Slobodan Praljak

Victims
Thousands of Bosnian Muslim victims, 1993. Tribunal finding on the HVO campaign; convicted of persecution, murder, wilful killing, deportation and other crimes.
Years active
January 1993 to November 1993
Location
Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings); Prozor, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings); Jablanica, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings).
Method
Killings during HVO military operations and a siege with gunfire and shelling; deaths of detainees from beatings and mistreatment in detention (ICTY Trial Chamber findings).
Status
20 years (May 29, 2013); some convictions reversed, the rest and the sentence affirmed on appeal (November 29, 2017). Died by suicide in custody in The Hague, November 29, 2017.

Slobodan Praljak was a theater director with degrees in engineering and the humanities when war came to Yugoslavia in 1991. Within two years he was a general in the Croatian Army, an assistant minister of defense in Zagreb and, from July to November 1993, the commander of the main staff of the Croatian Defense Council, the HVO, the armed forces of the Bosnian Croat entity known as Herceg-Bosna. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia found that he belonged to a joint criminal enterprise whose purpose was to remove the Muslim population from the parts of Bosnia and Herzegovina that the Herceg-Bosna leadership claimed, and that he had contributed to it substantially and with intent.

On May 29, 2013, a Trial Chamber in The Hague convicted him of crimes against humanity, violations of the laws or customs of war and grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, among them persecution, murder and wilful killing, and sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment. On November 29, 2017, in the last judgment the tribunal ever delivered, the Appeals Chamber reversed several of his convictions, affirmed the rest and affirmed the 20-year sentence. He took his own life in the courtroom moments after the ruling and died later that day.

Čapljina, Zagreb and the stage

Praljak was born on January 2, 1945, in Čapljina, a town in the south of Bosnia and Herzegovina close to the Croatian border. He went on to study in Zagreb, and by the early 1970s he held degrees in electrical engineering, in philosophy and sociology, and in directing. The tribunal's indictment later described him as a man who had worked as a theatrical, film and television producer and as a lecturer in philosophy, psychology and electrical engineering.

His early working life ran on two tracks. For a time he managed an electronics laboratory; then he turned to the stage and to television, working as a director and producer. In 1989 he directed a feature film, The Return of Katarina Kozul. He had no military experience at all when Croatia's war began.

Into uniform, 1991 to 1993

Praljak joined the army of the Republic of Croatia in the early summer of 1991, as fighting spread between Croatian forces and rebel Serbs. In September of that year he volunteered to lead defense operations at Sunja, near Sisak in central Croatia. He was a colonel by November 1991. His rise from there was fast. By about March 14, 1992, he was Assistant Minister of Defense of the Republic of Croatia, working closely with the minister, and by April 3, 1992, he held the rank of major general in the Croatian Army.

In April 1992 he volunteered to command forces in southeastern Herzegovina, an area that took in Čapljina, Mostar, Jablanica and Konjic. On September 10, 1992, he was appointed one of the fourteen members of Croatia's Council of National Defense, a post he held until at least June 15, 1993, and on May 13, 1993, he was named to the Croatian state commission for relations with the United Nations Protection Force. For much of this period, roughly March 1992 to July 1993, he served at once as a senior Croatian Army officer, as an assistant defense minister and as the senior representative of Croatia's Ministry of Defense to the government and armed forces of Herceg-Bosna.

The war in Bosnia had begun with Bosnian Croats and Bosniak Muslims fighting the Bosnian Serbs side by side. In 1993 that alliance collapsed, and the two former partners fought each other for eleven months. Bosnian Croat leaders had created Herceg-Bosna, first as the Croatian Community and later as the Croatian Republic of Herceg-Bosna, and its army was the HVO. On July 24, 1993, at his own request, Praljak became the commander of the HVO Main Staff. He held the post until November 9, 1993, when he gave it up and returned to Croatia, where he later headed the military cabinet of President Franjo Tudjman and served as an adviser to the Croatian Minister of Defense.

