On the night of May 29, 2020, as crowds filled the streets of downtown Oakland in protest over the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, two contract officers of the Federal Protective Service stood guard at a federal building. One of them died that night, and the other was badly injured. Eight days later, in the mountain town of Ben Lomond in Santa Cruz County, deputies answered a report of a suspicious van; a sheriff's sergeant was killed and other officers were injured, and by nightfall a suspect was in custody. Both cases led to the same man: Steven Carrillo, a 32-year-old staff sergeant in the United States Air Force who lived in Ben Lomond.
He answered for the two deaths in two courts, and in each one he pleaded guilty. The federal government took the Oakland killing, the State of California took Ben Lomond, and in 2022, within three months of each other, both cases ended without a trial.
The man killed in Oakland was David Patrick Underwood, known to his friends as Pat. In the 1980s he pitched left-handed for his high school baseball team in Pinole, in Contra Costa County, and played basketball, and after his playing days he gave money to youth sports groups in his town. He worked as a contract security officer for the Federal Protective Service, the Department of Homeland Security agency that protects federal buildings, and on the night he died he and a fellow officer were on duty together.
The sergeant killed in Ben Lomond was Damon Gutzwiller. He grew up in Santa Cruz County and played for Aptos High School, and he came to law enforcement by the slow road. He started at the Sheriff's Office in civilian work, volunteered in community policing, and went through the police academy at Gavilan College before the Santa Cruz County Sheriff's Office hired him in 2006.
For ten days Carrillo was only a Santa Cruz County defendant, while the FBI looked into whether the deaths in Ben Lomond and Oakland were connected. By June 12, 2020, county prosecutors had filed 19 counts against him. The heaviest was the murder of the sergeant, carried with two special allegations: that he had killed a peace officer in the performance of his duties, and that he had done it while lying in wait. Others charged the premeditated attempted murder of four officers and of a local resident. The special allegations made him eligible for death or for life without parole. He was held without bail.
On June 16, 2020, federal prosecutors in the Northern District of California charged him with the murder of the Oakland officer and the attempted murder of his partner. They described Carrillo as a follower of a far-right, anti-government movement hostile to law enforcement. A second man was charged as his accomplice in Oakland. A federal grand jury indicted Carrillo that month on charges of murdering and attempting to murder persons assisting an officer or employee of the United States, and he pleaded not guilty in both courts. The two prosecutions went forward side by side, each on its own track.
The federal case broke first. In January 2022 federal prosecutors agreed not to seek the death penalty, and on February 11, 2022, Carrillo pleaded guilty in federal court to the murder of the Oakland officer and the attempted murder of the second officer, under an agreement that called for 41 years in prison. In entering the plea he admitted that he had aligned himself with the anti-government movement and that he had meant to commit violent acts against federal law enforcement officers in particular. On June 3, 2022, the district judge accepted the agreement and sentenced him to 41 years in federal prison, to be followed by supervised release for the rest of his life.
Three weeks later the Ben Lomond case ended with little warning. On June 27, 2022, Carrillo pleaded guilty in Santa Cruz County Superior Court to all nine felony counts still pending against him, including murder with special circumstances and the attempted murder of four law enforcement officers and one civilian. The agreement took the death penalty off the table and left life without the possibility of parole as the sentence.
On August 26, 2022, the Superior Court judge imposed it: life in prison without the possibility of parole for the murder of the sergeant, with further terms of 15 years to life and of life for the attempted murders of two sheriff's deputies, two California Highway Patrol officers and the resident. The state terms run concurrently with each other and with the federal sentence, and under the plea agreement he gave up his right to appeal. He was committed to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation for life, and as of August 2022 he had been moved to state prison.
The man charged as his accomplice in Oakland did not plead guilty. A federal jury convicted him in September 2023 of aiding and abetting murder and attempted murder, and in March 2024 he was sentenced to life in federal prison.
Carrillo's age is given as 32 in June 2020, 33 at the federal plea in February 2022 and either 33 or 34 at the sentencings later that year; his birth date has not been made public.
The number of officers injured in Ben Lomond varies in coverage from two to four. The court record settles the figure that matters: he was convicted of attempting to murder two sheriff's deputies, two Highway Patrol officers and one civilian.
Reports differ on whether the federal plea and sentencing hearings were held in San Francisco or in Oakland.
May 29, 2020: a Federal Protective Service contract officer is killed and a second is injured in Oakland during protests over the death of George Floyd.
June 6, 2020: a Santa Cruz County sheriff's sergeant is killed and other officers are injured in Ben Lomond; Carrillo is taken into custody the same day.
June 12, 2020: Santa Cruz County prosecutors have filed 19 counts, including special-circumstance murder; he is held without bail.
June 16, 2020: federal prosecutors charge Carrillo with murder and attempted murder; a second man is charged as his accomplice.
June 2020: a federal grand jury indicts him.
January 2022: federal prosecutors agree not to seek the death penalty.
February 11, 2022: Carrillo pleads guilty in federal court to murder and attempted murder under an agreement for 41 years.
June 3, 2022: he is sentenced in federal court to 41 years and lifetime supervised release.
June 27, 2022: he pleads guilty in Santa Cruz County Superior Court to all nine remaining felony counts, including murder with special circumstances.
August 26, 2022: he is sentenced to life without the possibility of parole, with concurrent terms, and waives appeal.
September 2023 to March 2024: the accomplice is convicted by a federal jury and sentenced to life.