Stuart Hazell

Victims
1 girl murdered in New Addington, south London, 2012. Pleaded guilty on the fifth day of his Old Bailey trial, May 13, 2013; life with a minimum term of 38 years
Years active
August 2012
Location
New Addington, Croydon, south London
Method
Murder
Status
Life imprisonment, minimum term 38 years, less 272 days on remand (May 14, 2013); no appeal on record; held in England

Stuart Hazell was 37 years old in the summer of 2012 and had lived for more than five years in New Addington, a district on the southern edge of Croydon, with the grandmother of the girl he would later admit killing. In August of that year the Metropolitan Police arrested him and charged him with the murder of Tia Sharp. For nine months he denied it. Then, on the fifth day of his trial at the Central Criminal Court in London, with the prosecution one day from closing its case, he asked for the charge to be put to him again and answered that he was guilty.

The next day, May 14, 2013, a High Court judge sentenced him to life imprisonment and fixed a minimum term of 38 years before he could be considered for release. The sentencing turned on a question the law makes decisive in the murder of a child: whether the case reached the threshold for a whole life order, under which he would never be released. The judge concluded that, measured against the criminal standard of proof, it did not.

Hazell worked as a window cleaner. He was not a stranger to the courts. In 2003 he was jailed for 34 months for supplying a controlled drug, and in 2010 he was jailed for a year for a further offense. In 2006 he accepted a police caution for causing grievous bodily harm. The judge who later sentenced him for murder accepted that none of those earlier matters involved serious violence.

His place in the girl's life came through her grandmother, with whom he had lived in New Addington for more than five years. The girl had known him for many years. The two were not related. Her mother trusted him with her care, and so did her grandmother. That trust became the center of the case against him at sentencing.

She died in New Addington in early August 2012, while she was staying with her grandmother and in Hazell's care. The charge later laid against him alleged that the murder took place between August 2 and August 11, 2012.

The inquiry was led by the Metropolitan Police. Officers had first spoken to Hazell as a potential witness. On Friday, August 10, 2012, they arrested him. Detectives questioned him through the weekend, and in the first hours of Sunday, August 12, he was charged with murder. Scotland Yard announced the charge that day. As drawn, it alleged that the murder had been committed between August 2 and August 11, 2012.

On Monday, August 13, Hazell appeared at Camberwell Green Magistrates' Court in south London by video link from a police station in Sutton. The hearing was short. He confirmed his name and his date of birth, and no plea was entered. The magistrates remanded him in custody and sent the case to the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, where he was to appear two days later and where, the court was told, an application for bail might be made. A preliminary hearing at the Old Bailey was recorded for November 19.

Two days later, on Wednesday, August 15, 2012, Hazell appeared at the Old Bailey, again by video link from custody. A High Court judge presided. His leading counsel, a Queen's Counsel, made no application for bail that day, while telling the court that one might be made later. Hazell was remanded in custody to a plea and case management hearing on November 19, 2012, the date on which he was then due to enter his plea, and the court set a provisional trial date of January 21, 2013.

On Thursday, August 16, 2012, an inquest into the death was opened at South London Coroner's Court in Croydon. The hearing lasted about five minutes, and the inquest was adjourned.

Neither date held. The trial was moved to May 2013, and the arraignment followed in March.

The formal step that fixed the shape of the trial came on March 8, 2013. Appearing by video link before the Old Bailey, Hazell pleaded not guilty to murder. The indictment alleged that he had murdered the girl between August 2 and August 10, 2012. He was remanded in custody to stand trial at the same court on May 7, 2013, in a hearing expected to last about two weeks.

The trial opened at the Old Bailey on Tuesday, May 7, 2013, before a jury and a High Court judge. Hazell denied murder. The prosecution, led by a Queen's Counsel with a junior counsel, told the jury that its task would be to decide whether he was guilty of murder or whether the death had been an accident. Before the evidence began, the court warned the jurors that some of what they would see and hear might be distressing.

