In the summer and autumn of 2015, a night-shift security guard from a village in the Teltow-Fläming district of Brandenburg took two small boys who were strangers to him and killed them. The first was a young child from Potsdam, taken on July 8, 2015. The second, younger still, was the son of a refugee family from Bosnia and Herzegovina, taken in Berlin on October 1, 2015. Silvio S., who was 32 and had never been convicted of anything, was arrested at the end of October, after his own mother went to the police. Within a day he had confessed to both killings.
On July 26, 2016, the Potsdam Regional Court convicted him of murder in two cases, with other charges, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The court also found that his guilt was of particular gravity, and that part of the judgment became final in April 2017. A second question, whether he should be held in preventive detention after his sentence, went to the Federal Court of Justice and back to a Potsdam court, and in June 2019 it was left open, to be decided again before any release.
German press practice withholds the surnames of defendants, and through the trial and the appeals he was Silvio S., a former security guard. He had been living in Kaltenborn, in the Teltow-Fläming district south of Berlin, and had worked night shifts. He had no criminal record. The trial court found that he had never come to the attention of the authorities before 2015, a fact that would weigh heavily later, when the courts tried to judge how dangerous he would remain. A psychiatrist who examined him for the court diagnosed an avoidant personality disorder, and he was found criminally responsible.
The first boy lived with his family in Potsdam, the capital of Brandenburg. On July 8, 2015, Silvio S. took him away. The Federal Court of Justice, summarizing the trial court's findings, recorded that the boy was killed no later than July 9, 2015. For nearly four months nothing connected the child's fate to the man in Kaltenborn.
On October 1, 2015, in Berlin, he took the second boy away, and the trial court found that he killed him. For each child he was later convicted of murder together with the abduction of a minor, deprivation of liberty resulting in death, bodily injury and further offenses.
Late in October, Silvio S.'s mother went to the Berlin police, and on October 29, 2015, officers arrested her son. The same day he admitted the killing of the boy from Berlin, and overnight he confessed to the killing of the boy from Potsdam as well; the Berlin police announced the second confession on October 30. The two cases, one from Brandenburg and one from Berlin, were brought together, and the Potsdam public prosecutor's office took charge of the prosecution. He was held first in Berlin and then in pretrial detention in Brandenburg.
The trial opened before the serious-crimes chamber of the Potsdam Regional Court on June 14, 2016, when he was 33. He would not answer questions about the crimes.
On July 26, 2016, the court convicted him of murder in two cases, with other charges. It imposed life imprisonment as an aggregate sentence and found that his guilt was of particular gravity. It refused to order preventive detention: following the psychiatric expert, it could not establish, with the certainty the law requires, that he had a propensity to commit serious crimes.
Both sides appealed on points of law, the prosecution only against the refusal of preventive detention. In April 2017 the Fifth Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice rejected Silvio S.'s appeal as manifestly unfounded. From that point his conviction for both murders, the life sentence and the finding of particular gravity of guilt were final.
The prosecution's appeal was heard in Leipzig on June 28, 2017, and the Senate allowed it. It held that preventive detention may be ordered alongside a life sentence, even when the guilt has been found to be of particular gravity, and that the trial court had applied the wrong test: it had looked for a cause of the crimes in a mental disorder, when the question was whether the crimes themselves were symptoms of a propensity. The Senate set aside the refusal of preventive detention and sent that question back to a different serious-crimes chamber of the Potsdam Regional Court.
The new hearing began in Potsdam in May 2019. It did not reopen the murders, which were settled, and Silvio S., then 35 and held in Brandenburg, still gave no account of why he had done it. On June 28, 2019, the court again declined to order preventive detention outright, but this time it reserved the decision. It found his dangerousness proven and a propensity to such crimes probable but not proven, weighing two grave crimes committed within a few months against his previously blameless life and the relatively late age at which he first offended. Under the reservation, a court is to examine the question again with a new expert assessment before any release and decide then whether he must remain in detention after his sentence.
Silvio S. has never explained why he committed the crimes. He confessed in October 2015, but he stayed silent at his trial and again at the 2019 hearing.
Whether he has a lasting propensity to commit serious crimes has never been settled. The trial court in 2016 found it unproven. The Federal Court of Justice held in 2017 that the trial court had judged the question by the wrong standard. The court that heard the matter again in 2019 found it probable but not proven, and as of 2019 the decision stood reserved for a future hearing.
July 8, 2015: Silvio S. takes a boy from Potsdam, Brandenburg; the trial court found the child was killed no later than July 9.
October 1, 2015: He takes the son of a refugee family from Bosnia and Herzegovina in Berlin.
October 29, 2015: Arrested in Berlin after his mother goes to the police; he admits the Berlin killing.
October 30, 2015: Berlin police announce that he has also confessed to the killing of the Potsdam boy.
June 14, 2016: Trial opens at the Potsdam Regional Court.
July 26, 2016: Convicted of murder in two cases, with other charges; life imprisonment, particular gravity of guilt; preventive detention refused.
April 2017: The Federal Court of Justice rejects his appeal; conviction and sentence become final.
June 28, 2017: The Federal Court of Justice allows the prosecution's appeal on preventive detention and sends the question back to Potsdam.
May 2019: A new hearing on preventive detention opens in Potsdam.
June 28, 2019: The Potsdam Regional Court reserves preventive detention for a decision before any release.