What the Trial Chamber found about Herceg-Bosna

The Trial Chamber found, by a majority, that a joint criminal enterprise had existed whose ultimate goal was a Croatian territorial entity in Bosnia and Herzegovina, drawn partly on the borders of the Croatian Banovina of 1939, which would allow the reunification of the Croatian people. That entity was either to join Croatia once Bosnia and Herzegovina dissolved or to become an independent state inside Bosnia with direct ties to Croatia. As early as December 1991, the chamber held, the Herceg-Bosna leadership, including its president Mate Boban, and Croatian leaders, including Tudjman, considered it necessary to change the ethnic composition of the territories Herceg-Bosna claimed in order to reach that goal.

From at least the end of October 1992, the chamber found, Praljak and three of his co-accused knew that reaching the goal ran against the peace talks then under way in Geneva and would mean moving Muslim populations out of Herceg-Bosna. By mid-January 1993 the HVO leadership and certain Croatian leaders intended to consolidate HVO control over the provinces they regarded as Croatian and to ethnically cleanse them, so that their populations would be mostly or entirely Croat. The chamber dated the joint criminal enterprise from that point.

The crimes that followed, the judges held, were in most cases not the random acts of a few unruly soldiers. They followed a plan drawn up by members of the enterprise, who directed and coordinated events on the ground. The chamber described a system for expelling the Muslim population of Herceg-Bosna: displacement and confinement of civilians; murder and destruction of property during military operations; mistreatment during evictions; harsh conditions and mistreatment in detention; the widespread use of detainees for labor at the front lines; and, finally, the removal of detainees and their families from Herceg-Bosna once they were released. Thousands of people, the chamber found, were victims of these acts, which the HVO's military and political forces carried out in an organized way.

The case covered eight municipalities, Mostar, Prozor, Gornji Vakuf, Jablanica, Ljubuški, Stolac, Čapljina and Vareš, together with a network of HVO detention centers. The chamber found by a majority that the conflict between the HVO and the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the ABiH, was international in character, because troops of the Croatian Army fought alongside the HVO and Croatia had overall control over the HVO and the civilian authorities of Herceg-Bosna.

Praljak's part, as the Trial Chamber saw it

Between the autumn of 1992 and November 9, 1993, the Trial Chamber found, Praljak held significant authority over the HVO armed forces and its Military Police, de facto at first and then both de jure and de facto. Until July 24, 1993, while he still held office in Croatia's defense ministry, he directed the HVO by taking command of certain operations, giving orders to units, receiving reports from commanders in the field, representing the HVO in attempts to build a joint command with the ABiH and commanding some Military Police units. From July 24 to November 9, 1993, as commander of the Main Staff, he had effective command and control over every component of the HVO.

The judges tied him to specific operations. He planned, facilitated and was kept informed of the HVO operations in Gornji Vakuf on or around January 18, 1993. He planned and directed HVO operations in Prozor Municipality from July 24, 1993. He took part in directing and planning HVO operations in Mostar Municipality between July and early November 1993, including those of November 8, 1993, that ended in the destruction of the Old Bridge. He took part in planning and directing HVO operations in Vareš in October 1993. In each case, the chamber held, he thereby took part in committing the crimes those operations involved.

The chamber also found that he knew members of the armed forces were removing the Muslim population of Prozor and placing it in detention in July and August 1993; that he knew crimes would be committed in Mostar Municipality, including murders, the destruction of buildings in East Mostar and attacks on members of international organizations; and that he made no serious effort to stop crimes by HVO forces. Instead, the judges said, he denied the crimes committed against Muslims and helped ensure that their perpetrators went unpunished.

His Croatian posts mattered to the finding. Through his work in the Croatian government and the HVO at the same time, the chamber held, he came to know the policies of Croatia's most senior leaders toward Herceg-Bosna and showed that he wished to carry them out. He passed orders, communiques and instructions from Croatia's leaders to those of Herceg-Bosna and helped obtain Croatian military support for the HVO. The majority concluded beyond reasonable doubt that he made a substantial contribution to the joint criminal enterprise and intended its common purpose. It also held that he could reasonably have foreseen looting during the evictions in Gornji Vakuf in January 1993 and during the HVO operation at Raštani in August 1993, and that he accepted that risk.

