On the night of April 30 to May 1, 2021, Saman, the daughter of Shabbar Abbas, was killed in Novellara, a farming town in the province of Reggio Emilia in northern Italy. Three levels of Italian courts would hold her own family responsible. Abbas, who lived in the town, was convicted of her murder together with his wife, his brother and two of his nephews, and sentenced to life imprisonment. The sentence became final on July 15, 2026, when Italy's Court of Cassation rejected every appeal. He has denied the murder at every stage.
The inquiry came quickly. Suspicion arose in early May 2021, and prosecutors in Reggio Emilia began an investigation that at first concerned kidnapping. By the end of the month they were investigating a murder, with five relatives under investigation: Abbas, his wife, his brother and two of his nephews. The prosecutors closed their investigation in March 2022 and charged all five with kidnapping, premeditated murder and a further offense. On May 17, 2022, the judge of the preliminary hearing in Reggio Emilia sent all five to the Corte d'Assise, Abbas and his wife among them, although neither was then in Italy. The charge cast the two parents as the instigators of the murder.
For a year and a half he stayed beyond Italy's reach. He was arrested in Pakistan in November 2022, while Italy's request for his extradition on the murder charge was pending. A court in Islamabad upheld that request in July 2023, and on August 31, 2023, he was handed over to Italian police and brought to Italy.
The trial of the five relatives had already opened on February 10, 2023, before the Corte d'Assise of Reggio Emilia. Abbas was then still held in Pakistan, and the court set his position apart until he could appear; he joined the trial once he was in Italian custody. The charges were murder, kidnapping and a further offense. All five denied them.
On December 19, 2023, the Corte d'Assise of Reggio Emilia convicted Abbas and his wife of murder and sentenced both to life imprisonment. It rejected the aggravating circumstances of premeditation and of abject and futile motives, acquitted all five defendants of kidnapping and did not convict the parents of the further offense. The murder it found against the parents was aggravated by their relationship to the victim. It convicted his brother of murder and of the further offense, and it acquitted both nephews on the ground that they had not committed the act.
The court's written reasons set out how it saw the parents' part. It found that the decision to kill had been agreed between the parents and his brother, that the mother had taken an active part in the moments when her daughter's fate was decided, and that the parents and his brother were "equally and fully involved" in the murder. What had mattered to the family, the court found, was to stop the young woman from leaving home again. Against the two nephews it found the evidence scant.
The appeal went to the Corte d'Assise d'Appello of Bologna, which ruled on April 18, 2025. It confirmed the life sentences of Abbas and his wife, recognized the aggravating circumstances of premeditation and of abject and futile motives, and convicted all five defendants of the further offense as well as murder.
Its written reasons reversed the first court on the central questions. The appeal court found that the killing had been decided by the family group "with cold lucidity" and planned over a reasonable span of time, a premeditation it described as conditional: the decision would be carried out if the young woman chose to leave the family. It found that the parents had planned their daughter's killing but were not the ones who carried it out, and that his brother and the two nephews were. The nephews, it held, had acted in uncritical assent to the family's decision, and without them the murder would have been far harder to accomplish.
All five then appealed to the Court of Cassation. Premeditation was the issue common to every appeal. On July 15, 2026, its First Criminal Section rejected every appeal, and the convictions and sentences became final, the further offense with the murder.
The Cassation's written reasons, made public on November 6, 2026, upheld the appeal court's reconstruction. The court held that the murder "was not the fruit of a decision reached on the night of the crime" but the carrying out of a criminal plan worked out in advance and shared within the whole family. It found that the appeal court had been right to weigh the abject nature of the motive.
His wife received life imprisonment at first instance, confirmed on appeal. His brother received 14 years at first instance, raised to 22 years on appeal. His two nephews were acquitted at first instance and sentenced to life imprisonment on appeal. The Cassation's ruling made every one of those sentences final.
Shabbar Abbas is serving life imprisonment in Italy.
The courts disagreed over premeditation. The Reggio Emilia court rejected it, finding that the decision to kill was taken on the evening of the killing itself. The Bologna appeal court found a killing planned in advance by the whole family, and the Court of Cassation upheld that finding in reasons made public in November 2026: a plan prepared ahead of time and shared among the family's members, tied to a claimed family "honor," a motive the court held could not lessen the gravity of the crime.
The courts also differed on who carried out the killing. The first court did not rule out that the mother had done it herself. The appeal court found that neither parent did, that the parents planned it and that other relatives carried it out. The parents' convictions rest on that role, not on a finding that either of them killed their daughter.
Abbas has denied the murder throughout.
April 30 to May 1, 2021: Abbas's daughter is killed in Novellara.
May 2021: Prosecutors in Reggio Emilia begin an inquiry; by the end of the month Abbas and four relatives are under investigation for murder.
March 2022: The prosecutors close their investigation, charging kidnapping, premeditated murder and a further offense.
May 17, 2022: The judge of the preliminary hearing sends all five relatives to trial before the Corte d'Assise.
November 2022: Abbas is arrested in Pakistan.
February 10, 2023: The trial of five relatives opens before the Corte d'Assise of Reggio Emilia.
August 31, 2023: Abbas is extradited from Pakistan to Italy.
December 19, 2023: The Reggio Emilia court sentences Abbas and his wife to life imprisonment for murder.
April 18, 2025: The Corte d'Assise d'Appello of Bologna confirms the life sentences and recognizes premeditation and abject and futile motives.
July 15, 2026: The Court of Cassation rejects all appeals; the convictions become final.
November 6, 2026: The Cassation's written reasons are made public.