Sukhdev Singh Sukha

Victims
1 murder in Pune, India, August 10, 1986; also convicted of attempted murder of a second person the same day, with his co-convict Harjinder Singh Jinda.
Years active
August 10, 1986
Location
Pune, Maharashtra, India (killing); Pune, Maharashtra, India (arrest of Sukhdev Singh); Delhi, India (arrest of Harjinder Singh Jinda); Pune, Maharashtra, India (trial and death)
Method
Shot (court finding: the Designated Court and the Supreme Court of India).
Status
Death sentence October 21, 1989; confirmed by the Supreme Court of India July 15, 1992; petitions rejected September 16 and October 8, 1992. Executed in Pune, India, October 9, 1992.

On August 10, 1986, General Arun Shridhar Vaidya, who had led the Indian Army until the last day of January that year, was killed in Pune, the city in western India where he had settled in retirement. His wife, who was with him, was wounded and survived. Two men were convicted of the crime: Sukhdev Singh, known as Sukha, and Harjinder Singh Jinda, his co-convict. A Designated Court in Pune found them guilty of murder and attempted murder on October 21, 1989, and sentenced both to death. The Supreme Court of India confirmed the convictions and the death sentences in July 1992. Neither man ever appealed. They were executed in Pune on October 9, 1992, the day after the Supreme Court turned away one last petition filed on their behalf.

The prosecution's case, which the courts accepted as the motive, was revenge for Operation Blue Star, the army's 1984 operation at the Golden Temple in Amritsar, carried out while the general was army chief. The same courts held that the prosecution had failed to prove the wider conspiracy it alleged, and the trial court acquitted both men of the charges brought under India's anti-terrorism law of the time. What sent them to their deaths was the ordinary law of murder, applied by a special court that the anti-terrorism law had created.

The man who was killed was among the most decorated officers the Indian Army had produced. He was one of only six Indians to receive two Maha Vir Chakras, the first for the war of 1965 and the second for the war of 1971. In 1965 he commanded 9 Cavalry, the Deccan Horse, at Asal Uttar in the Khem Karan sector. In 1971 he commanded the 16th (Independent) Armoured Brigade in the battles around Basantar, Chakra and Dehira. He became eastern Army commander in 1982, and in 1983 he was named Chief of the Army Staff, the thirteenth officer to hold the post, passing over a more senior lieutenant general to reach it.

He retired on January 31, 1986. In May of that year he and his wife moved to Pune, and he was living there as a private citizen when he was killed, a little more than six months after leaving office.

Sukhdev Singh was arrested in Pune on September 7, 1986, four weeks after the killing, together with another man who was later tried with him and acquitted. The inquiry ran on through the following year, and in August 1987 the police filed their charge-sheet before the Designated Court at Pune. It accused five men of murder, attempted murder, criminal conspiracy, forgery and harboring an offender, together with offenses under the anti-terrorism law and the Passport Act. Four other people named in the case had absconded and were never brought to trial with the rest.

Harjinder Singh Jinda was arrested in Delhi on August 30, 1987, and brought to Pune in January 1988 to take his place among the accused. No test identification parade was ever held for him, a point that would matter when the courts came to weigh the evidence against him. The courts listed Sukhdev Singh as accused No. 1 and Harjinder Singh Jinda as accused No. 5, and found that the two had acted together in the killing.

When the charges were framed, all five accused denied them and claimed trial. The prosecution called a long list of witnesses. Then, on September 19, 1988, Sukhdev Singh told the court in open session that he wished to make a statement admitting the killing. A week later, on September 26, he filed a written statement in which he did so.

Harjinder Singh Jinda made his admission later, when the court examined him on the evidence against him. He said he had taken part in the crime and had acted with Sukhdev Singh, and he repeated it in writing. The Supreme Court later found that both men had decided to own their guilt before they made those statements.

The rest of the prosecution's case did not fare as well. The trial judge found that the photograph witnesses had been shown of Harjinder Singh Jinda did not resemble him, and disbelieved their identification. Witnesses who first picked out the accused in the courtroom, long after the events and without any earlier identification parade, were given little weight. Expert evidence comparing a railway reservation form with the handwriting of one of the accused was held too weak to stand alone.

