Stephan Ernst is serving a life sentence in Germany for the murder of Dr. Walter Lübcke, the regional governor of Kassel, who died on the night of June 1 to 2, 2019, in Wolfhagen, his hometown in northern Hesse. On January 28, 2021, after a trial of more than forty hearing days, the state security senate of the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main convicted Ernst of murder, imposed a life sentence, found that his guilt was of particular gravity and reserved the right to order preventive detention once the sentence has been served. The court found that he had acted from racist, xenophobic and political motives, and that the killing was committed with malice and from base motives, the two features of German law that turned it into murder.
The same court acquitted him of a second count, the attempted murder of a man in the town of Lohfelden in January 2016, and it acquitted his friend and co-accused of aiding the murder. On August 25, 2022, the Third Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe dismissed every appeal brought against the judgment, by Ernst, by the co-accused, by the Federal Public Prosecutor General and by the joint plaintiffs. The conviction, the sentence and both acquittals became final that day.
The case began with a death in a country town and no suspect. What came next was an arrest built on physical evidence, a confession, its withdrawal, a second account that blamed another man, and a third, given in open court, that the judges accepted only in part.
By the time of the murder Ernst lived in Lohfelden, near Kassel. He was 45 when he was arrested and 47 when he was sentenced. The Frankfurt court found that his hostility toward foreigners went back to his school days and hardened into a nationalist and racist worldview, and that he had belonged to the far-right scene in Kassel for many years. It found that as a young man he had committed serious crimes against migrants, and that his extremism had driven him to serious violence more than once. One of those offenses, an attempted attack on a hostel for asylum seekers in 1993, ended in a criminal conviction.
The friendship that later put a second man in the dock began in 2011. The court found that the two men shared the same views, that they were active together at political discussions and demonstrations, and that they trained together in 2015 and 2016 and on five further days between October 2016 and October 2018. The co-accused had no previous convictions.
The victim was the regierungspräsident of Kassel, the head of the regional administration for the northern part of the state of Hesse. He was a longtime member of the Christian Democratic Union, the party of Chancellor Angela Merkel, and Wolfhagen, on the western edge of the Kassel district, was his hometown. The Federal Court of Justice, in its final judgment, referred to him by his doctoral title.
He had supported the federal government's decision in 2015 to admit refugees. On October 14, 2015, he spoke at a citizens' meeting in Lohfelden called to discuss an emergency shelter for refugees in the town. He reminded the hall of the country's historic responsibility and defended the housing of people seeking protection, and when hecklers interrupted he answered that anyone who did not share those values was free to leave the country. The remark spread widely online and turned him into a target of far-right anger. He received threats that year.
Ernst and his friend were in the hall that evening. The Frankfurt court found that the co-accused filmed the meeting and posted an edited version online that put the governor's answer at its center. From then on, the court held, Ernst increasingly directed his hatred of foreigners at the governor, and that hatred grew over the following year.
On January 6, 2016, a man was gravely injured in Lohfelden, not far from the shelter the meeting had been called to discuss. Police questioned Ernst at the time, and he denied any involvement; the inquiry led nowhere. The case was reopened only after his arrest for the murder. On September 19, 2019, the Federal Public Prosecutor General announced that Ernst was also suspected of having tried to kill the man by stealth and from base motives, with his far-right views as the deciding factor. The count became part of the indictment the following spring. Ernst denied it throughout.
The regional governor died on the night of June 1 to 2, 2019, in the Istha district of Wolfhagen. The authorities confirmed the death on Monday, June 3. The Hesse state criminal police set up a special commission of twenty officers, and the public prosecutor in Kassel opened a homicide investigation.
Investigators linked Ernst to the killing through physical evidence. On June 15, 2019, he was provisionally arrested, and the next day the local court in Kassel ordered him held in pre-trial custody on suspicion of murder. Within days the Federal Public Prosecutor General in Karlsruhe took over the case, citing its special significance.
On June 25, 2019, the Federal Public Prosecutor General announced that Ernst had confessed. In that first account he said that he had prepared and committed the murder alone. The federal prosecutors made clear the next day that the confession did not end the inquiry, and that only further investigation could show whether anyone had helped him.
