Simon Bikindi

Victims
1 count, incitement to genocide (ICTR, 2008). Convicted of direct and public incitement to commit genocide; acquitted of genocide, complicity, conspiracy, murder and persecution.
Years active
June 1994
Location
Kivumu-Kayove road, Gisenyi prefecture, Rwanda (crimes: incitement to genocide); Leiden, Netherlands (arrest); Arusha, Tanzania (trial); Benin (sentence served).
Method
Method not recorded: no killing attributed to him by a court; convicted of public incitement to commit genocide (speech over a loudspeaker, late June 1994).
Status
15 years' imprisonment (December 2, 2008), affirmed on appeal March 18, 2010; sent to Benin to serve it, March 20, 2012. Died in 2018; place and custody status at death not on record.

Simon Bikindi was the most famous singer in Rwanda when the genocide against the Tutsi began in April 1994. He was a composer and bandleader whose patriotic songs had filled the national radio station's playlists through the war years, a civil servant in the youth ministry, and a member of the ruling party whose dance troupe performed at its meetings. On December 2, 2008, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, convicted him of one crime: direct and public incitement to commit genocide. Trial Chamber III found that toward the end of June 1994, on a road in Gisenyi prefecture, he publicly called for the extermination of the Tutsi. He was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment.

The same judgment acquitted him of the other five counts against him: conspiracy to commit genocide, genocide, complicity in genocide, murder as a crime against humanity, and persecution as a crime against humanity. That split defined the case. The judges found that three of his songs had manipulated Rwandan history to extol Hutu solidarity and had been put to use in the propaganda campaign of 1994, yet they held that the prosecution had not proved he played any part in broadcasting or spreading them that year, and the tribunal had no power to judge anything he wrote or performed before 1994. He was convicted for what he said in public on a road in his native region, not for the music that made his name. The Appeals Chamber dismissed his appeal and the prosecution's on March 18, 2010. He was transferred to Benin to serve the sentence in 2012 and died in 2018.

Bikindi was born on September 28, 1954, in Rwerere commune in the northwestern prefecture of Gisenyi. Through the 1980s and early 1990s he directed and starred in the Irindiro Ballet, a song and dance company that was hugely popular across Rwanda, and from October 1990 until July 1994, through the years of war with the Rwandan Patriotic Front, his patriotic songs were staples on Radio Rwanda, the national station.

He held a post in the Ministry of Youth and Association Movements, also known as the Ministry of Youth and Sports. He was a member of the MRND, the ruling party led by President Juvénal Habyarimana, and the Irindiro Ballet performed regularly at its meetings. In the months before the genocide he appeared at pro-Hutu rallies. He also held a stake in Radio Télévision Libre des Mille Collines, the private station known as RTLM, which broadcast anti-Tutsi messages through the genocide; he told the court he had owned a single share.

On April 4, 1994, two days before the genocide began, Bikindi left Rwanda. He returned through Zaire, now the Democratic Republic of the Congo, around June 12, 1994.

It was in the second half of June, after his return, that the events at the center of his conviction took place. The Trial Chamber found that toward the end of that month, in Gisenyi prefecture, he traveled with a convoy of the Interahamwe, the militia of the MRND built from the party's youth wing. On the road between Kivumu and Kayove, on the way out and again on the way back, he called on the people he passed to exterminate the Tutsi, referring to them in dehumanizing terms. The judges found both statements were made in public and amounted to a direct call to destroy the Tutsi as a group.

The tribunal's prosecutor confirmed an indictment against Bikindi on July 5, 2001. A week later, on July 12, Dutch authorities arrested him in Leiden, in the Netherlands, at the prosecutor's request. He fought his transfer in the Dutch courts and lost, and on March 27, 2002, he was flown to the United Nations Detention Facility in Arusha. At his initial appearance, on April 4, 2002, he pleaded not guilty to every count. The indictment was amended twice, and in its final form it charged six counts: conspiracy to commit genocide, genocide, complicity in genocide, direct and public incitement to commit genocide, and murder and persecution as crimes against humanity. Prosecutors alleged that he had helped to militarize and indoctrinate the young people who became the Interahamwe and had urged killings; the tribunal later found those allegations unproven.

The trial opened before Trial Chamber III on September 18, 2006. He was the first artist indicted before the tribunal. The prosecution closed its case on February 22, 2007, after 20 witnesses, two of them experts, and the three songs it relied on were played in full in the courtroom. The defense opened on September 24, 2007. It called Tutsi witnesses who said Bikindi had helped them survive in Gisenyi in 1994, and former members of his troupe who said he did not practice ethnic discrimination.

