Lisa Cecilia Harnum died in central Sydney on July 30, 2011. She had come from Ontario, Canada, and she was engaged to Simon Gittany, a Sydney man with whom she lived in the city center. In November 2013, after a four-week trial before a judge sitting without a jury, Justice Lucy McCallum of the Supreme Court of New South Wales found Gittany guilty of her murder. She found that he had killed his fiancee in a rage on discovering that she was planning to leave him.
Gittany, who was 40 when the verdict came, had always denied the charge. He pleaded not guilty, gave evidence in his own defense, and kept saying he was innocent after the verdict, at his sentencing and through his appeal. In February 2014 he was sentenced to 26 years in prison with a non-parole period of 18 years. The New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed his appeal against the conviction in 2016.
The case drew close attention in Australia while it was running, largely because of what the trial revealed about the relationship. The court heard that Gittany had watched his fiancee through cameras in the rooms they shared and through software that let him read her text messages and emails and follow her use of the internet. Messages put before the court showed his jealousy reaching the point that she was expected to keep her eyes on the ground when she was out in public. Gittany admitted on the stand that some of his behavior had been controlling. He denied that he had killed her.
Gittany's dealings with the courts went back almost two decades. In August 1993 he was found in Parramatta, in Sydney's west, with stolen goods. In March 1994, when he was 20, two police officers went to arrest him in Merrylands over those goods; he resisted, and one officer was injured. He pleaded guilty to maliciously wounding a police officer and to receiving stolen goods, and he was sentenced to two and a half years of periodic detention, served on set days in custody. In March 2000 he was a passenger in a car stopped by police in Double Bay, in Sydney's eastern suburbs. He pleaded guilty to supplying a prohibited drug and received weekend detention and home detention. He later ran several businesses. When he came to be sentenced for murder in 2014, the court took the 1994 conviction into account.
She had moved to Sydney and was living with Gittany as his fiancee. The evidence put before the court described the last stretch of her life as a period of close and constant watching: the cameras recorded her movements, and the software on the household computer gave him her messages and emails. She was living under rules about where she could look and whom she could write to.
By the end of July 2011, the judge found, tension between the couple had reached "a point of crisis." She had decided to break off the engagement and go home to Canada. The Crown's case, which the judge accepted, was that Gittany's discovery of her plan was the immediate cause of what followed, and the judge found that he flew into an uncontrollable rage. She died that morning in central Sydney. The verdict turned on her decision to leave.
New South Wales Police investigated the death as a homicide. One set of the household recordings was never handed to police, and at the trial Gittany agreed that he had kept it from them. He said it would have shown nothing different; the court heard evidence that it could have. Gittany was charged with her murder and was on bail from January 2012 until his trial, which opened in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Sydney in the second half of 2013.
The trial ran for about four weeks before Justice McCallum, sitting alone. The Crown case was that Gittany had killed his fiancee on learning that she meant to leave. The defense said she had not died at his hands.
Two strands of evidence carried most of the weight. The first was the relationship itself: the cameras, the software, the messages, and Gittany's own admissions about his conduct, which together set out the jealousy and control the Crown said lay behind the killing. The second was the evidence of a passer-by who gave an account of what he saw and heard that morning. The defense challenged that account. It called a psychologist who specializes in memory to give evidence that what the witness learned about the case after the event could have shaped what he later remembered.
Gittany gave evidence in his own defense in early November 2013. The judge later rejected his evidence as untruthful and found his account of the morning inherently implausible.
Justice McCallum delivered her verdict on November 27, 2013. She was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Gittany had murdered his fiancee. She found that he had acted in a fit of uncontrollable rage after discovering that she intended to leave him, and that in the relationship he had been controlling, dominating and at times abusive.
The judge rejected each alternative the defense had offered for the death. She found the suggestion that the young woman had been suicidal completely unfounded. She accepted the evidence of the passer-by after considering at length the factors that might have made it unreliable, and she gave the defense expert's evidence on memory little weight.
On February 11, 2014, Justice McCallum sentenced Gittany to 26 years in prison, with a non-parole period of 18 years, which set his earliest parole date in May 2031. The judge considered life imprisonment and found that it would be excessive.
The appeal against conviction was decided by the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal in 2016. Gittany's lawyers put three grounds. The first was that the trial judge had wrongly discounted the evidence of the defense expert on memory. The second was that she had been wrong to accept the passer-by's evidence as reliable. The third, which depended on the other two, was that the verdict was unreasonable and could not be supported by the evidence.
The court rejected all three. It found problems with the expert's evidence and no sign that the trial judge had wrongly discounted it, and it found that nothing the witness learned after the event had changed the core of his account. The trial judge had weighed the factors that might have made that evidence unreliable and had been entitled to accept it. With those two grounds gone, there was no basis for holding the verdict unreasonable. The appeal was dismissed, the conviction stood, and the sentence of 26 years with a non-parole period of 18 years remained in place. As of 2016 Gittany was serving that sentence in New South Wales; he cannot be considered for parole before May 2031.
Gittany has never admitted the murder. He denied it at trial, maintained his innocence after sentencing, and challenged the conviction on appeal; the Court of Criminal Appeal upheld the verdict on every ground. The trial judge rejected his account of the morning of July 30, 2011, and rejected the alternative explanations the defense put forward.
The contents of the recordings that were never handed to police are not known. Gittany said they would have shown nothing different; the court heard evidence that they might have.
August 1993: Gittany is found in Parramatta with stolen goods.
March 23, 1994: He resists arrest in Merrylands; he later pleads guilty to maliciously wounding a police officer and receiving stolen goods and is sentenced to two and a half years of periodic detention.
March 2000: He is arrested in Double Bay and later pleads guilty to supplying a prohibited drug; he receives weekend and home detention.
July 30, 2011: His fiancee dies in central Sydney, on the morning Gittany learned she planned to leave him and return to Canada.
January 2012: Gittany, charged with murder, is on bail.
November 2013: His judge-alone trial in the Supreme Court of New South Wales runs for about four weeks; he gives evidence in his own defense.
November 27, 2013: Justice Lucy McCallum finds him guilty of murder.
February 11, 2014: He is sentenced to 26 years in prison with a non-parole period of 18 years.
2016: The New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses his appeal against conviction.
May 2031: Earliest date of eligibility for parole.