Gornji Vakuf and Prozor

The first clashes between the HVO and the ABiH in the case came on January 11 and 12, 1993, in Gornji Vakuf. On January 16, acting on an order issued the day before, the HVO Main Staff demanded that ABiH forces in Gornji Vakuf place themselves under HVO command. The ABiH refused, and on January 18 the HVO launched operations against the town of Gornji Vakuf and several villages near it. The Trial Chamber found that the HVO destroyed Muslim property there, that seven people died in the village of Duša, and that women, children and elderly people from four villages were detained and expelled to territory held by the ABiH.

The Appeals Chamber later reversed the convictions for the deaths in Duša. It held that no reasonable trier of fact could have found that the HVO forces there had the state of mind required for murder and wilful killing, and it reversed the related persecution findings for the destruction of property in Gornji Vakuf on January 18, 1993. For Praljak, that reversal came on his own twelfth ground of appeal.

Prozor was the scene of the summer's mass detentions. Between June and August 1993 the HVO arrested Muslim men in the municipality, minors, elderly and sick men among them, and held hundreds of them for weeks. It also detained Muslim women, children and elderly people in several villages, where they lived in a climate of terror, and on August 28, 1993, transferred them to ABiH territory. On appeal Praljak argued that some of these civilians might have gone there of their own accord and kept some freedom of movement. The Appeals Chamber dismissed the argument, holding that imprisonment and unlawful confinement can exist even without guards. It likewise rejected his claim that the women, children and elderly people may have left by choice, noting the Trial Chamber's findings that he shared responsibility for their conditions and that the transfer took place when there was no fighting in the area and no possibility of return. The Appeals Chamber did reverse one conviction for murder concerning two unarmed men in Tošćanica, Prozor Municipality.

Mostar

Mostar sat at the center of the case. From May 9, 1993, the HVO carried out mass arrests of Muslims in West Mostar and separated the men from the women, children and elderly people. Between May 1993 and February 1994 HVO soldiers drove Muslims out of West Mostar, above all in major eviction operations in mid-May, mid-June, early July and September 1993, detaining the men and expelling their families to East Mostar. The Trial Chamber found that the soldiers used extreme violence in those operations.

From June 1993 to April 1994 the HVO besieged East Mostar. The Appeals Chamber described the population as confined to a cramped enclave, unable to leave and forced to live without food, water, electricity or adequate medical care, while the HVO kept up a prolonged military assault, deliberately targeted members of international organizations and hindered or blocked humanitarian aid. Both chambers held that these acts were specifically intended to discriminate against the Muslims of Mostar and to spread terror among the civilian population. Ten mosques in East Mostar were badly damaged or destroyed.

On November 8, 1993, as part of the offensive, HVO forces brought the Old Bridge of Mostar, the city's sixteenth-century Ottoman crossing over the Neretva, to the edge of collapse, and it fell the next morning. The Trial Chamber found by a majority that although the bridge was used by the ABiH and was a legitimate military target, its destruction caused disproportionate damage to the Muslim civilian population. That finding did not survive appeal.

Vareš

In Vareš, in central Bosnia, the HVO pressed the Croatian population to leave for Herceg-Bosna and committed numerous crimes against Muslims. On October 23, 1993, members of the HVO arrested Muslim men in the town of Vareš and held them in very harsh conditions. The same day HVO forces launched an offensive on the Muslim village of Stupni Do, where 36 people were killed, three children among them, and the whole village was destroyed. The Trial Chamber found that the highest HVO authorities told the international community that investigations were under way when none was ever carried out, and that the HVO commander at Vareš stayed in his post under another name and was never investigated.

The Trial Chamber held that Praljak facilitated the murders and the destruction of property in Stupni Do and contributed to efforts to conceal the HVO's responsibility. The Appeals Chamber granted his appeal on the first point, holding that no reasonable trier of fact could have concluded that he facilitated those murders and that destruction. It upheld, though, the finding that he took part in planning and directing the operations in Vareš Municipality, and it affirmed his contribution to the joint criminal enterprise in that respect.