The Designated Court gave its judgment on October 21, 1989. It held that the prosecution had "failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt" that the accused and the absconders had conspired together to murder the general. It found the charge under the anti-terrorism law not established and acquitted the accused of it. The three men tried alongside the two principal accused were acquitted of every charge and released. Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh Jinda were convicted of murder and of the attempted murder of the general's wife, the second man on the footing that the two had shared a common intention, and acquitted of the rest. For the murder the court sentenced both to death, subject to confirmation by the Supreme Court; for the attempted murder each received ten years' rigorous imprisonment. The trial judge held, relying on an earlier Supreme Court decision in Kehar Singh's case, that the killing fell within "the rarest of a rare" category in which Indian law permits a sentence of death.

Under the anti-terrorism law, a Designated Court's judgment could be challenged only in the Supreme Court of India, which also had to confirm any death sentence before it could be carried out. Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh Jinda filed no appeal. They challenged neither their convictions nor their sentences. The death reference came before the court together with an appeal by the State of Maharashtra against the acquittals.

A bench of two judges gave judgment in July 1992. It examined the whole of the evidence, as a death reference required. It agreed with the trial court that the conspiracy had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt and dismissed the State's appeal, leaving the three acquittals in place. It held that both men had clearly and unequivocally admitted their part in the killing, and that their convictions for murder were justified.

On sentence, the court found no extenuating circumstances and upheld the trial judge's reasoning. It rejected the argument that the accused had not been given a proper hearing on sentence, holding that both men had chosen to place no mitigating material before the court. The anti-terrorism acquittals made no difference: the convictions lay under the Indian Penal Code, which a Designated Court could apply, and the death sentences rested on them alone. The court confirmed the convictions and the sentences of death.

The two men did not seek to overturn the judgment, but others tried to do it for them. In July 1992 Amnesty International asked the President of India to commute both sentences. On August 19, the president of a Punjab political party filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court challenging the confirmation. The same two judges rejected it on September 16, 1992, without reaching its arguments: nothing on the record showed that either convicted man had authorized the petitioner to act for him, and the court held that he had no standing to bring it.

A further petition was then filed on their behalf, asking for the death sentences to be commuted or for a retrial, on the ground that the special procedure of the anti-terrorism law had denied the two men the appeal in two stages, first to a High Court and then to the Supreme Court, that an ordinary murder trial allowed. The Supreme Court rejected it on October 8, 1992. No clemency was granted. Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh Jinda were executed in Pune on October 9, 1992.

The prosecution alleged a wider plan behind the killing, involving the three men acquitted at trial and four people who absconded. Neither court found that plan proved, and the acquittals of the three co-accused stand. The four absconders were never tried in this case.

The anti-terrorism charges against Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh Jinda also failed. Indian press accounts describe the two men as members of the Khalistan Commando Force, an armed separatist group, but that is a press description, not a court finding: no court in their case made any finding on membership of any group.

The Supreme Court's judgment is dated July 15, 1992; one Amnesty International appeal of that month gives the date as July 16.

Timeline

January 31, 1986: The general retires as Chief of the Army Staff and later settles in Pune.

August 10, 1986: He is killed in Pune; his wife is wounded and survives.

September 7, 1986: Sukhdev Singh is arrested in Pune.

August 1987: The police file the charge-sheet before the Designated Court, Pune.

August 30, 1987: Harjinder Singh Jinda is arrested in Delhi.

January 1988: Harjinder Singh Jinda is brought to Pune for trial.

September 19, 1988: Sukhdev Singh tells the court he wishes to admit the killing.

September 26, 1988: He files a written statement admitting it.

October 21, 1989: The Designated Court convicts both men of murder and attempted murder, sentences both to death and acquits three co-accused; the anti-terrorism charges fail.

July 15, 1992: The Supreme Court of India confirms the convictions and death sentences and dismisses the State's appeal against the acquittals.

September 16, 1992: The Supreme Court rejects a third-party petition for want of standing.

October 8, 1992: The Supreme Court rejects a further petition seeking commutation or retrial.

October 9, 1992: Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh Jinda are executed in Pune.