For more than twenty years Sosthene Munyemana treated patients in the hospitals of southwestern France, first in emergency medicine and later in geriatric care. In the spring of 1994 he had been a gynecologist at the university hospital in Butare, in southern Rwanda, and a resident of Tumba, a sector of Butare prefecture. On December 20, 2023, the Paris assize court found him guilty of genocide, crimes against humanity and participation in a conspiracy to prepare those crimes. He was sentenced to 24 years of criminal imprisonment and taken into custody.
The case turned on a single building. Witnesses told the court that Munyemana held the key to the Tumba sector office, where Tutsi civilians were locked up in April and May 1994 before they were taken away and killed. He never denied having the key. He said he had used the office to shelter people. A second jury heard the case again in the autumn of 2025 and reached a narrower verdict: on October 23, 2025, the Paris assize court of appeal convicted him as the perpetrator of genocide constituted by willful attacks on life, and of conspiracy to commit genocide, and acquitted him of every count of crimes against humanity. It found that between April 23 and May 15, 1994, he controlled the key to an office where more than forty Tutsi were detained, and that all but one of them disappeared and died. The sentence stayed at 24 years. He has taken the case to the Cour de cassation, France's highest court.
The road to those verdicts took almost three decades. The first complaint against him was filed in Bordeaux in October 1995. His was the oldest case in France arising from the genocide against the Tutsi, and it was tried under a French law of May 22, 1996, which allows French courts to try genocide and crimes against humanity committed in Rwanda in 1994. The first trial did not open until November 2023.
Munyemana was born in 1955 in Gitarama, in central Rwanda. He trained as a doctor and specialized in gynecology, and from 1989 until June 1994 he worked at the university hospital in Butare, where he also lectured at the National University of Rwanda. He lived in Tumba, in what was then Ngoma commune. He was a friend of Jean Kambanda, who became prime minister of the interim government formed after President Juvénal Habyarimana's plane was brought down in April 1994, and Kambanda visited him in Tumba.
On April 17, 1994, Munyemana attended a security meeting in Tumba, chaired in part by the sector's councillor, at which roadblocks and night patrols were decided. Witnesses later told the Paris court that he helped set up both and that he was seen at the checkpoints. The patrols, called amarondo, were meant to identify and capture Tutsi; people stopped at the barriers in Tumba were arrested and then killed. The killing of Tutsi in Tumba began on April 21, 1994. That April, Munyemana also co-signed a motion of support for the interim government.
Munyemana admitted at trial that he took part in the night patrols. He said that he had joined them to protect the local population, not to hunt anyone, and described himself as a moderate Hutu who had tried to save Tutsi.
The Tumba sector office was a local administrative building, and from late April it became a place of detention. Between April 23 and May 15, 1994, more than forty Tutsi civilians were held there. The appeal court found that Munyemana controlled its key throughout that period, as most of the witnesses who spoke about the office at the first trial had said. The detainees did not stay long. They were taken from the office to other places, and all but one of them disappeared and died in circumstances the court could not establish.
Munyemana's account of the same weeks was the reverse. He agreed that he had the key. He said he had taken it in order to hide the people inside and keep them from the killers, and that he had offered them refuge in the office. He denied ever opening the door to hand anyone over. The two juries that heard the case did not accept his explanation.
Munyemana left Rwanda at the end of June 1994 and reached France in September. By October he was working with the University of Bordeaux, where he coordinated a working group on AIDS in Rwanda. He went on to work at the Saint-André hospital in Bordeaux and then at the hospital in Villeneuve-sur-Lot, in Lot-et-Garonne, as an emergency physician, and in his later years mainly in geriatric care. He stayed in practice for more than twenty years and retired about a year before his trial.
On October 18, 1995, a complaint was filed in Bordeaux accusing him of taking part in the genocide. Four French and Rwandan citizens brought it with the support of the Collectif girondin pour le Rwanda, and the human rights groups Survie and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) joined it. In 2001 the file moved to Paris. In January 2008 the National Court of Asylum rejected his application for asylum, finding serious reasons to believe he had committed a crime against humanity.
Rwanda pursued him on its own account. In 2006 it issued an international arrest warrant for war crimes and genocide, relayed by Interpol, and asked France to extradite him. In October 2008 a gacaca court in Butare, one of the community courts Rwanda set up to try genocide cases, convicted him in his absence and sentenced him to life imprisonment for crimes at the Butare hospital, with a further 30 years for crimes in Tumba. In January 2010 he was placed under judicial supervision in Bordeaux while the regional court of appeal considered Kigali's request. Speaking to the press that week, he called the accusations slanderous, said his file contained false documents and false testimony, and said he wanted a proper trial. On October 7, 2010, the Bordeaux court of appeal refused the extradition, and the supervision order was lifted. In November 2011, in a civil case he had brought, a Bordeaux court declined to treat the gacaca verdict as final, since he had not been present and the means of appeal open to him were unknown.
On December 14, 2011, investigating judges in Paris charged Munyemana with genocide and crimes against humanity and placed him under judicial supervision. He remained free and kept working. At the end of 2018 the judges sent him for trial before the assize court on charges of genocide, crimes against humanity, complicity in crimes against humanity and participation in a conspiracy formed to prepare those crimes. His challenges to that order ended on March 23, 2022, when the Cour de cassation dismissed his final appeal.