Bikindi testified in his own defense from October 31 to November 6, 2007. He defended the three songs as songs of peace, called the accusation that he took part in massacres fabricated, and denied that he had been a member of the Interahamwe or anything more than an ordinary member of the MRND. When one of the judges asked whether he accepted that the Tutsi had been victims of genocide in 1994, he answered yes. In all, the Chamber heard 20 witnesses for the prosecution and 37 for the defense, including Bikindi himself. At closing arguments on May 26, 2008, the prosecution asked for conviction on all six counts and a life sentence; the defense asked for acquittal.

The judgment was read on December 2, 2008. On count 4, direct and public incitement to commit genocide, Bikindi was found guilty. The finding rested entirely on his words on the Kivumu-Kayove road in late June 1994. The judges held that direct and public incitement is a crime of the most serious gravity and that he had abused his stature as a popular artist, an influential member of the MRND and a figure of standing in the Interahamwe.

On every other count he was acquitted. On conspiracy, the Chamber held that agreeing to spread ethnic hatred against a group is not the same as agreeing to destroy that group in whole or in part. On genocide and complicity in genocide, it found that the prosecution had not established his responsibility, and it rejected the allegations that he had personally taken part in killings or attacks on Tutsi. It likewise found his responsibility for murder as a crime against humanity unproven.

The persecution count turned on the songs. The Chamber found that the three songs manipulated the history of Rwanda to extol Hutu solidarity, and that two of them had been composed to promote pro-Hutu and anti-Tutsi feeling. It found that in a country with a strong oral tradition, and with RTLM so widely listened to, their broadcast in 1994 had an amplifying effect on the genocide. But the prosecution had not proved that Bikindi played any role in disseminating or deploying the songs in 1994, that he controlled their broadcast on RTLM or Radio Rwanda, or that he had sung them in public that year. The tribunal's jurisdiction began in 1994, and songs composed and performed before then lay beyond its reach.

The Chamber sentenced him to 15 years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since his arrest in the Netherlands.

Both sides appealed: Bikindi against his conviction, the prosecution against a sentence it considered inadequate. On March 18, 2010, the Appeals Chamber dismissed all six of his grounds, among them a claim that his former co-counsel had cross-examined a prosecution witness so poorly as to deny him effective assistance; it held that he had not rebutted the presumption that his lawyer acted competently. It also dismissed the prosecution's appeal, finding that 15 years had not been shown to be manifestly inadequate given the gravity of the crime and his role in it. The conviction and the sentence were affirmed.

Bikindi stayed in the detention facility in Arusha until a country to hold him could be designated. On March 20, 2012, he and two other convicted men were transferred to Benin to serve their sentences. He died in 2018.

Most of what the prosecution alleged about Bikindi was never proved. The tribunal rejected the charges that he planned the genocide with others, that he took part in killings or attacks, that he commanded or trained the Interahamwe in the killings, and that he ordered the deaths of particular people. No court tied any death to him.

The question of his songs was left unresolved in law. The judges found the three songs inflammatory and found that their broadcast in 1994 amplified the genocide, but they could not attribute that use to him. Bikindi maintained that the songs were about peace and unity and that he had no control over what radio stations did with them.

The Chamber found that he was an influential member of the MRND with standing in the Interahamwe, and the Appeals Chamber found no error in that finding, against defense evidence that he was an ordinary party member and an artist who had helped Tutsi survive in 1994.

Timeline

September 28, 1954: Simon Bikindi is born in Rwerere commune, Gisenyi prefecture, Rwanda.

April 4, 1994: He leaves Rwanda, two days before the genocide begins.

Around June 12, 1994: He returns to Rwanda through Zaire.

Late June 1994: On the Kivumu-Kayove road in Gisenyi prefecture, the tribunal later found, he publicly calls for the extermination of the Tutsi.

November 1994: The UN Security Council establishes the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

July 5, 2001: The tribunal confirms an indictment against him.

July 12, 2001: He is arrested in Leiden, the Netherlands.

March 27, 2002: He is transferred to the UN Detention Facility in Arusha.

April 4, 2002: He pleads not guilty to all counts.

September 18, 2006: His trial opens before Trial Chamber III.

December 2, 2008: He is convicted of direct and public incitement to commit genocide, acquitted of five counts and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment.

March 18, 2010: The Appeals Chamber dismisses both appeals and affirms the conviction and sentence.

March 20, 2012: He is transferred to Benin to serve his sentence.

2018: He dies.