Seth Ator

Victims
7 killed in Midland and Odessa, Texas, 2019; never tried. Police and federal prosecutors attributed the seven deaths and 25 woundings of August 31, 2019, to him; killed by police that day
Years active
August 31, 2019
Location
Midland and Odessa, Texas (Midland County and Ector County)
Method
Seven deaths attributed by investigators; never charged with any offense
Status
Dead (August 31, 2019). Texas Department of Public Safety final report, September 2021; the case closed with his death

On the afternoon of Saturday, August 31, 2019, the start of the Labor Day weekend, seven people were killed and 25 were wounded across Midland and Odessa, the two oil cities of the Permian Basin in West Texas. Police and federal prosecutors attributed every one of those deaths and injuries to Seth Aaron Ator, a 36-year-old man who lived on the outskirts of Odessa. Before the afternoon was over, police had killed him in Odessa.

Ator was never charged, never tried and never convicted of anything that happened that day. No jury heard evidence about him, and no judge made a finding. What stands in place of a verdict is the work of the agencies that reconstructed the afternoon: the Odessa and Midland police departments, the Texas Department of Public Safety and its Texas Rangers, the FBI and the federal ATF. In September 2021 the Department of Public Safety issued its final report, and the case closed with his death.

Little of Ator's life before August 2019 entered public view. He finished high school in 2001 in Lorena, a small town just outside Waco. Months later he was arrested in McLennan County, the county that takes in Waco and Lorena, on misdemeanor charges of criminal trespass and evading arrest. He pleaded guilty under a deferred prosecution agreement, and the charges were waived after 24 months of probation. They were the only criminal charges he ever faced, and neither carried any lasting legal disability in Texas. When the afternoon of August 31 began, he had no outstanding warrants.

The final report of the Department of Public Safety set his last day against a longer history. It traced his encounters with law enforcement back to the early 1990s and described a history of mental illness. Federal prosecutors, in a related case brought in 2020, stated that he fell within the category federal law calls "mentally defective," a status that placed him under a federal legal bar. No court proceeding about August 31 ever examined that history, because there was no living defendant.

He worked for Journey Oilfield Services, a company in the oil fields of the Basin.

On the morning of August 31, Journey Oilfield Services fired him. The firing ended in two calls to Odessa police, one from the company and one from Ator, each complaining about the other, and he had left before officers arrived. Later he placed calls of his own, to the FBI's National Tip Line and to local police dispatch. Officials said he made no threats in either call. The FBI said afterward that he had called its tip line before.

Not long after the call to the FBI, the killings began in Midland County and then reached Ector County and Odessa. Nothing found afterward suggested that any of those harmed had been chosen.

For a time police warned that more than one person might be involved. By the next day the Odessa police chief said investigators believed a single person had acted, and the FBI said its preliminary investigation had found no ties between Ator and any domestic or international terrorist group. Three law enforcement officers were among the wounded: a trooper of the Department of Public Safety, a Midland police officer and an Odessa police officer. Among the other wounded was a young child. The wounded came from Odessa and Midland and from towns across Texas, and others came from as far away as California, Arizona and Florida. Ator was killed by police in Odessa that afternoon.

On Monday, September 2, the City of Odessa released the names of the dead. They came from Odessa and from towns hundreds of miles away, and nothing linked most of them to one another beyond being in the two cities that afternoon.

Mary Granados lived in Odessa.

Rodolfo Julio Arco, known as Rudy, lived in Odessa.

Edwin Peregrino lived in San Antonio and was in Odessa for the holiday weekend.

Joseph Griffith lived in Odessa.

Leilah was a girl from Odessa.

Kameron Brown came from Brownwood, in Central Texas.

Raul Garcia lived in El Paso.

On the Sunday after the killings, investigators worked through the scenes in both counties and the places connected to Ator. Federal agents joined the local departments. Police released his name that day. Agents of the federal ATF joined the inquiry. In the days that followed, officials said the motive was still under investigation, and none was ever established.

The Texas Rangers, the investigative arm of the Department of Public Safety, assembled the full account. The final report, issued in September 2021, set the afternoon in order and set out Ator's earlier contacts with law enforcement. It counted seven people killed and recorded that another 15 people had been targeted and had come through without physical injury. It found that Ator died in his final encounter with law enforcement, and with his death the case concluded.

In a separate federal case in Lubbock, a private seller from that city pleaded guilty in October 2020 to dealing without a federal license and to subscribing to a false tax return, admitting a sale to Ator in 2016, and was sentenced on January 7, 2021, to two years in federal prison.

No motive was ever established. Police saw no link to terrorism.

Ator's responsibility for the seven deaths and the 25 woundings was never tested by a court. The finding that one person acted is an investigative conclusion, not a judicial one.

His mental-health history is known only in summary form, through the federal prosecutors' statement of his legal status and the final report's general description. No court ever weighed it.

Timeline

2001: Finishes high school in Lorena, near Waco.

2001 (later): Arrested in McLennan County on misdemeanor charges of criminal trespass and evading arrest; the charges were later waived under a deferred prosecution agreement after 24 months of probation.

August 31, 2019 (morning): Fired by Journey Oilfield Services; the company calls 911; he later calls the FBI's National Tip Line and local police dispatch.

August 31, 2019 (afternoon): Seven people killed and 25 wounded across Midland County and Ector County; Ator killed by police in Odessa.

September 1, 2019: Investigators work the scenes in both counties; the Odessa police chief says investigators believe one person acted; police release his name.

September 2, 2019: The City of Odessa releases the names of the dead.

October 2020: A Lubbock private seller pleads guilty in federal court to dealing without a federal license and to a false tax return.

January 7, 2021: The seller is sentenced to two years in federal prison.

September 2021: The Texas Department of Public Safety issues its final report; the case concludes with Ator's death.