Billy Jack Gaither was killed near Sylacauga, Alabama, on the night of February 19, 1999. Within two weeks two local men, Steven Eric Mullins and Charles Monroe Butler Jr., were in custody, after Butler confessed. Mullins, about 25, pleaded guilty to capital murder in June 1999 and testified for the state. Butler, 21, pleaded not guilty and went to trial in the Coosa County seat of Rockford, and in August 1999 a Coosa County jury convicted him of capital murder. Both men were sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The prosecution did not seek death.
The case drew national attention because of the reason Mullins gave for it. The victim was a gay man, and Mullins told the court that he hated gay men and that the hatred was why he killed him; police had described the motive the same way within days of the arrests. That account is his and the police's, not a finding of any court. Alabama's hate-crime law, passed in 1994, did not cover sexual orientation, so the motive played no formal part in the charge or the sentence.
The victim had lived his whole life in Sylacauga. On Sundays he sang in his church choir, and on weekend nights he went out dancing and playing pool with friends. The people who knew him described a quiet, easygoing man who was well liked in town, a familiar and welcome face in the places he went.
Mullins lived in Fayetteville, Alabama, and described himself to investigators as a former skinhead. Butler, a construction worker, was younger and much smaller, and a friend of Mullins. Both men were from Talladega County. Mullins knew the victim; Butler said he had never heard of him before that night.
What happened on February 19 is known mainly from the two men's own statements, which agree on the outcome and disagree on nearly everything else. Mullins killed the victim that night near Sylacauga, and Butler was there. The accounts split on the question that would decide Butler's case: whether he knew, when the evening began, that Mullins meant to kill. Mullins said he did. In his statement to police and later in court, he said he had told Butler of his intention beforehand and that the killing was a joint venture. Butler said he did not know the purpose of the evening. He admitted taking part afterward but said he acted on Mullins's orders and out of fear of him.
The case broke because Butler could not keep it to himself. He confessed to police, telling officers he had not been able to sleep since that night. Two days later Mullins admitted his own part. His statement to the Sylacauga Police Department is dated March 3, 1999, and in it he said that on February 19 he had decided the victim should die. Both men were arrested and charged with murder, and later with capital murder. In return for Mullins's testimony against Butler, the district attorney agreed to recommend life without parole for him.
In June 1999 Mullins pleaded guilty to capital murder. The plea committed him to testify for the state at Butler's trial, and his sentencing was put off until that trial was over.
Butler's trial opened in Rockford in August 1999. His defense was that Mullins had planned and carried out the killing, and that Butler had been drawn into it, shocked and frightened, by an older and stronger man who gave the orders. Mullins took the stand for the prosecution. He testified that he and Butler had acted together and that Butler had known what was going to happen and had taken an active part in the planning. The defense called witnesses who challenged the picture Mullins had given of his own life and of his dealings with the victim.
Butler testified in his own defense. He told the jury he had been in shock and had not known what to do. On cross-examination he agreed that he had gone along with Mullins every step of the way. The jury found him guilty of capital murder, and he was sentenced to life in prison without parole the same day. That August, Mullins received the same sentence. Neither man would ever be eligible for parole.
Both men went into the Alabama prison system. In an interview recorded in prison after the trial, Butler again said he had not known what Mullins intended that night. Mullins, in his own later interviews, held to the account that the two had planned it together.
Mullins died in Alabama state custody in February 2019, at 45. The Alabama Department of Corrections announced his death on March 4, 2019. As of March 2019, Butler was held in another Alabama state prison, serving life without parole.
The two men's accounts of the night never agreed. Mullins said Butler knew of the plan before the evening began and took part in it; Butler said he did not know the purpose of the evening and acted under Mullins's control. The jury rejected Butler's defense to the extent of convicting him of capital murder, but the division of the acts between the two men rests on their own conflicting statements.
The motive rests on the police account and on Mullins's own testimony. No court made a finding on it, because state law gave the court no occasion to, and the defense at Butler's trial called witnesses to cast doubt on Mullins's account of himself.
February 19, 1999: The victim is killed near Sylacauga, Alabama.
Early March 1999: Butler confesses to police; Mullins admits his part two days later.
March 3, 1999: Mullins gives a statement to the Sylacauga Police Department.
June 1999: Mullins pleads guilty to capital murder.
August 1999: Butler, who pleaded not guilty, is convicted of capital murder by a Coosa County jury in Rockford and sentenced to life without parole.
August 1999: Mullins is sentenced to life without parole.
February 2019: Mullins dies in Alabama state custody.
March 4, 2019: The Alabama Department of Corrections announces his death.
March 2019: Butler is serving life without parole in an Alabama state prison.