That investigation moved quickly. On June 26, 2019, his friend was provisionally arrested, and on June 27 the investigating judge of the Federal Court of Justice ordered him held in pre-trial custody on suspicion of aiding the murder.
On July 2, 2019, Ernst was brought before the investigating judge of the Federal Court of Justice. The judge issued a new arrest warrant for murder on the application of the Federal Public Prosecutor General, on grounds of strong suspicion of murder, and that warrant replaced the order of the Kassel local court. At the same hearing Ernst withdrew his confession. His lawyer at the time announced the withdrawal but gave no further detail.
Ernst then changed his account. In statements to investigators on January 8 and February 5, 2020, he said that he and his friend had gone to the governor's town together and that the friend had caused the death by accident. The friend was by then in custody himself, suspected of having supported the plan. Investigators did not accept the new version.
On April 29, 2020, the Federal Public Prosecutor General brought charges, in an indictment dated the previous day, before the state security senate of the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main. Ernst was charged with murder, with the attempted murder of the man injured in Lohfelden in 2016, together with bodily harm, and with offenses under the arms law. His friend was charged with aiding the murder and with an offense under the arms law.
The case against the friend rested largely on Ernst's first account of June 25, 2019. The indictment alleged that he had given Ernst encouragement and a sense of security, through the demonstrations they attended together and the training sessions between 2016 and 2018, and that from July 2016 at the latest he had reckoned with the possibility that Ernst would kill a political decision-maker and accepted it. The friend had not been told of the specific plan, the prosecutors said.
On June 2, 2020, the court opened the main proceedings and admitted the indictment for trial. It ordered both men kept in custody and extended and reformulated the warrant against the friend. The trial was set to begin on June 16, a little more than a year after the death, with the first hearings fixed for June 16, 18 and 30.
The trial opened in Frankfurt on June 16, 2020, before the Fifth Criminal Senate, which sits as the court's state security senate. The man injured in Lohfelden took part as a joint plaintiff on the second count. No witness had seen either event. The judges built their findings from the statements of the two defendants, the testimony of acquaintances, investigators and experts, and circumstantial evidence.
On August 5, 2020, Ernst gave his third account of the killing, and the first in court. His new lawyer read a written statement aloud, after which Ernst answered questions himself. In it he withdrew the earlier versions and admitted that he had caused the death himself, while insisting that his friend had been present. He denied the 2016 count. The friend's defense asked for a psychological assessment of whether Ernst was fit to testify. The friend himself stayed silent on the murder charge throughout.
The judges grew openly skeptical of the third account. On October 1, 2020, after twenty days of hearings, the court lifted the arrest warrant against the co-accused, who had then spent one year and three months in pre-trial custody. It found that there was no longer a strong suspicion that he had aided the murder: the evidence did not make it highly probable that he had reckoned with a killing, and the court had considerable doubts about the accuracy of the statements on which the suspicion had chiefly rested. Ernst had described his friend's part differently each time. A former partner of the co-accused, heard as a witness, had not only softened in court what she had told investigators but had raised serious doubts about that earlier account. Other evidence pointed to the co-accused having been elsewhere when the governor died. The judges also declined to treat him as a suspected co-perpetrator on the strength of Ernst's account in court. A strong suspicion remained only on an offense under the arms law, and the penalty to be expected for that was too low to justify further custody.
The Federal Public Prosecutor General challenged the release on October 6, 2020. On October 29, 2020, the Federal Court of Justice dismissed the complaint (StB 38/20). Only the court before which the evidence was being heard could judge from its own observation whether a strong suspicion survived, the federal judges held. The Frankfurt senate had set out its reasons in detail and in a consistent way, and the prosecutors had done little more than put their own reading of the evidence in place of the trial court's. The co-accused remained a defendant and attended the rest of the trial as a free man.
Later that month the trial turned for the first time to the 2016 count. A hearing on October 20, 2020, was given over entirely to it and to expert evidence, and on October 29 the man injured in Lohfelden testified, through an interpreter, as a witness and joint plaintiff. Ernst continued to deny the attack.