The trial opened before the Paris assize court on November 13, 2023, and ran for about six weeks. Most of the witnesses described how narrowly they had survived in Tumba; several spoke of family members taken from the sector office. The prosecution built its case on the motion of support for the interim government, his part in the local committee and meetings that organized the roundup of Tutsi civilians, his presence at the roadblocks and patrols, and his control of the sector office, and it asked for 30 years. Munyemana denied the charges throughout, and the defense called witnesses of its own.
The verdict was read on December 20, 2023. The court found that he had belonged to a group that prepared, organized and directed the genocide in Tumba from day to day, and that his part in it at the level of Tumba amounted to participation in the genocide across Rwanda.
He was convicted, as perpetrator, of genocide constituted by willful attacks on life and by serious attacks on physical or mental integrity, and of crimes against humanity constituted by torture or inhumane acts. He was convicted as an accomplice to crimes against humanity constituted by summary executions and by abductions followed by disappearance, and of participation in a conspiracy to commit genocide. He was acquitted of conspiracy to commit crimes against humanity. The sentence was 24 years of criminal imprisonment, with a minimum term of eight years before any release could be considered, and the court ordered his immediate arrest. He appealed.
The appeal opened before the Paris assize court of appeal on September 16, 2025. Munyemana had been in custody since the first verdict. The witnesses, the sector office and the key were examined again, and he maintained his innocence. This time the prosecution sought life imprisonment.
On October 23, 2025, the court of appeal convicted Munyemana as the perpetrator of genocide constituted by willful attacks on life and of participation in a conspiracy formed to prepare genocide, the counts at the center of the first verdict. It acquitted him of genocide constituted by serious attacks on physical or mental integrity, of torture and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity, and of complicity in crimes against humanity by summary executions and abductions followed by disappearance. The acquittal on conspiracy to commit crimes against humanity was confirmed.
In its reasons the court pointed to how long ago the events had taken place, to the lack of material evidence and to the impossibility of technical inquiries that might have settled the remaining charges. On the counts it upheld, its findings were specific: from April 23 to May 15, 1994, he controlled the key to the office where more than forty Tutsi were held, all but one of whom disappeared and died, and he took part in the meetings at which the patrols and barriers were set up to identify and capture Tutsi. The sentence was again 24 years of criminal imprisonment.
Munyemana then lodged an appeal with the Cour de cassation against the judgment and its sentence. In November 2025 that appeal was pending. He has been held in custody in France since December 20, 2023.
Munyemana has denied the charges from the start. His account is that he took the key to the sector office in order to protect the Tutsi held there and that he joined the night patrols to protect the population of Tumba. Two juries rejected that account on the counts of genocide and conspiracy to commit genocide.
The two verdicts did not agree on everything. The first court convicted him of crimes against humanity and of complicity in crimes against humanity; the appeal court acquitted him of both, as well as of genocide by serious attacks on physical or mental integrity, citing the age of the events and the lack of material evidence. Only the appeal verdict is under review by the Cour de cassation, and until that court rules, his conviction is not final.
Accounts of the appeal judgment differ on one point that matters: the detailed count-by-count reports say the crimes-against-humanity counts fell on appeal, while a Belgian wire report said that conviction was upheld. One Associated Press report said he had never been detained and would stay free during an appeal, but other reports say he was taken into custody at the first verdict and has been held since. Some reports date the first verdict to December 19, 2023, the day the jury retired, while others say it was read in the early hours of December 20. One account dates the appeal verdict to October 24, 2025, rather than October 23.
The gacaca court's life sentence of 2008 was passed in his absence. A French court declined in 2011 to treat it as a final judgment, and France never extradited him to serve it.
1955: Sosthene Munyemana is born in Gitarama, Rwanda.
1989 to June 1994: He works as a gynecologist at the university hospital in Butare.
April 6, 1994: President Juvénal Habyarimana's plane is brought down; an interim government is formed.
April 17, 1994: He attends the Tumba security meeting at which roadblocks and night patrols are decided.
April 1994: He co-signs a motion of support for the interim government.
April 21, 1994: The killing of Tutsi in Tumba begins.
April 23 to May 15, 1994: More than forty Tutsi civilians are held in the Tumba sector office, whose key he controls; all but one die.
Late June 1994: He leaves Rwanda.
September 1994: He arrives in France.
October 18, 1995: A complaint is filed against him in Bordeaux.
2001: The case moves to Paris.
2006: Rwanda issues an international arrest warrant and seeks his extradition.
January 2008: The National Court of Asylum rejects his asylum application.
October 2008: A gacaca court in Butare convicts him in his absence and sentences him to life imprisonment.
January 2010: He is placed under judicial supervision in Bordeaux pending the extradition hearing.
October 7, 2010: The Bordeaux court of appeal refuses extradition to Rwanda.
November 2011: A Bordeaux court declines to treat the gacaca verdict as final.
December 14, 2011: He is charged in Paris with genocide and crimes against humanity.
End of 2018: The investigating judges send him for trial before the assize court.
March 23, 2022: The Cour de cassation dismisses his challenge to the trial order.
November 13, 2023: His trial opens before the Paris assize court.
December 20, 2023: He is convicted of genocide, crimes against humanity and conspiracy and sentenced to 24 years; he is taken into custody.
September 16, 2025: The appeal trial opens before the Paris assize court of appeal.
October 23, 2025: The appeal court convicts him of genocide and conspiracy to commit genocide, acquits him of crimes against humanity and sentences him again to 24 years.
November 2025: His appeal to the Cour de cassation is pending.