Alongside the military operations, the Trial Chamber found, the HVO created and ran an entire network of detention centers for Muslims, opened between June 1992 and April 1993, which held thousands of civilians and soldiers without distinction. The premises were unfit for so many people, and overcrowding grew worst in the summer of 1993, after great waves of arrests in May and July. Detainees in every center were undernourished, sanitary conditions were appalling, and most went without adequate medical care. HVO members regularly mistreated them. Detainees were forced to work at the front lines, where some were killed. From December 1993 the HVO emptied the centers, sending many detainees and their families to third countries by way of Croatia and others to territory held by the ABiH.

Indictment, trial and judgment

The indictment against Praljak and five other senior Herceg-Bosna figures, Jadranko Prlić, Bruno Stojić, Milivoj Petković, Valentin Ćorić and Berislav Pušić, was confirmed on March 4, 2004, and made public on April 2. It charged them with 26 counts: grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, violations of the laws or customs of war and crimes against humanity, within a joint criminal enterprise alleged to have run from on or before November 18, 1991, to about April 1994. All six surrendered and were transferred to the tribunal on April 5, 2004. The next day each pleaded not guilty to every count.

The trial of the six opened on April 26, 2006. Praljak took the witness stand in his own defense in the spring of 2009. He argued that wartime articles in the Croatian Defense Ministry's official journal showed that Croatia had no designs on Bosnian territory. He said Bosnia and Herzegovina would not exist without Croatia and the Bosnian Croats, described Herceg-Bosna as a defensive force and blamed Bosnia's wartime president, Alija Izetbegović, for leaving the country unready for war. He rejected the prosecution's case that Tudjman stood at the head of a joint criminal enterprise.

The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on May 29, 2013. It found Praljak guilty on 20 counts, most of them unanimously and four by a majority with the presiding judge dissenting, and by a majority it declined to convict him on the counts of rape and of inhuman treatment by sexual assault. The convictions covered persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds, murder, deportation, imprisonment and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity; cruel treatment, unlawful labor, destruction or wilful damage to institutions dedicated to religion or education, plunder of public or private property, unlawful attack on civilians and unlawful infliction of terror on civilians as violations of the laws or customs of war; and wilful killing, unlawful deportation, transfer and confinement of a civilian, inhuman treatment, and extensive destruction and appropriation of property not justified by military necessity and carried out unlawfully and wantonly, as grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions.

The chamber unanimously sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had already spent in detention. Prlić received 25 years; Stojić and Petković, 20 years each; Ćorić, 16 years; and Pušić, 10 years.

The appeal

The prosecution appealed too, seeking longer sentences. Praljak challenged the findings that he held command authority over the HVO and its Military Police, that he served as a conduit between the Croatian government and the HVO, and that he contributed significantly to the joint criminal enterprise with the required intent. He was the only party to the case who did not appeal his sentence.

The Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment on November 29, 2017. On the broad questions it sided with the Trial Chamber. It held that an international armed conflict had existed, that Croatia, through the HVO, exercised actual authority over the relevant municipalities, so that they were under occupation, and that the joint criminal enterprise had aimed at a Croatian entity in Bosnia and Herzegovina that would reconstitute earlier borders and help reunify the Croatian people. None of the six succeeded in overturning that finding.

On the Old Bridge it reversed course. The bridge had been a military target at the time, the Appeals Chamber held, with one judge dissenting, so its destruction offered a definite military advantage and could not in itself be wanton destruction not justified by military necessity. It acquitted all six of persecution and unlawful infliction of terror on civilians in relation to the bridge, finding that no reasonable trier of fact could have found the required intent to discriminate or to spread terror in that act.

