On the morning of March 15, 1921, in the Charlottenburg district of Berlin, Mehmet Talaat was killed. He had been the Ottoman Empire's interior minister during the Armenian genocide of 1915 and its grand vizier until the autumn of 1918, and since December of that year he had lived in Berlin under an assumed name. An Armenian named Soghomon Tehlirian made no attempt to escape and was arrested by the Berlin police the same morning.
Eleven weeks later Tehlirian stood trial for murder before the jury court of Berlin District Court III in Moabit. He admitted the act and denied that it was a crime, and the question that decided the case was whether the law could hold him responsible for it. On June 3, 1921, the jury answered the question of his guilt with one word: "No." He left the courtroom a free man, and within days the German authorities had expelled him from the country.
The verdict left a great deal about the defendant unsaid. The court never learned that he belonged to the Armenian Revolutionary Federation or that historians would later tie his journey to Berlin to a secret network of its members. He lived another thirty-nine years, most of them under another name, and died in San Francisco in 1960.
Tehlirian was born on April 2, 1896, in the village of Nerkin Bagarij, in the Ottoman province of Erzurum. From 1905 he grew up in the nearby town of Erzincan, where he attended the Protestant school and then the Armenian central school, finishing in 1912. The next year he went to Serbia to study engineering.
When the war began in 1914 he made his way to Tiflis and joined the Armenian volunteer units that fought alongside the Russian army on the Caucasus front, and he stayed with them until 1918. In those years he began to suffer attacks that left him unconscious, the first of them in Yerevan in July 1915. Doctors later diagnosed a form of epilepsy, and the attacks would become the central question at his trial.
After the armistice of October 1918 he went to Constantinople, and from there, late in 1919 or in 1920, to the United States. He arrived in Berlin in December 1920, registered as a student of mechanical engineering.
The former grand vizier had left the Ottoman Empire with German help in November 1918 and reached Berlin the following month. On July 5, 1919, an Ottoman court martial in Constantinople sentenced him to death in absentia. The sentence was never carried out, and the German foreign minister refused two Ottoman requests for his extradition.
The charge against Tehlirian was murder under section 211 of the Imperial Criminal Code: that he had intentionally killed the former grand vizier and had done so with deliberation. In April 1921 the court's medical officer examined him for the prosecution and found that he suffered from epilepsy in a nervous form but not from a psychological disturbance. Everything turned on whether that condition brought the case within section 51 of the code, the provision on acts committed in a state of mental incapacity.
The trial opened in open court on June 2, 1921, in the criminal courts building at Moabit, and lasted a day and a half. Nine witnesses and experts were summoned, five of them on the medical question, and two of the medical experts told the court that the conditions of section 51 were met.
On June 3 the jury retired. When it returned, the foreman was asked whether Tehlirian was guilty of having intentionally killed the former grand vizier on March 15, 1921, in Charlottenburg, and he answered: "No." The verdict was unanimous. The presiding judge announced the acquittal on the offense charged, with costs to the state; the order for Tehlirian's detention was annulled and he was released. The jury gave no reasons. At the prosecution's request the police expelled him from Germany as an undesirable foreigner, and he left at once.
He never returned. He went first to the United States, then to Marseille and then to Serbia, where he settled in Belgrade and lived until 1950. There he took the name Saro Melikian, and he kept it for the rest of his life. From 1950 to 1955 he lived in Casablanca, then in Paris, and in the second half of the 1950s he moved to San Francisco, where he worked as a postal employee. His memoirs were published in Armenian in Cairo in the 1950s. He died in San Francisco on May 23, 1960.
According to historians of the case, Tehlirian came to Berlin for Nemesis, a secret network of Armenian Revolutionary Federation members formed after the war to kill former Ottoman leaders: his trip to the United States was paid for by the network, and he received the assignment in the autumn of 1920. None of this came before the court, which heard nothing of his party membership or his service in the volunteer units. He presented himself, and was judged, as a survivor acting alone.
His courtroom account of 1915 is also in question. At trial he described himself as an eyewitness to the deportations; his memoirs place him with the volunteer units at the time. Historians have described the trial account as a construction drawn from the common experience of survivors, and at least one writer has argued that the defense shaped his whole story of 1915 to 1921 to win an acquittal.
A 1919 killing in Constantinople, of Harutyun Mkrtchyan, is attributed to Tehlirian by historians; no court ever tried it, and its date is not settled.
April 2, 1896: Born in Nerkin Bagarij, Erzurum Province.
1905: Moves to Erzincan.
1913: Goes to Serbia to study engineering.
1914 to 1915: Joins the Armenian volunteer units on the Caucasus front.
July 5, 1919: An Ottoman court martial sentences the former grand vizier to death in absentia.
December 1920: Arrives in Berlin.
March 15, 1921: The former grand vizier is killed in Berlin-Charlottenburg; Tehlirian is arrested the same morning.
June 2 and 3, 1921: Tried before the jury court of Berlin District Court III, Moabit.
June 3, 1921: The jury answers "No"; acquitted, released and expelled from Germany.
1950: Leaves Belgrade for Casablanca.
Later 1950s: Moves to San Francisco.
May 23, 1960: Dies in San Francisco.