was likely to commit such crimes again. It described the murder as the outcome of a strained personal relationship and of his possessiveness, and held that it was not an offense against society. It found that he had shown remorse and that the possibility of reform was not closed. It held that one aggravating feature the lower courts had accepted was not established by the medical evidence, and it took into account that he had spent more than ten years under sentence of death. His flight from Delhi, it said, went to his culpability rather than to the sentence.
The operative words of the order read: "In view of the above discussion, we commute the death sentence awarded to appellant - Sushil Sharma to life sentence." The court added that the life sentence ran "for the whole of remaining life of the appellant subject to the remission granted by the appropriate Government," a power hedged by its own statutory checks.
Life sentences in Delhi come before the Sentence Review Board, whose recommendations go to the Lieutenant Governor. On September 15, 2015, while Sharma's application for premature release was pending, the Delhi High Court released him on parole until the competent authority decided it; he had then been in custody for more than 20 years. On October 4, 2018, the board rejected his case on the ground of the brutality of the crime, and the Lieutenant Governor affirmed that recommendation without giving reasons.
Sharma challenged the decision in the Delhi High Court, relying on the board's own guidelines, under which a life prisoner convicted of a single offense was to be released after 20 years and one convicted of an aggravated murder after 25. On December 21, 2018, the High Court quashed the board's recommendation and set aside the Lieutenant Governor's affirmation of it. The board, it held, owed its existence to the guidelines and was strictly bound by them; its rejection of Sharma's case was arbitrary, made without proper application of mind to the guidelines, and illegal. The court noted that the Department of Social Welfare, a probation officer and the jail authorities had all given favorable reports indicating that he was ready to return to society. By then he was held in a semi-open facility and worked on construction. The court found that the State had given no cogent or compelling reason for keeping him in custody, held that imprisonment does not suspend a prisoner's right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution, and directed that he be released forthwith.
Sharma, then 56, left custody that day, more than 23 years after his arrest in Bangalore.
Sharma never admitted the killing. At trial he denied murder, gave an alibi placing him at Tirupati and in Madras in the first week of July 1995, and said that police had taken his car and other property while he was away. The trial court, the High Court and the Supreme Court all rejected that account, and the Supreme Court held the alibi to be false.
His 2018 petition put his time served two ways: 23 years and six months of actual custody, and 29 years counting remission. The High Court's December 2018 order accepted that he had passed the thresholds in the board's guidelines; the figure of 23 years is the period of actual custody.
The Supreme Court held that the medical evidence did not establish one aggravating feature that the trial court and the High Court had accepted, and that finding formed part of its reasons for commuting the death sentence. It did not disturb the finding that Sharma had killed his wife.
1989: Sharma is president of the Delhi Youth Congress (I); his future wife is general secretary of its girls' wing.
1992: The couple marry in secret, the courts later find.
July 2, 1995: Sharma's wife is killed in New Delhi; police detain the manager of his business that night.
July 10, 1995: Sharma is arrested in Bangalore.
July 11, 1995: Sharma is handed over to Delhi Police.
November 3, 2003: Sharma is convicted of murder and of criminal conspiracy read with causing the disappearance of evidence; the manager is convicted of the evidence conspiracy; three men are acquitted of harboring.
November 7, 2003: Sharma is sentenced to death; the manager receives seven years of rigorous imprisonment.
February 19, 2007: The Delhi High Court dismisses the appeal and confirms the death sentence.
October 8, 2013: The Supreme Court upholds the conviction and commutes the death sentence to life imprisonment.
September 15, 2015: The Delhi High Court releases Sharma on parole pending a decision on premature release.
October 4, 2018: The Sentence Review Board rejects his premature release.
December 21, 2018: The Delhi High Court quashes the board's recommendation and orders his release; Sharma leaves custody.