The court closed the taking of evidence on December 17, 2020. On December 22, 2020, the fortieth hearing day, the Federal Public Prosecutor General's office gave its closing argument. It held Ernst's guilt proven on both counts and asked for a life sentence, a finding of particular gravity of guilt and an order for preventive detention. It treated Ernst's first account, in which he acted alone, as largely credible, and it did not accept that the friend had been present. It still asked for the friend to be convicted of aiding the murder, on the footing that he had strengthened Ernst's resolve, and of the offense under the arms law, and sought nine years and eight months.
On January 21, 2021, the defense spoke. Ernst's lawyer argued that his client could be convicted only of manslaughter, not murder, and asked the court to avoid both a finding of particular gravity and preventive detention. On the 2016 count the defense sought an acquittal. The friend's lawyers asked for his acquittal.
On January 28, 2021, the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main convicted Ernst of the murder of the regional governor and sentenced him to life imprisonment. It found that his guilt was of particular gravity and reserved the imposition of preventive detention. It acquitted him of the attempted murder and dangerous bodily harm of the man injured in Lohfelden. The trial had lasted 45 days, the day of judgment included.
The court found that Ernst had held a racist, nationalist worldview for years, and that the citizens' meeting of October 2015 was the moment at which his hatred fastened on the governor. It found that he had set out to kill the governor for his political convictions and for his work in office, and to punish him for the line he had taken on refugees. It found the two qualifying features of murder under German law: the killing exploited a victim who was unsuspecting and defenseless, and it was committed from base motives. It found that Ernst had acted alone.
On the confessions the court drew a sharp line. It found the three accounts contradictory, thin on detail and adjusted each time to the state of the evidence, and it did not believe any of them on the friend's part. It accepted them only insofar as Ernst described his own conduct.
The particular gravity of guilt rested on the racist and far-right attitude that the court identified as the overriding motive for the killing, and on Ernst's earlier violent crimes, which had also been driven by extremism. Preventive detention was reserved rather than ordered. Under the provisions the court applied, an immediate order would have required convictions for more than one qualifying offense, and Ernst was convicted of one. The court nonetheless found, on the basis of expert psychiatric evidence, that further serious crimes of the same kind had to be expected. It ordered him to remain in custody.
The co-accused was acquitted of aiding the murder. The court was not satisfied that he had been at the scene, because objective evidence of his presence was lacking and there were indications that he had been elsewhere. Nor was it satisfied that the training sessions and the demonstrations had strengthened Ernst's resolve, or that the friend had seriously reckoned with a killing. Doubts that remain after all the evidence has been heard must favor the accused, the court said. It convicted him instead of an offense under the arms law and sentenced him to one year and six months, suspended on probation for three years, with the time already spent in custody credited. It rejected the Federal Public Prosecutor General's application for a new arrest warrant against him.
On the 2016 count the court found that the attack in Lohfelden had happened as charged but that it could not establish that Ernst had committed it. Evidence on dates undermined a central strand of the prosecution's case, and other physical findings could not be reliably attributed. The doubt again went to the accused.
Appeals on points of law followed within days, from every side. The federal prosecutors confined their appeal to the two acquittals and to the decision only to reserve, rather than order, preventive detention. The man injured in Lohfelden challenged Ernst's acquittal on the 2016 count. Ernst challenged his murder conviction, seeking one for manslaughter, and the co-accused challenged his conviction under the arms law.
The Third Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice heard the appeals in Karlsruhe on July 28, 2022.
On August 25, 2022, the Federal Court of Justice dismissed all the appeals (3 StR 359/21) and declared the Frankfurt judgment final. The federal judges reviewed it for errors of law only and heard no witnesses. Their starting point was that the weighing of evidence belongs to the trial court, whose conclusions need only be possible, not compelling.
On the co-accused, the prosecutors had argued that the Frankfurt senate was wrong to rely on Ernst's first account only where it concerned his own conduct, his attitudes and his thoughts and feelings. The Federal Court of Justice disagreed. Ernst had changed his account again and again, and in his later statements he had falsely implicated not only the co-accused but also a witness. The trial court was entitled to subject everything he said about others to especially critical scrutiny and to test it against other evidence. No rule of experience required a court to believe a witness entirely or not at all, and to give a self-accusation more weight than an accusation of someone else was a possible conclusion, soundly reasoned. The judges left open whether the trial court had fully weighed the outward side of aiding, because its finding that the co-accused had not even considered it possible that Ernst would kill the governor, or any other official or political decision-maker, was free of error and decided the point on its own.
