Steven Hayes and Joshua Komisarjevsky

Victims
3 people murdered in Cheshire, Connecticut, July 23, 2007. Hayes convicted on 16 of 17 counts (2010) and Komisarjevsky on all 17 (2011), each including six counts of capital felony.
Years active
July 23, 2007
Location
Cheshire, Connecticut; tried in New Haven, Connecticut
Method
Capital felony and murder, with kidnapping in the first degree, burglary, assault and other charges
Status
Death sentences (2010, 2012) vacated after the state's highest court barred executions; six consecutive life terms without release (2016). Komisarjevsky's convictions affirmed 2021

On the morning of July 23, 2007, police in Cheshire, Connecticut, arrested two men who had held a family captive in the New Haven suburb. A mother and her two daughters were dead. The father was the only one of the four to survive. The two men were Steven Hayes, a 44-year-old from Winsted, and Joshua Komisarjevsky, a 26-year-old who lived in Cheshire itself. Both were on parole from prison sentences for burglary.

Connecticut tried them separately in New Haven Superior Court, a year apart. A jury convicted Hayes in October 2010 of 16 of the 17 counts against him, among them six counts of capital felony, and sentenced him to death. A second jury convicted Komisarjevsky in October 2011 of all 17 counts against him, again including six counts of capital felony, and he too was sentenced to death. Neither sentence was ever carried out. In 2012 the legislature abolished the death penalty for future crimes, and in August 2015 the Connecticut Supreme Court held that executing anyone already condemned would violate the state constitution. In the summer of 2016 both men were resentenced to six consecutive terms of life imprisonment without the possibility of release. Hayes gave up his appeal that August. Komisarjevsky's appeal ran until 2021, when the state's highest court affirmed his convictions, and the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case that December.

Hayes and Komisarjevsky came to Cheshire that summer from the same corner of the state's correction system. Each had more than 20 prior burglaries on his record, and each had been sent to prison on burglary convictions from 2003. In 2006 both spent time in the same halfway house in Hartford. Both were paroled in the spring of 2007, on terms that required weekly reports to parole officers and full-time work. Neither man's record included a conviction for violence.

On the night of July 22, 2007, the Connecticut Supreme Court later found, the two men came to believe that a family in Cheshire had a large sum of money. In the early hours of July 23 they held the four members of that family captive. Before the morning was out, Jennifer Hawke-Petit and her two daughters were dead. Her husband survived. Hayes and Komisarjevsky were arrested in Cheshire the same morning and arraigned the next day.

After his arrest, Komisarjevsky waived his rights and gave a recorded statement to investigators that was later admitted into evidence at his trial. In it he admitted some of the crimes charged against him and blamed Hayes for the deaths.

The state charged each man with 17 counts, among them six of capital felony, three of murder and four of kidnapping in the first degree, and decided to seek death sentences. Each defendant offered to plead guilty in exchange for a life sentence. Prosecutors declined and pressed for capital trials.

Hayes was tried first, in the fall of 2010. His defense did not contest most of the state's case. It conceded that he had taken part in the crimes, including the death of the mother, and argued that Komisarjevsky had escalated the violence and that the state had not proved Hayes intended the deaths of the two daughters. Prosecutors answered that the two men were equally responsible.

On October 5, 2010, the jury found Hayes guilty on 16 counts, including the six counts of capital felony and the three counts of murder, and acquitted him on the remaining count. The same jury moved to a separate penalty trial, and on November 8, 2010, it unanimously chose death on each of the six capital counts.

The trial judge formally imposed the sentence in early December 2010. At the hearing Hayes spoke briefly. He told the court that he was deeply sorry for what he had done and for the pain he had caused.

Komisarjevsky's trial came the following year.

A fight that spring was over the lists of witnesses the two sides had filed with the court, which had been sealed. A newspaper asked the trial court to open them. In April 2011 the trial court did, finding that Komisarjevsky had not made the specific showing needed to keep them closed, and the Appellate Court refused to block the release. The Connecticut Supreme Court reversed that August. It held that the trial court had failed to weigh what disclosure would do to his rights to prepare a defense and to a fair trial, that naming potential witnesses before trial could make them less willing to cooperate, and that the public's interest in the list itself was extremely limited, since the public could still watch jury selection and the trial. The lists stayed sealed.

The trial court also refused to hold fresh probable cause hearings on the revised charges the state filed in March 2011. Komisarjevsky had waived those hearings on the original charges, and the court found that the new counts were not substantially different from the old ones.

When testimony began in 2011, the defense did not deny that Komisarjevsky had been present or that he had committed crimes there. Its case was that he had never intended for anyone to die and that Hayes had been the leader.

Near the end of the trial, after the close of the evidence, the state disclosed letters that Hayes had written while in custody. Komisarjevsky's lawyers asked for a mistrial. The trial court refused, finding that the letters, if anything, described the crimes as a joint venture.

On October 13, 2011, the jury found Komisarjevsky guilty on all 17 counts. On December 9, 2011, it unanimously returned a sentence of death on each of the six capital counts.

In January 2012 the trial judge formally imposed six consecutive death sentences, followed by a term of 140 years in prison on the remaining counts. Komisarjevsky addressed the court, spoke of regret, and denied taking part in the killings.

On April 25, 2012, Connecticut abolished the death penalty for crimes committed after that date. The new law did not touch the sentences already imposed, and Hayes and Komisarjevsky remained under sentence of death.

That changed on August 13, 2015. In State v. Santiago, an appeal brought by another condemned prisoner, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled that carrying out any execution after the prospective repeal would violate the state constitution's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. In October 2015 the court refused the state's request to reconsider. On May 26, 2016, in State v. Peeler, it reaffirmed the ruling, declined to overturn Santiago, and ordered that the defendant in that case be sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of release on each capital count. None of the men on the state's death row could now be executed, and their sentences had to be corrected.

