Shrien Dewani

Victims
His wife's murder in Cape Town, 2010; he was acquitted, 2014. Found not guilty on all five counts, December 8, 2014; three other men were convicted
Years active
November 13, 2010 (the murder); acquittal December 8, 2014.
Location
Cape Town, South Africa; Bristol and London, England.
Method
Murder (for which three other men were convicted); Dewani was charged and acquitted.
Status
Acquitted December 8, 2014; the prosecution could not appeal the discharge. Never convicted of any offense.

Shrien Dewani stood trial for murder in Cape Town and was never required to say a word in his own defense. On December 8, 2014, the Western Cape High Court stopped his trial at the close of the prosecution's case and found him not guilty on all five counts. He has never been convicted of any offense, and he has always denied any part in the crime.

The crime was the murder of his wife, Anni Dewani, in Cape Town on November 13, 2010, during the couple's honeymoon in South Africa. Dewani was a businessman from Bristol, England.

Three Cape Town men were convicted over her death. Zola Tongo, the driver, pleaded guilty under a plea agreement on December 7, 2010, and was sentenced to an effective 18 years; he was granted parole in 2022 and released that June, after serving 11 years. Mziwamadoda Qwabe pleaded guilty under a plea agreement in August 2012 and was sentenced to 25 years. Xolile Mngeni denied the charges, was convicted of premeditated murder and robbery with aggravating circumstances on November 19, 2012, and was sentenced to life imprisonment; he died in custody in October 2014.

Dewani was arrested in England on December 7, 2010, at South Africa's request. For more than three years he fought extradition on mental-health grounds, held as a psychiatric patient in England; the High Court in London halted his return in 2012, allowed it on conditions in January 2014, and he was flown to Cape Town that April. He was declared fit to stand trial in August 2014.

The trial opened in the Western Cape High Court on October 6, 2014, on counts of murder, kidnapping, robbery with aggravating circumstances, conspiracy to commit those crimes, and defeating the ends of justice. He pleaded not guilty to every one. The state's case rested on accomplice witnesses, Tongo and Qwabe among them, who alleged that Dewani had arranged the killing. When the prosecution closed its case, his counsel applied for his discharge.

The judge granted it. She found the accomplice evidence so full of "mistakes, lies and inconsistencies" that it fell far below what a conviction required, and held that an accused who could be convicted only if he testified was entitled to be discharged. She found him not guilty on all counts. The prosecution could not appeal the ruling, and Dewani was free to leave South Africa.

The only evidence that tied Dewani to the crime came from accomplice witnesses, and the court that heard it found it unreliable. He was acquitted, and the prosecution's case against him was never proved. Mngeni's conviction settled his own guilt only; it decided nothing about Dewani, who was not on trial in that case.

Timeline

November 13, 2010: The murder in Cape Town.

December 7, 2010: Tongo pleads guilty under a plea agreement and is sentenced to an effective 18 years; Dewani is arrested in England at South Africa's request.

March 30, 2012: The High Court in London halts his extradition on mental-health grounds.

August 2012: Qwabe pleads guilty and is sentenced to 25 years.

November 19, 2012: Mngeni is convicted.

December 5, 2012: Mngeni is sentenced to life imprisonment.

January 31, 2014: The High Court allows extradition on conditions.

April 2014: Dewani is extradited to Cape Town.

August 2014: He is declared fit to stand trial.

October 6, 2014: The trial opens; he pleads not guilty to all five counts.

October 2014: Mngeni dies in custody.

December 8, 2014: The Western Cape High Court finds Dewani not guilty on all counts.

June 2022: Tongo is released on parole.