For four days the prosecution built its case. The junior counsel presented much of it, and by the end of the fourth day the Crown was one sitting from closing.

Much of the evidence reached the jury in a form the defense did not contest. Agreed facts were read, and many witness statements were put before the jury in writing rather than through live testimony.

On Monday, May 13, 2013, the fifth day of the trial, Hazell's leading counsel asked the trial judge for permission for his client to be arraigned again. The murder charge was put to him a second time. He answered "Guilty." The jurors, who had heard four days of evidence on a charge he had denied for nine months, were then asked to return a formal verdict of guilty, and did so.

The court adjourned so that the defense could put its plea in mitigation. Sentence was passed the following day.

On May 14, 2013, the judge addressed Hazell in the Central Criminal Court. "You have pleaded guilty to the murder," he began, and he went on to explain the only choice the law left him. Murder carries one sentence, life imprisonment. What the judge had to decide was how long Hazell must serve before he could even ask to be released, or whether he should never be released at all.

The prosecution argued that the case met the test for a whole life order. The judge weighed that submission against the evidence and found that he could not be sure of the facts on which it depended. He thought the prosecution's reading of part of the evidence more likely than not to be right, but he observed that in a criminal case that is not enough: a judge sentencing on a contested fact must be sure of it. Unable to reach that certainty, he concluded that this was not a case for a whole life order.

He placed the murder instead in the band that the law treats as of particularly high seriousness, with a starting point of 30 years. From there he moved upward. One aggravating feature was the youth of the victim. Another was the abuse of a position of trust: the girl's mother had let her stay because she trusted Hazell to look after her, and her grandmother, working that night, had trusted him in the same way.

On the other side of the scale, the judge took into account the matters put forward in mitigation, which included Hazell's personal history and psychiatric history, while saying that none of them excused what he had done. He accepted that there was no evidence that the murder had been premeditated.

That left the plea. It had come, the judge said, "on day five of the trial and the day before the prosecution was due to close its case." Because it came so late, it earned only modest credit.

He then told Hazell to stand. For the murder, he was sentenced to life imprisonment. "The minimum term will be 38 years." The 272 days Hazell had spent on remand were to be deducted from that term, subject to administrative correction if the figure proved wrong.

The guilty plea closed the question of guilt; the minimum term fixed on May 14, 2013 remains the governing order. Hazell is serving his life sentence in England. Release, if it ever comes, can be considered only after the minimum term, less the remand time, has run its course.

The court did not determine Hazell's motive, and it found no evidence of premeditation. The prosecution's case that the facts required a whole life order rested in part on medical evidence that the judge found persuasive on the balance of probabilities but not to the criminal standard, and he sentenced on the footing most favorable to Hazell on that point.

The account Hazell gave before his plea, that the death had been accidental, fell away with his own plea of guilty to murder.

The charge as reported in August 2012 alleged a murder between August 2 and August 11, 2012; the indictment on which he was arraigned in March 2013 gave the dates as August 2 to August 10.

Timeline

August 2012: A girl in Hazell's care dies in New Addington, south London.

August 10, 2012: The Metropolitan Police arrest Hazell.

August 12, 2012: After questioning by detectives, he is charged with murder in the first hours of the day.

August 13, 2012: He appears by video link from a police station in Sutton at Camberwell Green Magistrates' Court; no plea is entered; he is remanded in custody and the case is sent to the Old Bailey.

August 15, 2012: First appearance at the Old Bailey by video link; no bail application; a plea and case management hearing is set for November 19, 2012, and a provisional trial date of January 21, 2013.

August 16, 2012: An inquest is opened at South London Coroner's Court in Croydon and adjourned.

March 8, 2013: He pleads not guilty to murder at the Old Bailey; trial set for May 7, 2013.

May 7, 2013: The trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.

May 13, 2013: On the fifth day of trial he changes his plea to guilty, and the jury returns a formal verdict of guilty.

May 14, 2013: He is sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 38 years, less 272 days spent on remand.