At a brief hearing in New Haven in June 2016, the trial judge vacated Hayes's death sentences and imposed six consecutive life sentences without the possibility of release. Komisarjevsky followed on July 26, 2016. On the strength of Santiago and Peeler, the trial court granted his motion to correct an illegal sentence, vacated his death sentences and imposed six consecutive terms of life imprisonment without the possibility of release, followed by 140 years.

On August 2, 2016, Hayes went before the trial judge and formally withdrew his appeal. He told the judge, "I'm guilty," and said he had played a part in the crimes in Cheshire. The withdrawal left his convictions and his life sentences final.

That same month the Connecticut Department of Correction moved both men to a prison in Pennsylvania under the Interstate Corrections Compact, citing reasons of safety and security. When the Connecticut Supreme Court decided Komisarjevsky's appeal in 2021, it noted that he was still incarcerated in Pennsylvania.

Komisarjevsky's direct appeal went to the Connecticut Supreme Court, which heard argument in October 2019. The court framed the principal issue as whether Connecticut's individual questioning of prospective jurors had protected his right to a fair trial against the publicity surrounding an unusually well-known case. He also argued that the trial court had wrongly refused to excuse 12 prospective jurors for cause, that the late disclosure of the Hayes letters had harmed his defense, that recordings of police communications from 2007 had been withheld from his trial lawyers, that the state had failed to correct misleading expert testimony, and that the strict conditions of confinement the law sets for prisoners resentenced from death to life without release had been applied to him unconstitutionally.

On April 12, 2021, the court rejected every claim and affirmed the judgment. On publicity it accepted part of his argument. The coverage weighed in his favor, the court said, and the years since 2007 had not blunted it, because his trial came only months after Hayes's conviction and death sentence had brought the case back into the news. But it found neither presumed nor actual prejudice. The New Haven jury pool was large, and the individual questioning had been no blind acceptance of jurors' promises of impartiality but a long and thorough probing of their answers by both sides and the court. On the challenges for cause, it held that any error was harmless, because none of the jurors he had challenged actually sat to decide his guilt.

On the letters, the court held that the trial court had not abused its discretion in refusing a continuance, a mistrial or a reopening of the evidence, and it agreed that the letters described a joint venture that would, if anything, have strengthened the case against him. It was undisputed that the state had failed to disclose certain communications among Cheshire police officers, but the court held that none of them was material to the questions of guilt the jury had to decide. On the expert testimony, it assumed without deciding that the testimony had been false or misleading and held that there was no reasonable likelihood it had affected the verdict.

The court declined to decide the conditions claim. Komisarjevsky argued that the restrictions, as the Department of Correction applied them, were an ex post facto law, denied him equal protection and amounted to excessive punishment under the federal and state constitutions. The court found the claim ripe but not reviewable on direct appeal, because the record held no evidence of the conditions actually imposed on him in Pennsylvania. The proper vehicle, it held, was a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, where he could present evidence and a habeas court could make the factual findings an appellate court cannot.

Komisarjevsky's lawyers asked the United States Supreme Court to review the decision, arguing again that he had been denied a fair trial in New Haven. In December 2021 the Court declined to hear the case.

The two men's responsibility for the deaths was the central contested issue at both trials. Hayes's defense argued that Komisarjevsky escalated the violence and that Hayes had not intended the deaths of the daughters. Komisarjevsky's defense argued the reverse, that Hayes was the leader and that Komisarjevsky had never intended anyone to die. Each jury rejected the defense on the capital counts, and the trial court found that Hayes's own letters described the crimes as a joint venture.

Komisarjevsky's challenge to his conditions of confinement was never decided on its merits; the Connecticut Supreme Court left it to a habeas proceeding.

Timeline

2003: Both men are sentenced to prison on burglary convictions.

2006: Both spend time in the same halfway house in Hartford.

Spring 2007: Both are released on parole.

July 23, 2007: A mother and her two daughters die in Cheshire, Connecticut; the husband survives; Hayes and Komisarjevsky are arrested.

July 24, 2007: Both are arraigned.

October 5, 2010: Hayes is convicted on 16 of 17 counts, including six counts of capital felony.

November 8, 2010: The jury chooses death on all six capital counts.

December 2010: Hayes is formally sentenced to death.

February 2011: The trial court refuses to move Komisarjevsky's trial out of New Haven.

October 13, 2011: Komisarjevsky is convicted on all 17 counts.

December 9, 2011: The jury chooses death on all six capital counts.

January 2012: Komisarjevsky is formally sentenced to six consecutive death sentences and 140 years.

April 25, 2012: Connecticut abolishes the death penalty for future crimes.

August 13, 2015: The Connecticut Supreme Court rules in State v. Santiago that no execution may be carried out after the repeal.

October 2015: The court refuses the state's request to reconsider Santiago.

May 26, 2016: The court reaffirms Santiago in State v. Peeler.

June 2016: Hayes is resentenced to six consecutive life terms without release.

July 26, 2016: Komisarjevsky is resentenced to six consecutive life terms without release, followed by 140 years.

August 2, 2016: Hayes withdraws his appeal.

August 2016: Both men are transferred to a prison in Pennsylvania under the Interstate Corrections Compact.

October 2019: The Connecticut Supreme Court hears Komisarjevsky's appeal.

April 12, 2021: The Connecticut Supreme Court affirms Komisarjevsky's convictions.

December 2021: The United States Supreme Court declines to hear his case.