On the 2016 count the federal judges found the reasoning neither circular nor incomplete. The trial court had weighed each strand of circumstantial evidence and drawn them together in a final overall assessment, and the prosecutors' objections came down to their own reading of the evidence.
The decision to reserve rather than order preventive detention also stood. None of Ernst's earlier convictions could count toward the measure under the statute's time limits, which left only a route that required a conviction in this trial for a second offense. With the acquittal on the 2016 count upheld, there was none.
The appeal of the man injured in Lohfelden, confined to Ernst's acquittal on his count, failed on both its procedural complaint and the substance.
Ernst's own procedural complaint was inadmissible because it had not been set out. On the substance, the court held that the findings were supported by the evidence and carried the conviction, and that a killing for political reasons is by itself a killing from base motives under the murder statute, whatever the details of the motive. The trial court had therefore not counted the same factor twice when it weighed his racist and xenophobic motives separately in finding the particular gravity of guilt: those motives went beyond the political one, and the Criminal Code names them expressly among the aggravating factors in sentencing. The co-accused's appeal against his conviction under the arms law failed for the reasons the Federal Public Prosecutor General had given in writing.
As of November 2026, Ernst is serving his life sentence in Germany. Whether he will be held in preventive detention after his sentence is a question the courts left open in 2022, to be decided in separate proceedings toward the end of his term. The co-accused has been free since October 2020; his suspended sentence is final.
The central dispute was who was present when the governor died. Ernst gave three accounts: that he acted alone; that his friend had caused the death by accident; and that he had done it himself with the friend at his side. The trial court rejected every version of the friend's involvement, and the Federal Court of Justice upheld that finding. The friend was acquitted of aiding the murder, an acquittal that is final.
The attack on the man injured in Lohfelden in January 2016 remains unresolved in law. The trial court accepted that it happened but acquitted Ernst because his part in it could not be established, and that acquittal is final.
October 14, 2015: The regional governor of Kassel defends a planned refugee shelter at a citizens' meeting in Lohfelden; Ernst and his friend are present.
January 6, 2016: A man is gravely injured in Lohfelden; Ernst is questioned and denies involvement.
June 1 to 2, 2019: The regional governor dies in Wolfhagen.
June 3, 2019: The authorities confirm the death; a special commission of the Hesse state criminal police begins work.
June 15, 2019: Ernst is provisionally arrested; held in pre-trial custody from June 16.
June 25, 2019: The Federal Public Prosecutor General announces Ernst's confession that he acted alone.
June 26 and 27, 2019: The friend is arrested and held in custody on suspicion of aiding the murder.
July 2, 2019: Ernst withdraws the confession; the investigating judge of the Federal Court of Justice issues a new warrant for murder.
September 19, 2019: Federal prosecutors announce that Ernst is suspected in the 2016 attack.
January 8 and February 5, 2020: Ernst gives a second account blaming his friend.
April 29, 2020: Federal Public Prosecutor General indicts Ernst for murder, attempted murder and offenses under the arms law, and the friend for aiding murder.
June 2, 2020: The court opens the main proceedings and admits the indictment.
June 16, 2020: Trial opens before the state security senate of the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main.
August 5, 2020: Ernst gives his third account in court.
October 1, 2020: The court releases the co-accused from pre-trial custody.
October 29, 2020: The Federal Court of Justice dismisses the prosecutors' complaint against the release; the man injured in Lohfelden testifies in Frankfurt.
December 17, 2020: The taking of evidence closes.
December 22, 2020: Federal prosecutors ask for life, particular gravity of guilt and preventive detention.
January 21, 2021: The defense gives its closing argument.
January 28, 2021: Ernst is convicted of murder and sentenced to life; particular gravity found; preventive detention reserved; acquitted on the 2016 count; the co-accused acquitted of aiding murder and given a suspended sentence under the arms law.
February 1 and 2, 2021: Appeals on points of law filed.
July 28, 2022: Federal Court of Justice hears the appeals.
August 25, 2022: Federal Court of Justice dismisses all appeals; the judgment becomes final.