The chamber also limited Praljak's responsibility in time. The Trial Chamber had found that he ceased to be a member of the enterprise when he gave up his HVO functions on November 9, 1993, but it had failed to give reasons on whether it convicted him for later crimes, including the destruction of seven mosques in East Mostar and incidents there the following year. The Appeals Chamber held that he could not be responsible for crimes committed after November 9, 1993. It found that the Trial Chamber had failed to give a reasoned opinion on his intent for the crime of unlawful infliction of terror on civilians, but concluded that he had not shown how that error invalidated his conviction. His remaining challenges were dismissed.

For Praljak, the Appeals Chamber reversed his convictions, as a participant in the joint criminal enterprise, for persecution, murder and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity and wilful killing and inhuman treatment as grave breaches, with regard to the seven civilians in Duša; for murder and wilful killing with regard to the two men in Tošćanica; for persecution in relation to the destruction of houses in Gornji Vakuf on January 18, 1993; for persecution and unlawful infliction of terror on civilians in relation to the Old Bridge; and, on the chamber's own motion, for extensive destruction of property as a grave breach in Vareš Municipality. It affirmed the remainder of his convictions and dismissed his appeal in all other respects.

The prosecution won part of its own appeal. The Appeals Chamber held that the Trial Chamber had applied too high a threshold under the third category of joint criminal enterprise liability, and that it had erred in failing to enter convictions for wanton destruction of Muslim property in Prozor Municipality and of mosques in East Mostar between June and November 9, 1993. It declined to quash the acquittals, order a retrial or enter new convictions. It then affirmed his sentence of 20 years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had already spent in detention.

Disputed and unproven points

The 2004 indictment gives his date of birth as January 1 or 2, 1945; other accounts give January 2.

Praljak never accepted the findings against him. He pleaded not guilty to every count in 2004, testified that Croatia had no territorial designs on Bosnia and that Herceg-Bosna was a defensive force, and rejected the appeal judgment in court on the day it was read.

The judges themselves divided on several points. At trial the presiding judge dissented on the use of joint criminal enterprise as the mode of liability, on Praljak's convictions under Counts 2, 3, 22 and 23, and on the majority's finding about the Old Bridge. On appeal one judge dissented from the reversal on the Old Bridge, and another dissented from every part of the judgment dealing with unlawful infliction of terror on civilians, holding that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction over that crime.

The Trial Chamber's finding that Praljak facilitated the murders at Stupni Do was reversed for lack of a reasonable basis, though his part in planning and directing the Vareš operations stands. The convictions for the deaths in Duša were reversed for every accused. The Trial Chamber never entered convictions on the rape and sexual assault counts against him, and the Appeals Chamber, while finding legal error in some of his acquittals under the third category of joint criminal enterprise, declined to convict him of anything new.

Timeline

January 2, 1945: Born in Čapljina, Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Early summer 1991: Joins the army of the Republic of Croatia.

September 1991: Volunteers to lead defense operations at Sunja, near Sisak.

About March 14, 1992: Becomes Assistant Minister of Defense of Croatia.

By April 3, 1992: Holds the rank of major general in the Croatian Army.

September 10, 1992: Appointed to Croatia's Council of National Defense.

Mid-January 1993: The joint criminal enterprise begins, as found by the Trial Chamber.

January 18, 1993: HVO operations in Gornji Vakuf, which he planned and facilitated.

May 9, 1993: Mass arrests of Muslims in West Mostar begin.

June 1993: The HVO siege of East Mostar begins; it lasts until April 1994.

July 24, 1993: Becomes commander of the HVO Main Staff.

October 23, 1993: HVO operations in Vareš Municipality.

November 8 and 9, 1993: The Old Bridge of Mostar is brought down.

November 9, 1993: Gives up his HVO functions; his part in the enterprise ends.

March 4, 2004: Indictment confirmed; made public April 2, 2004.

April 5, 2004: Surrenders and is transferred to the ICTY.

April 6, 2004: Pleads not guilty to all 26 counts.

April 26, 2006: Trial opens.

May 2009: Testifies in his own defense.

May 29, 2013: Convicted and sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment.

March 20 to 28, 2017: Appeal hearing.

November 29, 2017: Appeals Chamber reverses some convictions and affirms the rest and the sentence; he dies the same day after taking his own life in the courtroom.